My original post asks: "Apart from the AF issues, which I am unlikely to encounter, what are the things that could and should easily be changed by Canon in a revised version?" For me there is little difference between a problem and something which needs improving. Either way we are obstructed in our uses of the camera. I can see that the semantics are confusing, so I have changed the title of the thread to disambiguate. Hope that's OK.
I agree with Jeff and bcaslis regarding most of these listed as personal preferences, rather than bona fide problems. They are not in the same realm as the Servo focus problems that a number are facing.
They were not intended to be in the same realm. Of course joystick FP selection is a personal preference. I am not suggesting that Canon should disable the much loved method of pressing a button with your thumb and then scrolling on two different scroll dials with forefinger and aforementioned thumb. I am suggesting that those of us who like the intuitive method available on other Canon cameras like the 5D should have an option to use the existing joystick as a focus-point selector. I shot 4000 images at the weekend under difficult and rushed circumstances, and the absence of joystick FP control slowed me down and denied shots hundreds of times. I call that a problem.
I also call it a problem if features which used to exist and could easily exist get disabled, even if I personally don't need them. I have no idea what stanj's X-assist preference is about, but I have put it in the list here because it seems like that particular configuration should be an option and would make life easier for stanj without making life worse for me. With a camera this configurable there is no line in the sand between someone else's preferences and poor usability.
>...I really like using it for switching back and forth between my last chosen AF point and my set "home" focus point. I love that.
Great, and I hope Canon always gives you that option, even though I myself would never use it. I respect your personal preference and I think you would have a right to call it a problem if Canon removed your preferred method from the camera for no known reason even though the relevant controllers were there.
>My LCD was a bit yellow until I switched to a different Picture Style (Faithful), even though I shoot RAW exclusively. I would expect different styles to display different colorings or color casts. I don't see that as a "problem".
It is a huge problem because, while shooting, the monitor is the only way to judge how to make colour adjustments. It should not be accurate for some Styles and inaccurate for others, and frankly I don't believe it is.
>I don't believe that brianric's email alone, was the sole engine for changes that were made to the 5D
Nor do I. Each of us has only one tiny voice, but that doesn't mean that we shouldn't use it. Like Churchill said, "where democracy ends, there slavery begins". I hope that each of us will let Canon know about the things we do want changed in a 1D4. I am sure that helps to bring about a better camera. If Normcar wants to ask Canon NOT to introduce an OPTION to enable joystick focus-point selection, as he suggested, then he is free to do that. I hope more photographers ask for that option, and that Canon listens and solves the problem. Stanj can count on me to ask Canon for that feature he wants even though I don't need it myself.