aeubank wrote:
This issue has gotten way out of control. Mostly fueled by people that have no firsthand knowledge of the issue. I would say that Canon's reaction to this issue is about right. This assumes that more than 90% of the cameras are actually functioning to spec, and the rest is a bunch of Internet hot air from people that do not own the camera to begin with.
By your own admission, you have no firsthand knowledge of the problem; after all, your camera 'works'. There have been ample threads around here with more than several people confirming a problem, and to suggest that it is mostly internet hysteria would tend to ignore the evidence, however anecdotal it may be. I agree that the internet tends to inflate problems out of proportion, but there are an equal number of people whose cameras work who are screaming that there is no problem, when there quite obviously is.
Thus, the stalemate. Until people start sending their cameras to Canon, I'm afraid that the issue won't be taken quite as seriously as if they had hundreds sitting on the bench. Once fall soccer season is over, mine is going in regardless, if nothing else as the first step to getting a replacement that works.
I simply cannot believe that the AF problems with the 1D3 are not systemic. From my own experience, I have owned three MkIIIs and used four more and every one of them has exhibited the same problem - a problem that does not affect my MkIIN, my MkII or my original 1D.
I strongly believe that those who believe that they have a fully functional camera have simply not been exposed to the conditions that trigger the problem - whatever those problems may be. Many people have speculated that the problems arise in bright sunlight and hot temperatures but I have experienced exceptionally poor AF performance from the MkIII in a variety of conditions that are markedly not bright and hot. I have also experienced serious AF problems in One-Shot mode, so I do not believe the problem is limited to servo.
Rob Galbraith says he's tested six and found six with the problem.
I've owned three, used four others and all seven have had the problem.
How long are we going to entertain the notion that the problem does not exist in all 1D3 bodies?
Me thinks so too. I've been using the 1D3 since day one, serial #505XXX with serious AF problems. Be it servo or one shot. Most of my press photographers coleagues have the same problems like myself. Not even one out of more than 20 photogs has no AF problems with his/her 1D3. They are all fed up with Canon not resolving the issue.
Kier wrote:
I simply cannot believe that the AF problems with the 1D3 are not systemic. From my own experience, I have owned three MkIIIs and used four more and every one of them has exhibited the same problem - a problem that does not affect my MkIIN, my MkII or my original 1D.
I strongly believe that those who believe that they have a fully functional camera have simply not been exposed to the conditions that trigger the problem - whatever those problems may be. Many people have speculated that the problems arise in bright sunlight and hot temperatures but I have experienced exceptionally poor AF performance from the MkIII in a variety of conditions that are markedly not bright and hot. I have also experienced serious AF problems in One-Shot mode, so I do not believe the problem is limited to servo.
Rob Galbraith says he's tested six and found six with the problem.
I've owned three, used four others and all seven have had the problem.
How long are we going to entertain the notion that the problem does not exist in all 1D3 bodies?...Show more →
But why worry so much if all others have problems, even if they say their camera is good In your place I would worry about my own cameras instead.
But why worry so much if all others have problems, even if they say their camera is good In your place I would worry about my own cameras instead.
That has to be the dumbest thing I have read yet on this issue. Please don't take offence to this but man the whole idea is to get them all fixed! Even if your camera seems to be working there maybe, is , a flaw in all of them that needs to be addressed not just one individuals!
jomor wrote:
But why worry so much if all others have problems, even if they say their camera is good In your place I would worry about my own cameras instead.
That has to be the dumbest thing I have read yet on this issue. Please don't take offence to this but man the whole idea is to get them all fixed! Even if your camera seems to be working there maybe, is , a flaw in all of them that needs to be addressed not just one individuals!
No, your statement was the dumbest Telling people that the whole idea is to fix all cameras. Even the ones that works good and don't have any fault. Do you really belive that all people that are sure their camera is perfect will send it in for a repair
Lasse, I assume then that if Canon announce tomorrow that they are recalling all 1D3 bodies sold so far because they have discovered that there is a serious fault in the AF system that becomes evident under certain conditions, you would not be returning yours for a replacement, because you are confident that your camera is 100% free of flaws, and you are not concerned that one day on an important shoot you will encounter the conditions that cause the flaw to become apparent and have that entire shoot ruined?
Kier,
Your theory assume that all the Canon cameras has a serious AF fault. And that most people don't understand that they are using a faulty camera.
Canon have not recalled any cameras the last half year. But instead keept on selling thousends of them every month. And they will not recall them tomorrow.
In your place (bad camera) I would place my energy and time on trying to fix/replace/sell/change the camera. Instead of trying to convince people that are happy with their new camera, that they have a bad camera with faults.
Lasse Eriksson wrote:
In your place (bad camera) I would place my energy and time on trying to fix/replace/sell/change the camera. Instead of trying to convince people that are happy with their new camera, that they have a bad camera with faults.
Believe me, I have. This is my third MkIII and it still has problems - I am highly dubious that if I returned this one for yet another replacement that I would see any difference.
If your camera has worked perfectly up to now then that's fine. If next week you encounter the problem and have a shoot completely wasted, I'll try not to say "I told you so".
This has become a yelling match. Lasse keep your camera, and I'm happy that your camera has no apparent problems. But those people out there that have problems need a fix and are in a hold their breath mode for it! I still believe that Mk3 has problems across the board! Any product that is mass produced, is electronic, and is showing more problems than not.....has a major problem!
The story of my buddy buying one, opening it up and watching the focus screen come dropping out is a tell tale sign of mass production and anything is possible.
Lasse Eriksson wrote:
In your place (bad camera) I would place my energy and time on trying to fix/replace/sell/change the camera. Instead of trying to convince people that are happy with their new camera, that they have a bad camera with faults.
Kier wrote:
Believe me, I have. This is my third MkIII and it still has problems - I am highly dubious that if I returned this one for yet another replacement that I would see any difference.
If your camera has worked perfectly up to now then that's fine. If next week you encounter the problem and have a shoot completely wasted, I'll try not to say "I told you so".
Kier wrote: Lasse Eriksson wroteIn your place (bad camera) I would place my energy and time on trying to fix/replace/sell/change the camera. Instead of trying to convince people that are happy with their new camera, that they have a bad camera with faults.Kier wroteBelieve me, I have. This is my third MkIII and it still has problems - I am highly dubious that if I returned this one for yet another replacement that I would see any difference.
If your camera has worked perfectly up to now then that's fine. If next week you encounter the problem and have a shoot completely wasted, I'll try not to say "I told you so".Okay so I can't resist after all.
Lasse Eriksson wrote:
Kier,
Your theory assume that all the Canon cameras has a serious AF fault. And that most people don't understand that they are using a faulty camera.
Canon have not recalled any cameras the last half year. But instead keept on selling thousends of them every month. And they will not recall them tomorrow.
In your place (bad camera) I would place my energy and time on trying to fix/replace/sell/change the camera. Instead of trying to convince people that are happy with their new camera, that they have a bad camera with faults.
I wonder if Lasse Eriksson and Lars Johnsson would like to reaffirm any of their recent posts regarding the Mark III? Has word of canons recall and mirror box assembly fix reached them?