Thank you all for the great replies. Very helpful indeed. I don't have any brand loyalty and I've been running several camera systems since the film days. So over the years I have acquired a few excellent lenses. I probably will convert and use the following lenses in the yet to be decided camera: Nikon 17-35; C/Y 21; Leica 35/2; Leica 50/1.4; Leica 100/2.8 and Leica 180/3.4. All these lenses clear the 5D mirror. The A850 should be fine but I'm not really too sure about the D700.
Why I want to retire the 5D: because I don't like its color rendering. The color saturation is somewhat washed. Also, every now and then, I will find some colors which are "unnatural", mainly greens that are yellowish and blues that are too light. If I want to print them (I don't print large, though), I have to PS them quite a bit. I know many here find the 5DII a great camera. I also know that the 5D needs profiling and I've done that to the best I could but still it's not entirely satisfying.
So, if the 5DII is broadly similar to the 5D in color rendering, I would not be interested. From what I've read, the 5DII's colors are similar to the 5D's.
Currently, I have the Pentax K10 and K20. When I first got the K10, I like its colors slightly better than the 5D. That was about 3 years ago. Last year, after I got the K20, I like its colors a lot. The files, straight after raw conversion, are beautiful and requires almost no PP. Pentax has not FF DSLR.
I read that the A850 has very good colors, similar to the A900. I'm not sure how good the D700 may be. If the D700 (in terms of its colors) is just as good as the A850, I would want it simply because of the better AF. Besides, I do have a few Nikon AF lenses that I can put to use. If the D700 is just slightly inferior to the A850, I will have a hard time deciding between the two. By then, Nikon's better system support would be a valid consideration.
Nevertheless, color rendering is still the primary concern. I'm sure the 5DII is a great camera but its just that I don't love the 5D.
m_appeal wrote: James R wroteI somewhat agree with your first statement. But, I not sure that an a900 is a no "brainer." I've been tempted to switch from Nikon to Canon, but, it never made financial sense.I didn't lose much $ from switching, except for the hit I took on the 1ds3, but even then I didn't lose that much...
I just got very lucky buying the Sony Alpha 900 for a rather ridiculous price of $ 2000 USD new including shipping and taxes.
Glad it didn't hurt. Surprised you sold a 1Ds3. Everybody I know who shoots it seem to love it.
Take a CF card to a camera store and shoot a few frames with various cameras and see which color renderings suit your taste. Hopefully, you have a cooperative store near-by.
James R wrote:
Glad it didn't hurt. Surprised you sold a 1Ds3. Everybody I know who shoots it seem to love it.
I traded it... selling it has been difficult. And I got rid of it at least in part because I can't afford it right now. It's a big body as well although surprisingly lite for its type... I'd rather be shooting with something smaller. I prefer D700/5d2 size cameras...the smaller the better.
Sorry, just a small correction: the Leica 50/1.4 will hit the 5D mirror unless the plastic shoud at the last element is removed.
I love those alt lenses and as long as the conversion process is reversible, as the Leitax's is, I will not hesitate to convert them.
The 5D has been great. It has allowed me to try many exotic lenses from Leica, Contax/Zeiss, Nikon and Zuiko. It's would be a dream if somehow I could also try some Leica M, Pentax K or Minolta lenses on a single FF DSLR.
m_appeal wrote "I don't think you can convert the Nikon 17-35 to use on the Sony A850? I don't know for sure though."
You are right. The Leitax adaptor can't do it on the Sony/Alpha mount. Thanks a lot. I am sure I can find something else and if all else fail, the ZA 16-35 or the 24/70 are not too bad.
BTW, I love to print but only up to about 20 or 24 inches max. With some upres, the 5D can do that comfortably in terms of sharpness. But the colors need a bit of work.
m_appeal wrote:
I don't think you'll be disappointed with those 2.
When I said that, I actually mean they are great lenses, only if they can be less conspicious (and they are conspicious!) and lighter. Between the two, I would probably choose the 24-70 but I don't see using it a lot because of the weight issue.
m_appeal wrote:
From what I've seen Nikon 14-24 is sharp into the extreme corners even wide open. I have not seen samples with the D3X though....
Apparently, the Nikon 24-70 doesn't perform as well on the D3x as the Zeiss does on the A900, although I'm more speculating on that than anything... BUT I did read that 24-70 isn't perfect on the D3x.
Most lenses will take a severe hit when used on 24mp cameras. The 12mp sensor of the D700 is very kind on lenses.
I have no doubt however that the 14-24 is the best UWA zoom on the market. But when comparing it to the Zeiss 16-35, one has to take a few things in consideration. The most obvious one is that it can't be used on the Alpha mount. Also that it is a 1.7X zoom while the 16-35 is a 2.18X, a bit more ambitious but involving more design compromises. The 25 to 35mm range does not exist on the Nikon, while the 14-15mm range is missing on the Zeiss, they are not exactly in the same category and the Zeiss gives more flexibility with a wider zoom range.
One last word about the cameras themselves. The D3X is probably the best DSLR out there. I love its color rendition, even though I prefer that of the A900. One recent test on lenstip shows that there is very little difference in sharpness between the AA filterless M9 and the D3X, which means the AA filter on the D3X is almost non existant. The A900 is very similar to the 1Ds3, whic was considered to have a weak AA filter, but there is a day and night difference with the D3X, which leads me to believe the AA filter on both Canon and Sony is unnecessarily strong in comparison. Sony also has the AA filter further away from the sensor to help with dust, but in fact this tends to exagerate the filter strength and while it helps to hide dust spots, the ones that are visible become huge due to this distance and are a pain to clone out.
I am sure if the Zeiss were to be available for the Nikon mount, it would be even more stellar on the D3X. My hope is that Sony's A900 successor will have a more reasonable AA filter especially that it is not really needed with the high pixel count.
Chris48 wrote:
Why I want to retire the 5D: because I don't like its color rendering. The color saturation is somewhat washed. Also, every now and then, I will find some colors which are "unnatural", mainly greens that are yellowish and blues that are too light. If I want to print them (I don't print large, though), I have to PS them quite a bit. I know many here find the 5DII a great camera. I also know that the 5D needs profiling and I've done that to the best I could but still it's not entirely satisfying.
I was in your exact same situation. Believe me you will love the A850 color rendering. In my photo club, there are many 5D2 and D700 users, and they are always amazed at the colors of my A900 even when we are out on a shoot and comparing the images on the camera LCD.
Specularist wrote:
The A900/A850, D700 and 5D Mark II together prove that digital SLRs are still in their infancy. These cameras each have serious drawbacks in addition to their remarkable capabilities.
The A900 has worse high-ISO performance than the best crop-sensor cameras, lacks Live View, inherited the proprietary Minolta flash shoe, can't record to both memory cards simultaneously, and doesn't have much in the way of in-production lens selection (though there are a few great ones).
On the plus side, it has superior overall craftsmanship, a far better viewfinder than the others, it surely looks prettier on the shelf, and more importantly: it has the best outright image quality (at low ISO). It offers superb resolution and colour, and it probably does have the largest usable dynamic range of the trio at base ISO, though the D700 would push it very close (and significantly lower noise in the mid-tones). Whether Sony will expand and support the Alpha system at the high end for another two, five, ten years is anyone's guess.
The D700 is a far more accomplished camera than the others in many ways. Its autofocus is in a different league, it can shoot at 8 fps, it has vastly shorter mirror black-out and shutter-lag times than the other two, it's designed with an attention to detail that Canon hasn't achieved in decades and that Sony won't achieve for years, and it's the best low-light camera on the market except for the new D3S.
But these advantages are tied to a sensor and antialiasing filter that result in vaguely soft 12-megapixel images: unacceptable to many in late 2009, if only because other cameras do so much better. Read noise is too high too, resulting in lack-lustre low-ISO dynamic range compared to the high-ISO performance. The little built-in flash compromises the top-half, and worse, it's just ridiculous. The viewfinder is the worst of the lot, with 95% coverage and no official options for a decent focusing screen. The camera is limited to 5 fps without the grip, for no obvious reason other than selling overpriced grips. The D700 is also the most over-complicated way in history to select an f-stop and shutter speed (the manual has 450 pages and would need more).
The 5D Mark II has the shapeless, androgynous design—if it can be called design—of all the big EOS cameras (its slouched shoulders one of many sins Luigi Colani has committed against the world). Inside are more features than you can shake a stick at, most of them half-baked. It shoots bad video, has a crap shutter, uses yesteryear's autofocus, and offers a selection of ISO speeds from 100 to far-too-high, none of them class-leading but all of them tolerable enough.
This camera wins praise for detail retention, but only by using a weak antialiasing filter that encourages false colour at the drop of a hat. The colour filter array isn't very colourful. The build and construction are fussy and obviously of a lower standard than the D700 or A900; but no-one cares about that these days. There are more EOS lenses than anyone could ever want, most of them also pretty crap. Some of them though, are better than any comparable lenses by anyone, bar none. But its biggest flaw is inexcusable: it suffers from worse shadow banding than any camera in recent memory. Any old DSLR has better usable dynamic range at base ISO.
If the A900 is a low-ISO tripod expert and the D700 an action camera, the 5D Mark II is a Jack of all trades and master of none. Its perfect blend of mediocrity appeals to me not at all (in case you didn't notice ).
To add insult to injury, all three of these cameras are heavier and much larger than they should be. Even the Sony, which is the best built of the three, should be better built for the price. And the price is very high for cameras with such flaws.
As someone above said, pick your poison, because none of these cameras are anywhere near perfect. I suppose that's the result of just three Japanese companies "competing" against each other....Show more →
Just out of curiosity, which of these 3 camera's do you actually own or have used for more than 3 months ?
In these discussions of color rendering between systems, I'm just curious: are we assuming that no color calibration is being used, e.g. the Adobe color profiling tools? Or are we saying that even with these calibrations, the systems are still that much different?
edwardkaraa wrote: Chris48 wroteWhy I want to retire the 5D: because I don't like its color rendering. The color saturation is somewhat washed. Also, every now and then, I will find some colors which are "unnatural", mainly greens that are yellowish and blues that are too light. If I want to print them (I don't print large, though), I have to PS them quite a bit. I know many here find the 5DII a great camera. I also know that the 5D needs profiling and I've done that to the best I could but still it's not entirely satisfying.I was in your exact same situation. Believe me you will love the A850 color rendering. In my photo club, there are many 5D2 and D700 users, and they are always amazed at the colors of my A900 even when we are out on a shoot and comparing the images on the camera LCD.
joekraft, this isn't about calibration and profiles. Canon has openly admitted to using more transmissive color filters lately to improve high ISO, and that requires the cameras to gain up certain colors, which results in error. Here are some interesting comments from RPP developer Iliah Borg, who owns/has owned all of the cameras we're talking about.
Thanks, I'll look at that. douglasf13 wrote:
joekraft, this isn't about calibration and profiles. Canon has openly admitted to using more transmissive color filters lately to improve high ISO, and that requires the cameras to gain up certain colors, which results in error. Here are some interesting comments from RPP developer Iliah Borg, who owns/has owned all of the cameras we're talking about.
Cool. Don't get me wrong, I'm certainly not saying that one camera is better than another. In fact, all of these fullframe DSLRs are great, and each has its strengths and weaknesses. My A900/850 recommendations are just based on the OP's requests.
Specularist, I agree with much of what you say, except when (talking about the D700), you say:
The viewfinder is the worst of the lot, with 95% coverage and no official options for a decent focusing screen. The camera is limited to 5 fps without the grip, for no obvious reason other than selling overpriced grips. The D700 is also the most over-complicated way in history to select an f-stop and shutter speed (the manual has 450 pages and would need more).
A comment or two: yes, the VF is "only" 95%, but is is huge and bright, and its AF is excellent AND the Live View is excellent for work that is more critical than what 95% gives you. In architectural and product work (except for quick and dirty) it is Live View all the time for me (TS lenses in particular), and the results are fast to achieve and 100% reliable, and all parts of the image can be checked, unlike the 5DII, and at sub-pixel level if you need it.
As for adjusting ƒ-stop and shutter speed, I just can't see anything easier than front or back command wheels (and you can reset the standard function of either if you have a preference; you can set auto ISO to kick in at any minimum shutter speed; and there are other ways to, including direct exp. comp.—what were you looking for? The degree of customisation is large enough for me, at least, so I am not sure what you mean here. cheers, kl
Yeah, I'm not arguing anything either way. I just think it is an important clarification, because there are solutions now, that are very easy to implement. So I'm just wondering if these differences can be overcome, just like we calibrate monitors.