p.1 #1Sony FE 400mm F4.5 GM OSS vs Sony FE 600mm F6.3 GM OSS - which one to choose?
Hi all,
After reading multiple forum threads, checking reviews and browsing Facebook groups, I'm still struggling to decide which lens would suit me best. I've come across quite a few conflicting opinions and claims, as well as several calculations regarding the effective focal lengths of these lenses. Since I'm certainly no expert in optics, I'm not entirely sure whether these calculations are accurate or how much weight I should give them when making my decision.
I'd appreciate some input from people who have experience with either lens, or preferably both.
First the obvious specs that are provided by Sony to start the comparison:
Image sharpness
One example of the conflicting information I've come across is the difference between Dustin Abbott's review and Tony Northrup's review regarding the sharpness of the 400mm F4.5 GM with the 1.4x TC compared to the bare 600mm F6.3 GM.
I've also read somewhere (although I can't recall the exact source or testing conditions) that the 600mm with the 1.4x TC delivers marginally higher resolution than the bare 600mm when compared to cropping the latter to achieve the same field of view.
I'd be interested to hear whether anyone has come across reliable comparisons of these combinations, preferably at different subject distances.
Effective focal length and focus breathing
Another interesting topic is the calculation of effective focal lengths by @dclark in the following thread :https://api.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1960859/ and a user in the Facebook group "Sony 400 & 600 lightweight GM primes". First of all, thanks for taking the time to work these calculations out. Please don't take my questions as criticism; I'm simply trying to understand the underlying calculations and their practical implications.
Please find the overview of their findings below:
These results suggest that the 400mm + 1.4x TC would provide almost the same field of view as the bare 600mm. Interestingly, the 400mm + 2.0x TC would even provide a slightly narrower field of view than the 600mm + 1.4x TC.
On the other hand, I came across a calculation in the Facebook group "Sony 400 & 600 lightweight GM primes", where someone compared the effective focal lengths of several lenses at their minimum focusing distance.
The calculation was based on the minimum focusing distance and maximum magnification. According to these results, the 400mm lens suffers considerably less from focus breathing than the 600mm. This seems to paint a rather different picture compared to their nominal focal lengths, particularly when considering close focusing distances.
I'm curious whether both calculation methods are technically sound and whether the results are directly comparable. Could relatively small measurement errors have a significant impact on the calculated effective focal lengths?
Autofocus performance
Another point I've noticed in several discussions is that some users report relatively slow AF performance with the 600mm in shaded or darker environments. Some even describe it as slower than their 200-600mm G lens.
I realise these are subjective observations rather than controlled measurements, but I'd be interested to know whether others have experienced something similar.
My personal situation and intended use
All of this has made me reconsider what initially seemed like an almost "instant-buy" for the 600mm.
For some context, my current setup consists of:
• Sony 300mm F2.8 GM, including both teleconverters.
• Sony 70-200mm F2.8 GM II.
• Sony 24-70mm F2.8 GM II.
• Sony A7R VI.
I purchased the 300mm F2.8 GM shortly before rumours about the two lenses mentioned above started circulating. I also went somewhat over budget to get a lightweight setup for my A7R VI. I intend to sell the 300mm F2.8 GM after my safari in Uganda next February. Both the 400mm and 600mm would be considerably cheaper and lighter alternatives for my needs, and I don't really need the F2.8 aperture. My primary subject is small birds, which I photograph mostly here in the Netherlands. Reaching distant subjects and retaining as much detail as possible are therefore important considerations.
Questions
General questions (hopefully useful for others facing the same dilemma as well):
1. Has anyone come across a good, controlled comparison between the 400mm and 600mm at multiple focusing distances, particularly regarding image quality, sharpness and actual field of view?
2. Are there any other important factors I should consider when comparing these two lenses?
3. Is all of the above any relevant or am I perhaps overthinking this?
4. For anyone with a deeper understanding of optics: are the effective focal length calculations described above technically correct? Could relatively small measurement errors result in significant differences in the calculated focal lengths?
Personal question:
Considering my current setup, my intended use (primarily small birds in the Netherlands), and everything mentioned above, would you recommend the 400mm or the 600mm?
I appreciate input from people who have used one or both lenses in real-world conditions.
Thanks in advance for taking the time to share your thoughts and experiences!
PS: This is my first real post, if you have any feedback - let me know!
p.1 #2Sony FE 400mm F4.5 GM OSS vs Sony FE 600mm F6.3 GM OSS - which one to choose?
Focus breathing refers to changes in Field of View, FOV, as the lens focus distance changes. A lens with no focus breathing has the same FOV at all focus distances. It is easy to show that no focus breathing means the focal length needs to shrink at shorter focus distances. Saying the focal length should not change is a very common error, lots of internet "experts" get it wrong.
It's easy to measure the FOV. The only issue is where front principle plane of the lens is located. If you use the front end of the lens to compute the FOV that should be approximately correct.
Focus breathing is not an issue for shooting still images of birds. That is more of an issue for video shooting if you are pulling focus. For wildlife you don't want the FOV to grow since the wildlife will be smaller in the frame.
p.1 #3Sony FE 400mm F4.5 GM OSS vs Sony FE 600mm F6.3 GM OSS - which one to choose?
dclark wrote:
Focus breathing refers to changes in Field of View, FOV, as the lens focus distance changes. A lens with no focus breathing has the same FOV at all focus distances. It is easy to show that no focus breathing means the focal length needs to shrink at shorter focus distances. Saying the focal length should not change is a very common error, lots of internet "experts" get it wrong.
It's easy to measure the FOV. The only issue is where front principle plane of the lens is located. If you use the front end of the lens to compute the FOV that should be approximately correct.
Focus breathing is not an issue for shooting still images of birds. That is more of an issue for video shooting if you are pulling focus. For wildlife you don't want the FOV to grow since the wildlife will be smaller in the frame. ...Show more →
Hi Clark! Thanks for your reply! I only knew this from videos and focus pulls indeed. What is your conclusion then if you read the outcome of the calculations? Or do you think it was misinterpreted?
p.1 #4Sony FE 400mm F4.5 GM OSS vs Sony FE 600mm F6.3 GM OSS - which one to choose?
MrSnooZzz wrote:
Considering my current setup, my intended use (primarily small birds in the Netherlands), and everything mentioned above, would you recommend the 400mm or the 600mm?
When the 400/600 were first announced I had to make the same tough choice too. Previous to getting the 600 6.3 I had been using 300+2x TC combo mostly so I went with 600 because I mainly shoot birds. It depends if you want to prioritize low light capability or bird filling the frame capability. With the 400 you have to crop more so any light advantage is negated, see:
In the post above that one I posted a pic of a junco I took in low light and still came out ok, even at 6.3.
Junco is a small active bird so even though I was roughly 10m away you can still see how much I had to crop to bring out the detail. A lot of people say 6.3 is too slow, and maybe it is but I found I could still take useable bird pics in low light by dropping the shutter speed and jacking up ISO. Lower shutter speed is not ideal since the birds are always moving, sure, your "keeper rate" is going to go down by shooting at such low shutter speed on moving birds but if you shoot 30 FPS then at least one will come out good if you shoot long bursts. Shooting at 4.5 is a great advantage sure but I don't think its absolutely necessary. If your going to more environmental shots with more of the background/scenery in the shot, 400 would work. Or 600 works just as well as those, just don't get so close.
I feel if i got the 400 4.5, the 1.4x TC would be on it all the time and sure that's fine but I still have a hard time believing a lens with a TC in front of it is better than a similar lens with no TC in front of it.
I looked at it like this:
How many times would i shoot 400 bare? Probably not many times, since when I had the 300 2.8 I shot exactly zero times as 300 2.8, very few times as 300+1.4x TC and 99% of time as 300+2x TC. So to me it made more sense to get the 600. There's been many fine images posted in the 600 thread you can see above, I don't think image quality or sharpness matters in this there both very good.
A small advantage to 600 though is shooting at 600 without TC. Maybe you get an AF advantage over 400+1.4x who knows but I can tell the weight advantage is real. Sure only weighs 166g but I just spent two days of shooting mostly with bare lens and when I put 1.4x on the 600 I was like oooh yeah i can feel that hahah. Every gram matters! Funny i say that when I used to carry 600f4, not fun haha. Cheers, you can't go wrong with chosing either lens though.
p.1 #5Sony FE 400mm F4.5 GM OSS vs Sony FE 600mm F6.3 GM OSS - which one to choose?
pdog109 wrote: MrSnooZzz wroteConsidering my current setup, my intended use (primarily small birds in the Netherlands), and everything mentioned above, would you recommend the 400mm or the 600mm?When the 400/600 were first announced I had to make the same tough choice too. Previous to getting the 600 6.3 I had been using 300+2x TC combo mostly so I went with 600 because I mainly shoot birds. It depends if you want to prioritize low light capability or bird filling the frame capability. With the 400 you have to crop more so any light advantage is negated, see:
In the post above that one I posted a pic of a junco I took in low light and still came out ok, even at 6.3.
Junco is a small active bird so even though I was roughly 10m away you can still see how much I had to crop to bring out the detail. A lot of people say 6.3 is too slow, and maybe it is but I found I could still take useable bird pics in low light by dropping the shutter speed and jacking up ISO. Lower shutter speed is not ideal since the birds are always moving, sure, your "keeper rate" is going to go down by shooting at such low shutter speed on moving birds but if you shoot 30 FPS then at least one will come out good if you shoot long bursts. Shooting at 4.5 is a great advantage sure but I don't think its absolutely necessary. If your going to more environmental shots with more of the background/scenery in the shot, 400 would work. Or 600 works just as well as those, just don't get so close.
I feel if i got the 400 4.5, the 1.4x TC would be on it all the time and sure that's fine but I still have a hard time believing a lens with a TC in front of it is better than a similar lens with no TC in front of it.
I looked at it like this:
How many times would i shoot 400 bare? Probably not many times, since when I had the 300 2.8 I shot exactly zero times as 300 2.8, very few times as 300+1.4x TC and 99% of time as 300+2x TC. So to me it made more sense to get the 600. There's been many fine images posted in the 600 thread you can see above, I don't think image quality or sharpness matters in this there both very good.
A small advantage to 600 though is shooting at 600 without TC. Maybe you get an AF advantage over 400+1.4x who knows but I can tell the weight advantage is real. Sure only weighs 166g but I just spent two days of shooting mostly with bare lens and when I put 1.4x on the 600 I was like oooh yeah i can feel that hahah. Every gram matters! Funny i say that when I used to carry 600f4, not fun haha. Cheers, you can't go wrong with chosing either lens though. ...Show more →
Yeah I guess I will be an outlier as well, as I don’t like the image my 300mm+ 2xTC is producing compared to the 300mm + 1.4xTC and cropping.
Regarding the picture of the junco, that’s a nice example! I often feel that I have to crop quite a bit with the 300mm + 1.4. Thats why I would have instantly bought the 600mm, until I read that the effective focal length is not far off the 400mm.
I now often use the 420mm focal length, as I explained before on the disappointing results of the 2x TC. I guess I will mostly use the 400mm with the 1.4x as well, with the exception of some low light shots.
I hope some of the tests on focal length are reproduced and some comparisons will come online on these lenses in terms of TC sharpness.
Thanks for your thoughts, insights and decision making process!
p.1 #6Sony FE 400mm F4.5 GM OSS vs Sony FE 600mm F6.3 GM OSS - which one to choose?
You have probably read my decision on here but I first bought the 600 as I thought it would be most usefull as a 600 and then sometimes an 840 lens. Something my 300GM can't reach to. I couldn't wrap my head around any scenario where the 300/2x would match the 600 bare for IQ and especially AF.
However, after my testing the IQ is virtually identical...with maybe the slightest edge to the 600 at 200% comparison. Meaningless in real life.
The AF is harder to say. But the 600 certainly didn't have any magic over the 300/2x that I could find. I do wish I had my April swallows around for a more challenging test but alas it is November.
In my case I use my 300 bare maybe 15-20% of the time and I use the 300/1.4TC ~30%. 300/2x ~50%.
Therefore I was always feeling the 600, being stuck at 600, was limiting my versatility when out shooting it. I kept thinking I now needed to carry both the 600 and the 300/1.4TC to cover what I wanted to do each day. That is a downgrade from just using the 300 with TCs.
My overall impressions from all the reviews I read and watched showed the 400/1.4TC to be close to equal to the 600 and then there were Dave's focal length calculations that made the 560 vs 600 meaningless.
In my own testing I found the 600/1.4TC was just slightly better than the 600 cropped. So there is a case to be made for that use case if one wants 840 enough of the time. I'm not exactly sure how the 400/2x will compare to the 600/1.4x.
That then led me to return the 600 and go for the 400. My 400 arrives next week. I did shoot my friend's 400 yesterday but the light was abysmal and the tides so high there were very few subjects.
I think if one has little to no use of 400mm then the 600 is for sure the lens to buy. If one wants more versatility to drop back to 400 then I think they are so similar at the comparable focal lengths that the 400 is the way to go.
And of course the 300 with both TCs may still be a better option for some/many if they can use it at 300 some of the time.
p.1 #7Sony FE 400mm F4.5 GM OSS vs Sony FE 600mm F6.3 GM OSS - which one to choose?
pdog109 wrote: MrSnooZzz wroteConsidering my current setup, my intended use (primarily small birds in the Netherlands), and everything mentioned above, would you recommend the 400mm or the 600mm?When the 400/600 were first announced I had to make the same tough choice too. Previous to getting the 600 6.3 I had been using 300+2x TC combo mostly so I went with 600 because I mainly shoot birds. It depends if you want to prioritize low light capability or bird filling the frame capability. With the 400 you have to crop more so any light advantage is negated, see:
In the post above that one I posted a pic of a junco I took in low light and still came out ok, even at 6.3.
Junco is a small active bird so even though I was roughly 10m away you can still see how much I had to crop to bring out the detail. A lot of people say 6.3 is too slow, and maybe it is but I found I could still take useable bird pics in low light by dropping the shutter speed and jacking up ISO. Lower shutter speed is not ideal since the birds are always moving, sure, your "keeper rate" is going to go down by shooting at such low shutter speed on moving birds but if you shoot 30 FPS then at least one will come out good if you shoot long bursts. Shooting at 4.5 is a great advantage sure but I don't think its absolutely necessary. If your going to more environmental shots with more of the background/scenery in the shot, 400 would work. Or 600 works just as well as those, just don't get so close.
I feel if i got the 400 4.5, the 1.4x TC would be on it all the time and sure that's fine but I still have a hard time believing a lens with a TC in front of it is better than a similar lens with no TC in front of it.
I looked at it like this:
How many times would i shoot 400 bare? Probably not many times, since when I had the 300 2.8 I shot exactly zero times as 300 2.8, very few times as 300+1.4x TC and 99% of time as 300+2x TC. So to me it made more sense to get the 600. There's been many fine images posted in the 600 thread you can see above, I don't think image quality or sharpness matters in this there both very good.
A small advantage to 600 though is shooting at 600 without TC. Maybe you get an AF advantage over 400+1.4x who knows but I can tell the weight advantage is real. Sure only weighs 166g but I just spent two days of shooting mostly with bare lens and when I put 1.4x on the 600 I was like oooh yeah i can feel that hahah. Every gram matters! Funny i say that when I used to carry 600f4, not fun haha. Cheers, you can't go wrong with chosing either lens though. ...Show more →
I was thinking that constantly switching between the 1.4x and 2x teleconverters on the 400mm would be a real pain.
On the other hand, having a native 400mm would be a big advantage in certain situations. At the zoo (with the kids), for example, bringing the 200-600mm always felt like too much of a commitment, so I usually end up taking the 70-200mm instead. I suspect 600mm would often be too long, but if I had a 400mm, I'd probably be much more inclined to bring that over the 70-200
p.1 #9Sony FE 400mm F4.5 GM OSS vs Sony FE 600mm F6.3 GM OSS - which one to choose?
I chose the 400 for the same reasons he mentioned for I travel a lot and weight is a huge factor for me
Besides with the 400 I can extend it, but cannot make the 600 shorter
After 2 weeks in Japan, I was totally happy with the 400 + 1.4TC
I shot at dawn so the wider aperture helps me control the ISO a bit easier
I only used the 2X in 1 occasion when the birds were so distant
I usually carry just 1 lens around so unlike him, I may let go of my beloved 300mm
On safari trips where the animals could come closer to you, a zoom may be preferable, but I don't so safaris
1 day should I feel silly and bored I may get the 600mm as a second lens for longer distance birds but that's not a must now that I have the 400 + 2 TCs
p.1 #10Sony FE 400mm F4.5 GM OSS vs Sony FE 600mm F6.3 GM OSS - which one to choose?
Just curious. What did you shoot in Japan with your 400? I plan to visit there but I just can't think of anything that would require a 400, much less with a 1.4 tc.
p.1 #11Sony FE 400mm F4.5 GM OSS vs Sony FE 600mm F6.3 GM OSS - which one to choose?
aCuria wrote:
I was thinking that constantly switching between the 1.4x and 2x teleconverters on the 400mm would be a real pain.
Shooting with just 600 bare solves that, but costs $1000 more. But then again whats $1000 when spending money on cameras and multiple lenses that don't get used, but except for certain scenarios. That's why I only have one lens.
p.1 #12Sony FE 400mm F4.5 GM OSS vs Sony FE 600mm F6.3 GM OSS - which one to choose?
Lots of ducks, Tits, Bulbuls, Egrets, Herons, Magpies, Wagtails , Vireos , Redstarts
Black Kites, Sparrowhawks (if lucky)
Common Kingfishers (my fav), Great Cormorants, Moorhens , Grebes (Crested also my fav) ...
400 is good, sometimes 600 , not worth shooting if further than 600
p.1 #13Sony FE 400mm F4.5 GM OSS vs Sony FE 600mm F6.3 GM OSS - which one to choose?
Lt.Deadeye wrote:
Just curious. What did you shoot in Japan with your 400? I plan to visit there but I just can't think of anything that would require a 400, much less with a 1.4 tc.
If you go to eastern Hokkaido you probably want 600mm +
p.1 #15Sony FE 400mm F4.5 GM OSS vs Sony FE 600mm F6.3 GM OSS - which one to choose?
l own both the 400 and 600.
400 is a hair sharper than 600 but real world usage you're not going to notice. They're both very close it is hard to tell even pixel peeping.
If your shots are usually 400mm then that is the right lens to get.
If your shots are usually 600mm then that is the right lens to get.
One of the big reason to get these new lenses is "weight". This has real world impact. You'll feel the difference. You can hold it longer. Travel further. Be more comfortable.
If you're mostly shooting 600mm+ and weight is the goal then 400+1.4 TC is the suboptimal choice. Even though the TC only adds 17-22% extra weight it does add up and you can definitely feel it. (I know I do on long hikes.) Probably why Sony created the 600. They love making things lighter/smaller.
However, if cost/versatility is the primary concern or you're just unsure then 400 is better with TC. It gives you 400/600/800 range for the same cost as one 600.
---
As for AF performance anyone have an idea how to test/measure this in a controlled environment? Maybe a zipline with some stuffed animals?