James Markus wrote:
Note: the file names contain an error. The f3.5 is an AI not an AIS. This new lens bugs me. The finish is better than the f3.5. It has a much smoother helical movement, and a more solid feel - plus it just looks better. But, the f3.5 is the better performer. I have a few lenses in this category. Beautiful paper weights I will never use. Looks like at some point I will need to get rid of these lenses.
Thank you for the previous explanation, James. My experience with lens tests is limited to AF fine-tuning of AF lenses. At f/5.6 the AIS lens is soundly beaten. My version isn't as good as the Dx micro 40mm or the G 60mm but it is compact and its manual focus action walks all over theirs. I find a lot of parallels in photography as in audio equipment. Perfection is rated very highly and people go to great lengths finding it. I can't argue with the results. Knowing what I know now based on your tests, given a choice between the two I may reach for the f/3.5 lens but if the movement is noticeably worse than the AIS' that would complicate the choice for me because at these image sizes, especially the tomatoe pictures, I can't tell the difference. I'll go for the one that's nicer to use. On the other hand in audio, I'm always reaching for the one where I press the button on the remote and the music starts playing.