Siphiwe, I shot everything at f5.6. I wanted a real world test of a macro lens lens as a macro lens. IMO 90% of the lenses have their maximum sharpness at f5.6. Sometimes it is f4, and sometimes it is f8, but of all my years of reading lens tests and my own experiences - f5.6 is the best. It corrects a host of problems with even marginal lenses like distortion, comma, edge sharpness, and corner sharpness etc. Both the f3.5 and f2.8 focus as close as less than 10 inches - so these were shot close to MFD (11"). I focused and shot each image individually in sets of four frames per setup. The extra lens group and lens element in the f2.8 + CRC correction may actually be contributing to the results. The feather is not flat, but I focused on the same area, and checked the rest of the frame to see if other areas reached better focus than the area focused upon. The record is flat and was my solution to the variable height surface of the feather.
Jim
SiMuMe wrote:
That is an interesting test, James. It does seem like the 3.5 is getting maximum points in this round. Are they both at their respective wide-open apertures? Looking forward to more.