fredmiranda.com Login

Samyang 28-135

  
 
dieterson
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Samyang 28-135
Some specifications leaked:
lens construction: 20 elements in 16 groups
size: 88x151mm
filter: 82mm
weight: 854g
mfd: 0.27-0.73m (magnification 1:51 to 1:53)
AF: VCM motor
Oct 01, 2026 at 10:39 AM
Alpunto
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Samyang 28-135


Maximilian wrote

It flares badly. For me a no-go.


I agree. It seems as though Samyang is trying to compete with Tamron by making “extreme” zooms, but they come with some serious issues and fall short in certain areas, such as coatings.

I preferred it when they focused on making good, fast and lightweight prime lenses.
Oct 01, 2026 at 01:51 PM
scrappydog
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Samyang 28-135
Maximilian wrote:
I hope the image quality will be better than that of the other Schneider-Samyang lenses so far.


My spouse has an excellent copy of the 14-24. Super sharp across the frame wide open. It's tiny, too.
Oct 01, 2026 at 02:49 PM
Newenglandrocks
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Samyang 28-135
This looks appealing. But my experience with Samyang lenses only includes 50 f/1.4 AFii, which even on my A9iii cannot focus on slow moving people and the 45 f/1.8 which was somewhat better but did hunt a lot.

If they could get the AF even to the level of the Tamron 28-200, this *could* be an interesting lens. I like the weight compared to the Tamron 35-150, but unless Samyang can nail the AF, I would hesitate to use it for even humdrum event work. The 35-150 AF is great for moderate speed subjects, and pretty much all the event work that I do, and its AF only breaks down when shooting something moving a lot faster like cycling. And even then, hit rate was pretty good, and the only reason I even knew there is room for improvement is when comparing it to modern native Sony glass.

Does anyone have experience with a Samyang lens with passable AF? This is my scale of AF performance from worst to best, and I'd appreciate your insights to compare any recent Samyang lenses the ones listed below. My experience is with these lenses on A7Rv, A9iii and A1ii, so the bodies are not to blame

Unusable: Samyang 50 f/1.4 AFii. Zero hit rate focusing on people slowly moving boxes.
Mediocre: Sigma 24-70 f/2.8 OG, Samyang 45 f/1.8. Struggles with moving subjects and eye AF, but some useable frames so long as subjects are moving slowly
Good / competent: Tamron 28-200, Sigma i35. When I am traveling, these get the job done. There is a meaningful number of misses in a long burst, but those situations occur very infrequently.
Very good: Tamron 35-150, Sony 70-300G, Sony 200-600G, FE35. Great for everything short of pretty fast moving subjects, i.e. sports. (FYI, I don't have the patience for wildlife, so it isn't part of my repertoire)
Excellent: Sony 20G, 24GM, 35GM, ZA55, FE85, 100GM macro, 70-200GMii. When shooting with the majority of native Sony glass I own, it seems that my own errors and poor decisions or being ambitious with photographing really darty insects are usually the culprits for missed AF, particularly with the new stacked sensor bodies.
Oct 12, 2026 at 02:50 PM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Samyang 28-135
I have had 2 SY lenses, the 18/2.8 and 75/1.8 and both AF’d fine for what they were, but I never used either on faster action.

What I do know is, the Tamron 35-150 AF’s very well and my copy is nice and sharp across the zoom range from wide open down, so I personally am not a likely customer for this SY.

I know, not very helpful, but I offer it in case anyone is comparing them.
Oct 12, 2026 at 02:56 PM
BigBabyMoses06
Online
Details
p.2 #6Samyang 28-135
My Tamron 35-150 nailed static subjects, was generally mediocre for action and subjects moving towards the lens, and totally unusable for zooming while focusing (like most non-native lenses). And then there was the build quality issues popping up and pretty bad dust infiltration, so I got rid of mine before that happened.

I'd expect the Sammy to be pretty similar in terms of AF.
Oct 12, 2026 at 04:47 PM
sonofjesse2010
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Samyang 28-135
28-135mm is a lot better than 35-150mm for me.

I like the idea of a 20-60mm or even 22-60. Very least a 24-60mm or 24-65mm.

I really use the 24-28 range.
Oct 13, 2026 at 02:39 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

Newenglandrocks
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Samyang 28-135
BigBabyMoses06 wrote:
My Tamron 35-150 nailed static subjects, was generally mediocre for action and subjects moving towards the lens, and totally unusable for zooming while focusing (like most non-native lenses). And then there was the build quality issues popping up and pretty bad dust infiltration, so I got rid of mine before that happened.

I'd expect the Sammy to be pretty similar in terms of AF.


Zooming while focusing is a known handicap on all 3rd party lenses and not unique to the 35-150. What body did you have that was struggling to focus with subjects coming at you? I know that the difference between the A7Rv and the A1ii or A9iii was pretty stark. With my A1ii and A9iii I was getting ~20% of shots with missed AF in longer bursts of cyclists coming at me between 20 and 40 km/h. I didn't find it mediocre. That would be the Samyang 50 f/1.4 AFii! The Tamron AF misses were meaningful enough that I shot the recent Montréal World cycling championship road races with the 70-200GMii instead. Once you're locked in with that lens and the settings are correct, every frame is in focus
Oct 13, 2026 at 03:06 PM
BigBabyMoses06
Online
Details
p.2 #9Samyang 28-135
Newenglandrocks wrote:
BigBabyMoses06 wroteMy Tamron 35-150 nailed static subjects, was generally mediocre for action and subjects moving towards the lens, and totally unusable for zooming while focusing (like most non-native lenses). And then there was the build quality issues popping up and pretty bad dust infiltration, so I got rid of mine before that happened.

I'd expect the Sammy to be pretty similar in terms of AF.
Zooming while focusing is a known handicap on all 3rd party lenses and not unique to the 35-150. What body did you have that was struggling to focus with subjects coming at you? I know that the difference between the A7Rv and the A1ii or A9iii was pretty stark. With my A1ii and A9iii I was getting ~20% of shots with missed AF in longer bursts of cyclists coming at me between 20 and 40 km/h. I didn't find it mediocre. That would be the Samyang 50 f/1.4 AFii! The Tamron AF misses were meaningful enough that I shot the
...Show more →

Interesting, thanks for the feedback. I was using an A7RV at the time. I also used a 70-200 GMii at one point for a pro hockey game, but found the A7RV to be the limiting factor there.

I wanted to love the 35-150 but from all the reports I was getting and reading, even using an A1 wasn't enough to make the lens really work for sports. I cannot recall if the research I did at the time talked about the A9iii or the A1ii however. I would like to try it again if it is that much better like you say.
Oct 13, 2026 at 03:13 PM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Samyang 28-135


BigBabyMoses06 wrote:
My Tamron 35-150 nailed static subjects, was generally mediocre for action and subjects moving towards the lens, and totally unusable for zooming while focusing (like most non-native lenses). And then there was the build quality issues popping up and pretty bad dust infiltration, so I got rid of mine before that happened.

I'd expect the Sammy to be pretty similar in terms of AF.


I used to shoot swallows in flight, also an osprey in flight, with the Tamron 35-150mm lens (I ordered my copy right after the lens was announced, and never needed a second - the first was perfect).
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1725635/24&year=2021#16231917
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1725635/23&year=2021#16221926
Oct 13, 2026 at 03:57 PM
Newenglandrocks
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Samyang 28-135
BigBabyMoses06 wrote:
Newenglandrocks wrote
BigBabyMoses06 wroteMy Tamron 35-150 nailed static subjects, was generally mediocre for action and subjects moving towards the lens, and totally unusable for zooming while focusing (like most non-native lenses). And then there was the build quality issues popping up and pretty bad dust infiltration, so I got rid of mine before that happened.

I'd expect the Sammy to be pretty similar in terms of AF.
Zooming while focusing is a known handicap on all 3rd party lenses and not unique to the 35-150. What body did you have that was struggling to focus with subjects coming at you? I know that the difference between the A7Rv and the A1ii or A9iii was pretty stark. With my A1ii and A9iii I was getting ~20% of shots with missed AF in longer bursts of cyclists coming at me between 20 and 40 km/h. I didn't find it mediocre. That would be the Samyang 50 f/1.4 AFii! The Tamron AF misses were meaningful enough that I shot the recent Montréal World cycling championship road races with the 70-200GMii instead. Once you're locked in with that lens and the settings are correct, every frame is in focus
Interesting, thanks for the feedback. I was using an A7RV at the time. I also used a 70-200 GMii at one point for a pro hockey game, but found the A7RV to be the limiting factor there.

I wanted to love the 35-150 but from all the reports I was getting and reading, even using an A1 wasn't enough to make the lens really work for sports. I cannot recall if the research I did at the time talked about the A9iii or the A1ii however. I would like to try it again if it is that much better like
...Show more →

To be clear for sports, the 35-150 is fine for sports where the absolute best available AF is not necessary. It was reasonably good for cyclists. I would not take it out on a frisbee or soccer pitch. The difference between the 35-150 and 70-200GMii is definitely noticeably on the newest stacked sensor bodies. I have had some experience with shooting the 35-150 on my A7Rv, and it was not that great at medium speed subjects such as snow monkeys and seagulls flying in open air markets. I feel amateur cyclists going uphill or on the flat are similarly challenging for AF and on the A1ii AF was pretty good, but not great compared to the 70-200GMii

Oct 17, 2026 at 09:25 PM
Planetwide
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Samyang 28-135
Maximilian wrote:
TravelinBriNY wrote
Maximilian wroteI hope the image quality will be better than that of the other Schneider-Samyang lenses so far.
I have heard quite good things about the 14-24 - do you have a different position?
It flares badly. For me a no-go.


I actually own the lens, and while I have not yet shot directly into the sun, it has no real issues when shot with he sun slightly out of the frame. If we get any decent sun in the next few days, I'll try to get a direct shot. The lens is vey sharp at both 14-24mm. my copy is well centred. it tends to render on the slightly magenta side, but that is easily fixed in Lightroom etc...

Here is a sample shot, A7R6 with the sun just slightly out of the frame.






Nov 02, 2026 at 09:21 AM
freaklikeme
Online
Details
p.2 #13Samyang 28-135
Planetwide wrote:
Maximilian wrote
TravelinBriNY wrote
Maximilian wroteI hope the image quality will be better than that of the other Schneider-Samyang lenses so far.
I have heard quite good things about the 14-24 - do you have a different position?
It flares badly. For me a no-go.
I actually own the lens, and while I have not yet shot directly into the sun, it has no real issues when shot with he sun slightly out of the frame. If we get any decent sun in the next few days, I'll try to get a direct shot. The lens is vey sharp at both 14-24mm. my copy is well centred. it tends to render on the slightly magenta side, but that is easily fixed in Lightroom etc...

Here is a sample shot, A7R6 with the sun just slightly out of the frame.

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-gChR4SV/0/NcFQ2m7zcVhRxgpknbWZMddDRxwJv6ZFb7ZQSW6mc/X3/i-gChR4SV-X3.jpg


I think the ring flare with strong light sources in the frame is the chief complaint most people have about the flare.
Nov 02, 2026 at 01:54 PM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister