p.3 #1Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
vijaykr.p wrote:
1) Compressed RAW
This is a big one for me. Nikon’s High Efficiency RAW files are around 12 MB, which is quite close to the size of a JPEG at around 10 MB. In comparison, RAW files from other brands with similar Megapixels are much larger. For someone who takes a lot of family photos, the smaller file size makes a noticeable difference in storage.
This is actually a fantastic point that I'm glad someone brought up HE* was one of the little things I noticed immediately when I switched over and now recommend to all Nikon shooters.
12mb raw files on the 24mp cameras, 33mb raw files on the 45mp cameras with absolutely zero detectable downside for 99.9% of shots. There is nothing else like it on the market.
p.3 #2Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
As a longtime Nikon shooter who took a detour to Sony the last three years, it is the Z8 that won me back over. And it ruined me for Sony, I was doomed as soon as I got the Z8 in hand and started shooting it. The ergonomics are perfect for me (no pinky dangling off the bottom, no grip knuckles shoved up against lens barrel), the feel in hand is superb, the output is gorgeous, the versatility is excellent. Shooting a speedy stacked sensor with no mechanical shutter is addictive. For my history and preferences, it looks and feels like my beloved D850, only better, and that vibe resonates with me. I love the size and weight and I take the Z8 everywhere, travel walk arounds with this cam fitting my hand so nicely are a joy for me with the 28/2.8 or 40/2 SE’s.
For landscape work I have it mated to the amazing Z 24-120 which is still unrivaled by any manufacturer, combined with a superb copy of the Z 100-400 for a simple and highly productive kit that suits how I see and compose. I shot the new A7RVI and that sensor is nice, but for me Z8 ergonomics won out. My walls have many prints hanging that I made from 45mp Nikons including the Z8 sensor (in the Z9) and they look gorgeous, no apologies needed, nothing lacking.
There are also intangibles to all this - for me it just feels good and right to have a Nikon back in my hands. I listened to my heart and intuition this time. Here are a few favorite shots from this year so far.
Spring blossoms in the Blue Ridge mountains
Sunset above stacked ridges in North Carolina
Travel walkaround on a beautiful winter evening in Florida
My beloved brain cancer patient niece, Abigail
560mm on 100-400 w/1.4x and very deeply cropped, holds up well
p.3 #3Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
Lance B wrote:
I'd look at all other brands and then still buy Nikon. I like Nikon ergonomics, their lens line up and the output. Other brands may offer a few better things here and there from time to time, but these things go in cycles. At the moment, my Z8/Z9 does everything I need those cameras to do and the lenses I have are as good as you'll get in their respective focal lengths. I am very satisfied where I am.
+1. No complaints from me. I also trust Nikon to remain the most innovative lens maker on the market.
p.3 #4Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
Ross Martin wrote:
As a longtime Nikon shooter who took a detour to Sony the last three years, it is the Z8 that won me back over. And it ruined me for Sony, I was doomed as soon as I got the Z8 in hand and started shooting it. The ergonomics are perfect for me (no pinky dangling off the bottom, no grip knuckles shoved up against lens barrel), the feel in hand is superb, the output is gorgeous, the versatility is excellent. Shooting a speedy stacked sensor with no mechanical shutter is addictive. For my history and preferences, it looks and feels like my beloved D850, only better, and that vibe resonates with me. I love the size and weight and I take the Z8 everywhere, travel walk arounds with the 28/2.8 or 40/2 SE’s is a joy for me.
For landscape work I have it mated to the amazing Z 24-120 which is still unrivaled by any manufacturer, combined with a superb copy of the Z 100-400 for a simple and highly productive kit that suits how I see and compose. I shot the new A7RVI and that sensor is nice, but for me Z8 ergonomics won out. My walls have many prints hanging that I made from 45mp Nikons including the Z8 sensor (in the Z9) and they look gorgeous, no apologies needed, nothing lacking.
There are also intangibles to all this - for me it just feels good and right to have a Nikon back in my hands. I listened to my heart and intuition this time. Here are a few favorite shots from this year so far....Show more →
Beautiful work and totally agree with your points. I haven't tried other systems in a long time, but Nikon's ergonomics always fit me perfectly.
p.3 #5Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
groob wrote: Ross Martin wroteAs a longtime Nikon shooter who took a detour to Sony the last three years, it is the Z8 that won me back over. And it ruined me for Sony, I was doomed as soon as I got the Z8 in hand and started shooting it. The ergonomics are perfect for me (no pinky dangling off the bottom, no grip knuckles shoved up against lens barrel), the feel in hand is superb, the output is gorgeous, the versatility is excellent. Shooting a speedy stacked sensor with no mechanical shutter is addictive. For my history and preferences, it looks and feels like my beloved D850, only better, and that vibe resonates with me. I love the size and weight and I take the Z8 everywhere, travel walk arounds with the 28/2.8 or 40/2 SE’s is a joy for me.
For landscape work I have it mated to the amazing Z 24-120 which is still unrivaled by any manufacturer, combined with a superb copy of the Z 100-400 for a simple and highly productive kit that suits how I see and compose. I shot the new A7RVI and that sensor is nice, but for me Z8 ergonomics won out. My walls have many prints hanging that I made from 45mp Nikons including the Z8 sensor (in the Z9) and they look gorgeous, no apologies needed, nothing lacking.
There are also intangibles to all this - for me it just feels good and right to have a Nikon back in my hands. I listened to my heart and intuition this time. Here are a few favorite shots from this year so far.Beautiful work and totally agree with your points. I haven't tried other systems in a long time, but Nikon's ergonomics always fit me perfectly.
Thank you! Yes, those ergonomics make a big difference to me also.
p.3 #6Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
Ross Martin wrote:
As a longtime Nikon shooter who took a detour to Sony the last three years, it is the Z8 that won me back over. And it ruined me for Sony, I was doomed as soon as I got the Z8 in hand and started shooting it. The ergonomics are perfect for me (no pinky dangling off the bottom, no grip knuckles shoved up against lens barrel), the feel in hand is superb, the output is gorgeous, the versatility is excellent. Shooting a speedy stacked sensor with no mechanical shutter is addictive. For my history and preferences, it looks and feels like my beloved D850, only better, and that vibe resonates with me. I love the size and weight and I take the Z8 everywhere, travel walk arounds with the 28/2.8 or 40/2 SE’s is a joy for me.
For landscape work I have it mated to the amazing Z 24-120 which is still unrivaled by any manufacturer, combined with a superb copy of the Z 100-400 for a simple and highly productive kit that suits how I see and compose. I shot the new A7RVI and that sensor is nice, but for me Z8 ergonomics won out. My walls have many prints hanging that I made from 45mp Nikons including the Z8 sensor (in the Z9) and they look gorgeous, no apologies needed, nothing lacking.
There are also intangibles to all this - for me it just feels good and right to have a Nikon back in my hands. I listened to my heart and intuition this time. Here are a few favorite shots from this year so far....Show more →
Great shots-
I think that is all that really matters- The gear needs to work with us not against us! What a crazy world we live in with so many world class options where we can debate minutia!
p.3 #7Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
Disclosures first: I am a dual-system user, enjoying Sony+Nikon. And I've been nodding as I was going through the comments in this thread. Don't want to repeat what's been said, but one thing is worth mentioning.
VALUE. The Z6 III and Z8 in particular are both incredible from the value perspective. The f/1.8 S-primes and the 24-120mm S f/4 also have no rivals on that front. And if you buy slightly used here on FM, it gets absolutely ridiculous.
Ok, I will repeat one more thing repeatedly mentioned here because it's very important IMO: ergonomics+menus.
p.3 #8Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
RustyRus wrote: Ross Martin wroteAs a longtime Nikon shooter who took a detour to Sony the last three years, it is the Z8 that won me back over. And it ruined me for Sony, I was doomed as soon as I got the Z8 in hand and started shooting it. The ergonomics are perfect for me (no pinky dangling off the bottom, no grip knuckles shoved up against lens barrel), the feel in hand is superb, the output is gorgeous, the versatility is excellent. Shooting a speedy stacked sensor with no mechanical shutter is addictive. For my history and preferences, it looks and feels like my beloved D850, only better, and that vibe resonates with me. I love the size and weight and I take the Z8 everywhere, travel walk arounds with the 28/2.8 or 40/2 SE’s is a joy for me.
For landscape work I have it mated to the amazing Z 24-120 which is still unrivaled by any manufacturer, combined with a superb copy of the Z 100-400 for a simple and highly productive kit that suits how I see and compose. I shot the new A7RVI and that sensor is nice, but for me Z8 ergonomics won out. My walls have many prints hanging that I made from 45mp Nikons including the Z8 sensor (in the Z9) and they look gorgeous, no apologies needed, nothing lacking.
There are also intangibles to all this - for me it just feels good and right to have a Nikon back in my hands. I listened to my heart and intuition this time. Here are a few favorite shots from this year so far.Great shots-
I think that is all that really matters- The gear needs to work with us not against us! What a crazy world we live in with so many world class options where we can debate minutia!
p.3 #9Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
So, I'll chime in from a completely different perspective. I used to be a huge Nikon fan ever since the "old film days". My last full frame Nikon was a D750 with a nice collection of AF-D and AF-S lenses. When Nikon abandoned the F mount, I hopped over to three different systems simultaneously; Canon EF and RF (both full frame and APS-C), Sony FE (full frame), and Micro Four Thirds (Panasonic and Olympus). I enjoy using gear of different brands and formats because it's fun for me.
If I were in that hypothetical "$10,000 to start over" scenario, I would be out of luck, as nowadays $10,000 doesn't buy you a bunch of great gear anymore. That would maybe get you a decent body and maybe two lenses.
As a current Sony owner (A7c and A7iv), I would definitely not waste money on going with Sony gear. Lots of hype out there about there being so many lenses available for Sony, but what they don't tell you is that 95% of those lenses are terrible. I've owned Sony, Tamron, Viltrox and Samyang lenses. Hands down, the best lenses available for Sony are Tamrons. The same Tamrons available in Z mount. Sony brand lenses have major quality control issues and suffer from really bad decentering issues. Viltrox and Samyang have issues with their electronics communicating with Sony bodies. Despite the fact that I still own my two full frame Sony's, I regret having purchased them. Great AF tracking, and lots of garbage lenses to choose from.
I used to be a fierce Nikon fan/Canon-hater until I purchased a Canon 7dmk2. I still own it. I've had several other Canon bodies (6dmk2, R6, R7, and currently an R6II). I dislike the limited choices of extremely expensive RF-L lenses, but I do like the fact that I can mount any old EF lens with an EF/RF adapter, and I will have perfect AF functions. While I love the feel/ergonomics of my R6II, it is heavy. Definitely not the perfect travel camera as I learned recently on a two-week vacation to Japan. I honestly think that the current RF-L lenses available today are uninspiring, overpriced, and way too large.
As for Micro Four Thirds; it's a fun little system but does not perform well in low light. Nice for all-weather shooting so long as you have good available light.
I've been thinking of maybe trying to "return" to Nikon, but I don't think it will be any different from my current camera gear from Sony or Canon.
My dream woukd be to go with a Leica M11 system, but that $10,000 would barely scratch the surface.
p.s. I still own lots of my old Nikon film gear (S2 Rangefinder, F, F2A, F3hp, F5, F100, N80, FM2N, plus a bunch of AiS and AF-D lenses). To sum up what I posted, all current mirrorless offerings from all manufacturers today are pretty much the same in one way or another. The grass isn't any greener over in Sony Land or Canon Land; it's just a different shade of green, but still just green.
p.3 #10Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
All the big camera companies make great gear. I moved over to Sony (waited on the Z8 that was "never" coming). Wow the Z8 is a power house.
Z8 and A1 are not too far apart in used prices here.
if you a long time Nikon shooter going to the Z8 would really help your muscle memory, Sony was a little learning curve, but got used to it.
My reason for Sony is the lens mount and 3rd part lenses and the majority of used gear on FM/FBM is Sony. I buy all my gear used so it made more sense for my goals.
p.3 #11Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
sonofjesse2010 wrote:
All the big camera companies make great gear. I moved over to Sony (waited on the Z8 that was "never" coming). Wow the Z8 is a power house.
Z8 and A1 are not too far apart in used prices here.
if you a long time Nikon shooter going to the Z8 would really help your muscle memory, Sony was a litlte learning curve, but got used to it.
My reason for Sony is the lens mount and 3rd part lenses and the majority of used gear on FM/FBM is Sony. I buy all my gear used so it made more sense for my goals. ...Show more →
Good point about muscle memory, it’s a major reason why the Z8 is meshing so well with me.
p.3 #12Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
I've been with Nikon since 2006 and a d5100. I'm very comfortable with the ergonomics and IQ. I'm still schlepping a D850/D500/D750 as they meet all my needs. I am however, considering going with a Z8 as I believe it will have better focus acquisition for what I do.
p.3 #13Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
I've been following this thread since its inception a few days ago, but had limited time to reply as I was on a camping photo trip. When I saw the question, I thought it might make sense to use Google's AI questioning function, so I did that before putting together my response. I will share Google's answer shortly.
First, as stated, I really think you need to articulate the use of the gear, because each manufacturer has speciality items in various niches, and while you might not be able to afford the RF 24-70 f2, or Sony 300mm f2.8, or Nikon 135mm f2 Plena with your $10000 (dollar or Euro) budget today, a future looking person might see lenses like these as aspirational items in the future. I know that a few uber-expensive optics motivated my decision even though it took me years to eventually add them to my bag.
Second, I'm a devoted nature photographer and my gear choice focused on durability, weather sealing, optics, and ergonomics. I ended up being a Nikon shooter, but I could be equally happy with Canon. I like a bigger camera body and both Nikon and Canon have these. I find the Sony bodies and buttons to be too small and tightly packed for the way my brain interacts with my fingers.
So... What could $10K buy in new gear from each system? I asked Google to build a system with two cameras that could be used for both landscape and wildlife photography. I told Google that the gear must be new and include 2 bodies and lenses for my desired use.
This is what Google Ai suggested:
Nikon Nature Kit
• Camera Bodies (x2): Nikon Z6 III
• Price: $2,196.95 each ($4,393.90 total)
• Why it fits: Features a 24.5MP partially-stacked sensor, blazing-fast subject tracking, and exceptional weather sealing for harsh outdoor conditions.
• Wildlife Lens: NIKKOR Z 180-600mm f/5.6-6.3 VR
• Price: $2,196.95
• Why it fits: An internal-zoom super-telephoto lens offering incredible reach for birds and mammals with seamless handheld stabilization.
• Landscape Lens: NIKKOR Z 24-120mm f/4 S
• Price: $999.95
• Why it fits: Delivers edge-to-edge sharpness across a versatile zoom range for sweeping vistas and trail details.
• Ultra-Wide Landscape Lens: NIKKOR Z 14-30mm f/4 S
• Price: $1,349.95
• Estimated Total Cost: $8,940.75 (Leaves room for extra batteries and memory cards).
Canon Nature Kit
• Camera Bodies (x2): Canon EOS R6 Mark II
• Price: $1,999.00 each ($3,998.00 total)
• Why it fits: Offers a 24.2MP full-frame sensor, advanced animal-detection autofocus (birds, cats, dogs, horses), and 40 fps electronic shutter speeds.
• Wildlife Lens: Canon RF 200-800mm f/6.3-9 IS USM
• Price: $1,899.00
• Why it fits: Provides massive ultra-telephoto reach in a relatively lightweight build for distant wildlife.
• Landscape/Walkaround Lens: Canon RF 24-105mm f/4 L IS USM
• Price: $1,299.00
• Why it fits: Professional weather-sealed L-series standard zoom ideal for landscapes and travel.
• Ultra-Wide Landscape Lens: Canon RF 14-35mm f/4 L IS USM
• Price: $1,499.00
• Estimated Total Cost: $8,695.00
Sony Nature Kit
• Camera Bodies (x2): Sony Alpha 7 IV
• Price: $1,999.99 each ($3,999.98 total)
• Why it fits: Pairs a high-resolution 33MP Exmor R CMOS sensor with AI-powered real-time tracking for birds and wildlife.
• Wildlife Lens: Sony FE 200-600mm f/5.6-6.3 G OSS
• Price: $1,998.00
• Why it fits: Internal zoom mechanism keeps balance steady while tracking erratic animal movement.
• Landscape Lens: Sony FE 24-105mm f/4 G OSS
• Price: $1,298.00
• Why it fits: Renowned for corner-to-corner clarity and reliable optical stabilization.
• Ultra-Wide Landscape Lens: Sony FE 16-35mm f/4 G PZ
• Price: $1,198.00
• Estimated Total Cost: $8,493.98
p.3 #14Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
I would rebuy the Z8, the 24-70mm f/2.8 S II, the 105mm Macro, and the 180-600mm. This is by far the most versatile, tough as nails kit for my nature, wildlife, landscape and coastal storm photography/videography. This kit has taken a beating from the elements and kept going strong. Nobody else even offers an internally zooming 24-70mm.
However, for my everyday carry, I wouldn't buy the Zf again. It is just too large and heavy. In fact, I am considering replacing it with the Lumix S9, a used Leica Q, or waiting to see if Sony releases an A7CIII with a decent EVF and LCD display. I was hoping that the Z5IIC was going to become my everyday carry. But alas, Nikon was lazy and crapped the bed with that release.
p.3 #15Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
old-gregg wrote:
Disclosures first: I am a dual-system user, enjoying Sony+Nikon. And I've been nodding as I was going through the comments in this thread. Don't want to repeat what's been said, but one thing is worth mentioning.
VALUE. The Z6 III and Z8 in particular are both incredible from the value perspective. The f/1.8 S-primes and the 24-120mm S f/4 also have no rivals on that front. And if you buy slightly used here on FM, it gets absolutely ridiculous.
Ok, I will repeat one more thing repeatedly mentioned here because it's very important IMO: ergonomics+menus.
This is a little beside the point of this thread, but I hadn’t really thought about until now. I bought a refurbished Z6iii + 24-70 f/4 for ~$1,600.
At bottom, I got a camera with twice as many megapixels and miles better performance than a D3s for under $2K — plus an S line lens! What a time to be involved in this hobby.
p.3 #16Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
Well, unless we get divorced, Nikon is my wife’s favored system. We each have our own camera bodies, and share a selection of F and Z lenses.
SLR/DSLR AF and AF-S lenses!
Nikon/Nikkor back catalog of manually-focused SLR lenses.
Nikon lenses have focusing and zoom rings that work in direction that I find intuitive.
Nikon’s pro/semi-pro DSLRs have in-viewfinder focusing aids that work wonderfully, for AF and MF, exactly as how I want to use them.
Nikon menus. Handling my wife’s employer’s Nikon D300s, in 2009, revealed to me how terrible Sony menus really are. I get along with Leica and Canon menus.
Ergonomics and controls. The above-mentioned handling of my wife’s employer’sD300s was a revelation. I actually built my first primary system around the class-leading Canon EOS EF 100mm f/2.8L Macro IS, an image-stabilized, weather-sealed, fast-AF lens, but, a few years later, started adding pre-owned Nikon DSLRs.
$10K goes mucn farther, buying DSLRs, and lenses for them. I might start with a well-preserved D5, which is a present favorite.
p.3 #17Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
I chose Nikon for its super telephoto PF lenses. The 600mm PF is the size and weight of a 70-200mm f/2.8 lens and can be easily used without a tripod. Same is true for the Nikon 800mm PF lens. Now I also own the 400mm f/2.8 with the internal teleconverter. For video I use the Sigma 60-600mm lens with the Megadap adapter with my Z9 cameras. Nikon also provides the best mini flash kit for macro photography.
p.3 #18Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
Compatibility with AF-S lenses is a main driver, but I also like the Z8's size and ergonomics better than the rest of the MILC field. Also like the 70-200 S II a lot.
p.3 #19Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
While other brands have the 50-150/2 (Sony), or a 28-70/2 (Canon/Sony), Nikon has stuff the other brands don't have, such as the 35/1.2S, 400/2.8S TC, and 600/4S TC.
The built-in TCs are huge for me especially because I don't have to detach my lens to add in a TC. No worry about the rear element or the TC fogging up when I could just flick my fore/middle finger to swap the TC in/out.
That and the color consistency among the S-line lenses have been huge for me.
I've played with the Canon R5/R5 II + the Sony A7 line when I considered switching, but the menus + ergonomics just don't sell to me. The AF isn't so much superior with the other brands that I notice, so I'm going to stick with my Z9s.
p.3 #20Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
I'm a Canon shooter. If I could start from zero with all my money back, I'd buy Nikon. The value proposition is too good, and the tradeoffs too minimal, especially now that Nikon is starting to incorporate VCM motors into its lenses. I'd miss the Canon customer service, and the back wheel, but I think otherwise I'd be quite happy with a Z camera. Plus, with Nikon, you at least stand *some* chance of seeing the development that cool, semi-niche camera or lens you've always wanted (see: the Zf). Canon is only ever going to make what Canon wants to make.