jimmuller wrote:
I have to ask, ...Where is the philosophical divide between image capture and image creation/modification?
Jim,
I use to argue this with editorial photogs all the time. In their mind they were "light scribes", or "purist". Nonsense! The modifications begin at the very first moment while composing the shot, and at every subsequent stage. I was a marketing photog, and wanted to capture idealized snippets of reality. (Think beads condensation on an iced tea glass.) Before AF, auto exposure, and all the digital stuff, there was a whole world of analog technology to learn - plus we used our brains. Photography was more a minds eye view of the world, because we took longer, and gave it thought. As a mkt photog I would setup shots. Now, with little thought, I could just point my D850 or 7DmkII at something and spray 10 fps knowing that one frame would be what I was looking to capture. I realize editorial needs to honestly record events accurately, but they do crop, adjust the images for color, contrast, highlight to shadow detail (no camera has the dynamic range of the human eye), and other technical reasons. The rest of us are free to engage our brains and use photography to convey a thought, idea, message, feeling, or simply be artistic. Therefore, the closest thing to "image capture" is a trail or surveillance cam (no human except for camera placement) - everything else is "image creation" - IMO.
Jim