fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2008 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2008Hard time with D3 focus ...

  
 
Brooke Clyde
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Hard time with D3 focus ...
Brooke Clyde wrote:
I do note some front focusing -- the AF was on Snoopy in the center frame.


A Fine Tuning setting of -5 (toward the camera) solved this.

Edited on Jan 24, 2008 at 12:50 AM
Jan 24, 2008 at 12:49 AM
Jammy Straub
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Hard time with D3 focus ...
Danya Plontz wrote:
I am inclined to think that the lower the number for this setting, the bigger the focus point will be, allowing you to focus in those hard to get low light compositions. I might be wrong, .


I tested that a few days ago actually, I didn't find it to be true. I also didn't find I got any better results in low light with fewer active AF points. Using less AF points does not cause the selected AF point to take on part of the sensitivity or area of its neighbors for focus acquisition. As far as I can tell. (tested on a D300, I would think the results are similar)



Edited on Jan 24, 2008 at 01:03 AM
Jan 24, 2008 at 01:01 AM
HerbChong
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Hard time with D3 focus ...
i always use all 51 focus points. tracking an erratically moving small bird with a big lens is hard and keeping it anywhere near the center of the frame is even harder. that is why i always shoot full resolution and plan to crop no matter which body i am using. HSC's 8FPS on the D2X wasn't useful compared to manually cropping to that size after the fact and living with 5FPS. i shoot the D300 the same way, but with the grip and the right batteries, it lets me shoot 8FPS with the full frame. file sizes don't bother me.

Herb...
Jan 24, 2008 at 09:28 AM
Danya Plontz
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Hard time with D3 focus ...
Jammy

Did you find that it hunted the same in low light as Brooke described? or were you acquiring focus well enough without issue? it was just a guess to help troubleshoot the problem, i thought since 51 points take up more room than 9, it would be logical to assume that the 9 point array would have a wider contact patch to the subject.

I would hate to see him send in and be without his camera before doing some basic testing.
Jan 24, 2008 at 10:01 AM
Brooke Clyde
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Hard time with D3 focus ...
Danya Plontz wrote:
I would hate to see him send in and be without his camera


You and me both! :-)

Deciding that the camera is defective is always a last resort. These things almost always come down to user error and/or the limitations of the technology. The Snoopy test showed me that the D3 *will* AF in the light I described - given the right target. My guess is thus that there's nothing to be "fixed". I just need to be conscious of the limitations and try to compensate or find work-arounds.
Jan 24, 2008 at 10:48 AM
bcaslis
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Hard time with D3 focus ...
Jammy Straub wrote:
Danya Plontz wroteI am inclined to think that the lower the number for this setting, the bigger the focus point will be, allowing you to focus in those hard to get low light compositions. I might be wrong, .
I tested that a few days ago actually, I didn't find it to be true. I also didn't find I got any better results in low light with fewer active AF points. Using less AF points does not cause the selected AF point to take on part of the sensitivity or area of its neighbors for focus acquisition. As far as I can tell. (tested on a D300, I would think the results are similar)



Yes, absolutely the Nikon AF system only uses the selected point to acquire focus unlike the 45 point Canon AF system. More points only expands the area that the AF uses to keep the locked subject in focus in dynamic mode. It makes no difference in acquired subject focus.

I'll still take this over the Canon system (at least until they ever get it working right). You just need to be aware of this when trying to acquire focus.

Jan 24, 2008 at 11:58 AM
maljo
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Hard time with D3 focus ...
I see the same focus issue with faces.
I also believe it is caused by a smaller focus reticule than
the D2X.

The focus on the cheek can hunt; not enough contrast?
Focus on an edge, like the eye itself, works OK.
What we get is more accurate AF, but we have to
carefully place that AF reticule on something contrasty.

Focus tracking works very well; better than any other camera
I have used.
maljo

Jan 25, 2008 at 06:40 AM
soonipi1957
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Hard time with D3 focus ...
And I know it will sound strange, but in the short time I was trying a D3 I noticed the same thing...until I put it into full blown idiot 3d color mode and I had perfect eyes every single time.

Just a thought.....as it is after all set up for skin and facial recognition above all else.

Edited on Jan 25, 2008 at 11:38 AM
Jan 25, 2008 at 11:38 AM
Brooke Clyde
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Hard time with D3 focus ...
soonipi1957 wrote:
And I know it will sound strange, but in the short time I was trying a D3 I noticed the same thing...until I put it into full blown idiot 3d color mode and I had perfect eyes every single time.

Just a thought.....as it is after all set up for skin and facial recognition above all else.


I had stayed away from that as gimmicky, but I'll try. Are you saying you got *faster* locking, or more accurate (because I have no trouble with the accuracy).
Jan 25, 2008 at 11:46 AM
Jammy Straub
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Hard time with D3 focus ...
Brooke Clyde wrote:
I had stayed away from that as gimmicky, but I'll try. Are you saying you got *faster* locking, or more accurate (because I have no trouble with the accuracy).


I can tell you 3D 51-pt with 11-pt AF selection is in no way a gimmick. It's actually pretty darn amazing. I tend to use it in most situations. I can't say it necessarily locks focus faster or more accurately but it definitely tracks better than anything I've ever seen. 3D focus could possibly acquire focus faster if the subject was low absolute contrast but had a strong color contrast. I'm not sure about that though...

One unique thing is it allows for me to focus with one of the 11 AF points and then recompose. The AF will follow the subject (an eye ball or a shirt) and continually track it and focus while I recompose the scene. Viola, no more focus recompose errors and less cropping.

Edited on Jan 25, 2008 at 03:05 PM
Jan 25, 2008 at 03:02 PM
James R
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Hard time with D3 focus ...
Moose Peterson has an article in the BT Journal, Volume 12.2, on how he uses the D3's AF system. He uses 3D 51 pts in many wildlife situations, especially BIF. The article was informative. I don't know where you can find the mag. The volume I read belonged to my friend who is a subscriber.

Safe to say, Nikon did not include any gimmicky AF modes. Just some that are not suited to every photographer.
Jan 25, 2008 at 05:19 PM
HerbChong
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Hard time with D3 focus ...
i don't like 3D for small birds in flight. they are too similar in color to the backgrounds i have to work with.

Herb...
Jan 25, 2008 at 08:44 PM
Hrow
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Hard time with D3 focus ...
Jammy Straub wrote:
Brooke Clyde wroteI had stayed away from that as gimmicky, but I'll try. Are you saying you got *faster* locking, or more accurate (because I have no trouble with the accuracy).
I can tell you 3D 51-pt with 11-pt AF selection is in no way a gimmick. It's actually pretty darn amazing. I tend to use it in most situations. I can't say it necessarily locks focus faster or more accurately but it definitely tracks better than anything I've ever seen. 3D focus could possibly acquire focus faster if the subject was low absolute contrast but had a strong color contrast. I'm not sure about that though...

One unique thing is it allows for me to focus with one of the 11 AF points and then recompose. The AF will follow
...Show more →

This is very interesting and would be really useful to me but I am not quite following how this works in real life. Can someone give me a quick overview or point me to a good reference article on using the 3D AF?

Many thanks.



Jan 26, 2008 at 12:11 AM
SoundHound
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Hard time with D3 focus ...
My un-repaired Mk III (one of the first to be delivered in the LA area) has always been an AI Servo focus hero in very low light-Ditto my D3 under the same conditions (AI servo, 9/11 pt single point focus).
Jan 26, 2008 at 11:50 AM
Jammy Straub
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Hard time with D3 focus ...
Hrow wrote:
Jammy Straub wroteOne unique thing is it allows for me to focus with one of the 11 AF points and then recompose. The AF will follow the subject (an eye ball or a shirt) and continually track it and focus while I recompose the scene. Viola, no more focus recompose errors and less cropping.
This is very interesting and would be really useful to me but I am not quite following how this works in real life. Can someone give me a quick overview or point me to a good reference article on using the 3D AF?

Many thanks.


I've never seen a comprehensive write up on the AF system in the D3/D300 online. I'll try and give you a quick overview about what I was talking about in my previous post. I'm going to layout my basic settings and then wrap up how they work together.

On the D3/D300 you can set the number of selectable AF points between 11 or 51 with a menu function. I have mine set to 11. 51pts take too long for me to work my way to the desired position in the field.

I very very rarely find I need to shoot with the D300 in single shot servo mode, it's in continuous servo 95% of the time. It doesn't seem to hunt on static subjects like some AF systems in continuous, but most of the time there's really no reason to leave it active on a static subject anyway.

There are three different focus point modes. 1. Automatic focus point selection, 2. dynamic focus point selection, and 3. single focus point selection.

1. Automatic focus point selection uses magic to determine what you want in focus a photo it will show you all of the focus points in the viewfinder that are in focus (ie multiple points will light up to show you focus has been achieved). It's good for ridiculously fast grab shots and handing off the camera to someone that doesn't know how to use it. It seems to work well, I rarely use it though. You have no control over what the focus will fall on in this mode, it's truly automatic. Continuous and single shot focus work in this mode. Servo focus does not show the active AF points in this mode.

2. Dynamica AF point selection allows you to set one of 4 different parameters. 3D 51pt, 51pt, 21pt, and 9pt. In this mode you set what focus point you want the camera to start with. Assuming you are in servo focus, depending on which above mode you set (3D 51, 51, 21, or 9) you camera will follow the target around the available AF points. Each mode will limit how far the subject can travel from the original focus point in a squarish pattern. (21pts away, 9 pts away, etc..) The various travel distances are useful depending on how erratic you subjects motion is and how hard it is to keep under the selected rectangle.

3. Single point mode works just like it sounds. Only one point is used and is user selectable.

In Dynamic AF, 3D 51pt mode, using 11 AF points for selection with continuos servo active you can easily focus on a face or an eye while holding down the AF-ON button and recompose. Even if you are only selecting your AF points with 11 available points the camera will track the subject across all 51pts and continually focus. In social situations it works incredibly well and is fast as all get out (that's a technical term).

3D AF seems to be dependent on a lot of different factors and doesn't always work 100% reliably, but most of the time it works very very well. I've known one person who found a specific sort of fluorescent lighting that made it go haywire. In low light levels with low color contrast it can be fooled. A brown duck flying across a de-foliaged forest probably wouldn't work too well for example. It does work well enough by far though that's its my default setting and I rarely have to switch to 9 or 21pt.

Do that sorta help?

Edited on Jan 26, 2008 at 09:31 PM
Jan 26, 2008 at 09:29 PM
Hrow
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Hard time with D3 focus ...
Thanks Jammy, I appreciate the info and the time it took to put down. Perhaps I'm wrong but I have never gotten the idea that my Canon's would do that and in fact, it seems pretty spooky but ever so useful. I need to look into this a little more because maybe I have just been missing something.
Jan 27, 2008 at 07:31 AM
Jammy Straub
Offline
Details
p.2 #17Hard time with D3 focus ...
You're spot on with the spooky comment. The first time I used it several expletives came out of my mouth and I fairly flabbergasted.

Edited on Jan 27, 2008 at 11:24 AM
Jan 27, 2008 at 11:23 AM
Alan321
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Hard time with D3 focus ...
Hrow, the primary difference between the Nikon 3D Af and the Canon AF is that the 3D system looks at colour as well as contrast whereas the Canon system only looks at contrast. There are bound to be circumstances where the colour helps the system to realise which of two diverging contrast patterns it should be tracking (e.g. a soccer ball and a players head), whereas the Canon system would have to guess or just get confused and lose both.

Even if the colours are similar between two potential tracking candidates the 3D system still has contrast and focus distance to work with just as the Canon system does.


The Canon system will track a contrast pattern as it leaves the scope of one AF sensor and enters the scope of another one nearby. Whether it pays attention to that depends on what level of AF expansion you have set (1,7,13 or 45 points). In AI Servo mode the Canon system starts tracking whatever your chosen (default=centre) sensor is focused on but is then able to follow it one or two or more layers away from that sensor. The small sensor size and the high sensor density make it a great tracking system (except for dicky 1D3 cameras) and let it perform better than the 9-point AF systems. 9-point systems have bigger sensors causing less selectivity and yet still have bigger gaps between them, which can result in a small subject (contrast pattern) falling between the sensors and being "lost" for long enough to end the focus tracking.

The key point is that these systems have until now only seen monochromatic contrast patterns in one or two dimensions, but Nikon has added the ability to follow colour as well. It knows which way the red ball went whereas Canon could lose it in the grass. Even so, history suggests that the Canon system has been pretty good for several years, so just imagine how much better the Nikon system ought to be.

- Alan
Mar 01, 2008 at 10:41 PM
rico
Offline
Details
p.2 #19Hard time with D3 focus ...
Jammy Straub wrote:
...
One unique thing is it allows for me to focus with one of the 11 AF points and then recompose. The AF will follow the subject (an eye ball or a shirt) and continually track it and focus while I recompose the scene. Viola, no more focus recompose errors and less cropping.


The 51-pt 3D AF is truly amazing, and exactly what I need for my candid portraits. Ability to recompose on-the-fly means I can use the center AF point all the time. The D300 with f/2.8 lens can track an eye or, in a group shot, a face. My 1Ds is far less capable: in 7-pt mode, AF can wander just 1 point from the starting AF point. 13-pt mode is barely better, and only activates with a 300mm telephoto.
Mar 02, 2008 at 02:40 AM
James R
Offline
Details
p.2 #20Hard time with D3 focus ...
I just shot surfing last week using 51-pt 3D. The jumping red selector point took a few minutes to get used to, but, once you get into the action, you forget all about it. I was surprised at the keeper rate, especially while shooting in burst. Since it was the first time shooting surfing, most of my bad shots were due to poor composition. I can't wait to give it a run at youth basketball and baseball.
Mar 02, 2008 at 08:50 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister