Hey to each their own. I'm glad Dean got himself a 24-70, and I don't for a second believe his goal was to get a brand new lens out of the deal, but rather to have his 28-70 calibrated.
I think the problem lies in Canon's procedure. I don't think it's hard to believe that something out of warranty and not in circulation might have lesser value applied to it.
And with the 2004 mustang, the problem there lies in the warranty. Most factory warranties are for many years. Now to even come close to an apples to apples (where Canon offers a 1 year with a 2 month grace period, as compared to say a 6-7 year or 10k miles per year warranty) you'd have to say something like a 1981 mustang or something. And ya, I have a feeling if they messed up the transmission they wouldn't give you a 2k9 model, but rather give you kelly blue book for the 81 stang.
But what does this all matter? Dean got a hopefully comparable lens, so alls well that ends well, no?
Max