fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2008 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2008A bird in the hand . . .

  
 
Rainer
Offline
Details
p.9 #1A bird in the hand . . .
PShizzy wrote:
Ok, here's what I'm seeing

You returned an out of warranty lens that's no longer made or supported by Canon. It's tangible value is not nearly that of the current and still supported 24-70. They offered you a 400 dollar lens (not a 200 dollar lens), which presumably is new and is definitely supported, plus warranteed.

And your complaint is?

If you didn't know better, than I'm sorry, but it's still your fault for buying a lens that's out of circulation. Caveat Emptor there. And I speak from experience. I own a 200 1.8 currently. I understand that if anything happens, I need
...Show more →

Exactly this is the point! They should have returned it, but for some reason they messed up, lost the lens or broke it. And now the right thing to do is to give Dean a lens of equal or higher value! And that would be the 24-70 f/2.8L, no questions asked. (Let's assume you send in your 200 f/1.8L, they lose it, and send you a brand new 200 f/2.8L -- since that's the currently available L series 200mm lens. Would you accept that deal?)
Feb 22, 2008 at 05:43 AM
timbop
Offline
Details
p.9 #2A bird in the hand . . .
pshizzy and tri tran, as pointed out by others Canon is not returning his lens, for reasons unknown. If they were to send his lens back in it's original condition, I would agree with you. But, they are not returning it so he is out an L grade f/2.8 lens - which is the crux of the matter. It seems you and canon are arguing that a new consumer grade variable aperture f/3.5 to f/5.6 lens is as good as a 6 year old L. That doesn't sound like a very intelligent stance to take for a company that thrives on the lustre of the "Luxury" designation.
Feb 22, 2008 at 06:08 AM
Tom_W
Offline
Details
p.9 #3A bird in the hand . . .
PShizzy wrote:
Ok, here's what I'm seeing

You returned an out of warranty lens that's no longer made or supported by Canon. It's tangible value is not nearly that of the current and still supported 24-70. They offered you a 400 dollar lens (not a 200 dollar lens), which presumably is new and is definitely supported, plus warranteed.

And your complaint is?


The street value of a 28-70 L is not $400 - it's around $800. Once that lens is in Canon's hands, they are responsible for it's safe return or refund or replacement in like kind. A 28-135 IS lens is NOT like a 28-70L. It's a lessor lens. The fault lies entirely with Canon and they need to make this right. Period.

Feb 22, 2008 at 06:21 AM
Tom_W
Offline
Details
p.9 #4A bird in the hand . . .
realkuhl wrote:
Dean, man do I wish you luck. This type of press on a board with this many readers is not going to help Canon on bit. This is NOT the time that bad PR like this needs to be on the air waves. I have a 50mm f1.4 that has been pretty useless since I purchased it 5 years ago that won't even focus at this point. Not sure I would send it to them now for fixing....


Canon has some issues here. A large entity always has a few hiccups, but they also have the means in place to deal with these hiccups and straighten things out in a timely manner. Canon seems to have lost or hidden that capability for now.

I'm not sure if it's due to lax management, improper placement of people, bad procedures, or what, but the fact that they've been unable to resolve this issue or even give a straight answer for several weeks indicates that there's a serious problem in the management structure.

Perhaps they've made a few too many politically-correct or good-old-boy (or girl) promotions instead of putting people in charge of operations that actually have a clue and some experience in the area in which they are charged.
Feb 22, 2008 at 06:29 AM
twistedlim
Offline
Details
p.9 #5A bird in the hand . . .
Max with all due respect I have to agree with Tom. Canon agreed to fix the lens and if they made it worse they must be held responsible. Imagine if you sent your 200 1.8 to a 3rd party repair shop for cleaning and they sent it back with a broken af motor and said they would replace it with a used 200 2.8. I have to think you would feel shorted. If you take your car in to Jiffy Lube to have the oil changed and they forget to put the plug in the oil pan casuing you motor to blow out they are responsible. I have to believe the same holds true here. I had a similar issue with a brand new 1d2n. Of course it was under warranty but they suggested perhaps I dropped the camera. If went in not focusing correctly in AI Servo and came back not autofocusing at all. In the end they replaced the body but not without what I would concede to being a major hassel. Unfortunatly there are those who do drop their camera/lens and want canon to fix it for free, hence the other side of the story. We have all read the posts here where people hope to get something for nothing and that will obviously make Canon skeptical of any repairs that are sent in. People who do this make it bad for everyone. In canon's defense there have been numerous posts on FM about how canon serviced cameras, replaced shutters, calibrated lenses even if they were out of warranty. All this being said Canon should do the right thing and replace the lens with either a refurb 28-70/24-70 or a new one. In no way shape or form is a 28-135 an adequate replacement for an L lens that still sells for over $1000 new (there was one actually on the shelf at a local ritz).
Feb 22, 2008 at 06:51 AM
darknite
Offline
Details
p.9 #6A bird in the hand . . .
Sorry Max,
Doesn't ring quite true. Imagine this had been, say for example, a 20 year old John Deer riding lawn mower, taken to a Authorized JD repair center for a tune up, who promised to do the work, then gave you a regular mower in return, refusing to even comment on your previously function riding mower other than it was unrepairable, even though it was working when you left it. You'd actually be OK with the regular mower that you had to push? Even though i less than a month you had promised to help someone mow their 4 acre lawn (OK, or go to Hawaii) It would be OK since it was old and out of warranty, and you should have known better, right?

What if you weren't OK with that, returned the 'replacement' without having even fired it up. Imagine the JD rep said, it won't start, you broke it?

It doesn't matter that its an old mower or lens. It doesn't matter that its out of warranty. The repair center made promises and failed to follow through, then repeatedly dodged questions about the original item. Maybe the people making the grand promises didn't have the actual authority, I don't know. Even if they didn't, They are the ones who should pay the price, NOT Dean. Even in auto shops you can pay a core charge and get your original non-functioning part returned to you. Canon screwed up.


PShizzy wrote:
Ok, here's what I'm seeing

You returned an out of warranty lens that's no longer made or supported by Canon. It's tangible value is not nearly that of the current and still supported 24-70. They offered you a 400 dollar lens (not a 200 dollar lens), which presumably is new and is definitely supported, plus warranteed.

And your complaint is?

If you didn't know better, than I'm sorry, but it's still your fault for buying a lens that's out of circulation. Caveat Emptor there. And I speak from experience. I own a 200 1.8 currently. I understand that if anything happens, I need
...Show more →
Feb 22, 2008 at 07:35 AM
PShizzy
Offline
Details
p.9 #7A bird in the hand . . .
I readily admit the error of Canon accepting the lens. As I said before, had I been on the CS team, I would have quickly told you the lens was out of circulation as well as out of warranty, given you third party contact info and let you be on your merry way.

That they accepted the lens was definitely bad. But in no way do I see how the "value" of a 28-70 out of circulation and warranty should match that of a new 24-70 with a warranty.

Again, I don't feel offering a 28-135 was an egregious offense. I feel accepting your lens and NOT giving it back to you is.

Oh and btw, I hate to tell you, but when you contact third parties about lenses like a 200 1.8, paperwork to the effect of "your lens is old and may be dead, this is not our fault" is often signed.

Again, this is our problem, not theirs. If you buy into an old lens, you should know this going into it. Not knowing it is not anyone's fault but yours. So yes, if/when my 200 1.8 dies, if it cannot be revived, I will be sad, but I will not lay the blame on a technician for not being able to fix some arcane lens technology that is no longer supported by the company that created the lens in the first place.

I will say I am biased, because Canon has gone beyond my expectation of their service for me on several occasions. Either I'm the luckiest guy in the world, or I just happen to know how to talk to them to get great service.

Max
Feb 22, 2008 at 08:58 AM
rachp
Offline
Details
p.9 #8A bird in the hand . . .
Rainer wrote:
And now the right thing to do is to give Dean a lens of equal or higher value!



And equal or higher QUALITY - which the 28-135mm is not. I had a great 28-135mm but it does not compare in quality to the 28/24-70mm.


Edited on Feb 22, 2008 at 09:07 AM
Feb 22, 2008 at 09:05 AM
Scott T
Offline
Details
p.9 #9A bird in the hand . . .
Max - I think you're missing some of the story? The lens worked fine when Dean sent it in, he was just seeking a calibration to fine tune it. He paid the service fee. they called him and said it was broken and can't be fixed. It wasn't broken when he sent it to them. Why can't he have the lens back and have Canon pay for 3rd party repairs? Why is anything less than the fair market value of his lens an ok solution? Canon is the one that has given him no options, he agreed to accept an older replacement 28-70 they "found", that sounds reasonable to me. Then they broke that deal as well. They are not treating him fairly.
Feb 22, 2008 at 09:16 AM
Tom_W
Offline
Details
p.9 #10A bird in the hand . . .
PShizzy wrote:
I readily admit the error of Canon accepting the lens. As I said before, had I been on the CS team, I would have quickly told you the lens was out of circulation as well as out of warranty, given you third party contact info and let you be on your merry way.


Being "out of circulation" doesn't mean that Canon won't back the product. There are very specific lenses that they will no longer repair due to the lack of parts, such as the 200/1.8. However merely no longer selling a lens does not remove it from the ranks of products that Canon will service. They still service the 400/2.8 Mk II (non-IS) which was discontinued in 1999 when the IS version came out.

That they accepted the lens was definitely bad. But in no way do I see how the "value" of a 28-70 out of circulation and warranty should match that of a new 24-70 with a warranty.

The "value" of a 28-70 is what the lens is worth, on average, on the market. In this case, it's around $800 because that is what people are willing to pay for a used copy of this lens. Canon is obligated, under the Uniform Commercial Code to make make the customer whole by either carrying out their obligation to repair the lens as promised for the usual or negotiated fee, returning the lens unrepaired, refunding the market value of the lens, or replacing it with one of equal or better value.

The 28-135 IS is nowhere near equal or greater value. It is an insult that they would try to pass it off as such.

I will say I am biased, because Canon has gone beyond my expectation of their service for me on several occasions. Either I'm the luckiest guy in the world, or I just happen to know how to talk to them to get great service.

Max


I've had good service from Canon in the past as well, but this situation doesn't match my past experience. Perhaps something has happened at Canon over the last 2 years or so since I've had work done there. Or perhaps this is an unusual case. At any rate, this needs to be resolved and if this is not an isolated incident, then heads need to roll at Canon.
Feb 22, 2008 at 09:16 AM
twistedlim
Offline
Details
p.9 #11A bird in the hand . . .
Max,

You are a well respected photographer who has worked for CS so I would expect that you would receive excellent service, and rightly so. And, I have to believe if you sent a lens in that was working and it came back not working you would be at least a little miffed regardless of the age of the lens and where you sent it. At the very least it should come back no worse than it was.

I just checked with CS and they do accept 28-70 2.8Ls in for cleaning and calibration so I would imagine that Deans request was not extaordiary. They agreed to calibrate the lens that is still on their lenses that they will service and broke the lens, they should then either replace the exact lens, or if they cannot find one they should compensate him for the fair market value. I do agree that a new 24-70 is not a fair market value trade so perhaps they have to come up with something other than that but the 28-135 is not it in my opinion.
Feb 22, 2008 at 09:22 AM
PShizzy
Offline
Details
p.9 #12A bird in the hand . . .
Twisted,

Forgive me if I misspoke or was misunderstood. When I said CS, I meant Customer Support. Not Canon. I do not, nor have ever worked for Canon.

I work for a large corporation and part of my role is that of systems administrator. Part of that role is playing the punching bag, in that I will receive blame for the efforts (or lack thereof) of others. For example, our database just croaked. I'm not a DB admin, just a systems admin. But because I'm the public "face" of the system, I'm the one who receives the harsh treatment.

And honestly, when I do, I offer only the basic due dilligence to help someone out. In other words, I treat them as robotically as possible without outright insubordination.

But, when someone actually speaks to me like a person, or when they listen to me, I do my best to let them know that I do care for their situation and try my best to keep them abreast of any changes as well as try to connect the dots and get issues remedied.

In the case of a simple cleaning and calibration, the problem is that often, if there is a miscalibration, the lens needs to be opened up and pieces need to be adjusted. Right there lies the problem. Again, Canon should have notified you and laid out a warning about this. I still say I probably wouldn't accept it, but once I did, I would warn you at every step to make sure you knew what could happen.

Depending on the demeanor of my customer, I would try to get a 24-70 out. Studies show that for every negative experience a consumer has with a product, they need to have 10 positive experiences in order to even it out.

Max
Feb 22, 2008 at 09:42 AM
twistedlim
Offline
Details
p.9 #13A bird in the hand . . .
Max,

Well stated and thoughful response. I agree 100% with the customer demeanor. People are people and if you back them into a corner...well you will probably get what you deserve. This I have learned. Be polite, patient, and kind and usually you will get a like response. I have delt with Dean and find him to be an upstanding guy so I am sure somewhere along the line someone pushed his buttons. In the end I hope he gets this resolved.


Rich
Feb 22, 2008 at 09:55 AM
thedigitalbean
Offline
Details
p.9 #14A bird in the hand . . .
PShizzy wrote:
But, when someone actually speaks to me like a person, or when they listen to me [..]
Max


Max, that cuts both ways. Far too often, the CSRs don't treat the individuals that call them like a person to being with. I fully understand that there are rude customers who want to treat the CSR as a punching bag and that this causes many CSR to become robotic and detached. However if a CSR treats me like an imbecile, they should expect the same treatment back. Since the CSR is paid pretty much to deal with the company's customers, they should be the one to set the tone of the conversation by treating the individual on the phone like a person and listening.
Feb 22, 2008 at 10:34 AM
PShizzy
Offline
Details
p.9 #15A bird in the hand . . .
Rich

I've never dealt with Dean but I have seen his posts. I didn't assume he flipped his lid, but being that the heart of this discuss is about customer service, I felt it a good platform for me to convey the message from the perspective of someone in a customer support role. You should hear my views on how to treat people in the food services industry... let's just say you should really consider voicing your opinion after getting your meal, never before.. never.

Max
Feb 22, 2008 at 10:36 AM
Trevor Dart
Offline
Details
p.9 #16A bird in the hand . . .
Well, I just read the entire thread and I was hoping to see you had gotten a new 5d with a 24-70. I don't think i've ever been so appauled with a customer service situation in my entire life. And I commend you with your patience, as little as you might have now. The kicker in my opinion is recieving the wrong lense, I can't think of anything that would have teken the wind out of my sail any more then that.

good luck. I don't really have anything else that could really help your situation.

if you dont get your 24-70, want to buy mine? hahaha just kidding. anyways, good luck.
Feb 22, 2008 at 10:54 AM
Antje
Offline
Details
p.9 #17A bird in the hand . . .
Hey Max, that's a pretty jaded view on CS. I'm part CS, too - well, rather Customer Relations and Product Support, which includes everything that's not directly about using wrenches or closing sales. So customers come to me with every problem, be it how to set up an experiment, how to keep an animal warm and cosy, or that their x-ray detector is defective. I work for a very big German company much like GE.

Let me say I would never ever let this happen to a customer who comes to me. If we break something that's theirs, we replace it. That's costly sometimes, but the alternative would be to lose their faith. And our customers tend to talk to each other, those sly dogs.

And personally, I care too much about every one of them to let them down. It's our job to go the extra mile for them all the time, and the job of others to see that we still make profit doing that.

Antje
Feb 22, 2008 at 11:04 AM
darknite
Offline
Details
p.9 #18A bird in the hand . . .
Actually, you would not have given out 3rd party contact info, or given the caller grief about a discontinued product that was out of warranty. If you worked for Canon CS in the repair dept, you would have followed Canon policy and procedures, which would have been to accept the lens since Canon still works on the lens to do calibration and adjustment. Its NOT bad that they took the lens, its their policy, and its on the list of serviceable goods.

There was no release of liability disclaimer that the lens couldn't (or wouldn't) be repaired. The repair dept made the offer of replacement with a product of equal or GREATER value, they need to stick to their offer. If the value was viewed from a $$$ point of view only, its suggested retail was well over $1000, its street price when in production was around $1000, and its used value is at $800. The current new street price of the 28-135 is $399 So maybe an equal monitary value would be not 1, but 2) 28-135 lenses based on current average price.

If the quality and function defined the value, their is NO comparison. The value of the 28-70L is in the large aperture of 2.8 and the background blur/ reduced depth of field produced by the aperture. The 28-135 starts on the wide end at 1/2 a stop slower at f/3.5, and deteriorates to f/5.6 at the long end.

Value must be figured as a combination of both price and function. A rebuilt 28-70 or refurb/ rebuild 24-70 (which is the current replacement/ incarnation of the discontinued 28-70) would be the right product at the right price.




PShizzy wrote:
I readily admit the error of Canon accepting the lens. As I said before, had I been on the CS team, I would have quickly told you the lens was out of circulation as well as out of warranty, given you third party contact info and let you be on your merry way.

That they accepted the lens was definitely bad. But in no way do I see how the "value" of a 28-70 out of circulation and warranty should match that of a new 24-70 with a warranty.

Again, I don't feel offering a 28-135 was an egregious offense. I
...Show more →
Feb 22, 2008 at 11:05 AM
twistedlim
Offline
Details
p.9 #19A bird in the hand . . .
. You should hear my views on how to treat people in the food services industry... let's just say you should really consider voicing your opinion after getting your meal, never before.. never.
Feb 22, 2008 at 11:27 AM
dcains
Offline
Details
p.9 #20A bird in the hand . . .
Looks like a new 24-70L is on its way - finally, and the $110 service charge is being refunded to my credit card. Ivan resurfaced, probably at the urging of the exec I spoke to yesterday, and re-offered the refurb'd 28-70L (4 years older than my original), and to "forgive" the damages (whatever they were) to the 28-135 I returned. I said "no thanks", and asked for the new 24-70L and refund of all service charges, which Ivan agreed to on a subsequent callback. So, hopefully all's well that ends well, and the new lens will be here Monday.

I don't have any ill feelings toward the two devil's advocates who recently joined this thread, but really, do you guys think my demands were unreasonable? 8 weeks later, and I STILL don't know what happened to my original lens, which Canon agreed to service (and they still do service that lens, BTW), their reneging on previous offers, their shuffling me around to various offices around the northeast and 7 or 8 different people? And, I only sent the lens in so it would be tweaked to the max for my vacation, which I've since had without that lens. Street value on a mint 28-70L is still at least $750, and I got a 28-135 (immediately sold on eBay) in my 40D kit last Fall for $200, not to mention the differences in image quality and build. The 24-70L was the only fair solution.

It was never my intent to scam Canon out of anything I didn't deserve, and they certainly had the option of returning my 28-70L unserviced, which would have been a reasonable resolution 6 weeks ago, and what I told Roderick to do. Will I ever send anything to Canon's Jamesburg service facility again? Not in this lifetime, but I appreciate that Canon has finally made this situation right, and I'll let them know.
Feb 22, 2008 at 02:18 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister