fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2025 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2025Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO

  
 
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.4 #1Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
Juha Kannisto wrote:
Today Cosina announced the new 28/2 APO-Lanthar VM officially for July release (specific date not yet given):

English Product Page:
https://www.cosina.co.jp/voigtlander/en/vm-mount/apo-lanthar-28mm-f2-aspherical/

Japanese Product Page:
https://www.cosina.co.jp/voigtlander/vm-mount/apo-lanthar-28mm-f2-aspherical/
Official Japan Price set by Cosina is 135K yen (before tax).
Map Camera has it at 126720 JPY (including tax): https://www.mapcamera.com/item/4530076132917



Block diagram:



MTF:




For reference, the VM 35/2 APO MTF:




VM 50/2 APO:



junglialoh wrote:
Leica SL 28/2 APO asph


The wide open MTF is insane!

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/ufiles/48/2912648.jpg
Jun 13, 2025 at 02:20 AM
ftllens
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
Oh man, I just rebought the ultron ii and the nokton thinking it would be months, but CV just knocking them out! I guess I'll just keep them and do a comparison.
Jun 13, 2025 at 03:25 AM
catacore
Offline
Details
p.4 #3Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
ftllens wrote:
Oh man, I just rebought the ultron ii and the nokton thinking it would be months, but CV just knocking them out! I guess I'll just keep them and do a comparison.


Yes, I'm quite interested at how it would compare against the Nokton, at f/2-f/2.8.
Jun 13, 2025 at 03:58 AM
rsolti13
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
catacore wrote:
ftllens wroteOh man, I just rebought the ultron ii and the nokton thinking it would be months, but CV just knocking them out! I guess I'll just keep them and do a comparison.
Yes, I'm quite interested at how it would compare against the Nokton, at f/2-f/2.8.


It’s about the same length, but a little chubbier than the Nokton. 265 grams for the APO vs 330 for the Type II Nokton (Type I is 250)
Jun 13, 2025 at 04:32 AM
phinix
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
I hope they do Z mount as well...
Jun 13, 2025 at 04:36 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.4 #6Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
phinix wrote:
I hope they do Z mount as well...


I'm personally waiting for E-mount version. I think they'll do both E and Z later since APO-Lanthars have generally been very good sellers in both E and Z too and since Cosina implied at CP+ that they are at least strongly considering releasing this lens for mirrorless systems as well. Since this is again highlighted as their highest performing lens in certain category I think it would be very logical to release it for other mounts too.

Also VM APO-Lanthars are not generally very adaptable to mirrorless without losing IQ (except 50/3.5) and Cosina have this warning again on their e-mail newsletter announcing this lens:

* This lens can be attached to Sony E-mount, Fujifilm X-mount, and Nikon Z-mount digital cameras via our mount adapters. However, since it is optimized for M-mount camera sensors, please note that the original optical performance will not be demonstrated with these cameras.

I think it's further reason for them to release optimized versions of mirrorless systems.

Edited on Jun 13, 2025 at 04:49 AM · View previous versions
Jun 13, 2025 at 04:48 AM
fjablo
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
junglialoh wrote:
Leica SL 28/2 APO asph


Comparing Leica’s f/5.6 with the CV‘s f/4 results, the latter looks quite impressive given the size, weight and price difference. The Voigtländer might actually have better corners but well into splitting hairs territory.

Edited on Jun 13, 2025 at 04:51 AM · View previous versions
Jun 13, 2025 at 04:49 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.4 #8Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
junglialoh wrote:
Leica SL 28/2 APO asph


Leica and Cosina MTFs are not comparable. It is not clear what Leica does for their MTFs. Cosina and Zeiss likely use the same machines for MTF made by Zeiss and likely are comparable to a point, but even here Zeiss reports percent contrast at 10, 20, & 40 lp/mm and Cosina reports percent contrast at 10. 30, &.40 lp/mm. I wouldn't put much into the comparison between the Leica SL 28 APO MTF and the MTF for this lens. It is really comparing apples to oranges.

Edited on Jun 13, 2025 at 05:01 AM · View previous versions
Jun 13, 2025 at 04:50 AM
fjablo
Offline
Details
p.4 #9Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
Steve Spencer wrote:
junglialoh wroteLeica SL 28/2 APO asph
Leica and Cosina MTFs are not comparable. It is not clear what Leica does for their MTFs. Cosina and Zeiss likely use the same machines for MTF made by Zeiss and likely are comparable to a point, but even here Zeiss reports percent contrast at 10, 20, & 40 lp/mm and Cosina reports percent contrast at 10. 30, &.40 lp/mm. I wouldn't put much into the comparison between the Leica SL 28 APO MTF and the MTF for this lens. It is really comparing apples to oranges.


Imo they are as comparable as they can be. Both are measured, not theoretical, and both include 40 lp/mm lines.

The tricky part is how much of that is visible in real world images, e.g the significant drop in the tangential line for the Leica towards the corners vs the sagittal line staying on an extreme high level throughout the frame.
Jun 13, 2025 at 05:15 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.4 #10Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
fjablo wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
junglialoh wroteLeica SL 28/2 APO asph
Leica and Cosina MTFs are not comparable. It is not clear what Leica does for their MTFs. Cosina and Zeiss likely use the same machines for MTF made by Zeiss and likely are comparable to a point, but even here Zeiss reports percent contrast at 10, 20, & 40 lp/mm and Cosina reports percent contrast at 10. 30, &.40 lp/mm. I wouldn't put much into the comparison between the Leica SL 28 APO MTF and the MTF for this lens. It is really comparing apples to oranges.
Imo they are as comparable as they can be. Both are measured, not theoretical, and both include 40 lp/mm lines.

The tricky part is how much of that is visible in real world images, e.g the significant drop in the tangential line for the Leica towards the corners vs the sagittal line staying on an extreme high level throughout the frame.


Well this isn't really a matter of opinion. Even if they are both measured, they aren't measured in the same way, which makes them not comparable.
Jun 13, 2025 at 05:18 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
fjablo wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
junglialoh wroteLeica SL 28/2 APO asph
Leica and Cosina MTFs are not comparable. It is not clear what Leica does for their MTFs. Cosina and Zeiss likely use the same machines for MTF made by Zeiss and likely are comparable to a point, but even here Zeiss reports percent contrast at 10, 20, & 40 lp/mm and Cosina reports percent contrast at 10. 30, &.40 lp/mm. I wouldn't put much into the comparison between the Leica SL 28 APO MTF and the MTF for this lens. It is really comparing apples to oranges.
Imo they are as comparable as they can be. Both are measured, not theoretical, and both include 40 lp/mm lines.

The tricky part is how much of that is visible in real world images, e.g the significant drop in the tangential line for the Leica towards the corners vs the sagittal line staying on an extreme high level throughout the frame.


+1

I can also interpolate the difference between 20 vs. 30 easy enough. 40 is 40, 10 is 10. The stuff in the middle is stuff in the middle.

I mean, it's either "tight and right" ... or squiggly and droopy.

Going back to Juha pics ... the have the "tight and right" vibe going on. They give me a "rendering vibe" similar to the Q3 43 APO or SL APO regarding how APO glass tends to look.
Jun 13, 2025 at 05:19 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
Steve Spencer wrote:
fjablo wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
junglialoh wroteLeica SL 28/2 APO asph
Leica and Cosina MTFs are not comparable. It is not clear what Leica does for their MTFs. Cosina and Zeiss likely use the same machines for MTF made by Zeiss and likely are comparable to a point, but even here Zeiss reports percent contrast at 10, 20, & 40 lp/mm and Cosina reports percent contrast at 10. 30, &.40 lp/mm. I wouldn't put much into the comparison between the Leica SL 28 APO MTF and the MTF for this lens. It is really comparing apples to oranges.
Imo they are as comparable as they can be. Both are measured, not theoretical, and both include 40 lp/mm lines.

The tricky part is how much of that is visible in real world images, e.g the significant drop in the tangential line for the Leica towards the corners vs the sagittal line staying on an extreme high level throughout the frame.
Well this isn't really a matter of opinion. Even if they are both measured, they aren't measured in the same way, which makes them not comparable.


I'd suggest they are not "reported" the same. That doesn't mean the information contained isn't comparable. You just have to use your noodle to understand the difference in expectation of 20 vs. 30 ... you know, that 30 is gonna perform closer to 40 and 20 is gonna perform closer to 10, in your expectation / interpretation. Getting bent by the reporting for 20 vs. 30 ... no reason to toss the baby out with the bathwater. 10 and 40 are still 10 and 40.


That's kinda like saying a ruler that is marked in 1/8ths vs. a ruler marked in 1/10ths doesn't let you understand how long something is, because one is reporting a different incremement. Yet, if you have a 3 inch item, they both can let you know it's three inches ... or a smidge under / over 3 inches, etc. even if not presented the same way (interpolation between 1/8 vs. 1/10) Meanwhile, whole and 1/2 increments remain as similar reporting.

Saying that I can't compare (i.e. get a good idea of) something measures with an inch ruler and a metric ruler isn't true. I may have to make some interpolation, but I can still get a pretty darn good idea that something that is 12mm is pretty darn close to something that is 1/2 inch, even if the scales are reported / presented differently.






Edited on Jun 13, 2025 at 05:36 AM · View previous versions
Jun 13, 2025 at 05:27 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
One interesting aspect of the lens that hasn't been mentioned is the 12-bladed aperture looks like it will have straight blades at every aperture and not round at some apertures like the 35 f/2 APO, 50 f/2 APO, and the 90 f/2.8 APO. I like having the rounded blades at some apertures, but this probably isn't a big deal for a wide angle lens. All straight blades might be the way forward with Cosina as the 90 f/2 APO Ultron also has straight blades at all apertures. I like the rounded aperture opening at some apertures not only for bokeh balls but also because I like the option of either having nice sunstars or not having sunstars at all.
Jun 13, 2025 at 05:30 AM
fjablo
Offline
Details
p.4 #14Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
Steve Spencer wrote:
fjablo wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
junglialoh wroteLeica SL 28/2 APO asph
Leica and Cosina MTFs are not comparable. It is not clear what Leica does for their MTFs. Cosina and Zeiss likely use the same machines for MTF made by Zeiss and likely are comparable to a point, but even here Zeiss reports percent contrast at 10, 20, & 40 lp/mm and Cosina reports percent contrast at 10. 30, &.40 lp/mm. I wouldn't put much into the comparison between the Leica SL 28 APO MTF and the MTF for this lens. It is really comparing apples to oranges.
Imo they are as comparable as they can be. Both are measured, not theoretical, and both include 40 lp/mm lines.

The tricky part is how much of that is visible in real world images, e.g the significant drop in the tangential line for the Leica towards the corners vs the sagittal line staying on an extreme high level throughout the frame.
Well this isn't really a matter of opinion. Even if they are both measured, they aren't measured in the same way, which makes them not comparable.


I wouldn’t be surprised if Leica was also using an optical bench provided by Zeiss.

I would, however, be very surprised if whatever optical bench Leica is using produced significantly different results compared to the one from Zeiss.

Thing is: you are just speculating that they are measured differently and that the specific methodology differences are big enough to make results not comparable. We don’t actually know that and hence I am of the opinion that it’s much more likely that they are quite comparable than not comparable.
Jun 13, 2025 at 05:33 AM
junglialoh
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
After using several 28mm lenses (Sigma 28/1.4, Nikon 28mm F1.4E, Leica R 28mm F2.8 II E55, Contax 28mm F2.8 MMJ, Pentax K 28mm F3.5, VM 28mm F2 II, ...) and comparing MTF chart each lens, I think Leica MTF does not much different from other company's MTF chart. And I believe Leica SL 28/2 APO is the sharpest 28mm lens in the 35mm lens market.
Jun 13, 2025 at 05:35 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.4 #16Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
RustyBug wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
fjablo wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
junglialoh wroteLeica SL 28/2 APO asph
Leica and Cosina MTFs are not comparable. It is not clear what Leica does for their MTFs. Cosina and Zeiss likely use the same machines for MTF made by Zeiss and likely are comparable to a point, but even here Zeiss reports percent contrast at 10, 20, & 40 lp/mm and Cosina reports percent contrast at 10. 30, &.40 lp/mm. I wouldn't put much into the comparison between the Leica SL 28 APO MTF and the MTF for this lens. It is really comparing apples to oranges.
Imo they are as comparable as they can be. Both are measured, not theoretical, and both include 40 lp/mm lines.

The tricky part is how much of that is visible in real world images, e.g the significant drop in the tangential line for the Leica towards the corners vs the sagittal line staying on an extreme high level throughout the frame.
Well this isn't really a matter of opinion. Even if they are both measured, they aren't measured in the same way, which makes them not comparable.
I'd suggest they are not "reported" the same. That doesn't mean the information contained isn't comparable. You just have to use your noodle to understand the difference in expectation of 20 vs. 30 ... you know, that 30 is gonna perform closer to 40 and 20 is gonna perform closer to 10, in your expectation / interpretation. Getting bent by the reporting for 20 vs. 30 ... no reason to toss the baby out with the bathwater.

That's kinda like saying a ruler that is marked in 1/8ths vs. a ruler marked in 1/10ths doesn't let you understand how long
...Show more →

Well, until Leica tells us a lot more about how they measure their MTFs (and even make it clear whether they measure and then adjust them in som way) I don't think they are comparable. Keep in mind, MTFs are a complex calculation with many decisions that have to be made. These include things like what wavelength of light you use, and whether you refocus for the corners and mid frame when you test. Things that can make a big difference in the percent contrast. If those things are not done the same way, then the graphs are not comparable even if you can interpolate for different lp/mm.

One salient point here is that the 10 lp/mm graph for Leica is almost always sky high (and yes, I know that Leica also includes 5 lp/mm) and it is for that SL 28 f/2 APO. It is higher than I have ever seen it for a Zeiss or Cosina lens. Is that a real difference or just because the MTFs are measured differently? We can't know. Said another way there is always an alternative explanation for why Leica and Zeiss or Leica and Cosina MTFs are different and that is the difference is because they were measured differently. With that alternative explanation being plausible as it almost always is, then it makes no sense to being making inferences about the lens from the comparisons of the chart. Any difference you are talking about could just be about the measurement and not about the lenses, and I don't think that is a matter of opinion. That is about making proper inferences from the evidence that is available.
Jun 13, 2025 at 05:35 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.4 #17Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
Steve Spencer wrote:
RustyBug wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
fjablo wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
junglialoh wroteLeica SL 28/2 APO asph
Leica and Cosina MTFs are not comparable. It is not clear what Leica does for their MTFs. Cosina and Zeiss likely use the same machines for MTF made by Zeiss and likely are comparable to a point, but even here Zeiss reports percent contrast at 10, 20, & 40 lp/mm and Cosina reports percent contrast at 10. 30, &.40 lp/mm. I wouldn't put much into the comparison between the Leica SL 28 APO MTF and the MTF for this lens. It is really comparing apples to oranges.
Imo they are as comparable as they can be. Both are measured, not theoretical, and both include 40 lp/mm lines.

The tricky part is how much of that is visible in real world images, e.g the significant drop in the tangential line for the Leica towards the corners vs the sagittal line staying on an extreme high level throughout the frame.
Well this isn't really a matter of opinion. Even if they are both measured, they aren't measured in the same way, which makes them not comparable.
I'd suggest they are not "reported" the same. That doesn't mean the information contained isn't comparable. You just have to use your noodle to understand the difference in expectation of 20 vs. 30 ... you know, that 30 is gonna perform closer to 40 and 20 is gonna perform closer to 10, in your expectation / interpretation. Getting bent by the reporting for 20 vs. 30 ... no reason to toss the baby out with the bathwater.

That's kinda like saying a ruler that is marked in 1/8ths vs. a ruler marked in 1/10ths doesn't let you understand how long something is, because one is reporting a different incremement. Yet, if you have a 3 inch item, they both can let you know it's three inches ... or a smidge under / over 3 inches, etc.
Well, until Leica tells us a lot more about how they measure their MTFs (and even make it clear they whether they measure and then adjust them in som way) I don't think they are comparable. Keep in mind, MTFs are a complex calculation with many decisions that have to be made. These include things like what wavelength of light you use, and whether you refocus for the corners and mid frame when test. Things that can make a big difference in the percent contrast. If those things are done the same way, then they graphs are comparable even
...Show more →

I'm quite certain that if we were to go through the archives ... we'd find somewhere that I took up a similar position that I used to (and still can be) splittin' hairs similarly. But, I've gotten to a place where I realize that the margin of difference between 0.78 vs. 0.81 isn't gonna make / break things. Seeing a straight line, with a skinny / none birdmouth ... vs. a diagonal line with a big dip, strong crossover or gaping birdmouth ... imo, that tells the story more importantly than worrying about test methods and reporting variance. The nature of beast is still presented well enough that I get a good vibe that it's gonna be pretty darn "tight and right".

As to the 5 ... does it really matter if it is 99.2 or 98.6?
Jun 13, 2025 at 05:43 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.4 #18Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
fjablo wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
fjablo wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
junglialoh wroteLeica SL 28/2 APO asph
Leica and Cosina MTFs are not comparable. It is not clear what Leica does for their MTFs. Cosina and Zeiss likely use the same machines for MTF made by Zeiss and likely are comparable to a point, but even here Zeiss reports percent contrast at 10, 20, & 40 lp/mm and Cosina reports percent contrast at 10. 30, &.40 lp/mm. I wouldn't put much into the comparison between the Leica SL 28 APO MTF and the MTF for this lens. It is really comparing apples to oranges.
Imo they are as comparable as they can be. Both are measured, not theoretical, and both include 40 lp/mm lines.

The tricky part is how much of that is visible in real world images, e.g the significant drop in the tangential line for the Leica towards the corners vs the sagittal line staying on an extreme high level throughout the frame.
Well this isn't really a matter of opinion. Even if they are both measured, they aren't measured in the same way, which makes them not comparable.
I wouldn’t be surprised if Leica was also using an optical bench provided by Zeiss.

I would, however, be very surprised if whatever optical bench Leica is using produced significantly different results compared to the one from Zeiss.

Thing is: you are just speculating that they are measured differently and that the specific methodology differences are big enough to make results not comparable. We don’t actually know that and hence I am of the opinion that it’s much more likely that they are quite comparable than not comparable.


No I am not speculating they are measured differently. What I am saying is that I don't know they are measured the same way and I need to know that to rule out that what I am thinking is a differences in the lenses isn't merely a difference in the way the MTFs were measured. We don't have enough information to rule out that possibility and I think it is quite plausible, so we should not be making those inferences.
Jun 13, 2025 at 05:46 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.4 #19Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
Steve Spencer wrote:
fjablo wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
fjablo wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
junglialoh wroteLeica SL 28/2 APO asph
Leica and Cosina MTFs are not comparable. It is not clear what Leica does for their MTFs. Cosina and Zeiss likely use the same machines for MTF made by Zeiss and likely are comparable to a point, but even here Zeiss reports percent contrast at 10, 20, & 40 lp/mm and Cosina reports percent contrast at 10. 30, &.40 lp/mm. I wouldn't put much into the comparison between the Leica SL 28 APO MTF and the MTF for this lens. It is really comparing apples to oranges.
Imo they are as comparable as they can be. Both are measured, not theoretical, and both include 40 lp/mm lines.

The tricky part is how much of that is visible in real world images, e.g the significant drop in the tangential line for the Leica towards the corners vs the sagittal line staying on an extreme high level throughout the frame.
Well this isn't really a matter of opinion. Even if they are both measured, they aren't measured in the same way, which makes them not comparable.
I wouldn’t be surprised if Leica was also using an optical bench provided by Zeiss.

I would, however, be very surprised if whatever optical bench Leica is using produced significantly different results compared to the one from Zeiss.

Thing is: you are just speculating that they are measured differently and that the specific methodology differences are big enough to make results not comparable. We don’t actually know that and hence I am of the opinion that it’s much more likely that they are quite comparable than not comparable.
No I am not speculating they are measured differently. What I am saying is that I don't know they are measured the same way and I need to know that to rule out that what I am thinking is a differences in the lenses isn't merely a difference in the way the MTFs were measured. We don't have enough information to rule out that possibility and I think it is quite plausible, so we should not be making those inferences.


Are you gonna shoot the lens always at the same distance that the test was conducted? Nope. You'll use it through a range of distances. We could argue that the MTF doesn't fully / accurately reflect that. Well, here's the thing ... even if they do use different methodologies that split the hair different, it's only useful as a guide for expectation. It's not like you're using the lens as a calibration tool / reference standard. You're trying to understand the "nature" of the lens, rather than performing a calibration competition in the lab.

Imo, the MTF's and the pics coming out of the lens ... they kinda line up. If the pics (Leica / Voigt) were vastly different from what the MTF's suggest, maybe I'd question the methods more. But, we've seen enough MTF's and the pics from lenses that (imo), we are WAY PAST the need to infer the integrity of the test methods might introduce meaningful variation that we have to be suspicious of them.

Edited on Jun 13, 2025 at 05:55 AM · View previous versions
Jun 13, 2025 at 05:51 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.4 #20Voigtlander VM 28mm f/2.0 APO
RustyBug wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
RustyBug wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
fjablo wrote
Steve Spencer wroteLeica and Cosina MTFs are not comparable. It is not clear what Leica does for their MTFs. Cosina and Zeiss likely use the same machines for MTF made by Zeiss and likely are comparable to a point, but even here Zeiss reports percent contrast at 10, 20, & 40 lp/mm and Cosina reports percent contrast at 10. 30, &.40 lp/mm. I wouldn't put much into the comparison between the Leica SL 28 APO MTF and the MTF for this lens. It is really comparing apples to oranges.
Imo they are as comparable as they can be. Both are measured, not theoretical, and both include 40 lp/mm lines.

The tricky part is how much of that is visible in real world images, e.g the significant drop in the tangential line for the Leica towards the corners vs the sagittal line staying on an extreme high level throughout the frame.
Well this isn't really a matter of opinion. Even if they are both measured, they aren't measured in the same way, which makes them not comparable.
I'd suggest they are not "reported" the same. That doesn't mean the information contained isn't comparable. You just have to use your noodle to understand the difference in expectation of 20 vs. 30 ... you know, that 30 is gonna perform closer to 40 and 20 is gonna perform closer to 10, in your expectation / interpretation. Getting bent by the reporting for 20 vs. 30 ... no reason to toss the baby out with the bathwater.

That's kinda like saying a ruler that is marked in 1/8ths vs. a ruler marked in 1/10ths doesn't let you understand how long something is, because one is reporting a different incremement. Yet, if you have a 3 inch item, they both can let you know it's three inches ... or a smidge under / over 3 inches, etc.
Well, until Leica tells us a lot more about how they measure their MTFs (and even make it clear they whether they measure and then adjust them in som way) I don't think they are comparable. Keep in mind, MTFs are a complex calculation with many decisions that have to be made. These include things like what wavelength of light you use, and whether you refocus for the corners and mid frame when test. Things that can make a big difference in the percent contrast. If those things are done the same way, then they graphs are comparable even if you can interpolate for different lp/mm.
I'm quite certain that if we were to go through the archives ... we'd find somewhere that I took up a similar position that I used to (and still can be) splittin' hairs similarly. But, I've gotten to a place where I realize that the margin of difference between 0.78 vs. 0.81 isn't gonna make / break things. Seeing a straight line, with a skinny / none birdmouth ... vs. a diagonal line with a big dip, strong crossover or gaping birdmouth ... imo, that tells the story more importantly than worrying about test methods and reporting variance. The nature
...Show more →

Kent,

I know you are a scientist. As such you know that what you are talking about in this post is a question of precision. You are right we have way more precision for MTFs than we need and focus on very precise measurements is not relevant.

What I am talking about is not precision, but making inferences from evidence. In science we do not make inferences when there are competing compelling hypotheses for the results, and there are competing compelling hypotheses when we compare Zeiss (and or Cosina) MTF graphs with Leica MTF graphs. The competing hypotheses are that any difference is a difference in how the lenses perform and that it is a difference in the way the MTFs were measured. Basic scientific reasoning requires that before we accept one of these hypotheses we rule out the other one and I don't think we have nearly enough information from Leica to rule out any difference between their MTFs and Zeiss or Cosina MTFs is due to the different ways MTF was measured.
Jun 13, 2025 at 05:52 AM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister