AJ Nadershahi wrote: Tom_W wroteHrow wroteMe thinks we have some folks from Canon's PR department trolling around these waters. I'm pretty certain that they're around, but probably not the ones that we think are them. I suspect more reading and less posting. If they want to get a feel for this part of the market.Then maybe we can help them out by reminding them what customer service entails, such as; http://www.crm-daily.com/story.xhtml?story_id=0130008TSE3D
That's an excellent reference. I wonder what it means when a company misses on all six points?
AJ Nadershahi wrote: geniousc wroteI think what Mike1 is trying to tell you is that everything has tolerances and in fact it does. The camera is made in one factory, the lens in another, they meet up in USA. So you are expecting everything to be right on to the millimeter and you don't want to pay very much for it yet your looking for world class precision. And you want availability all over the world?Think about it, no way is this going to happen because there are tolerances. Not with Canon, not with Nikon, not with anybody. JMO Why do think all the new Nikons have microfocus adjustments? Because all of their lenses are right on? No way!Biggest bunch of crock I've recently had the pleasure to read in these forums.
Yes, I am expecting tolerances to be within reasonable limits so that you don't have to receive your new camera and lens, then promptly ship them to a service center to have them brought up to usable levels. (I feel silly just typing this scenario!)
Isn't that what production technology and computer controlled production is supposed to allow? Are we making progess or taking steps backwards?
Tolerances are within reasonable limits *now* not before the mirror box firm ware upgrade. If you don't understand that there are such a thing manufacturing tolerances you just don't know anything about manufacturing. Go to the Nikonians, the first thread is "the never ending front focus back focus issue" Why do you think nikon added microfocus, to take care of the reasonable limits you are talking about that should be tuned in for you, that's why. To take care of your reasonable tolerances!
geniousc wrote: AJ Nadershahi wrotegeniousc wroteI think what Mike1 is trying to tell you is that everything has tolerances and in fact it does. The camera is made in one factory, the lens in another, they meet up in USA. So you are expecting everything to be right on to the millimeter and you don't want to pay very much for it yet your looking for world class precision. And you want availability all over the world?Think about it, no way is this going to happen because there are tolerances. Not with Canon, not with Nikon, not with anybody. JMO Why do think all the new Nikons have microfocus adjustments? Because all of their lenses are right on? No way!Biggest bunch of crock I've recently had the pleasure to read in these forums.
Yes, I am expecting tolerances to be within reasonable limits so that you don't have to receive your new camera and lens, then promptly ship them to a service center to have them brought up to usable levels. (I feel silly just typing this scenario!)
Isn't that what production technology and computer controlled production is supposed to allow? Are we making progess or taking steps backwards?Tolerances are within reasonable limits *now* not before the mirror box firm ware upgrade. If you don't understand that there are such a thing manufacturing tolerances you just don't know anything about manufacturing. Go to the Nikonians, the first thread is "the never ending front focus back focus issue" Why do you think nikon added microfocus, to take care of the reasonable limits you are talking about that should be tuned in for you, that's why. To take care of your reasonable tolerances!
i think that what you are talking about is the tiny amount of back focus front focus which you are right, it is normal and expected. however, what we are talking here is quite different than normal variance. we are talking about serious misfocus which is not normal nor acceptable. we see people that have to dial in +/- 15 just to get their lens to come even close to being in focus.
AJ Nadershahi wrote: Tom_W wroteHrow wroteMe thinks we have some folks from Canon's PR department trolling around these waters. I'm pretty certain that they're around, but probably not the ones that we think are them. I suspect more reading and less posting. If they want to get a feel for this part of the market.Then maybe we can help them out by reminding them what customer service entails, such as; http://www.crm-daily.com/story.xhtml?story_id=0130008TSE3D
don't be silly, they gave you a solution in the form of keep sending all your lenses and bodies to us time and time again or in simple Hebrew words "Leh hapes"
i think that what you are talking about is the tiny amount of back focus front focus which you are right, it is normal and expected. however, what we are talking here is quite different than normal variance. we are talking about serious misfocus which is not normal nor acceptable. we see people that have to dial in +/- 15 just to get their lens to come even close to being in focus.
Yes, you are correct. I really haven't had any of these problems with the two I have owned but I can and do certainly symapthize with people that have had problems. I guess I can't really relate to it properly having not seen it. I have used mine for BIF more than anything, I am amazed at how good it is! I use long lenses that bring out the worst. But I'll tell you something else. When I first got my second camera I felt the need to play with the micro focus adjustment and screwed the whole camera up until I learned how to do it. It's a very dangerous adjustment for the uninformed. Now all my lenses as I recall are set to zero and I get excellent results.
Prior to sending to VA for submirror, I was at 0 on my adjustments...worked fine.
Sent to VA for submirror, and some of my lenses were front focused by feet...ie, in soccer pictures the ground in front of the player 2-3 ft in front was where the focus point was. ALSO, there was some focal plane issues as well..
I sent to Irvine, CA... They acknowledged that the calibration in VA was incorrect and recalibrated. Now, lenses are still all around +10 out of alignment, but at least my focal plane issues are fixed. With +10 on my longer lenses, I can at least get acceptable shots now. Although, I still get the random nothing in focus shots from time to time in bursts.
blonde wrote:
i think that what you are talking about is the tiny amount of back focus front focus which you are right, it is normal and expected. however, what we are talking here is quite different than normal variance. we are talking about serious misfocus which is not normal nor acceptable. we see people that have to dial in +/- 15 just to get their lens to come even close to being in focus.
Well... that also depends on how old the lens is and how often it gets used as well. Which brings us back the calibration part. CPS recommends that we have our lens and cameras checked at least once a year since pros use their cameras more than the "weekend warriors." Sure it costs money, it is part of the business expenses and it also pays for itself. Nobody says that photography is cheap. It never has been cheap, even back in the film days, except that there are less "professional" photographers than there were before the DSLR era. Think about the cost dark room equipment, the costs for bulk rolls of film and chemicals, on top of the "annual" maintainance & checkup. However cameras today are more sophisticated than the Nikon F of the 70's. The design was straightforward. My Nikon F has gone through heavy rain, snow, mud, humidity, etc. It is a lot more durable than any of the cameras today and it never need a battery to boot. In fact, mine has taken a dunk in the river for a minute or so when I dropped it into a riverbank as I slipped and it fell out of my hand. After letting it dry out, it was working fine again. I wouldn't be doing that to my 1D3 today, it would be back at Canon service center on life support. Also, with the sophistication comes complex settings that are built into the camera. IMO I think there are a lot more "Curious Georges" that fiddles with the settings and have no idea what they are for and had no idea what they just did.
Yes I do sympathize with the people that have received the bad batch w/o the sub mirror fix. I think those that received the defective batch should get a new fixed BD replacement. I think this issue has blown way out of proportion. I had the same problem when I had my 1D MK I when I made the transition from film to digital and I was curious. I didn't go about and went on a "customize this camera spree," but instead, ask Canon what they are. Surprisingly, level 1, support had no clue so I had to talk to level 2, who gave me the answers that I needed.
Wow, a few days of being sick & with a lot of time on the net got me this...
Tom_W wrote: Hrow wroteMe thinks we have some folks from Canon's PR department trolling around these waters. I'm pretty certain that they're around, but probably not the ones that we think are them. I suspect more reading and less posting. If they want to get a feel for this part of the market.
I think any PR person engaging in actual posting and arguing regarding a product like this would get their butt in a wringer pretty fast from the company execs. Plus which Canon is not dumb enough to hire someone that would say stuff like what's in the following quote. Give me a break. The MkIII was supposed to be a "low production" camera? (Say what? Canon didn't have an excellent idea from the 1DMkI, 1DMkII and 1DMkIIn what the demand for the camera would be?) If that were true you'd fire not only the PR people that publicly said this but also the market research and production departments for not knowing some basic facts. Quality decreases as demand increases? I guess what that means is that it's impossible for any company to become "large" because by definition as it gets there it starts turning out crap and people don't buy the products.
"I guess quality is decreased as demands have increased....The Mark III was supposed to be a low production camera and the demand had exceeded the supply. Noticed the LONG waiting list for it after it came out, and the "fixed" ones just started to pop up now? Just ask ANY Leica (minus the M8 digital) or Lamborghini or Ferrari owners about quality and customer service. Now it's just crunching the numbers to meet the demands, not every lens or camera will get tested, but rather, random and like i said, it's just like rolling the dice and hope that your number comes up."
Mike1 wrote: blonde wrotei think that what you are talking about is the tiny amount of back focus front focus which you are right, it is normal and expected. however, what we are talking here is quite different than normal variance. we are talking about serious misfocus which is not normal nor acceptable. we see people that have to dial in +/- 15 just to get their lens to come even close to being in focus.Well... that also depends on how old the lens is and how often it gets used as well. Which brings us back the calibration part. CPS recommends that we have our lens and cameras checked at least once a year since pros use their cameras more than the "weekend warriors." Sure it costs money, it is part of the business expenses and it also pays for itself. Nobody says that photography is cheap. It never has been cheap, even back in the film days, except that there are less "professional" photographers than there were before the DSLR era. Think about the cost dark room equipment, the costs for bulk rolls of film and chemicals, on top of the "annual" maintainance & checkup. However cameras today are more sophisticated than the Nikon F of the 70's. The design was straightforward. My Nikon F has gone through heavy rain, snow, mud, humidity, etc. It is a lot more durable than any of the cameras today and it never need a battery to boot. In fact, mine has taken a dunk in the river for a minute or so when I dropped it into a riverbank as I slipped and it fell out of my hand. After letting it dry out, it was working fine again. I wouldn't be doing that to my 1D3 today, it would be back at Canon service center on life support. Also, with the sophistication comes complex settings that are built into the camera. IMO I think there are a lot more "Curious Georges" that fiddles with the settings and have no idea what they are for and had no idea what they just did.
Yes I do sympathize with the people that have received the bad batch w/o the sub mirror fix. I think those that received the defective batch should get a new fixed BD replacement. I think this issue has blown way out of proportion. I had the same problem when I had my 1D MK I when I made the transition from film to digital and I was curious. I didn't go about and went on a "customize this camera spree," but instead, ask Canon what they are. Surprisingly, level 1, support had no clue so I had to talk to level 2, who gave me the answers that I needed.
Wow, a few days of being sick & with a lot of time on the net got me this... ...Show more →
i think that we have been down that "it's the setting stupid" road before don't you think? i remember that before canon had the balls to even admit that they have a problem, they came out with that brilliant paper that explains how to set the mkIII up and i also remember that the entire document was a bunch of BS made by Canon to show the users that they are idiots and it is all their fault.
no matter how hard you will try to spin this, i don't think that many of us will buy that theory of yours that the problems are a result of users fiddling with CF's. show me one CF that can screw the AF so much to the point where it can't take a shot in focus...
lastly, you seem to assume that just because we are not all "pros" or belong to CPS we have no idea what to expect from the camera or how to use it which in my own humble opinion, is just insulting. just because i don't shoot for money doesn't mean that i didn't shoot with a 1D, 1DmkII, 1DmkIIn, 1DsmkII before i bought this camera or that i have no clue what i am doing.
Paul B wrote: Tom_W wroteHrow wroteMe thinks we have some folks from Canon's PR department trolling around these waters. I'm pretty certain that they're around, but probably not the ones that we think are them. I suspect more reading and less posting. If they want to get a feel for this part of the market.I think any PR person engaging in actual posting and arguing regarding a product like this would get their butt in a wringer pretty fast from the company execs. Plus which Canon is not dumb enough to hire someone that would say stuff like what's in the following quote. Give me a break. The MkIII was supposed to be a "low production" camera? (Say what? Canon didn't have an excellent idea from the 1DMkI, 1DMkII and 1DMkIIn what the demand for the camera would be?) If that were true you'd fire not only the PR people that publicly said this but also the market research and production departments for not knowing some basic facts. Quality decreases as demand increases? I guess what that means is that it's impossible for any company to become "large" because by definition as it gets there it starts turning out crap and people don't buy the products.
"I guess quality is decreased as demands have increased....The Mark III was supposed to be a low production camera and the demand had exceeded the supply. Noticed the LONG waiting list for it after it came out, and the "fixed" ones just started to pop up now? Just ask ANY Leica (minus the M8 digital) or Lamborghini or Ferrari owners about quality and customer service. Now it's just crunching the numbers to meet the demands, not every lens or camera will get tested, but rather, random and like i said, it's just like rolling the dice and hope that your number comes up."...Show more →
Grinning smiley means I'm not being serious. I was just trying to convey that there are a couple of folks on this thread that Canon would be proud to have as employees.
blonde wrote:
i think that we have been down that "it's the setting stupid" road before don't you think? i remember that before canon had the balls to even admit that they have a problem, they came out with that brilliant paper that explains how to set the mkIII up and i also remember that the entire document was a bunch of BS made by Canon to show the users that they are idiots and it is all their fault.
no matter how hard you will try to spin this, i don't think that many of us will buy that theory of yours that the problems are a result of users fiddling with CF's. show me one CF that can screw the AF so much to the point where it can't take a shot in focus...
lastly, you seem to assume that just because we are not all "pros" or belong to CPS we have no idea what to expect from the camera or how to use it which in my own humble opinion, is just insulting. just because i don't shoot for money doesn't mean that i didn't shoot with a 1D, 1DmkII, 1DmkIIn, 1DsmkII before i bought this camera or that i have no clue what i am doing. ...Show more →
I'm not saying that it's you. I'm just saying that there are other people out there that are doing that. I was at my local store one day and the sales guy told me the story of this one guy that came into the store bought a Mark II N (pre-Mark III days) because one of his "friends" was hooking him up with a paid job as a sports photographer and he's getting his 1st shot on the field of a college football game. The guy had no clue as to what photography is. He just wants the good lens and the BEST camera for the job. The guy had no clue as far as what he needs or even knows what he's talking about, he just had money to burn. The staff at the shop that weren't helping were laughing their a$$ off after he left and he settled for a Mark II N and a 400 f5.6 in the end because it was within his "range." Another example was when I saw were the infamous "Teenage Paparazzi" whose parents bought them their gears and they were inside the store that I go to while I was out buying gear. Disgusted? Yes I am!!! Photography is that much easier now than it was before. No more waiting for the film to develop in the darkroom (and pray if you're using an E-6 and that you didn't "accidentally" use a C-41), or putting your images on emulsion paper. Yes, I can say that there are a lot more "pros" that happened to be "pros" because of their "connections," and people that do paparazzi work and do not follow the ethics of photojournalism because they could get THOUSANDS for a shot of a celebrity doing something wrong, or people that just want the best and have no idea how to use them, look at doctors and lawyers for example. I think it is more of an insult to us. I'm not being offensive in anyway but these are the realities of things today.
Yes, a bad batch is a bad batch and it needs to be replaced, not repaired. I had to speak to the Engineering department of Canon in to have them say that the sensor of my 1D Mark I needs replacement. If you REALLY know what the problem is, and you can pinpoint it, be VERY specific, and go through Canon's chain of commands as I did to get the new sensor changed for my MK I. They will treat it as a specific case, and not a generalized one. You don't have to be CPS to be able to do that.
Over the months Canon told me directly or through official material...
* That there are no problems. This is direct from a Canon Rep before I bought mine. He said there were some issues with the first run that were all resolved.
* That I had the only camera that was having focus problems. (Multiple times with Canon tech support)
* That the focus problems that I alone had would be addressed by a firmware upgrade. (I felt honored that they would do this only for me.)
* That the firmware fixed everybody else's camera (didn't know anyone else was having problems) and that once again I was the only having issues.
* That the sub-mirror repair would fix the problem that a "few" users were experiencing.
* Sent it in for the sub-mirror and it came back with the note that "All adjustments and corresponding testing have been completed to Canon factory standards." Camera was worse.
* Sent it in again. They acknowledged that it was constantly back focusing. Returned it with the note that "All adjustments and corresponding testing have been completed to Canon factory standards." Camera was much worse.
* Canon told me that the focus problems were my fault for using the * button to focus with. It took three days to finally talk to someone who would acknowledged that this was a stupid response.
* Sent it in again. They acknowledged that the there was a problem - that being that the rear flange distance to the sensor was wrong. "Returned with a note that said, "All adjustments and corresponding testing have been completed to Canon factory standards." Camera is now useless.
* Canon now comes out and says that the 1DMkIII is working better than an previous EOS model. Glad to hear that, makes me feel all warm and fuzzy. Yes, I am being sarcastic.
If it was just me then I would say sh*t happens. However, you can find the same story from others here as well as from folks from SportsShooter and Naturescapes. There are too many serious shooters out there that have a clue about what we are doing to see much humor in your attitude that there are "more "Curious Georges" that fiddles with the settings and have no idea what they are for and had no idea what they just did". That's just insulting.
* That the focus problems that I alone had would be addressed by a firmware upgrade. (I felt honored that they would do this only for me.)
Sweet! So YOU'RE the one responsible for the birth of firmware 1.1.3.
Thanks!
OMG, reading the runaround Canon gave you almost makes ME want to go to Canon Service with a billy club and....
I would have gone APE-SHIZZLE!
Numerous others have experienced the same or worse treatment and reading this "Curious George" drivel just pisses me off.
Over the months Canon told me directly or through official material...
* That there are no problems. This is direct from a Canon Rep before I bought mine. He said there were some issues with the first run that were all resolved.
That is true because of the sub mirror problem with the 1st batch.
Hrow wrote:
* That I had the only camera that was having focus problems. (Multiple times with Canon tech support)
How far did you get as far as speaking with Canon tech support? They were probably getting a bunch of calls and trained their tech support rep to give you the runaround because of the volume of calls that they are receiving.
Hrow wrote:
* That the focus problems that I alone had would be addressed by a firmware upgrade. (I felt honored that they would do this only for me.)
That was wrong on their part, you should have tried to nitpick the issue. If they can't answer any engineering related questions, you're sure to move up to the next level.
Hrow wrote:
* That the firmware fixed everybody else's camera (didn't know anyone else was having problems) and that once again I was the only having issues.
The BD I have, serial # 551XXXX had no problems after the 1.1.3 upgrade.
Hrow wrote:
* That the sub-mirror repair would fix the problem that a "few" users were experiencing.
What was the serial # of your 1D3? You should be more specific with your problems when you speak to them.
Hrow wrote:
* Sent it in for the sub-mirror and it came back with the note that "All adjustments and corresponding testing have been completed to Canon factory standards." Camera was worse.
Typical Canon repair statement... Was there anything else that were stated that was done on your statement? PCB changes, parts replacements etc.?
Hrow wrote:
* Sent it in again. They acknowledged that it was constantly back focusing. Returned it with the note that "All adjustments and corresponding testing have been completed to Canon factory standards." Camera was much worse.
Have you had your lens tested with the micro adjustments? You can use that in your favor you know? Also test the same lens(es) on another body, if you have one.
Hrow wrote:
* Canon told me that the focus problems were my fault for using the * button to focus with. It took three days to finally talk to someone who would acknowledged that this was a stupid response.
That was wrong on their part, I have used the * to start focus since the film 1 series, and there is no more need for it now since AF start button does it for you, instead of the registered focus point on the previous 1 series.
Hrow wrote:
* Sent it in again. They acknowledged that the there was a problem - that being that the rear flange distance to the sensor was wrong. "Returned with a note that said, "All adjustments and corresponding testing have been completed to Canon factory standards." Camera is now useless.
I think you and the rest of the guys with the bad batch should get together and file for a petition for a replacement of your defective camera.
Hrow wrote:
* Canon now comes out and says that the 1DMkIII is working better than an previous EOS model. Glad to hear that, makes me feel all warm and fuzzy. Yes, I am being sarcastic.
Partially right since some of the 1D3 with BDs & the 1.1.3 firmware is the "fixed" version.
Hrow wrote:
If it was just me then I would say sh*t happens. However, you can find the same story from others here as well as from folks from SportsShooter and Naturescapes. There are too many serious shooters out there that have a clue about what we are doing to see much humor in your attitude that there are "more "Curious Georges" that fiddles with the settings and have no idea what they are for and had no idea what they just did". That's just insulting.
You'd be surprised, I used to live in the area where there are people that are ACTUALLY like that... Sorry if it insults you, it also insults me & my credibility as well...
drisley wrote:
OMG, reading the runaround Canon gave you almost makes ME want to go to Canon Service with a billy club and....
I would have gone APE-SHIZZLE!
You haven't been there when I showed up at Canon Irvine when my 1D MK I needed a new sensor replacement a few years ago. Had to use a rental that was covered by my insurance for a few jobs. Let me say it again, RENTALS & LOANERS SUX!!! It's just like breaking up with a girl and you had to go on a blind date... THEN you're back with her and she's not the same...
geniousc wrote:
Tolerances are within reasonable limits *now* not before the mirror box firm ware upgrade. If you don't understand that there are such a thing manufacturing tolerances you just don't know anything about manufacturing. Go to the Nikonians, the first thread is "the never ending front focus back focus issue" Why do you think nikon added microfocus, to take care of the reasonable limits you are talking about that should be tuned in for you, that's why. To take care of your reasonable tolerances!
I do understand "manufacturing tolerances", but it doesn't take a scientist to recognize the difference between well designed and shoddy tolerances. If you're speaking based on your own manufacturing experience, your comment isn't doing you any favors.
Having micro-focus adjustment is fine and dandy as long as it's not used as a crutch for lack of quality control.
The thread you reference has been in place for over a year with only 18 posts, with about half explaining how to test for focus accuracy. Are you attempting to compare that to this fiasco?