Gregory.Rotter wrote:
^ I wonder what it would have looked like with a CPL filter. I wouldn't mind seeing some 16mm vs 16mm shots with the 16-35 VR vs the 14-24, with and without a CPL. That's the one thing that's stopping me from being tempted to get the 14-24, the lack of being able to use a cpl :/
I actually have both lenses right now and was wanting to switch to the 16-35 for easy filter use. So far I have ruined a lot of photos that would have been great due to the CPL creating a completely convoluted sky when used for UWA. It doesn't appear to be as wicked on the DSLR screen when viewing it out in the sun, but it is often un-fixable with my PP skills. The 14-24 is also miles ahead sharper at all apertures in the corners and even the center is a bit better, so I am going to get rid of the 16-35 and keep the 14-24. I will still try and build my own filter holder for the 14-24, but I have learned my lesson with the CPL on wide angle (plus a CPL really softens the edges on a UWA lens.) If my wife ever left me, I would marry my 14-24.