Does Nikon/Canon offer something I really need that Sony cannot offer?
In my case, unfortunately, yes. TS and Live View so that you can be sure of what you are shooting. It's dawn here; I am waiting to shoot the interior of a beach-side architect-designed house, and I have the 24 PC-E, 14-24, the new 60/2.8 and 105 VR macros. My point is that these are all specialist lenses, all available, and Live View makes them so easy to use with complete confidence.
And an event I am shooting at a local embassy this coming Thursday will rely on the D700's excellent high ISO and handling of mixed and flash light.
Reading the whole thread again, I can appreciate the Sony's great finder, great files and the lack of he need for PP to get top colour, but right now, the combination of Live View, TS lenses, macros and other lenses, the Nikon CLS and the high ISO when needed make the D3/D700 system hard to beat, IMHO. One decent wide TS and Live View (or whatever Sony will call it) and some more AF Zeiss lenses, and the equation will change, to be sure. cheers to all, kl
kosmoskatten wrote:
James, I agree almost to the letter with what you wrote.
I do think it is fair though - on a completely subjective basis - to dismiss a few lenses in a line up as "unnecessary" as with the 14/2.8. A gap in a lens line up only occurs for me when I need that particular lens they cannot provide. There are a few lenses I have never been interested in so I am perhaps more lenient in my idea of a "complete" lens line up.
A complete lens line up in my book starts at around 18-20mm, has at least one really wide T/S lens, some nice wide angle primes a few good 2.8 zooms, a variety of macro lenses, at least two portrait lenses and fast telephoto lenses up to 600/4 and TC's to match. I have honestly not been going through Sonys offerings but if you boil it all down I think they cover a lot of it where as Nikon and Canon has an awful lot of "duplicate" lenses in the line up.
The interesting summary in a comparison for me is:
Does Nikon/Canon offer something I really need that Sony cannot offer? If so, are they working on it or am I left out in the cold. If Sony leaves me out in the cold I will look at something else. A lens line up of 70 lenses is not impressive to me. A lens line up of twenty awesome lenses does cause squeaking sounds from my wallet.
As it stands today, Sony offers most of what is necessary but they do have a few gaps to fill and if they do fill them instead of making similar lenses to what they already offer I will applaud them for that. If their solutions turn out to be mediocre I will look at other options.
I'm not a fan of the 14 2.8, but the 14-24 is spectacular, zoom or not. I think your approach is well thought out. It prevents decisions based on brand and puts the onus on photographic needs.
edwardkaraa wrote:
Funny that you would mention that. I was thinking along the same lines. The M9 would be a great companion to the A900. The colors are equally nice, no AA filter, small body and lenses. The only other alternative would be a D3X, not cheap either. No more Canon for me thanks. The colors suck big time and still do even with the newest models.
An M9 with 3 Zeiss lenses to cover the 21-50 range, sounds like a good idea. And the ZM in this range are actually cheaper than the ZF.2 (and they focus the right way )
I'm keeping my D3 as a complement to the M9 (with a 35 cron, 50 lux, and 90 cron). I wanted a D3X but its ISO performance is similar to the M9. Now, I'm certain in a year, or so, a D3s will be in my bag.
mawz wrote:
Nikon users can walk into any Nikon Dealer and buy those lenses. Sony users need to track down used copies, which are somewhat rare. Very different situation.
They are not rare...well the 35 f2 is, but the 35 1.4 is in production. The 24 2.8 is available on ebay all the time
But you do have very limited options unless you want to go searching for moderately to extremely rare used lenses it's a lot easier to find those exotic Nikon lenses used than the pedestrian 35/2 or 24/2.8 Minolta's.
I'm not sure why you keep calling the 35 2 RS pedestrian when it's a very good lens and possibly better than Nikon's 35 f2. I don't believe either Nikon's 24 2.8 or Minolta are that great, so I'm not sure why you would want them in the first place.
In fact, with the 14-24 on the Nikon side, I don't see why you'd want any of these primes in that range ... and 16-35 is a very good performer in that range.
m_appeal wrote: mawz wroteNikon users can walk into any Nikon Dealer and buy those lenses. Sony users need to track down used copies, which are somewhat rare. Very different situation.They are not rare...well the 35 f2 is, but the 35 1.4 is in production. The 24 2.8 is available on ebay all the time
Earlier quoteBut you do have very limited options unless you want to go searching for moderately to extremely rare used lenses it's a lot easier to find those exotic Nikon lenses used than the pedestrian 35/2 or 24/2.8 Minolta's.I'm not sure why you keep calling the 35 2 RS pedestrian when it's a very good lens and possibly better than Nikon's 35 f2.
Doesn't matter how good it is if it is very difficult to obtain. The 35f1.4 is large; expensive; and frankly from the reviews I've seen not that great.
Kit Laughlin wrote:
Hey Henrik; Kit here. You wrote:
Earlier quoteDoes Nikon/Canon offer something I really need that Sony cannot offer?In my case, unfortunately, yes. TS and Live View so that you can be sure of what you are shooting. It's dawn here; I am waiting to shoot the interior of a beach-side architect-designed house, and I have the 24 PC-E, 14-24, the new 60/2.8 and 105 VR macros. My point is that these are all specialist lenses, all available, and Live View makes them so easy to use with complete confidence.
And an event I am shooting at a local embassy this coming Thursday will rely on the D700's excellent high ISO and handling of mixed and flash light.
Reading the whole thread again, I can appreciate the Sony's great finder, great files and the lack of he need for PP to get top colour, but right now, the combination of Live View, TS lenses, macros and other lenses, the Nikon CLS and the high ISO when needed make the D3/D700 system hard to beat, IMHO. One decent wide TS and Live View (or whatever Sony will call it) and some more AF Zeiss lenses, and the equation will change, to be sure. cheers to all, kl
...Show more →
Not meant as a debate since I own none of them but why nikon over canon? Is it due to imaging quality of bodies; lenses or just personal preference ?
For me the sony is very intriguing and if the 35f2 was readily available (and as good as folks suggest) then would be reasonable option; but as far Sony has no interest in producing more zeiss primes (other than perhaps a rumored 24f1.4) and the zooms; while very good do not make a system nor are my cup of tea (but i'm just repeating what i've written before). (the 35 is critical for me because then I could at least have a usable system of 35/50/{85 or 135}.
Specularist wrote:
The A900/A850, D700 and 5D Mark II together prove that digital SLRs are still in their infancy. These cameras each have serious drawbacks in addition to their remarkable capabilities.
The A900 has worse high-ISO performance than the best crop-sensor cameras, lacks Live View, inherited the proprietary Minolta flash shoe, can't record to both memory cards simultaneously, and doesn't have much in the way of in-production lens selection (though there are a few great ones).
On the plus side, it has superior overall craftsmanship, a far better viewfinder than the others, it surely looks prettier on the shelf, and more importantly: it has the best outright image quality (at low ISO). It offers superb resolution and colour, and it probably does have the largest usable dynamic range of the trio at base ISO, though the D700 would push it very close (and significantly lower noise in the mid-tones). Whether Sony will expand and support the Alpha system at the high end for another two, five, ten years is anyone's guess.
The D700 is a far more accomplished camera than the others in many ways. Its autofocus is in a different league, it can shoot at 8 fps, it has vastly shorter mirror black-out and shutter-lag times than the other two, it's designed with an attention to detail that Canon hasn't achieved in decades and that Sony won't achieve for years, and it's the best low-light camera on the market except for the new D3S.
But these advantages are tied to a sensor and antialiasing filter that result in vaguely soft 12-megapixel images: unacceptable to many in late 2009, if only because other cameras do so much better. Read noise is too high too, resulting in lack-lustre low-ISO dynamic range compared to the high-ISO performance. The little built-in flash compromises the top-half, and worse, it's just ridiculous. The viewfinder is the worst of the lot, with 95% coverage and no official options for a decent focusing screen. The camera is limited to 5 fps without the grip, for no obvious reason other than selling overpriced grips. The D700 is also the most over-complicated way in history to select an f-stop and shutter speed (the manual has 450 pages and would need more).
The 5D Mark II has the shapeless, androgynous design—if it can be called design—of all the big EOS cameras (its slouched shoulders one of many sins Luigi Colani has committed against the world). Inside are more features than you can shake a stick at, most of them half-baked. It shoots bad video, has a crap shutter, uses yesteryear's autofocus, and offers a selection of ISO speeds from 100 to far-too-high, none of them class-leading but all of them tolerable enough.
This camera wins praise for detail retention, but only by using a weak antialiasing filter that encourages false colour at the drop of a hat. The colour filter array isn't very colourful. The build and construction are fussy and obviously of a lower standard than the D700 or A900; but no-one cares about that these days. There are more EOS lenses than anyone could ever want, most of them also pretty crap. Some of them though, are better than any comparable lenses by anyone, bar none. But its biggest flaw is inexcusable: it suffers from worse shadow banding than any camera in recent memory. Any old DSLR has better usable dynamic range at base ISO.
If the A900 is a low-ISO tripod expert and the D700 an action camera, the 5D Mark II is a Jack of all trades and master of none. Its perfect blend of mediocrity appeals to me not at all (in case you didn't notice ).
To add insult to injury, all three of these cameras are heavier and much larger than they should be. Even the Sony, which is the best built of the three, should be better built for the price. And the price is very high for cameras with such flaws.
As someone above said, pick your poison, because none of these cameras are anywhere near perfect. I suppose that's the result of just three Japanese companies "competing" against each other....Show more →
m_appeal wrote: mawz wroteNikon users can walk into any Nikon Dealer and buy those lenses. Sony users need to track down used copies, which are somewhat rare. Very different situation.They are not rare...well the 35 f2 is, but the 35 1.4 is in production. The 24 2.8 is available on ebay all the time
And the 35/1.4 is not well suited to many uses, it's a specialist lens suited primarily to work where outright speed is the main requirement and centre sharpness is far more important than edge performance. Given a choice between the two, I'd take the 35/2 any day of the week for general use. But getting one is difficult. The 24/2.8 is much easier to get but is still not anything approaching common.
Earlier quoteBut you do have very limited options unless you want to go searching for moderately to extremely rare used lenses it's a lot easier to find those exotic Nikon lenses used than the pedestrian 35/2 or 24/2.8 Minolta's.I'm not sure why you keep calling the 35 2 RS pedestrian when it's a very good lens and possibly better than Nikon's 35 f2. I don't believe either Nikon's 24 2.8 or Minolta are that great, so I'm not sure why you would want them in the first place.
In fact, with the 14-24 on the Nikon side, I don't see why you'd want any of these primes in that range ... and 16-35 is a very good performer in that range.
Stick a 24/2.8 from either maker beside those zooms and you'll see why I want the option, not everybody wants to haul 1Kg zooms everywhere. Both lenses are thoroughly competent but not exceptional (well, the Nikon was exceptional when introduced, but that was in the late 60's. It's an old design which has aged surprisingly well through a half-dozen variations)
The 35/2 is pedestrian lens when compared to exotics like a 14/2.8. That's a commentary on how common and useful the lens is, not the quality of said lens. A 35/2 or a 24/2.8 are bread & butter lenses of a reasonably complete lineup. And ones which Sony lacks. NIkon on the other hand does not lack in bread & butter lenses OR the more exotic ultra-wides which are totally lacking in the Sony line.
you2 wrote:
Doesn't matter how good it is if it is very difficult to obtain. The 35f1.4 is large; expensive; and frankly from the reviews I've seen not that great.
It's actually rather compact, being marginally smaller and lighter than the Zeiss ZF 35/2. It's also a quite good lens when viewed in regards to its original place in the Minolta lens lineup, as a high-speed alternative to a 35/2 for when you need speed for low-light event/PJ work. An excellent lens as a second 35 in the line, however not a replacement for a good 35/2 as a general purpose lens.
Overall, the problem with the Sony lineup is a lack of options, not quality. The only poor lens in the prime lineup is the 28/2.8. But Sony made some unfortunate choices when they picked which lenses to produce. They should have chosen the 35/2 and 24/2.8 or 28/2 over the 35G and the 28/2.8. Sony really is assuming that you're going to go for f2.8 zooms over all other options on FF.
The 35/2 is pedestrian lens when compared to exotics like a 14/2.8.
Not sure which 35 f2 you are talking about, but the 35 f2 RS isn't pedestrian compared to anything.
A 35/2 or a 24/2.8 are bread & butter lenses of a reasonably complete lineup. And ones which Sony lacks.
It doesn't lack them for the most part... it has choices (perhaps less readily available), but you just don't like them or you want additional choices. I agree that 35 1.4 is an expensive one...
NIkon on the other hand does not lack in bread & butter lenses OR the more exotic ultra-wides which are totally lacking in the Sony line.
14mm *is* exotic... you don't really absolutely need that focal lens... again... it's want vs need. Nikon doesn't have good quality zooms in the 70-300 range and 80-400 r- which hasn't been updated in ages. It does have the 200-400 for which you have to pay tons of $. Sony on the other hands offers 70-300 and 70-400 both of which are visibly superior to the Nikon counterparts. I personally think these are very important zooms... and Sony offers better quality in that area.
m_appeal wrote: Earlier quoteThe 35/2 is pedestrian lens when compared to exotics like a 14/2.8.Not sure which 35 f2 you are talking about, but the 35 f2 RS isn't pedestrian compared to anything.
You seem to be purposely misunderstanding me here. 35/2 is a pedestrian focal length. I'm not commenting on the optics but rather the place in the lineup compared to exotics like a 14/2.8.
Earlier quoteA 35/2 or a 24/2.8 are bread & butter lenses of a reasonably complete lineup. And ones which Sony lacks.It doesn't lack them for the most part... it has choices (perhaps less readily available), but you just don't like them or you want additional choices. I agree that 35 1.4 is an expensive one, but hey, they
I'd settle for options that I can buy without jumping through hoops. As in a lens which I can walk into a major retailer and purchase(or at least order). The 35/1.4 is very good at what it does but it's unsuitable for landscape or architectural work and a general-purpose 35/2 is unavailable for all intents and purposes. Any lens which I'd have to spend at least a couple weeks haunting eBay or KEH to get my mitts on is not really acceptable as an alternative when comparing systems, no matter how good the lens is.
Earlier quoteNIkon on the other hand does not lack in bread & butter lenses OR the more exotic ultra-wides which are totally lacking in the Sony line.14mm *is* exotic... you don't really absolutely need that focal lens... again... it's want vs need. Nikon doesn't have good quality zooms in the 70-300 range and 80-400 r- which hasn't been updated in ages. It does have the 200-400 for which you have to pay tons of $. Sony on the other hands offers 70-300 and 70-400 both of which are visibly superior to the Nikon counterparts.
The point on the 14 is that I can walk into any Nikon dealer and buy one. Nikon's exotics are more readily available than non-exotic lenses like a 35/2 or 24/2.8 for Sony.
Actually Nikon's got a very good 70-300 available, it's Canon that lacks a truly good 70-300 in the sub-$1000 market. The 70-300VR may not be quite up to the standards of the 70-300G, but it's a damned good lens overall and matches or exceeds the optical performance of some higher-end lenses (like the 70-200 VR). The 70-300G is not a significantly better lens than the 70-300VR and the Nikon is around $300 cheaper. I've seen nothing which indicates more than a marginal difference between the two.
And yes, Sony's 70-400G is superb. Best lens in its range and Nikon's 80-400VR is mediocre at best. The 200-400 on the other hand simply blows the 70-400G out of the water in performance but costs about twice as much. Nikon users have been bitching about this for years. But x0-400 lenses are not exactly bread & butter lenses in a lineup, but rather lenses which round out a lineup. Sony's lineup is much stronger in the telephoto side than it is in the wide-angle side of things. The only thing Sony is really lacking is a 300/4 prime and maybe a 200mm prime.
m_appeal wrote:
14mm *is* exotic... you don't really absolutely need that focal lens... again... it's want vs need. Nikon doesn't have good quality zooms in the 70-300 range and 80-400 r- which hasn't been updated in ages. It does have the 200-400 for which you have to pay tons of $. Sony on the other hands offers 70-300 and 70-400 both of which are visibly superior to the Nikon counterparts. I personally think these are very important zooms... and Sony offers better quality in that area.
Nikon is reworking its lens line-up. The Nikon's 35 f2 isn't a great lens. I would be interest to see how the 70-200 VR II matches up to Sony's. I don't have much interest in slow lenses ranging from 70's to 300/400. I have seen few fix wides that match Nikon's 14-24 at comparable mm. But, this is not necessarily a reason to switch, unless it meets your need.
I know you are a big supported of Sony, so, I'm not going to argue one camera against another. However, putting aside cost, the thing that keeps me tethered to Nikon is its CLS lighting. I don't know much about Sony's flash system, but, I would have heard rumbling if superior to Nikon's. There are many things beyond lenses that attract a shooter.
James R wrote:
Nikon is reworking its lens line-up. The Nikon's 35 f2 isn't a great lens. I would be interest to see how the 70-200 VR II matches up to Sony's. I don't have much interest in slow lenses ranging from 70's to 300/400. I have seen few fix wides that match Nikon's 14-24 at comparable mm. But, this is not necessarily a reason to switch, unless it meets your need.
Yeah, it depends on your needs... I like to have sharp 70-300 and 70-400 lenses... for daylight shooting these are great if you don't have to haul a 70-200 2.8 or primes.
I know you are a big supported of Sony, so, I'm not going to argue one camera against another. However, putting aside cost, the thing that keeps me tethered to Nikon is its CLS lighting. I don't know much about Sony's flash system, but, I would have heard rumbling if superior to Nikon's. There are many things beyond lenses that attract a shooter.
I'm not as much a big supporter of Sony... I just don't think they are lacking as much as it's being said compared to others or at least they have their own lenses which are the best.. Nikon's flash system should be quite a better than Sony's...or more developed at least.
I'd settle for options that I can buy without jumping through hoops. As in a lens which I can walk into a major retailer and purchase(or at least order). The 35/1.4 is very good at what it does but it's unsuitable for landscape or architectural work and a general-purpose 35/2 is unavailable for all intents and purposes. Any lens which I'd have to spend at least a couple weeks haunting eBay or KEH to get my mitts on is not really acceptable as an alternative when comparing systems, no matter how good the lens is.
That's your choice, but it is doable... not as available maybe, but you can get it if you look for it.
NIkon on the other hand does not lack in bread & butter lenses OR the more exotic ultra-wides which are totally lacking in the Sony line.
Nikon's 70-300 isn't sharp at 300mm... or at least my copy which was supposedly good wasn't great. I'm not sure if anybody else's good copies are different.
. The 200-400 on the other hand simply blows the 70-400G out of the water in performance but costs about twice as much. Nikon users have been bitching about this for years. But x0-400 lenses are not exactly bread & butter lenses in a lineup, but rather lenses which round out a lineup.
I personally think 70-300 / 70-400 type zoom *is* much more bread and butter than a 24 2.8 or whatever... it's a very versatile daylight zoom... And "blows out of the water"
Sony's lineup is much stronger in the telephoto side than it is in the wide-angle side of things. The only thing Sony is really lacking is a 300/4 prime and maybe a 200mm prime.
Again, they have the Minolta 200mm 2.8 and 300/4 prime. I know all of these lenses are more difficult to get due to the fact they are not in production, but it's not THAT difficult if you look around.
Well, it looks like my first experience with a Sony DSLR system turns out to be a rather lousy one. My A850 and Sony 50mm 1.4 seem to back-focus so strongly that even dialling in a max. fine-tune of -20 doesn't fully correct it, although it gets close. So, before I return these lemons, is there anything I may have forgotten on the way? I know how to use a camera, so unless there's some kind of magic thing or issue with the Sony way, one or both of these are a lemon.
mortyb wrote:
Well, it looks like my first experience with a Sony DSLR system turns out to be a rather lousy one. My A850 and Sony 50mm 1.4 seem to back-focus so strongly that even dialling in a max. fine-tune of -20 doesn't fully correct it, although it gets close. So, before I return these lemons, is there anything I may have forgotten on the way? I know how to use a camera, so unless there's some kind of magic thing or issue with the Sony way, one or both of these are a lemon.
Make sure that 'Spot' is selected in the manu option for 'AF area'. If wide or local are selected, that could be your issue. The other menu option I have set is 'AF-A' for the 'AF-A setup' option. For testing, you also might make sure that 'S' is selected for the focusing mode on the front of the camera near the lens mount and that 'steady shot' is turned off. If it is none of these, then you may have received the one bad camera Sony made (I say that because in a recent Consumer Reports article on digital cameras, Sony is rated above both Canon and Nikon for reliability/defects in the DSLR category).
Nah, same results. Ony changed to 'Spot'. Using -20 it's about there, although I'd guess a couple of clicks more would have been even better. Anyway, I've lost confidence in these two, and they are going back.
m_appeal wrote: Earlier quoteI'd settle for options that I can buy without jumping through hoops. As in a lens which I can walk into a major retailer and purchase(or at least order). The 35/1.4 is very good at what it does but it's unsuitable for landscape or architectural work and a general-purpose 35/2 is unavailable for all intents and purposes. Any lens which I'd have to spend at least a couple weeks haunting eBay or KEH to get my mitts on is not really acceptable as an alternative when comparing systems, no matter how good the lens is.That's your choice, but it is doable... not as available maybe, but you can get it if you look for it.
Yep, and I personally probably would (I expect to end up shooting Sony FF at some point). But you simply can't say two systems are comparable when you have to go searching seriously for used copies of lenses in one system which are commonly available in most stores for the other.
Earlier quoteNIkon on the other hand does not lack in bread & butter lenses OR the more exotic ultra-wides which are totally lacking in the Sony line.Nikon's 70-300 isn't sharp at 300mm... or at least my copy which was supposedly good wasn't great. I'm not sure if anybody else's good copies are different.
My experience with the 70-300VR was weak at 300 compared to shorter lengths, but not poor. The 70-300G definitely performs a bit better at 300, but at shorter lengths the two are indistinguishable.
. Earlier quoteThe 200-400 on the other hand simply blows the 70-400G out of the water in performance but costs about twice as much. Nikon users have been bitching about this for years. But x0-400 lenses are not exactly bread & butter lenses in a lineup, but rather lenses which round out a lineup.I personally think 70-300 / 70-400 type zoom *is* much more bread and butter than a 24 2.8 or whatever... it's a very versatile daylight zoom... And "blows out of the water"
The 200-400 is critically sharp wide open and with a TC14E mounted, it's better at f4 and 400mm than the 70-400G is at 400 and f8 (and that's saying something, as the 70-400 is a superb lens). It's an absolutely stunning lens. But it's huge and expensive. I'd agree that a 70-300 type zoom is bread & butter, but the longer 70-400's are specialist lenses (as the price difference between the two attests).
Earlier quoteSony's lineup is much stronger in the telephoto side than it is in the wide-angle side of things. The only thing Sony is really lacking is a 300/4 prime and maybe a 200mm prime.Again, they have the Minolta 200mm 2.8 and 300/4 prime. I know all of these lenses are more difficult to get due to the fact they are not in production, but it's not THAT difficult if you look around.
Once again, these lenses are NOT in Sony's lineup. They're available used if a dedicated person goes looking for them but that does not make them part of the lineup. A lens lineup is what one can actually order. And the 300/4 is once again somewhat hard to find.
mortyb wrote:
Nah, same results. Ony changed to 'Spot'. Using -20 it's about there, although I'd guess a couple of clicks more would have been even better. Anyway, I've lost confidence in these two, and they are going back.
I'd try a second lens first. It's more likely that a $300 lens has an issue than that the body's got problems, and easier to resolve too.