fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2006 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2006Interesting interview

  
 
Beni
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Interesting interview
I had understood that you could not shift a FF sensor with an internal IS system simply because you don't have enough lens circle spare to do so as opposed to an APC system where you have plenty room to shift to given that it is a substantial crop of the lens imaging circle.

That makes the dilemma even worse for canon.
Sep 22, 2006 at 06:28 AM
Tentacle
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Interesting interview
Also, keep in mind that both Nikon and Canon have announced that they will stop (have stopped? I can't recall the date) film SLR developments.

Sooner or later dSLR will be body IS, except maybe for the super-telezooms, where a stable viewfinder is important for getting composition right.

I've shot up to 480 mm effectively handheld, and while the shaking was evident in the viewfinder, it wasn't hampering. So my experience suggests that only after 300 mm there may remain a demand for in-lens IS.
Sep 22, 2006 at 06:28 AM
Tentacle
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Interesting interview
Beni wrote:
I had understood that you could not shift a FF sensor with an internal IS system simply because you don't have enough lens circle spare to do so as opposed to an APC system where you have plenty room to shift to given that it is a substantial crop of the lens imaging circle.

That makes the dilemma even worse for canon.


There may be some truth to this, but I expect that the margin in projection circle is more than enough to allow for a few mm of shift in horizontal and vertical direction. Worst case it would cause some more vignetting because corners are less exposed for part of the duration of the exposure.
Sep 22, 2006 at 06:34 AM
lexvo
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Interesting interview
Beni wrote:
I had understood that you could not shift a FF sensor with an internal IS system simply because you don't have enough lens circle spare to do so as opposed to an APC system where you have plenty room to shift to given that it is a substantial crop of the lens imaging circle.

That makes the dilemma even worse for canon.


I don't know the image circle of EF-S lenses, but if it is very thight around the sensor, then Canon would have no room there also for in-camera IS....
Sep 22, 2006 at 06:37 AM
Gerry Szarek
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Interesting interview
Tentacle wrote:
Beni wroteI had understood that you could not shift a FF sensor with an internal IS system simply because you don't have enough lens circle spare to do so as opposed to an APC system where you have plenty room to shift to given that it is a substantial crop of the lens imaging circle.

That makes the dilemma even worse for canon.
There may be some truth to this, but I expect that the margin in projection circle is more than enough to allow for a few mm of shift in horizontal and vertical direction. Worst case it would cause some more vignetting because corners are less exposed for part of the duration of the exposure.


I am no optical engineer, but I think the movement of a few mm is just a tad high, it doesn't feel right to this mechanical engineer.

Gerry
Sep 22, 2006 at 07:12 AM
Yero
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Interesting interview
Probably a stupid suggestion, but wouldn't it be possible to put IS in a small converter (such as a 1,4x extender?) for a fair price? You would then have IS with every lens and it's visible in the viewfinder too!
Sep 22, 2006 at 07:29 AM
Tentacle
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Interesting interview
Gerry Szarek wrote:
[...]

I am no optical engineer, but I think the movement of a few mm is just a tad high, it doesn't feel right to this mechanical engineer.


Well, this to-be Materials Science engineer based the "few mm" movement on the demonstration movies which can be found in some Konica Minolta DiMage A1/A2 reviews. For instance those on DPReview. The demo gives you a rough idea of the movement a "floating" sensor can do. Allthough please keep in mind that the DiMage has a 2/3" sensor, not APS-C.
Sep 22, 2006 at 07:53 AM
gfiksel
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Interesting interview
Looking through my handhold shots I couldn't find blurring larger than about 1mm when using under 100mm lenses. I think this amount of shake compensation is completely up to task for in-camera IS. With longer lenses better results can be obtained with in-lens IS, so one can just turn the camera IS off.
Sep 22, 2006 at 08:44 AM
Me_XMan
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Interesting interview
I will never buy in-body IS. It's wasted money since depreciation is way faster with body than lens.

Pixel Perfect wrote:
Someone on dpreview translated interview with Engineer from 400D team. One point is that he implies Canon is not going to offer inbody IS, but instead will expand it's in lens IS to many more lenses. He calims in body is not good as you don't see stabilization through the viewfinder.

Here is link:

http://photojpn.org/bbs/viewtopic.php?t=772

The author has requested do not copy and paste his article.

Sep 22, 2006 at 08:55 AM
bouch
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Interesting interview
In body IS works for the special case of using 35mm lenses with an APS body. Canon's EF lenses don't have the image circle to enable in-body IS with FF, and I suspect their EF-S lenses don't have the image circle to enable in-body IS with APS.

Honestly I can't figure out why you people complain here. If you must have in-body IS, there are a bunch of choices. Go buy one of them.
Sep 22, 2006 at 09:04 AM
pookipichu
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Interesting interview
bouch wrote:
In body IS works for the special case of using 35mm lenses with an APS body. Canon's EF lenses don't have the image circle to enable in-body IS with FF, and I suspect their EF-S lenses don't have the image circle to enable in-body IS with APS.

Honestly I can't figure out why you people complain here. If you must have in-body IS, there are a bunch of choices. Go buy one of them.


First of all speculation about whether the image circle of Canon's lenses are big enough to support in-body IS is just that, speculation.

What we do know is that Minolta, Sony and Pentax have successfully produced cameras with in-body IS, and their cameras have the same image circle as Canon lenses. Secondly we do know that they have produced, or in the case of Pentax, will be releasing these bodies at a price point lower than the XTi.

If you can't figure out why people complain, well complaint is often the best indicator of a problem with the product. In one extreme, you have people who complained because their laptop battery set their pants on fire. Without complaints, companies grow complacent, or fail to supply services/products that the consumer desires/needs.

Lastly, if you own a camera or cameras and lenses of one brand, leaving is not that simple. If you've ever been through or witnessed a divorce, you know that leaving is not that simple. It's messy and expensive, you need to start all over again. Not to mention the gidgets and gizmos of canon accessories, flashes etc...

The United States is a country formed and built by complainers. If people didn't complain or were supressed from complaining by wiretaps, secret prisons, threat of professional destruction by outing undercover operatives working for national security, hegemonistic cabal, we'd be living in a fascistic society.

Edited by pookipichu on Sep 22, 2006 at 03:41 PM GMT
Sep 22, 2006 at 09:37 AM
Tentacle
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Interesting interview
bouch wrote:
In body IS works for the special case of using 35mm lenses with an APS body. Canon's EF lenses don't have the image circle to enable in-body IS with FF, and I suspect their EF-S lenses don't have the image circle to enable in-body IS with APS.

[...]


It's a misconception to assume a strictly defined image circle. Lenses project to a bigger area then what they are designed for. It's just that the quality outside of the intended projection circle is of no concern when designing the lens. In other words: There is some margin to play with.

For example: Just put a Tokina 12-24 mm lens (which is APS-C optimised) on a APS-H (1.3x crop) camera and you will have full coverage from 18 mm up. Below 18 mm there is heavy vignetting. The lens was not designed to work on APS-H but nevertheless extends coverage beyond APS-C.

The same goes for FF lenses. They are made to project an image in the FF image circle, but that doesn't mean there is NO light at all just outside that circle.
Sep 22, 2006 at 09:39 AM
JohnJ80
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Interesting interview
Two other concerns that have not been addressed, and a comment on pricing.

Comments:
1. I would suspect that the reliability of body IS where you move the sensor around is less than in lens IS. You need to now have a more robust electrical connection scheme that will be more prone to fail. As well, there could be the concern that in body IS failing, might render the body inoperable.

If you lens IS is inoperable, you are still in business if you have another lens.

2. IP: Let's take two cases - the first being that in Lens IS is superior in every way. In that cae, it is not unlikely that between Canon and Nikon there are enough patents to make it almost impossible to come up with a new lens IS system. If the profit model works so well for Canon and Nikon, would not the other camera systems want to do that too?

The second case is that in body IS is superior in every way but more difficult to do or it would have been done first. In this case then perhaps the suppliers of in body IS have it over Canon and Nikon and they cannot address it because of IP issues.

I suspect the first and not the second (i.e. reliability), if I had to guess. Consider a sensor that moves - a delicate semiconductor with a delicate interconnection scheme. A drop could cause some pretty high accelerations to really damage that sensor easily.

The comment:

Surely in lens IS does not cost anywhere near the $500-600 that Canon gets for it. It is an additional lens group or so, some tiny gyros (which are not all that expensive) and a microcontroller (very cheap). The cost is most likely in the R&D necessary to come up with, and refine the approach. If this is the case, and presuming that Canon has paid back that initial R&D and only needs to sustain improvement engineering, then they have the option of putting it on new lenses at very low cost. That could and would take away the cost advantage of in body IS.

So, should this be the case, it is also likely that Canon is just watching market share vs profits and will make the business decision when prudent to do so. That's what I would do - maximize profits until you feel the other guys are worrisome and threatening from a business/market share perspective. Currently, the are not. There is no groundswell rush to those guys at the expense of Canon and Nikon market share or profits.

J.
Sep 22, 2006 at 10:16 AM
bouch
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Interesting interview
pookipichu wrote:
The United States is a country formed and built by complainers. If people didn't complain or were supressed from complaining by wiretaps, secret prisons, threat of professional destruction by outing undercover operatives working for national security, hegemonistic cabal, we'd be living in a fascistic society.

Edited by pookipichu on Sep 22, 2006 at 03:41 PM GMT


Wow, you got me pookipichu! Unfortunately for you I work for the govenrment, and now I'm going to authorize wiretapping for all the 'Jade Youngs' in NYC. This is becuase I'm a fascist and I don't want any 'leftists' like you forcing Canon to implement in camera IS. If you don't shut up then you're going to Gitmo!

Oh, by the way, Sony, Mintolta, Pentax, etc. all use APS sized sensors and 35mm lenses... meaning the image circle is much bigger than the sensors.
Sep 22, 2006 at 10:33 AM
rceres
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Interesting interview
-I have one EOS camera body and 3 EOS lenses (none IS). If my body were IS and the IS died I'm down to zero photographic capability. If one of my lenses dies, I still have the other two. Theoretical advantage to in lens IS.
-IS is going to make equipment more delicate. Advantage to lens IS.
-IS in lense can be optimized to the lens design. Advantage to lens IS.
-IS is far more important for long focal lengths than for short for a lot of reasons (ease of camea handling without inducing shake, reduction in relative effect of vibration, generally faster glass at shorter focal lengths...) Theoretical advantage to IS since guys like me who generally don't have any need for IS don't have to pay for it.
-In my opinion it is better to buy faster glass since that give greater DoF options AND ability to shoot at lower speeds.
Sep 22, 2006 at 10:34 AM
bouch
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Interesting interview
Tentacle wrote:
It's a misconception to assume a strictly defined image circle. Lenses project to a bigger area then what they are designed for. It's just that the quality outside of the intended projection circle is of no concern when designing the lens. In other words: There is some margin to play with.


Zoom lenses may have some margin to play with in parts of their range, but across the product line there are no doubt a lot of lens focal length & aperature combinations that would cause problems. The lens you mention, the Tamron 12-24, is still basically a 35mm lens on an APS camera. Only the EF-S lens with their shorter back focus distance are really APS lenses. People complain all the time that their lenses aren't good enough in the corners on FF. Imagine how bad it would be if the sensor was moving around.

Anyways, have you ever looked inside a full-frame body? Ever noticed how there no room for the sensor to move? A moving FF sensor would mean a bigger mirror box, a bigger mirror... a problem for EF lenses. The other manufacturers can get away with this because they are using 35mm lenses with a tiny APS mirror.
Sep 22, 2006 at 10:40 AM
Tentacle
Offline
Details
p.2 #17Interesting interview
Good point on reliability JohnJ80, allthough I think that if the sensor can no longer move, you're not out of luck in the "Taking pictures" market. In most cases you'll just loose the IS functionality. But you're off on your assumption that IF in-body IS is superior, it would have been done first.

Canon and Nikon both have developed in-lens IS because you can not stabilise film!

IS was around quite a while before dSLR became available. In-lens IS wil work just as well for film as for digital, but in-body will only work for digital.

But let's face it, this isn't about what is ultimately superior. In-lens IS is better: It also works on film, it also stabilises the viewfinder, it can be optimised for the specific lens optics and we don't need speculation at all on if it will work on FF. But the premium is also huge, every IS lens carries an extra fee.

Contrast this to in-body IS: One investment and you're set. You'll have IS "on every lens" because it's on the body.

And erhh, "what price premium?"

Both Sony Alpha 100 and Pentax K10D have a US$ 899 list price (body only) while the 30D had an introduction list price of US $1399.
Sep 22, 2006 at 10:43 AM
Tentacle
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Interesting interview
bouch wrote:
[...]

The lens you mention, the Tamron 12-24, is still basically a 35mm lens on an APS camera. Only the EF-S lens with their shorter back focus distance are really APS lenses. People complain all the time that their lenses aren't good enough in the corners on FF. Imagine how bad it would be if the sensor was moving around.

[...]


I have to correct two things: The TOKINA (sorry, not Tamron) lens is optimised for an APS-C sized sensor. The fact that EF-S allows for deeper intrusion of the rear element into the camera has little to do with optimisation for projection circle.

Most EF-S lenses can be hacked to work on the 10D, while some will wreck its mirror. Which means not all EF-S lenses fully utilise the possibility that the specifications allow.

Sigma optimises for the smaller projection circle and puts a DC tag in the lens designation. Tamron puts the Di II tag in there. Tokina has the DX addition. All these optimise for smaller projection without using the extra allowed penetration.
Sep 22, 2006 at 10:51 AM
Roy NN7DX
Offline
Details
p.2 #19Interesting interview
OK... Canon and Nikon use in lens IS...
If I'm not missing something, the new Panasonic (and similar Leica) SLR offers an IS kit lens... It's a detachable "Leica" lens with Panasonic's Super Steady Shot IS system built into the lens...
It seems like C&N are not the only players with in-lens IS...
Sep 22, 2006 at 11:06 AM
cogitech
Offline
Details
p.2 #20Interesting interview
I prefer the 3rd choice: No IS
Sep 22, 2006 at 11:11 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister