fredmiranda.com Login

Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?

  
 
michaelgunne
Offline
[X]

p.1 #1Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
Hey folks,

I’m a Nikon guy for over 5 years now and I’m quite happy. Sometimes I look over the fence and see what’s going on at Sony, canon, Fuji, etc. Just out of curiosity and there is a lot of exciting stuff.

So, let’s do a little scenario. You win at a big photo competition (BPC) with your out of focus cat picture which was outstanding and put photography into a new perspective. The price: 10.000€/$. BUT in the same second a meteorite slams into your camera gear and destroys everything. So good time to start over again.

Let’s use the 10k we won. Would you invest into the Nikon ecosystem in 2026 again? What would you buy and why? What’s the reason you value Nikon higher than the other brands?

(Just for clarification. I didn’t win at a photo competition and I don’t plan to switch ecosystem. Just curious about people’s opinions with all the new releases)
Sep 30, 2026 at 10:42 AM
shinyobject
Online
Details
p.1 #2Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
After shooting Fuji for ten years I wanted to try full frame, wanted to have improved autofocus, and wanted to have access to modern manual focus aids. Nikon offered these things at a good price. I’m very happy with my Z5II.

I haven’t gotten rid of my XT-3 yet. It’s worth more to me than the pittance I would get for selling it. I might even upgrade to another Fuji because the Fuji experience does have some special sauce.

One thing that I haven’t got used to yet completely in changing to Nikon are the ISO settings, which are a little more involved than Fuji, which just has a dial. I have no problem in principle with Nikon having a multi-dial system when choosing between auto ISO and manually selecting a single ISO value, but if it’s going to be more convoluted like that, I’d also like to be able to control the minimum shutter speed that auto ISO allows without having to go into the menus. Just a small thing that doesn’t often come up. I digress.

To answer your question, I’d probably go with Nikon again. I like the lens selection and UI. I’m sure I’d be very happy with Sony too once I found my lenses of choice.
Sep 30, 2026 at 12:02 PM
Vento
Offline
Details
p.1 #3Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
It's hard to say, because—at least for me—investing in the Z system was a gradual process that spanned several years.
So it was never a case of, “Here’s 10 or even 20k—let’s go on a big shopping spree.”

It started with a Nikon Z6 Gen 1 and a Z 24-70/4 S kit zoom; the alternative at the time was the Sony A7III.
My main goal wasn’t even so much to build up an extensive collection of Z lenses, but rather to adapt my existing vintage Canon FD lenses—gems like the FD 85/1.2 L, FD 20-35/3.5 L, Mamiya 645 Sekor lenses, and various heirlooms in the M42 mount.
Since autofocus was a secondary consideration for me at the time—a better EVF and LCD were my main priorities for adapting my existing dozen or so manual-focus lenses—I ended up choosing a Nikon Z6 over the Sony A7III.

Back then, the Z6 was the right choice for me, and a lot more has built on that since.
Little by little, I added a Z 14-30/4 S, a Z 50/1.8 S, a Z MC 105/2.8 VR S, a Z 400/4.5 VR S, and a Z TC-1.4x.
I got rid of the Z 24-70/4 S kit zoom and replaced it with the Z 24-120/4 S.
Later on, I wanted better autofocus for action/wildlife/sports, so I got a Z8.
A Z 135/1.8 S Plena, and a few manual-focus lenses, such as the 35/2 Apo Lanthar Z and the Thypoch Simera 28/1.4 Z.

If I were to do it over today, I’d definitely invest a little less.
Sometimes less is more, and I can barely keep up with the sheer number of lenses I have—especially since I still love and use some of my vintage lenses.

For one thing, I’m with Nikon primarily because of the lenses—lenses like the Z 24-120/4 S, the Z 135/1.8 S Plena, and the Z 400/4.5 VR S.
For another, the Z8 was unbeatably affordable for its performance class.
I paid €3,400 just under two years ago; that price already includes the mandatory 20% VAT here.
For that price, all I could get from Sony right now is a Sony A7V—an A1 costs still €2,000 more, and an A1II costs more than €4,000 more—so there’s no comparison.

After enjoying the benefits of a fully stacked sensor with an extremely fast readout for two years with the Z8, there's no turning back for me now.
So Sony is out of the running—3/4 of the 10k budget would go just for the fully stacked body, so it's not an option.
Neither is the A1; it's still way too expensive, with no real added value compared to a Z8.
The price of the Z8 hasn't dropped here in two years, so it would still cost around €3,500 today—but that would be only 35% of the 10k budget, not 75% like with a Sony A1II.
Since I still frequently and happily use classic, high-quality manual-focus lenses, Nikon is also exemplary when it comes to manual-focus assists (manual-focus subject detection/face and eye detection).

So not much would change.
I’d end up with a Z8 again today, but I’d buy one or two fewer lenses—the Z 14-30/4 S and the Z MC 105/2.8 VR S are gathering dust on my shelf, or rather, they’ve been replaced by the Plena and the Apo Lanthar, including a multi-row nodal adapter, which allows me to achieve any desired field of view at Voigtländer Apo Lanthar quality in panoramic photography.

Canon would be an option today with the R5II, but I don’t have the lenses I’d find with Nikon or Sony.
Apart from that, Canon burned a bridge with me after switching from the FD mount to the EF mount.
Sure, from Canon’s perspective, it was the right move, but from the perspective of a photographer who’d invested many thousands of hard-earned dollars in the FD system, it wasn’t so funny.
It wasn’t until MILC came along that my old FD lenses were brought back to life, because before that, they could only be used without loss of quality in the FD mount.


Edited on Sep 30, 2026 at 01:03 PM · View previous versions
Sep 30, 2026 at 12:38 PM
Superscroll
Offline
Details
p.1 #4Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
Yes because the glass, particularly S stuff.

Enjoyed my XT3 but while i kinda wish i'd held on to it as a pocket backup with the 33 1.4 there truly is no comparison to the Z stuff i have now.

Canon looks interesting but the lens choice is decidedly poor for folks after pro-sumer level tele stuff.
Sep 30, 2026 at 12:45 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.1 #5Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
Nikon is the most compelling option in the midrange. A Z5ii or Zf with something like a 50/1.8 or 24-120/4 will give you better images with more ease than any other comparable system, and it's the cheapest too.

There is also the extreme Tele niche that Nikon has dominated.

Canon is more compelling for the absolute beginner, and Sony can make a case for those that demand the highest performance out of their camera bodies.

Where Nikon has struggled is small, compact full frame cameras. Most of this is down to the sheer size of the Z mount...they can only make a camera so small. They have also not delivered any high quality compact lenses unlike their competition.
Sep 30, 2026 at 12:50 PM
fjablo
Offline
Details
p.1 #6Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
I’d likely pick Nikon again because the system offers a good range of bodies and lenses at attractive price points. And I enjoy using Nikon cameras.

Sony would be tempting for access to Sigma, but I don’t love the user interface of Sony..

I like Canon ergonomics, but not a fan of the strictly closed RF mount.. but €10k should suffice to build a nice Canon kit too

Fuji X might be an option if the X-T6 fixes their autofocus. I was quite happy with the X-T1 and X-T3, but the Zf is just much better overall..
Sep 30, 2026 at 01:03 PM
sungphoto
Offline
Details
p.1 #7Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
I've shot Canon, Sony, Fuji, Leica, even a little Pentax if you count my old K1000, but Nikon always pulls me back because they're in the goldilocks area for what I value in a camera system.

The ergonomics and control layout make the most sense to me, comfortable for 10+ hour days. The bodies wear well with heavy use (whereas Sonys look ratty as soon as they start getting some brassing on the corners). The colors are in the sweet spot (Fuji is on par, but I found Canon too warm and Sony ugly magenta), and reproduce well in print. Lenses are affordable, resolve well for the 45mp sensor, and I have a great choice of rendering looks between the modern Z-mount through legacy F-mount glass. Lighting integration with speedlites and strobes is great (hate the plastic MIS hotshoe on the Sony and TTL metering wasn't as good as Nikon and Canon with 3rd party speedlites). They seem like a camera company run by photographers, rather than a tech company that wants to squeeze out more money with largely incremental upgrades and hidden gotchas.
Sep 30, 2026 at 01:35 PM
DWOfPaul
Offline
Details
p.1 #8Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
I went from Nikon DSLR to Sony Mirrorless and now to Nikon Mirrorless as my main system. If I had to buy in again, I would go with Nikon Mirrorless. While I still have my Sony setup, Nikon just hits the sweet spot for my needs. I have never used a more well balanced camera that just gets out of my way and lets me take pictures than my Z8. Nikon is also at a much better price point for my needs. The closest Sony has to a Z8 is the a1II, which is basically twice the price. With 10k, I would basically get 1 camera and 1 lens with Sony.

As for other systems. I would want to stick FF. Canon is out due to the lack of support for third party lenses. The L mount is getting better and better, but they don't currently have a stacked sensor camera.
Sep 30, 2026 at 02:17 PM
michaelgunne
Offline
[X]
Details
p.1 #9Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
Vento wrote:
It's hard to say, because—at least for me—investing in the Z system was a gradual process that spanned several years.
So it was never a case of, “Here’s 10 or even 20k—let’s go on a big shopping spree.”

It started with a Nikon Z6 Gen 1 and a Z 24-70/4 S kit zoom; the alternative at the time was the Sony A7III.
My main goal wasn’t even so much to build up an extensive collection of Z lenses, but rather to adapt my existing vintage Canon FD lenses—gems like the FD 85/1.2 L, FD 20-35/3.5 L, Mamiya 645 Sekor lenses, and various heirlooms
...Show more →
Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. I actually like that your Z journey started more because of the vintage glass than because you were trying to build a huge Nikon lens collection.

And the Z8 argument is pretty hard to ignore. Once you get used to a stacked sensor and that fast readout, I can see why going back to a slower sensor would feel like a downgrade. And getting that kind of performance without spending A1/A1 II money is a pretty big deal.

The manual-focus stuff is interesting too. I hadn’t really thought about Nikon’s MF assists being a reason to stay in the system, but if you’re regularly using FD/M42/Voigtländer glass, that suddenly matters a lot.

Also, I’m laughing at the “I’d buy fewer lenses” part. 😂 Probably the most realistic answer to the $10k scenario. The 24-120, Plena and 400/4.5 already cover a ridiculous amount of ground.
Sep 30, 2026 at 02:33 PM
michaelgunne
Offline
[X]
Details
p.1 #10Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
sungphoto wrote:
I've shot Canon, Sony, Fuji, Leica, even a little Pentax if you count my old K1000, but Nikon always pulls me back because they're in the goldilocks area for what I value in a camera system.

The ergonomics and control layout make the most sense to me, comfortable for 10+ hour days. The bodies wear well with heavy use (whereas Sonys look ratty as soon as they start getting some brassing on the corners). The colors are in the sweet spot (Fuji is on par, but I found Canon too warm and Sony ugly magenta), and reproduce well in print. Lenses
...Show more →

Yeah, “Goldilocks” is a good way to describe it Ergonomics and the lighting system are underrated too Sometimes it’s the little things that keep you with a system
Sep 30, 2026 at 02:35 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

michaelgunne
Offline
[X]
Details
p.1 #11Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
Superscroll wrote:
Yes because the glass, particularly S stuff.

Enjoyed my XT3 but while i kinda wish i'd held on to it as a pocket backup with the 33 1.4 there truly is no comparison to the Z stuff i have now.

Canon looks interesting but the lens choice is decidedly poor for folks after pro-sumer level tele stuff.


Yeah, the S-line glass is a huge reason I’d stay with Nikon too. The telephoto options are especially interesting Canon’s lineup is probably the area I’d look at most closely before switching For anyone shooting wildlife or sports, lens availability can matter just as much as the body
Sep 30, 2026 at 02:37 PM
jjjwolf7722
Offline
Details
p.1 #12Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
I honestly think Sony, Nikon, Canon are the exact same. They all have the same lens and camera quality. So I think all three are good options. My only Sony issue is all their service stuff is outsourced. You really cant go wrong with any of the above brands currently.
Sep 30, 2026 at 02:40 PM
ottokbre
Offline
Details
p.1 #13Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
RoamingScott wrote:
Nikon is the most compelling option in the midrange. A Z5ii or Zf with something like a 50/1.8 or 24-120/4 will give you better images with more ease than any other comparable system, and it's the cheapest too.

There is also the extreme Tele niche that Nikon has dominated.

Canon is more compelling for the absolute beginner, and Sony can make a case for those that demand the highest performance out of their camera bodies.

Where Nikon has struggled is small, compact full frame cameras. Most of this is down to the sheer size of the Z mount...they can only make a camera
...Show more →

There really is no denying these points. Nikon sort of dominates the cash to performance equation. I don't love a lot of choices they make but they tend to make the ones I can live with.

The Fuji proposition in the XT2/XT3 era was that you could get pro level bodies, compact glass with aperture rings and then step into pro level zooms and accessories like battery grips. It was awesome. But then they cranked up their prices, dropped grip support from their XT5 and went from kaizen to an upgrade only path, which given that their issues are often AF software related, sort of stinks. So the compromises they give me (APSC and Xtrans goofiness) has become slightly less tolerable to me.
Sep 30, 2026 at 02:52 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.1 #14Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
Ah, back when grips enabled BOOST MODE like some N64 Expansion Pak. What a time.
Sep 30, 2026 at 04:14 PM
asdfghreturns
Offline
Details
p.1 #15Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
Image quality value for money. Former Fuji XF shooter here. I loved my Fuji system, but grew frustrated with its dynamic range limitations and weak AF. I always wanted more DR but full frame was too expensive, and Fuji started pushing higher MP, video features, and higher prices instead of DR. At some point I discovered photonstophotos.net, saw that the Z5 had very good DR, and when it went on sale for $1k, I pulled the trigger. An unexpected bonus to the Z system is it can adapt all the other mirrorless systems as well as M and DSLR mounts. So I've now collected a range of high value secondhand lenses as well, and can make images my old Fuji system could only dream of.
Sep 30, 2026 at 04:20 PM
neoshazam
Offline
Details
p.1 #16Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
Still Nikon but it'd be a different camera:
Z5II (+battery grip x2) , 24-120mm F4, 50mm 1.8Z , 85mm 1.2Z , 70-200mm E FL 2.8, FTZ Adapter

if I had to choose Sony;
Sony A7V + battery grip , 24-70mm 2.8 GM II, 85mm 1.4 GM II, 70-200mm F4 II, I like the camera upgrade but I'd probably get an adapter to get Minolta 100/2 and 200/2.8 in there as well.

if I had to choose Canon;
Canon R6 III + battery grip , EF 24-70 F2.8 II, normal EF to RF Adapter, neutral density EF to RF Adapter, EF 85mm 1.2 II , EF 100mm 2 , EF 200mm 2.8, EF 70-200mm F4 (if I have extra $ this would be upgraded to a 2.8 ), I like the camera upgrade and if the used lenses hold up it would be a fun fit.

I could probably switch to most if not all brands but I really like the 85Z/105E/180AF options for Nikon, when Nikon presumably updates the Z7III and Z6IV I'll be set.
Sep 30, 2026 at 04:41 PM
RustyRus
Online
Details
p.1 #17Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
It depends on what you're after.

Sony has the most complete system out of anyone right now. I don't think anyone could really debate that based on first-party lens selection and camera bodies alone.

Cinema cameras from prosumer all the way to true Hollywood productions
Global shutter to a 67MP stacked sensor, etc.
2 or 3 lens options in every zoom range and focal length
The deepest third-party lens support of any mount (Sigma, Tamron, Viltrox, etc.)

Nikon is getting long in the tooth, and I really think their inability to build their own sensors and the slow pace of new bodies is what's holding them back. Nikon can design a great sensor, but they depend on outside fabs (mostly Sony) to make them, so Sony's own bodies get the newest silicon first and Nikon ends up a step behind. The Z8 and Z9 were fantastic, but they're aging, and Nikon has been quiet while Sony keeps shipping.

The ZR is a great hybrid for the money, no argument there. But the RED tech isn't really trickling in like we all thought it would after the acquisition. Outside the ZR it hasn't shown up across the rest of the lineup, and even the ZR's firmware has been slow. The 2.0 update they just announced is mostly filling gaps, and open gate isn't coming until 2027.

Glass is the other thing. Nikon makes some of the best optics out there, but a lot of the S-line lenses are big and heavy compared to Sony's latest GM II glass, especially the f/1.2 primes. If you're carrying a kit all day, you feel it.

If you're already invested in Z-mount, there's no urgent reason to jump. But if you're starting fresh, or you want one system that covers stills, hybrid, and cinema without compromise, Sony is the safer bet today.

My opinion here-
Sep 30, 2026 at 04:57 PM
michaelgunne
Offline
[X]
Details
p.1 #18Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
I think that’s a fair take, especially if you’re evaluating the systems as a whole rather than just individual bodies. Sony definitely has an advantage in breadth and ecosystem, particularly when you factor in the third-party lens support and the range from hybrid bodies to dedicated cinema cameras.

That said, I think some of the Nikon criticism is a little too absolute. The Z8/Z9 platform is still extremely capable, and Nikon’s lens lineup has gotten pretty strong. The size and weight argument is also somewhat lens-dependent.

For me, the bigger question is what someone actually shoots. If you need one mount to cover stills, hybrid work, and cinema, Sony’s breadth is hard to ignore. But if you’re primarily a photographer and already invested in Z-mount, I don’t think there’s a compelling reason to switch systems just because Sony is releasing bodies faster.

So I’d frame it less as “Sony is objectively better” and more as “Sony currently offers the broader ecosystem, while Nikon still has some very compelling strengths depending on the type of shooting you do.”
Sep 30, 2026 at 05:41 PM
RustyRus
Online
Details
p.1 #19Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
michaelgunne wrote:
I think that’s a fair take, especially if you’re evaluating the systems as a whole rather than just individual bodies. Sony definitely has an advantage in breadth and ecosystem, particularly when you factor in the third-party lens support and the range from hybrid bodies to dedicated cinema cameras.

That said, I think some of the Nikon criticism is a little too absolute. The Z8/Z9 platform is still extremely capable, and Nikon’s lens lineup has gotten pretty strong. The size and weight argument is also somewhat lens-dependent.

For me, the bigger question is what someone actually shoots. If you need one mount to
...Show more →

I agree the Z8 is still an amazing camera- it’s just massive!!! Epically for travel and packing in smaller bags. It’s the reason I sold mine. Way too large in a backpack with a lens attached for surf trips etc.

I think most would welcome a smaller high performance Nikon body with a MP count above 24-
Sep 30, 2026 at 06:00 PM
jpelt78
Offline
Details
p.1 #20Why would you choose Nikon over the other brands?
Nikon tends to want to design their own , in particular the backside electronics, rather than directly use a Sony variant. Beyond that Sony sensors are actually built on Nikon Precision steppers and lithography equipment. So Nikon in a way does build some of its own sensors. They just don’t physically maintain their own fab.

RustyRus wrote:
It depends on what you're after.

Sony has the most complete system out of anyone right now. I don't think anyone could really debate that based on first-party lens selection and camera bodies alone.

Cinema cameras from prosumer all the way to true Hollywood productions
Global shutter to a 67MP stacked sensor, etc.
2 or 3 lens options in every zoom range and focal length
The deepest third-party lens support of any mount (Sigma, Tamron, Viltrox, etc.)

Nikon is getting long in the tooth, and I really think their inability to build their own sensors and the slow pace of new bodies is what's holding them
...Show more →
Sep 30, 2026 at 06:42 PM


FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister