Looks like a new 24-70L is on its way - finally, and the $110 service charge is being refunded to my credit card. Ivan resurfaced, probably at the urging of the exec I spoke to yesterday, and re-offered the refurb'd 28-70L (4 years older than my original), and to "forgive" the damages (whatever they were) to the 28-135 I returned. I said "no thanks", and asked for the new 24-70L and refund of all service charges, which Ivan agreed to on a subsequent callback. So, hopefully all's well that ends well, and the new lens will be here Monday.
I don't have any ill feelings toward the two devil's advocates who recently joined this thread, but really, do you guys think my demands were unreasonable? 8 weeks later, and I STILL don't know what happened to my original lens, which Canon agreed to service (and they still do service that lens, BTW), their reneging on previous offers, their shuffling me around to various offices around the northeast and 7 or 8 different people? And, I only sent the lens in so it would be tweaked to the max for my vacation, which I've since had without that lens. Street value on a mint 28-70L is still at least $750, and I got a 28-135 (immediately sold on eBay) in my 40D kit last Fall for $200, not to mention the differences in image quality and build. The 24-70L was the only fair solution.
It was never my intent to scam Canon out of anything I didn't deserve, and they certainly had the option of returning my 28-70L unserviced, which would have been a reasonable resolution 6 weeks ago, and what I told Roderick to do. Will I ever send anything to Canon's Jamesburg service facility again? Not in this lifetime, but I appreciate that Canon has finally made this situation right, and I'll let them know.