Ok, I'm going to call a spade a spade. Canon has screwed up again and it's getting a little disgusting IMO. I too have a 1D3 in transit and not knowing if it is or is not a good one, irrespective of the mysterious blue dot, is not reassuring.
Canon has not effectively communicated to either the repair centers, the customer base, the retailers, nor their phone support people that the problem exists and there is a "solution". What a cluster F this is turning out to be. The only way to handle a mess like this is to state clearly and unequivocally, what should be fixed and why, as well as what should not be fixed (those cameras with SN > xxxyyy. The notion that "some" 1D3s in the suspect SN range "might" have a problem is disingenuous if not downright deceitful.
You don't fix things like that, if SN 1 through 1,000,000 used bad part xxx, you replace all suspected bad parts that may have already failed or may fail in the future. You don't make the customer "prove" to you that he/she has a failed camera, you proactively clean up the mess and do your best to satisfy your customer base.
This confusion should NOT be our problem and is extremely easy to solve! Canon needs to do 3 things immediately, but we all know they won't because they've shown little to no willingness to deal with this issue in a straight forward manner. Assuming they really do have a fix, IMO they should
1) Communicate to all necessary Canon employees what has happened, what Canon has been done internally to solve the issue, what action they will be taking as a company to resolve the matter with customers and dealers.
2) Communicate to all external contacts, meaning retailers, customers, etc. Anyone that needs to know which cameras are affected and how to return their camera(s) to canon for replacement or repair should get the message immediately. This statement must be clear and unequivocal. You should not cause further upset, confusion, or animosity in the dealer channel or among customers.
3) Repair/replace all cameras in the SN range. Don't cherry pick which cameras you want to fix, fix them all!
To Canon - Do the right thing for a change; instead of trying to minimize and hide the problem, state openly that you will clean it up because you recognize that it's simply the RIGHT thing to do, and you also want satisfied customers......