fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2008 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2008So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!

  
 
Chris Dees
Offline
Details
p.15 #1So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Wickedfn4u wrote:
Chris Dees wroteIt seems my 1DMkIII is fixed now. Last Thursday I had all my gear calibrated.
This weekend I was out with my 400DO and 500L, shooting birds, etc.
In the past my keeper rate was about 25% and now its above 90%. Almost everything is sharp. I tried to track birds against a "busy" background and no problems.
Yesterday I did a couple of (unscientific) tests in one-shot with my shorter lenses and the were all sharp as well.
So finally, after about 9 monts, I have a proper functioning 1DMkIII
Glad to hear it Chris, my only thought or concern is what happens if you buy a new lens? Do you have to send it in each time for calibration?


I'm afraid I have to send the lens in with the body
But it will take some time before I buy something new from Canon.
My lens kit is complete and I'm looking to Nikon and not to Canon.
Mar 11, 2008 at 11:51 AM
SLD
Offline
Details
p.15 #2So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Chris Dees wrote:
I'm afraid I have to send the lens in with the body
But it will take some time before I buy something new from Canon.
My lens kit is complete and I'm looking to Nikon and not to Canon.



The problem here is that is it the only solution by sending all your lens along with the Mark III to Canon for calibration ?

And why all the sudden your trusted and well performed lens with all your Canon DSLR need to be recalibrated just b/c you got the Mark III ?



Edited on Mar 11, 2008 at 04:31 PM
Mar 11, 2008 at 04:31 PM
Hrow
Offline
Details
p.15 #3So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
The Canon rep who was involved in my second cycle of repairs called today to find out how I made out with cycle #3. Even he agreed that sending all of the lenses in plus any future lenses was not a very elegant solution. As I expressed to him before, they wouldn't be selling many cameras if it was SOP to buy a new body, wait anxiously for its arrival at your doorstep so that you could then pack everything you own up and send it Canon so that they could make it work properly. When viewed from that perspective, Canon's response isn't just silly, it is asinine.

I think it really bothered him that I was so calm when I told him that camera is now confined to a shelf and is totally useless. I very nicely declined his offer of further undefined assistance and informed him that my dealer was working on a solution and if that failed then I wasn't going to bother working within their system any more and would simply litigate it. I think that it finally dawned on him that I am serious and that I am no longer playing the game on their terms.




Mar 11, 2008 at 09:15 PM
jkurkjia
Offline
Details
p.15 #4So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Hrow wrote:
I wasn't going to bother working within their system any more and would simply litigate it.



I'm very sympathetic regarding your situation; it's really unfortunate and of course, a totally frustrating situation from your perspective. That said, just out of curiosity, what would be the basis of your litigation?

The reason I'm curious is it seems to me that the basis (the one I have in my mind) almost becomes a "he said, she said" situation with Canon saying the camera is within their specification and you reply that it's not good enough. How would you prove the camera does not meet Canon's specification? Could you demand to see the specification as part of the court process? Also, if you take Canon to court isn't the burden of proof entirely your responsibility?

Thanks in advance for your reply.

Regards,

Joe Kurkjian
Mar 11, 2008 at 09:56 PM
Chris Dees
Offline
Details
p.15 #5So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
lidesun wrote:
Chris Dees wroteI'm afraid I have to send the lens in with the body
But it will take some time before I buy something new from Canon.
My lens kit is complete and I'm looking to Nikon and not to Canon.
The problem here is that is it the only solution by sending all your lens along with the Mark III to Canon for calibration ?

And why all the sudden your trusted and well performed lens with all your Canon DSLR need to be recalibrated just b/c you got the Mark III ?



They said the calibration of the lenses shouldn't be of any influence. But they did this to make sure to get the best possible AF.
Mar 12, 2008 at 01:49 AM
Hrow
Offline
Details
p.15 #6So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
jkurkjia wrote:
Hrow wroteI wasn't going to bother working within their system any more and would simply litigate it.
I'm very sympathetic regarding your situation; it's really unfortunate and of course, a totally frustrating situation from your perspective. That said, just out of curiosity, what would be the basis of your litigation?

The reason I'm curious is it seems to me that the basis (the one I have in my mind) almost becomes a "he said, she said" situation with Canon saying the camera is within their specification and you reply that it's not good enough. How would you prove the camera does not meet Canon's specification? Could you demand to see the specification as part of the court process?
...Show more →

I have spoken with a lawyer and he is very comfortable with the case. The simple fact is that currently my camera, with a zoom lens on it, can not take an in focus picture at both ends of the zoom range. It is easy to see and can be readily demonstrated just using Live View. 13 x 19 prints are simply appalling. No one would believe that the camera is working right which is what pisses me off so badly. In terms of the basis, there are a number of different "counts" that could be used to start the case and once opened, discovery could be a bitch for Canon and hugely expensive for them.

I am still hoping it doesn't go this way and that an alternative solution can be worked out. All I want is a camera that works or my money back and I'll call it a day.

PS. I am now into my fourth month since the camera has been able to take a single, usable picture.



Edited on Mar 12, 2008 at 05:41 AM
Mar 12, 2008 at 05:37 AM
Yakim Peled
Offline
Details
p.15 #7So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
I wonder what their defence would be in a class action. Camera is within manufacture's specification?

Happy shooting,
Yakim.
Mar 12, 2008 at 06:31 AM
drobertfranz
Offline
Details
p.15 #8So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
icandyimages wrote:
Canon says Mark III fixed, fixed to whos satisfaction?............


MY mk3 is fixed to MY satisfaction. Took 3 trips but now it's better than any Canon body I've used. No excuses for Canon the whole situation is shameful..


Edited on Mar 12, 2008 at 11:38 AM
Mar 12, 2008 at 11:37 AM
Bob Davis
Offline
Details
p.15 #9So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
So my journey begins today. I called Canon's Irvine service center regarding my Mark III 508xxx. I've had it back for about month after patiently wait for nearly 3 months to get it in for service for the AI-SERVO AF recall repair. I have been shooting sports, both in and outdoors, my keeper rate varies but is NOT anywhere close to the rate from my Mark IIn. Nearly the same problem exists, soft or OOF shots. After some discussion with the represenatative and an off-line consult with a supervisor, they will be accepting my Mark III and two lenses; 300 2.8 and and my 70-200 2.8 for calibration. If after calibrating the service techs decide the AF is still in need of additional services they'll foward it on to Virginia. So back to my trusted, old reliable Mark IIn...
Mar 12, 2008 at 11:41 AM
mill4570
Offline
Details
p.15 #10So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Bob Davis wrote:
So my journey begins today. I called Canon's Irvine service center regarding my Mark III 508xxx. I've had it back for about month after patiently wait for nearly 3 months to get it in for service for the AI-SERVO AF recall repair. I have been shooting sports, both in and outdoors, my keeper rate varies but is NOT anywhere close to the rate from my Mark IIn. Nearly the same problem exists, soft or OOF shots. After some discussion with the represenatative and an off-line consult with a supervisor, they will be accepting my Mark III and two lenses;
...Show more →


Bob,

The 300f2.8 and the 70-200f2.8 are my "bread and butter" lenses for sports. Hope you have some serious backup hardware.

Richard K.
Mar 12, 2008 at 12:09 PM
Hrow
Offline
Details
p.15 #11So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Bob Davis wrote:
So my journey begins today. I called Canon's Irvine service center regarding my Mark III 508xxx. I've had it back for about month after patiently wait for nearly 3 months to get it in for service for the AI-SERVO AF recall repair. I have been shooting sports, both in and outdoors, my keeper rate varies but is NOT anywhere close to the rate from my Mark IIn. Nearly the same problem exists, soft or OOF shots. After some discussion with the represenatative and an off-line consult with a supervisor, they will be accepting my Mark III and two lenses;
...Show more →

I am confused. It sounds like your camera had the sub-mirror fix. Is that correct? If so, why would it go back to Va. as I have been told repeatedly by Canon reps that they are only set-up to handle the sub-mirror problem and nothing else.
Mar 12, 2008 at 12:24 PM
apdieb
Offline
Details
p.15 #12So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
I will not allow my camera to go back to VA under any circumstances. Those people (IMHO), are there to perform one task and one only (submirror stopper replacement). They successfully hosed my AF after their "FIX".

Mar 12, 2008 at 01:02 PM
Paul B
Offline
Details
p.15 #13So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
jkurkjia wrote:
Hrow wroteI wasn't going to bother working within their system any more and would simply litigate it.
I'm very sympathetic regarding your situation; it's really unfortunate and of course, a totally frustrating situation from your perspective. That said, just out of curiosity, what would be the basis of your litigation?

The reason I'm curious is it seems to me that the basis (the one I have in my mind) almost becomes a "he said, she said" situation with Canon saying the camera is within their specification and you reply that it's not good enough. How would you prove the camera does not meet Canon's specification? Could you demand to see the specification as part of the court process?
...Show more →

Maybe I'm missing something but Canon's assertion is that the MkIII has the best AF system in the world (or at least better than previous Canon cameras.) There's "third-party" data that it underperforms the MkIIn in many/most situations (the RG report.) Seems to me there's plenty of evidence that Canon will have issues refuting (although it will get into a battle of whether the RG stuff is "right" or not.) Of course, if Canon were really going to fight this (as opposed to just replacing the camera) they'd be forced to come up with detailed info on their specs and why their tests show the MkIII meets those specs. That would certanly be interesting and probably spawn a whole new series of debates and threads all over the place.

Edited on Mar 12, 2008 at 01:09 PM
Mar 12, 2008 at 01:07 PM
Harvey Moore
Offline
Details
p.15 #14So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
hrow said:
I have spoken with a lawyer and he is very comfortable with the case. The simple fact is that currently my camera, with a zoom lens on it, can not take an in focus picture at both ends of the zoom range. It is easy to see and can be readily demonstrated just using Live View. 13 x 19 prints are simply appalling. No one would believe that the camera is working right which is what pisses me off so badly. In terms of the basis, there are a number of different "counts" that could be used to start the case...Show more →

Considering the fact that you are not a pro photog and your income does not depend on this camera body, what damages will you sue for?
Mar 12, 2008 at 02:11 PM
blonde
Offline
Details
p.15 #15So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Harvey Moore wrote:
hrow said:
Earlier quoteI have spoken with a lawyer and he is very comfortable with the case. The simple fact is that currently my camera, with a zoom lens on it, can not take an in focus picture at both ends of the zoom range. It is easy to see and can be readily demonstrated just using Live View. 13 x 19 prints are simply appalling. No one would believe that the camera is working right which is what pisses me off so badly. In terms of the basis, there are a number of different "counts" that could be used to start the case and once opened, discovery could be a bitch for Canon and hugely expensive for them.

I am still hoping it doesn't go this way and that an alternative solution can be worked out. All I want is a camera that works or my money back and I'll call it a day.

PS. I am now into my fourth month since the camera has been able to take a single, usable picture.
Considering the fact that you are not a pro photog and your income does not depend on this camera body, what damages will you sue for?


i don't understand your question. so if i buy a car and it doesn't work (only drives about 20% of the time), i can't sue GM because i am not a professional NASCAR race driver? why can't he just sue them for selling a defective product and not fixing it? he never said that he is going to sue them for emotional damage or loss of income...
Mar 12, 2008 at 02:15 PM
Bob Davis
Offline
Details
p.15 #16So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
My Mark III will first go to Irvine with two lenses to see if there is back/front focusing issue with my Mark III that doesn't seem to happen with my Mark IIn...If after correcting mirco-adjustment, which I don't feel comfortable, nor qualified to do, AND they still think there are some AF problems, IRVINE will forward my gear onto Virginia for more testing/repairs. Or at least that's the story and they're sticking to it.
As for being out-of-service due sending my gear in. Well my fallback lens is my Sigma 120-300 f2.8. Not quite as nimble as my 300 f2.8 but certainly more flexible.
Mar 12, 2008 at 02:52 PM
Harvey Moore
Offline
Details
p.15 #17So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
blonde wrote:
i don't understand your question. so if i buy a car and it doesn't work (only drives about 20% of the time), i can't sue GM because i am not a professional NASCAR race driver? why can't he just sue them for selling a defective product and not fixing it? he never said that he is going to sue them for emotional damage or loss of income...


You don't have to understand it blonde, I was asking hrow.

I am implying nothing, just curious what damages apply here.


Mar 12, 2008 at 03:06 PM
blonde
Offline
Details
p.15 #18So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
oh ok, my bad than.

Edited on Mar 12, 2008 at 03:24 PM
Mar 12, 2008 at 03:23 PM
Hrow
Offline
Details
p.15 #19So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Harvey Moore wrote:
hrow said:
Earlier quoteI have spoken with a lawyer and he is very comfortable with the case. The simple fact is that currently my camera, with a zoom lens on it, can not take an in focus picture at both ends of the zoom range. It is easy to see and can be readily demonstrated just using Live View. 13 x 19 prints are simply appalling. No one would believe that the camera is working right which is what pisses me off so badly. In terms of the basis, there are a number of different "counts" that could be used to start the case and once opened, discovery could be a bitch for Canon and hugely expensive for them.

I am still hoping it doesn't go this way and that an alternative solution can be worked out. All I want is a camera that works or my money back and I'll call it a day.

PS. I am now into my fourth month since the camera has been able to take a single, usable picture.
Considering the fact that you are not a pro photog and your income does not depend on this camera body, what damages will you sue for?


I don't want damages - I want a camera that works or my money back. Pretty simple. I suspect that what the lawyer is interested in is doing a fishing expedition to test the waters for a class action which, along with the likely recovery of legal costs, makes it worth it for him to do it at no cost to me. This is just noise to Canon, they can't even have a meeting on defending a potential suit that won't cost more than the suit itself so I doubt that they will let this get very far, and again, I am still hopeful that a solution is at hand and that none of this will be necessary.








Mar 12, 2008 at 03:28 PM
jkurkjia
Offline
Details
p.15 #20So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Good luck Hrow, I hope you get what you want (refund or camera that works); sounds very reasonable to me.

Regards,

Joe Kurkjian
Mar 12, 2008 at 05:54 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister