fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2008 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2008So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!

  
 
Hrow
Offline
Details
p.5 #1So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Gnarl wrote:
Alan321 wrote:
...
I can't afford the financial loss to abandon all of my Canon gear but I'm surely not going to rush into another Canon DSLR purchase with any currect model or any new model within three months of release. I've also put the brakes on my Canon lens purchases....

- Alan

Alan, my sentiments exactly. As the saying goes, "fool me once shame on you, fool me twice shame on me"...



I've held off on an 85L and an MP-E 65mm. No point in buying while a switch is a possibility. Not the same league as not buying a 600mm but you get enough of these together and it starts to make a difference.

The other factor is that even when a small number of people shift you see a big increase in the number of lenses that hit the used market, thus diluting potential new lens sales.


Mar 05, 2008 at 10:11 PM
MedHead
Offline
Details
p.5 #2So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
To those switching to Nikon:

Did your EOS-1D Mark II N suddenly stop working? Are your lenses now made of putty? Canon screwed up on their latest camera - that doesn't mean the earlier version is now worthless! Wait it out and get the III when it is finally fixed. Switching entirely for the sake of one camera seems rather petty, considering the lineup of lenses and bodies that have performed so well in Canon's selection.
Mar 05, 2008 at 10:14 PM
AGeoJO
Online
Details
p.5 #3So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
MedHead/David, do you work for Canon ? Just kidding....
Mar 05, 2008 at 10:24 PM
Hrow
Offline
Details
p.5 #4So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
MedHead wrote:
To those switching to Nikon:

Did your EOS-1D Mark II N suddenly stop working? Are your lenses now made of putty? Canon screwed up on their latest camera - that doesn't mean the earlier version is now worthless! Wait it out and get the III when it is finally fixed. Switching entirely for the sake of one camera seems rather petty, considering the lineup of lenses and bodies that have performed so well in Canon's selection.



You assume that those considering switching had/have a MkII. I don't.

You assume that everyone liked the the 1DMkII. I never was much of a fan which is why I didn't buy one new and why I am even less thrilled about buying one used.

Mar 05, 2008 at 10:38 PM
jkurkjia
Offline
Details
p.5 #5So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Hrow wrote:
You assume that everyone liked the the 1DMkII. I never was much of a fan which is why I didn't buy one new and why I am even less thrilled about buying one used.



Too bad because you are missing out on one heck of a camera; it's great for sports, action wildlife shots, and when you put a 17-40 on it you wind up with great landscapes.

Regards,

Joe Kurkjian
Mar 05, 2008 at 10:42 PM
Canon 10D
Offline
Details
p.5 #6So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
I have a feeling that 1D Mark III N is going to Beijing with me this summer, and I can hear it calling my name already. We will be sharing the same hotel room and sleep on the same bed. I am, however, always wrong on this kind of thing.

One thing I know for sure is that the final fix will definitely come before the big game.

Those who know can't post; those who don't know (like me) post

Edited by Canon 10D on Mar 06, 2008 at 12:34 AM GMT

Edited on Mar 05, 2008 at 11:34 PM
Mar 05, 2008 at 11:32 PM
sivrajbm
Offline
Details
p.5 #7So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
What did you guys do with Ruckus
That guy smelled like troll
Mar 05, 2008 at 11:33 PM
dvarnav
Offline
Details
p.5 #8So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
drisley said
As I was looking through those, I immediately thought the top half of pictures looked better, more colour and contrast, with a nicer, smoother tone. Then I realized they were the 1D MK3 pictures! The quality is close, but the D3 images do look a little "plasticky" a term I hear a lot about the D3 output. The reds look especially bad to me.

Also I noticed that on the D3 photos and now I am conviced that all the photos that I have seen from Digital Nikon cameras are more plastic coloured than Canons DSLRS and thats due to the sensor diferences between the 2 companies. This is avery well known issue that many sports photographers really do not care

Edited on Mar 05, 2008 at 11:49 PM
Mar 05, 2008 at 11:48 PM
MedHead
Offline
Details
p.5 #9So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Hrow wrote:
You assume that those considering switching had/have a MkII. I don't.

That's quite a small group of people you're mentioning. Why would you switch to a different brand when you're not part of the demographic that's affected? Replace "MKII" with any Canon camera that you own, if it makes it easier: the fact remains that, even if Canon stops producing good cameras, your current Canon camera will continue to take pictures.

Hrow wrote:
You assume that everyone liked the the 1DMkII. I never was much of a fan which is why I didn't buy one new and why I am even less thrilled about buying one used.

Those that have invested heavily in the Canon brand are likely going to be using something other than Rebels, and a MKII to MKIII purchase was the most logical example for me to use. Again, if you're stuck on my use of "MKII", replace it with the camera model of your choice. My point was that those who were stating they were switching to a different brand because of one bad model (MKIII) were welcome to go back to their previous camera.

I don't own either camera, as I can only afford a 30D. The Canon 40D is a superior camera to my own, and I would one day like to be able to re-afford the **D line. Despite my wish to one day purchase a 40D, my 30D continues to satisfy my needs, and I am in no way discontent that I have the camera. Now, if Canon's next **D (say, a "50D") were to come out with massive failures, would it make sense for me to throw away my 30D and move to Nikon, despite my satisfaction with the 30D? In my opinion, that would be crazy.

The "jump ship" folks just seem more focused on buying gear than taking photographs, and that attitude seemed prevalent to me with this thread. It was like they were looking for an excuse to proclaim their departure from the brand.

Oh, and no, I don't work for Canon. I just like my camera, which happens to be a Canon.

Edited on Mar 06, 2008 at 12:44 AM
Mar 06, 2008 at 12:42 AM
James R
Offline
Details
p.5 #10So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
dvarnav wrote:
drisley said
As I was looking through those, I immediately thought the top half of pictures looked better, more colour and contrast, with a nicer, smoother tone. Then I realized they were the 1D MK3 pictures! The quality is close, but the D3 images do look a little "plasticky" a term I hear a lot about the D3 output. The reds look especially bad to me.

Also I noticed that on the D3 photos and now I am conviced that all the photos that I have seen from Digital Nikon cameras are more plastic coloured than Canons DSLRS and thats due to the sensor diferences between the 2 companies. This is avery well known issue that many sports photographers really do not care


Gee, the pros I know complain about Canon's producing too much red. I have never complained or had a complaint that my D3 produced bad "reds." Please, take a look at Dave Black's work on his website, or any other pro shooting the D3 and point out a "bad" red. I much prefer to look at photos taken by people who know how to use the the D3 or 1D3 than test shots from somebody who doesn't use the camera everyday. I can take a 1D3 and muck the shots up big time because I'm not familiar with camera and its controls. Heck I mucked up a few D3 shots as I was getting familiar with the camera.

I obviously don't get this claim that the D3 produces plastic pics. I've seen 1D3 and D3 shots that I can't tell which was which. All these cameras produce good stuff, I don't think all this comparison and finger pointing does much good. Unless it makes you feel better about your camera system.



Edited on Mar 06, 2008 at 01:18 AM
Mar 06, 2008 at 01:16 AM
Peter Woods
Offline
Details
p.5 #11So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
James R wrote:
I obviously don't get this claim that the D3 produces plastic pics. I've seen 1D3 and D3 shots that I can't tell which was which. All these cameras produce good stuff, I don't think all this comparison and finger pointing does much good. Unless it makes you feel better about your camera system.



Well said James, lets all just go out there and take great pictures

Edited on Mar 06, 2008 at 02:31 AM
Mar 06, 2008 at 02:30 AM
Chris Dees
Offline
Details
p.5 #12So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
So my 1DMkIII is fixed by declaration.
Someone want to buy a used 1D3?

At this moment mine is at the repair centre for the 3rd time.
I'm not too hopefull they fix it
Mar 06, 2008 at 03:25 AM
Hrow
Offline
Details
p.5 #13So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
MedHead,

You and quite a few others miss the very basic point that a camera is but a tool and that tool is only one component in a system. If the tool fails to the job then it is necessary to look for another tool. If another brand's tool does the job in the manner you need then it is perfectly logic to take a good, long look at that brand.

Does my 20D still take good pictures? Sure, in fact it takes better pictures than my 1DMkIII. Does it take the type of pictures I want it to? No. That's why I bought the 1DMkIII. You see, different cameras actually serve different purposes and markets. They take different types of images. Different cameras are different which is why manufacturers make them.

While you are quite satisfied with the 30D (a fine camera BTW) it does not meet my needs. Nor does the 5D or a 1DsMkII. The 1DMkII does meet my needs but I have always found the controls to be clumsy. Other people love them, I hate them. No right or wrong here, just differences. Other than the 1DMkIII, Canon doesn't have a body that meets my needs and preferences. That doesn't mean that they don't have good bodies. You really have to understand the difference.

For me, in my price range and for my needs (please note the use of the word "my"), the only bodies that fit the bill are the Canon 1DMkIII and the Nikon D3. I am not going to lose a shooting season while Canon continues to f*&k around and try to fix my camera. Three times they have sent it back and said it was working within spec. Three times the OOF problems got worse and worse.

If people are suggesting that we take Canon at their word that the problem is fixed because they have declared it to be so, then we'll do the same thing for my camera, they declared that fixed as well. If that's the case then I have to tell you that Canon's factory standard of excellence is "fuzzy."

Since the body is but one component in the system one must take a good look at the lenses they use. Nikon and Canon have different strengths and weaknesses and those have to be weighed in to the equation. Makes it a tough decision with no clear and easy answer which is why so many people ask various questions about how the two systems compare. Those that are asking are the smart ones.

To end, you have to understand that the job of the photographer is to create images, not to take pictures. Once you do understand that you will also understand why so much thought goes into the process and why the little differences are of importance.

Mar 06, 2008 at 06:49 AM
blonde
Offline
Details
p.5 #14So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Hrow,

i really don't understand why you would even waste your time arguing over this. it is clear that your camera and many other's as well are not fixed and even if Canon puts out 200 more press releases and Ruckus will meet 10 more people with no issues it still won't make your camera fixed.

also, i fully understand where you are coming from regarding the mkII and other Canon cameras. if you can't find any other camera other than the mkIII in the canon lineup that will work for you, switch to Nikon and don't look back. just do whatever you need to do to be happy and if that means buying the D3 (amazing camera btw) so be it.

Edited by blonde on Mar 06, 2008 at 02:56 PM GMT

Edited on Mar 06, 2008 at 08:56 AM
Mar 06, 2008 at 08:10 AM
mill4570
Offline
Details
p.5 #15So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
I am glad to see this thread power back some. Calling posters names and discounting their opinion based on the length time they have been a member, is not what FM does.

Canon has stated the MKIII will outperform other 1D cameras based on their tests. They probably ran a series of both high and low light, plus high and low contrast tests for both One Shot and AI Servo. They are saying "overall" the MKIII is better. They are not saying the MKIII won every test, I'm sure it didn't. Plus I doubt any of us will see the test results. I believe a properly working MKIII is going to be operate similar to what RG has found in his tests. If Canon shot more low light than Rob, then overall the MKIII might win out.

Henry, your camera is broken ....period. I don't know what else can be said. If the loaner you had this past weekend did not perform to your satisfaction.....your choice is clear.

To everyone who insists we all jump ship to Nikon.....what would you have us do when the MKIV comes out and blows the doors off the Nikon D3? Jump back to Canon to teach Nikon a lesson?

Professional photographers do not jump from brand to brand using the excuse that the camera is only a tool. Pros buy new equipment or change brands only when their business is or could be affected in one way or another.

Richard K.

Edited on Mar 06, 2008 at 08:24 AM
Mar 06, 2008 at 08:21 AM
R Longenbach
Offline
Details
p.5 #16So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Well Canon response or not, my MkIII is going back to the service center for the third time (2nd was for the submirror). I had a keeper rate of 38% marginally acceptable from a batch of AI Servo, and the true keeper rate was closer to 10%. What made me finally pull the trigger on it was when I looked in Imagebrowser, and the AF point was the center, and the camera was focusing on items not in the center; and it also seemed to be favoring focus on one side kind of like what Jeff's camera was doing.

I bought the 1DMk3 for the larger buffer, modern processing (at the time, DigicIII), and the better than XXD/5D AF. I had no problems with the servo AF with my old EOS-3, and a much higher keeper rate! The MkIII's AF should be at least the same as a 10 year old film camera! So yes, while some are probably great, I for one am not happy about the tone of what Canon decided to post.
Mar 06, 2008 at 09:38 AM
CMOS
Offline
Details
p.5 #17So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
mill4570 wrote:
Pros buy new equipment or change brands only when their business is or could be affected in one way or another.
Richard K.


And when your gear is repeatedly in shipment to and from Canon and not working right even when you do have it, that affects your business.

What about the psychological hit on the shooter? You are out there shooting your subject and you just don't know for sure if you are getting the shots in focus. You need that confidence when shooting. If you are on a job and have to repeatedly worry if you are getting the shot, you are toast. You need to focus on creating whatever it is that you are trying to create, not whether the silly AF is cheesing out on you.

So yes, this affects business. That's why Canon reps flew out to the Australia Open when photogs had problems (http://www.robgalbraith.com/bins/content_page.asp?cid=7-9258-9300)

Edited on Mar 06, 2008 at 09:53 AM
Mar 06, 2008 at 09:52 AM
Jeff
Offline
Details
p.5 #18So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
How can you guys not ignore someone with a screen name like 'ruckus'?

Mar 06, 2008 at 10:08 AM
mill4570
Offline
Details
p.5 #19So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
CMOS wrote:
mill4570 wrotePros buy new equipment or change brands only when their business is or could be affected in one way or another.
Richard K.
And when your gear is repeatedly in shipment to and from Canon and not working right even when you do have it, that affects your business.

What about the psychological hit on the shooter? You are out there shooting your subject and you just don't know for sure if you are getting the shots in focus. You need that confidence when shooting. If you are on a job and have to repeatedly worry if you are getting the shot, you are toast. You need to focus on creating whatever it is that you are trying to create, not whether the silly
...Show more →

So you are telling me the camera is affecting "your" business. If that is the case.....switch. But remember...never trust your business to any new piece of equipment. I and some others kept our MKII's until such time as the MKIII proved itself. In my case, I trust my MKIII for any gigs where One Shot AF is used,(weddings) or low light Servo AF (Friday Night Lights). In bright sun or very high contrast lighting, the MKIIN is still just as good as ever.

CMOS, If you are taking a questionable piece of equipment on a job where you worry more about the equipment than the final image, then you are making the mistake, not Canon. The psychological hit you describe is self imposed. I and some others have not lost a nickel due to the MKIII. The camera is tax deductible, and I have found areas where I can use it without worry. Canon has paid for all shipping and repairs to the camera so far, and although I don't believe it is completely fixed, it is not hurting my reputation as a photographer. If it did, that would be my fault not Canon's. Canon is responsible for providing me the camera described in their Whitepaper / Press Release.....the one I paid for. Taking quality images for clients is mine.

Richard K.
Mar 06, 2008 at 10:38 AM
blonde
Offline
Details
p.5 #20So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
mill4570 wrote:
CMOS wrote
mill4570 wrotePros buy new equipment or change brands only when their business is or could be affected in one way or another.
Richard K.
And when your gear is repeatedly in shipment to and from Canon and not working right even when you do have it, that affects your business.

What about the psychological hit on the shooter? You are out there shooting your subject and you just don't know for sure if you are getting the shots in focus. You need that confidence when shooting. If you are on a job and have to repeatedly worry if you are getting the shot, you are toast. You need to focus on creating whatever it is that you are trying to create, not whether the silly AF is cheesing out on you.

So yes, this affects business. That's why Canon reps flew out to the Australia Open when photogs had problems (http://www.robgalbraith.com/bins/content_page.asp?cid=7-9258-9300)
Canon is responsible for providing me the camera described in their Whitepaper / Press Release.....the one I paid for.


and do you feel that Canon did that? i mean provided you with the camera that was described in their whitepaper/ press release?
Mar 06, 2008 at 10:42 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister