p.1 #1Lightroom adjustments to custom Canon Picture Styles (Monochrome)
Hi everyone,
I spend quite a bit of time in Lightroom adjusting exposure and contrast for my photos. Recently, I’ve been looking into Canon’s Picture Style Editor to see if I can recreate my usual Lightroom adjustments directly in-camera.
The main idea is to get the JPEG preview—and ideally straight-out-of-camera (SOOC) results—much closer to my final intended look right at the time of capture.
I’ve been experimenting with a custom Monochrome Picture Style profile using the following settings:
p.1 #4Lightroom adjustments to custom Canon Picture Styles (Monochrome)
I use Silver Efex for b&w pics - Pen-F, Q2M and R3 - but just for shots I want to tweak deeper.
My take on your shots - a tad dark and loosing detail - and I am a guy that likes dark, high contrast tonalities.
as far as in-camera settings, I shoot in raw, but use filters on the Q2M.
p.1 #5Lightroom adjustments to custom Canon Picture Styles (Monochrome)
You asked for Tri-X 400 in your other thread, but that one's full of AI promotion, so let's get this sorted out here.
Modern Tri-X 400 turned out to be a bit trickier than expected, as it's actually more uneven in its spectral sensitivity than the older version, so I couldn't just use my original Tri-X replication as a base. I've had to approach this one from scratch, and since Tri-X 400 isn't a film I ever care to use myself and online examples are useless (you never know how a film image was developed, scanned, and possibly edited further on computer), I could only work from the official datasheet. This means I've copied a hypothetical 'ideal' batch of Tri-X 400 and not necessarily the reality of whatever small variations have happened in production. It also means I've made it based on Kodak's own standard development and can't account for whatever differences in development you may be used to.
Most importantly, though, it turns out the modern Tri-X 400 has a a broader, overall larger response to UV than the old version; its UV peak isn't as high as the old one, but it's generally high over the whole UV range, whereas the old version had a higher peak over a shorter range. This basically means that to replicate Tri-X 400 correctly you need a camera which has been converted for UV or full spectrum. Obviously, there is no colour processing which can compensate for that; a regular, non-converted camera literally won't see some of the light which the real film sees. The only way to add that digitally is to actually fake it with something like Photoshop.
Also, I can't see your examples (imgur blocks the UK), but judging from your use of the yellow filter option, the look you're trying to get may not actually be what Tri-X 400 does...
Lastly on the list of disclaimers is the simple fact that I don't have a 6D to verify this matrix on. It's coming out as expect on files from a 6DmkII, R5, and R50, but every camera sensor and processor combination is different and I can't promise the 6D will behave the same way. Check it on raw files in DPP before you load it into your camera.
So, here's the base profile, clearly named TRI-X 400 BASE: https://storage.to/I9EJmjQAa
That file will be deleted in 3 days, but I don't know any really reliable, permanent, and free file hosts, so... that'll have to do.
And yeah, it's only 1.31kb. That's how small a colour matrix is... no matter what nonsense Fujifilm's management says about it being impossible to put new profiles on old cameras.
I've left it 'unlocked' so you can edit it further in standard PSE if you want. If you do edit the file in PSE at all, remember to save it as a .PF2 (PSE will default to .PF3) and don't use the larger RGB curve. Your 6D simply doesn't support that.
Since it's a film replication it exposes in a logarithmic way, meaning that you'd often want to slightly overexpose it if you were shooting jpg or video with it. To use it simply as a kind of preview for a raw file, you will probably want to open it in PSE and edit the final L curve (that's the small one on the 'specific colours' tab) for a general increase in mid and highlight tones. Of course, like film grain, noise will also increase in an exponential way opposite to the curve exposure increases on, so don't expect to be shooting this at 12800 or whatever and get a clean image. You asked for a replica of Tri-X 400 and that's what this is, including the limitations which are part of how it gets its look.
You'll see I've set the default values of the in-camera controls to Contrast -2, Saturation -1, and Colour Tone 0. Contrast -2 is because that is the true neutral setting, giving us the most range to set the contrast with curves. Of course you can change this if you like, but just be aware that any setting other than -2 means a loss of information. Saturation is at -1 because, again, that's the neutral position. Decreasing it further won't do much. Increasing it will slightly darken blues and yellows. Similarly, Colour Tone is neutral at 0, reducing it will slightly lighten reds, and increasing it will slightly darken reds.
Since you're using a 6D, sharpening should just be left at 0, really. The 6D's sharpening is the equivalent of Fineness and Threshold both at 4, which is quite chunky and uneven. If you ever move to a camera which supports the Fineness and Threshold settings then the most film-like experience will be with Strength 1, Fineness 1, Threshold 1; for some reason the cameras themselves only support Fineness and Threshold in a range of 1-5, not the 0-10 range that DPP and PSE do. (And yes, Fineness works the opposite way the name suggests, and turning it down makes the sharpening finer.) In my experience the totally even, very light sharpening of 1/1/1 can look quite grain-like at low and medium ISO, especially on a larger-resolution file downsampled.
p.1 #6Lightroom adjustments to custom Canon Picture Styles (Monochrome)
pressedbunny thank you for follow up!
this is incredible and magic to me, appreciate your effort and dedication to this community
will give this a try with using R5Mark2 and r8, and share pictures on how those came out.
the 6D was what picked my interest with film emulations, do not own it but have few EF
Sigma lense and was considering only for this reason. this preset though might make it irrelevant
new to this forum and was not clar how to share pics, will make Ficker account with the results.
I've saved your TRI-X 400 BASE, and if anyone that comes along when this is expired will
re-share.
p.1 #7Lightroom adjustments to custom Canon Picture Styles (Monochrome)
I don't do a ton of editing, but I used LR for years, until Adobe thought I should start renting it. I am currently using DXO PL10, which is amazing in some regards.
Anyway, If you build this Custom Picture Style for one camera, you still do not have it for another camera. That could get tedious. If you were to shoot raw, with any camera, you have in your hand all the data the sensor could collect. No way to improve on that. Seems to me it would be a bit simpler, and more portable, if you developed a Lightroom 'recipe' for processing your monochrome photos. Such a 'recipe' could also be tweaked as needed in the future.
Just for fun, shoot a few pics raw. I'll think you'll be amazed what you can do to B&W photos manipulating nothing but the HSL sliders.
p.1 #8Lightroom adjustments to custom Canon Picture Styles (Monochrome)
TomSchriefer wrote:
Anyway, If you build this Custom Picture Style for one camera, you still do not have it for another camera.I can’t fathom where you got that idea from. Yes, every sensor+processor combination will have its own look, but broadly a file from an R5, R8, and 5D4 all have more-or-less the same look, other than resolution. What small differences there are can be tweaked and compensated for easily. The vast majority of the time you can use the same custom profile in any Canon camera and get 99% the same results from them all.
There is much less variation between cameras than there is between batches of the ‘same’ film stock or development fluids.
Shooting raw and setting your look in post will always give you the most control; that’s obvious, nobody is disputing that, and it shouldn’t need to be reiterated. But having the right look set for your raw preview can help with composing or just getting into the right mindset, and if you do want an in-camera file for whatever reason (typically speed), it’s good to know how to get the settings as close to what you like, and if you can just get the shot right in-camera first time… then why not?
p.1 #9Lightroom adjustments to custom Canon Picture Styles (Monochrome)
pressedbunny wrote: TomSchriefer wroteAnyway, If you build this Custom Picture Style for one camera, you still do not have it for another camera.I can’t fathom where you got that idea from. Yes, every sensor+processor combination will have its own look, but broadly a file from an R5, R8, and 5D4 all have more-or-less the same look, other than resolution. What small differences there are can be tweaked and compensated for easily. The vast majority of the time you can use the same custom profile in any Canon camera and get 99% the same results from them all.
There is much less variation between cameras than there is between batches of the ‘same’ film stock or development fluids.
Shooting raw and setting your look in post will always give you the most control; that’s obvious, nobody is disputing that, and it shouldn’t need to be reiterated. But having the right look set for your raw preview can help with composing or just getting into the right mindset, and if you do want an in-camera file for whatever reason (typically speed), it’s good to know how to get the settings as close to what you like, and if you can just get the shot right in-camera first time… then why not? ...Show more →
Thanks for the clarification. I believed that each camera was different enough to make a difference. I've been shooting raw for so long I have given up on getting it right in-camera. I am always tweaking something. I actually spend way more time processing raws than I did when I shot JPG. An obsession, perhaps?
I stand by my assertion that raw is way more flexible with B&W. That said, if you're getting the output you want direct from the camera, you are winning the game.
p.1 #10Lightroom adjustments to custom Canon Picture Styles (Monochrome)
pressedbunny wrote:
You asked for Tri-X 400 in your other thread, but that one's full of AI promotion, so let's get this sorted out here.
Modern Tri-X 400 turned out to be a bit trickier than expected, as it's actually more uneven in its spectral sensitivity than the older version, so I couldn't just use my original Tri-X replication as a base. I've had to approach this one from scratch, and since Tri-X 400 isn't a film I ever care to use myself and online examples are useless (you never know how a film image was developed, scanned, and possibly edited further on computer), I could only work from the official datasheet. This means I've copied a hypothetical 'ideal' batch of Tri-X 400 and not necessarily the reality of whatever small variations have happened in production. It also means I've made it based on Kodak's own standard development and can't account for whatever differences in development you may be used to.
Most importantly, though, it turns out the modern Tri-X 400 has a a broader, overall larger response to UV than the old version; its UV peak isn't as high as the old one, but it's generally high over the whole UV range, whereas the old version had a higher peak over a shorter range. This basically means that to replicate Tri-X 400 correctly you need a camera which has been converted for UV or full spectrum. Obviously, there is no colour processing which can compensate for that; a regular, non-converted camera literally won't see some of the light which the real film sees. The only way to add that digitally is to actually fake it with something like Photoshop.
Also, I can't see your examples (imgur blocks the UK), but judging from your use of the yellow filter option, the look you're trying to get may not actually be what Tri-X 400 does...
Lastly on the list of disclaimers is the simple fact that I don't have a 6D to verify this matrix on. It's coming out as expect on files from a 6DmkII, R5, and R50, but every camera sensor and processor combination is different and I can't promise the 6D will behave the same way. Check it on raw files in DPP before you load it into your camera.
So, here's the base profile, clearly named TRI-X 400 BASE:
That file will be deleted in 3 days, but I don't know any really reliable, permanent, and free file hosts, so... that'll have to do.
And yeah, it's only 1.31kb. That's how small a colour matrix is... no matter what nonsense Fujifilm's management says about it being impossible to put new profiles on old cameras.
I've left it 'unlocked' so you can edit it further in standard PSE if you want. If you do edit the file in PSE at all, remember to save it as a .PF2 (PSE will default to .PF3) and don't use the larger RGB curve. Your 6D simply doesn't support that.
Since it's a film replication it exposes in a logarithmic way, meaning that you'd often want to slightly overexpose it if you were shooting jpg or video with it. To use it simply as a kind of preview for a raw file, you will probably want to open it in PSE and edit the final L curve (that's the small one on the 'specific colours' tab) for a general increase in mid and highlight tones. Of course, like film grain, noise will also increase in an exponential way opposite to the curve exposure increases on, so don't expect to be shooting this at 12800 or whatever and get a clean image. You asked for a replica of Tri-X 400 and that's what this is, including the limitations which are part of how it gets its look.
You'll see I've set the default values of the in-camera controls to Contrast -2, Saturation -1, and Colour Tone 0. Contrast -2 is because that is the true neutral setting, giving us the most range to set the contrast with curves. Of course you can change this if you like, but just be aware that any setting other than -2 means a loss of information. Saturation is at -1 because, again, that's the neutral position. Decreasing it further won't do much. Increasing it will slightly darken blues and yellows. Similarly, Colour Tone is neutral at 0, reducing it will slightly lighten reds, and increasing it will slightly darken reds.
Since you're using a 6D, sharpening should just be left at 0, really. The 6D's sharpening is the equivalent of Fineness and Threshold both at 4, which is quite chunky and uneven. If you ever move to a camera which supports the Fineness and Threshold settings then the most film-like experience will be with Strength 1, Fineness 1, Threshold 1; for some reason the cameras themselves only support Fineness and Threshold in a range of 1-5, not the 0-10 range that DPP and PSE do. (And yes, Fineness works the opposite way the name suggests, and turning it down makes the sharpening finer.) In my experience the totally even, very light sharpening of 1/1/1 can look quite grain-like at low and medium ISO, especially on a larger-resolution file downsampled. ...Show more →
---------------------------------------------
ruslanrusu wrote:
pressedbunny thank you for follow up!
this is incredible and magic to me, appreciate your effort and dedication to this community
will give this a try with using R5Mark2 and r8, and share pictures on how those came out.
the 6D was what picked my interest with film emulations, do not own it but have few EF
Sigma lense and was considering only for this reason. this preset though might make it irrelevant
new to this forum and was not clar how to share pics, will make Ficker account with the results.
I've saved your TRI-X 400 BASE, and if anyone that comes along when this is expired will
re-share.