rscheffler wrote:
One can already get an idea about the VM 28 APO's image quality from the sample images Juha posted from CP+ with a link here.
The other variable in the size/performance triangle is price. One can see this with the 35 APO-M options. VM 35 APO is reasonably priced, but larger than a 50 Lux ASPH. Leica's 35 APO-M is smaller and IMO has more pleasing wide open OOF background character. But the price... That aside, based on MTFs, the Leica 35 APO-M has higher wide open performance that drops a bit as it's stopped down due to diffraction. The VM's MTFs at f/2 and f/4 show that performance increases stopped down to f/4... so the takeaway would appear to be that the Leica is sharper from wide open. Since the new VM 28/2 APO is an APO Lanthar, Cosina *should* publish MTFs for it...
Leica's SL APO ASPH primes I suspect are 'over-specced' and actually closer to f/1.4 capable but 'detuned' to f/2 for optimized image quality. Canon's recently released VCM primes at 24, 35 and 50mm are all f/1.4 and very similar in physical dimensions to the SL primes. Contrary to Leica, Canon has likely 'stretched' these designs to be f/1.4....Show more →
---------------------------------------------
RustyBug wrote: rscheffler wroteOne can already get an idea about the VM 28 APO's image quality from the sample images Juha posted from CP+ with a link here.
The other variable in the size/performance triangle is price. One can see this with the 35 APO-M options. VM 35 APO is reasonably priced, but larger than a 50 Lux ASPH. Leica's 35 APO-M is smaller and IMO has more pleasing wide open OOF background character. But the price... That aside, based on MTFs, the Leica 35 APO-M has higher wide open performance that drops a bit as it's stopped down due to diffraction. The VM's MTFs at f/2 and f/4 show that performance increases stopped down to f/4... so the takeaway would appear to be that the Leica is sharper from wide open. Since the new VM 28/2 APO is an APO Lanthar, Cosina *should* publish MTFs for it...
Leica's SL APO ASPH primes I suspect are 'over-specced' and actually closer to f/1.4 capable but 'detuned' to f/2 for optimized image quality. Canon's recently released VCM primes at 24, 35 and 50mm are all f/1.4 and very similar in physical dimensions to the SL primes. Contrary to Leica, Canon has likely 'stretched' these designs to be f/1.4.I missed that one ... thanks for the link.
Somehow, I missed these samples too! Just to clarify, these were taken with the 33MP A7CII, a sensor that very likely does not work well with this lens.
Fred Miranda wrote: rscheffler wroteOne can already get an idea about the VM 28 APO's image quality from the sample images Juha posted from CP+ with a link here.
The other variable in the size/performance triangle is price. One can see this with the 35 APO-M options. VM 35 APO is reasonably priced, but larger than a 50 Lux ASPH. Leica's 35 APO-M is smaller and IMO has more pleasing wide open OOF background character. But the price... That aside, based on MTFs, the Leica 35 APO-M has higher wide open performance that drops a bit as it's stopped down due to diffraction. The VM's MTFs at f/2 and f/4 show that performance increases stopped down to f/4... so the takeaway would appear to be that the Leica is sharper from wide open. Since the new VM 28/2 APO is an APO Lanthar, Cosina *should* publish MTFs for it...
Leica's SL APO ASPH primes I suspect are 'over-specced' and actually closer to f/1.4 capable but 'detuned' to f/2 for optimized image quality. Canon's recently released VCM primes at 24, 35 and 50mm are all f/1.4 and very similar in physical dimensions to the SL primes. Contrary to Leica, Canon has likely 'stretched' these designs to be f/1.4.---------------------------------------------
RustyBug wroterscheffler wroteOne can already get an idea about the VM 28 APO's image quality from the sample images Juha posted from CP+ with a link here.
The other variable in the size/performance triangle is price. One can see this with the 35 APO-M options. VM 35 APO is reasonably priced, but larger than a 50 Lux ASPH. Leica's 35 APO-M is smaller and IMO has more pleasing wide open OOF background character. But the price... That aside, based on MTFs, the Leica 35 APO-M has higher wide open performance that drops a bit as it's stopped down due to diffraction. The VM's MTFs at f/2 and f/4 show that performance increases stopped down to f/4... so the takeaway would appear to be that the Leica is sharper from wide open. Since the new VM 28/2 APO is an APO Lanthar, Cosina *should* publish MTFs for it...
Leica's SL APO ASPH primes I suspect are 'over-specced' and actually closer to f/1.4 capable but 'detuned' to f/2 for optimized image quality. Canon's recently released VCM primes at 24, 35 and 50mm are all f/1.4 and very similar in physical dimensions to the SL primes. Contrary to Leica, Canon has likely 'stretched' these designs to be f/1.4.I missed that one ... thanks for the link. Somehow, I missed these samples too! Just to clarify, these were taken with the 33MP A7CII, a sensor that very likely does not work well with this lens.
Yup, I picked up on the Sony vs. M diff ... data point, noted.
I wasn't too picky about judging the edges / corners, etc. Just wanted to get a broad sense of the falloff to oof, as a "first look" wrt rendering. Picky comes when you get your hands on it.
RustyBug wrote: Fred Miranda wroterscheffler wroteOne can already get an idea about the VM 28 APO's image quality from the sample images Juha posted from CP+ with a link here.
The other variable in the size/performance triangle is price. One can see this with the 35 APO-M options. VM 35 APO is reasonably priced, but larger than a 50 Lux ASPH. Leica's 35 APO-M is smaller and IMO has more pleasing wide open OOF background character. But the price... That aside, based on MTFs, the Leica 35 APO-M has higher wide open performance that drops a bit as it's stopped down due to diffraction. The VM's MTFs at f/2 and f/4 show that performance increases stopped down to f/4... so the takeaway would appear to be that the Leica is sharper from wide open. Since the new VM 28/2 APO is an APO Lanthar, Cosina *should* publish MTFs for it...
Leica's SL APO ASPH primes I suspect are 'over-specced' and actually closer to f/1.4 capable but 'detuned' to f/2 for optimized image quality. Canon's recently released VCM primes at 24, 35 and 50mm are all f/1.4 and very similar in physical dimensions to the SL primes. Contrary to Leica, Canon has likely 'stretched' these designs to be f/1.4.---------------------------------------------
RustyBug wroterscheffler wroteOne can already get an idea about the VM 28 APO's image quality from the sample images Juha posted from CP+ with a link here.
The other variable in the size/performance triangle is price. One can see this with the 35 APO-M options. VM 35 APO is reasonably priced, but larger than a 50 Lux ASPH. Leica's 35 APO-M is smaller and IMO has more pleasing wide open OOF background character. But the price... That aside, based on MTFs, the Leica 35 APO-M has higher wide open performance that drops a bit as it's stopped down due to diffraction. The VM's MTFs at f/2 and f/4 show that performance increases stopped down to f/4... so the takeaway would appear to be that the Leica is sharper from wide open. Since the new VM 28/2 APO is an APO Lanthar, Cosina *should* publish MTFs for it...
Leica's SL APO ASPH primes I suspect are 'over-specced' and actually closer to f/1.4 capable but 'detuned' to f/2 for optimized image quality. Canon's recently released VCM primes at 24, 35 and 50mm are all f/1.4 and very similar in physical dimensions to the SL primes. Contrary to Leica, Canon has likely 'stretched' these designs to be f/1.4.I missed that one ... thanks for the link. Somehow, I missed these samples too! Just to clarify, these were taken with the 33MP A7CII, a sensor that very likely does not work well with this lens.Yup, I picked up on the Sony vs. M diff ... data point, noted.
I wasn't too picky about judging the edges / corners, etc. Just wanted to get a broad sense of the falloff to oof, as a "first look" wrt rendering. Picky comes when you get your hands on it.
It’s tough to say for sure, but I think I like the rendering. It reminds me of the 35mm f/2 APO-Lanthar.
I would hope it shares the rendering if it shares the name!
Fred Miranda wrote: RustyBug wroteFred Miranda wroterscheffler wroteOne can already get an idea about the VM 28 APO's image quality from the sample images Juha posted from CP+ with a link here.
The other variable in the size/performance triangle is price. One can see this with the 35 APO-M options. VM 35 APO is reasonably priced, but larger than a 50 Lux ASPH. Leica's 35 APO-M is smaller and IMO has more pleasing wide open OOF background character. But the price... That aside, based on MTFs, the Leica 35 APO-M has higher wide open performance that drops a bit as it's stopped down due to diffraction. The VM's MTFs at f/2 and f/4 show that performance increases stopped down to f/4... so the takeaway would appear to be that the Leica is sharper from wide open. Since the new VM 28/2 APO is an APO Lanthar, Cosina *should* publish MTFs for it...
Leica's SL APO ASPH primes I suspect are 'over-specced' and actually closer to f/1.4 capable but 'detuned' to f/2 for optimized image quality. Canon's recently released VCM primes at 24, 35 and 50mm are all f/1.4 and very similar in physical dimensions to the SL primes. Contrary to Leica, Canon has likely 'stretched' these designs to be f/1.4.---------------------------------------------
RustyBug wroterscheffler wroteOne can already get an idea about the VM 28 APO's image quality from the sample images Juha posted from CP+ with a link here.
The other variable in the size/performance triangle is price. One can see this with the 35 APO-M options. VM 35 APO is reasonably priced, but larger than a 50 Lux ASPH. Leica's 35 APO-M is smaller and IMO has more pleasing wide open OOF background character. But the price... That aside, based on MTFs, the Leica 35 APO-M has higher wide open performance that drops a bit as it's stopped down due to diffraction. The VM's MTFs at f/2 and f/4 show that performance increases stopped down to f/4... so the takeaway would appear to be that the Leica is sharper from wide open. Since the new VM 28/2 APO is an APO Lanthar, Cosina *should* publish MTFs for it...
Leica's SL APO ASPH primes I suspect are 'over-specced' and actually closer to f/1.4 capable but 'detuned' to f/2 for optimized image quality. Canon's recently released VCM primes at 24, 35 and 50mm are all f/1.4 and very similar in physical dimensions to the SL primes. Contrary to Leica, Canon has likely 'stretched' these designs to be f/1.4.I missed that one ... thanks for the link. Somehow, I missed these samples too! Just to clarify, these were taken with the 33MP A7CII, a sensor that very likely does not work well with this lens.Yup, I picked up on the Sony vs. M diff ... data point, noted.
I wasn't too picky about judging the edges / corners, etc. Just wanted to get a broad sense of the falloff to oof, as a "first look" wrt rendering. Picky comes when you get your hands on it. It’s tough to say for sure, but I think I like the rendering. It reminds me of the 35mm f/2 APO-Lanthar.
Fred Miranda wrote: RustyBug wroteFred Miranda wroterscheffler wroteOne can already get an idea about the VM 28 APO's image quality from the sample images Juha posted from CP+ with a link here.
The other variable in the size/performance triangle is price. One can see this with the 35 APO-M options. VM 35 APO is reasonably priced, but larger than a 50 Lux ASPH. Leica's 35 APO-M is smaller and IMO has more pleasing wide open OOF background character. But the price... That aside, based on MTFs, the Leica 35 APO-M has higher wide open performance that drops a bit as it's stopped down due to diffraction. The VM's MTFs at f/2 and f/4 show that performance increases stopped down to f/4... so the takeaway would appear to be that the Leica is sharper from wide open. Since the new VM 28/2 APO is an APO Lanthar, Cosina *should* publish MTFs for it...
Leica's SL APO ASPH primes I suspect are 'over-specced' and actually closer to f/1.4 capable but 'detuned' to f/2 for optimized image quality. Canon's recently released VCM primes at 24, 35 and 50mm are all f/1.4 and very similar in physical dimensions to the SL primes. Contrary to Leica, Canon has likely 'stretched' these designs to be f/1.4.---------------------------------------------
RustyBug wroterscheffler wroteOne can already get an idea about the VM 28 APO's image quality from the sample images Juha posted from CP+ with a link here.
The other variable in the size/performance triangle is price. One can see this with the 35 APO-M options. VM 35 APO is reasonably priced, but larger than a 50 Lux ASPH. Leica's 35 APO-M is smaller and IMO has more pleasing wide open OOF background character. But the price... That aside, based on MTFs, the Leica 35 APO-M has higher wide open performance that drops a bit as it's stopped down due to diffraction. The VM's MTFs at f/2 and f/4 show that performance increases stopped down to f/4... so the takeaway would appear to be that the Leica is sharper from wide open. Since the new VM 28/2 APO is an APO Lanthar, Cosina *should* publish MTFs for it...
Leica's SL APO ASPH primes I suspect are 'over-specced' and actually closer to f/1.4 capable but 'detuned' to f/2 for optimized image quality. Canon's recently released VCM primes at 24, 35 and 50mm are all f/1.4 and very similar in physical dimensions to the SL primes. Contrary to Leica, Canon has likely 'stretched' these designs to be f/1.4.I missed that one ... thanks for the link. Somehow, I missed these samples too! Just to clarify, these were taken with the 33MP A7CII, a sensor that very likely does not work well with this lens.Yup, I picked up on the Sony vs. M diff ... data point, noted.
I wasn't too picky about judging the edges / corners, etc. Just wanted to get a broad sense of the falloff to oof, as a "first look" wrt rendering. Picky comes when you get your hands on it. It’s tough to say for sure, but I think I like the rendering. It reminds me of the 35mm f/2 APO-Lanthar.
+1
Caveat ... different apertures / different subject distances.
Seemed to have some of that Zeiss-ish look, without anything glaringly offensive in the rolloff. The oof's looked clean enough.
Will be good to see how it does, when you put it through its paces.
Fred Miranda wrote: RustyBug wroteFred Miranda wroterscheffler wroteOne can already get an idea about the VM 28 APO's image quality from the sample images Juha posted from CP+ with a link here.
The other variable in the size/performance triangle is price. One can see this with the 35 APO-M options. VM 35 APO is reasonably priced, but larger than a 50 Lux ASPH. Leica's 35 APO-M is smaller and IMO has more pleasing wide open OOF background character. But the price... That aside, based on MTFs, the Leica 35 APO-M has higher wide open performance that drops a bit as it's stopped down due to diffraction. The VM's MTFs at f/2 and f/4 show that performance increases stopped down to f/4... so the takeaway would appear to be that the Leica is sharper from wide open. Since the new VM 28/2 APO is an APO Lanthar, Cosina *should* publish MTFs for it...
Leica's SL APO ASPH primes I suspect are 'over-specced' and actually closer to f/1.4 capable but 'detuned' to f/2 for optimized image quality. Canon's recently released VCM primes at 24, 35 and 50mm are all f/1.4 and very similar in physical dimensions to the SL primes. Contrary to Leica, Canon has likely 'stretched' these designs to be f/1.4.---------------------------------------------
RustyBug wroterscheffler wroteOne can already get an idea about the VM 28 APO's image quality from the sample images Juha posted from CP+ with a link here.
The other variable in the size/performance triangle is price. One can see this with the 35 APO-M options. VM 35 APO is reasonably priced, but larger than a 50 Lux ASPH. Leica's 35 APO-M is smaller and IMO has more pleasing wide open OOF background character. But the price... That aside, based on MTFs, the Leica 35 APO-M has higher wide open performance that drops a bit as it's stopped down due to diffraction. The VM's MTFs at f/2 and f/4 show that performance increases stopped down to f/4... so the takeaway would appear to be that the Leica is sharper from wide open. Since the new VM 28/2 APO is an APO Lanthar, Cosina *should* publish MTFs for it...
Leica's SL APO ASPH primes I suspect are 'over-specced' and actually closer to f/1.4 capable but 'detuned' to f/2 for optimized image quality. Canon's recently released VCM primes at 24, 35 and 50mm are all f/1.4 and very similar in physical dimensions to the SL primes. Contrary to Leica, Canon has likely 'stretched' these designs to be f/1.4.I missed that one ... thanks for the link. Somehow, I missed these samples too! Just to clarify, these were taken with the 33MP A7CII, a sensor that very likely does not work well with this lens.Yup, I picked up on the Sony vs. M diff ... data point, noted.
I wasn't too picky about judging the edges / corners, etc. Just wanted to get a broad sense of the falloff to oof, as a "first look" wrt rendering. Picky comes when you get your hands on it. It’s tough to say for sure, but I think I like the rendering. It reminds me of the 35mm f/2 APO-Lanthar.
I would only judge sharpness and rendering in the central portion of the frame. Peripheral nervousness might be a byproduct of sensor stack mismatch. Or might not be. We won't know until you have a review copy for evaluation.
Has anyone yet seen a cross section of the upcoming 28mm/f2.0 Apo Lanthar?
E.g. any information on the number of elements and lenses, number of aspherical surfaces, number of high refractive lenses etc.?
Knut. wrote:
Has anyone yet seen a cross section of the upcoming 28mm/f2.0 Apo Lanthar?
E.g. any information on the number of elements and lenses, number of aspherical surfaces, number of high refractive lenses etc.?
It has 12 elements in 8 groups. It also is called Asph, so at least one element must be an Asph element, but there could be more than one. I assume it will have APD elements, given that it is an APO lens, but how many and in what position I don't think we know yet.
Steve Spencer wrote: Knut. wroteHas anyone yet seen a cross section of the upcoming 28mm/f2.0 Apo Lanthar?
E.g. any information on the number of elements and lenses, number of aspherical surfaces, number of high refractive lenses etc.?
Has anything leaked yet?From the link Cosina posted for CP+ here:
It has 12 elements in 8 groups. It also is called Asph, so at least one element must be an Asph element, but there could be more than one. I assume it will have APD elements, given that it is an APO lens, but how many and in what position I don't think we know yet.
What's great about the new Voigtlander 28mm f/2 APO-Lanthar is that Cosina will release its MTF diagram, allowing us to compare it with the Voigtlander 35mm f/2 APO-Lanthar. The 35mm has one less element but features two double aspherical elements and five APD elements. I expect a similar level of complexity for the new 28mm.
This is the one I am waiting for. Based on Voigtlander's recent track record, it will surely be the highest performing 28mm on M mount. I hope they include a detent at 0.7m. Otherwise, the size and overall design looks great.
costa44 wrote:
This is the one I am waiting for. Based on Voigtlander's recent track record, it will surely be the highest performing 28mm on M mount. I hope they include a detent at 0.7m. Otherwise, the size and overall design looks great.
I think there was no detent at 0.7m on the demo version of the lens at CP+ (which I tried) and they also didn't mention about it on the preliminary spec information / CP+ product introduction video for the new lens(es). Last year when they pre-announced Apo-Lanthar 50/3.5 at CP+ the detent was clearly mentioned in the video at least... So I think it might not be there on the 28/2. Remains to be seen when they make official announcement about the lens as until then they could make some adjustments.
Today Cosina already announced the 3 new versions of VM f1.2 lenses for May (35/1.2 IV, 50/1.2 II) and June (40/1.2 II) release so they are starting to release the new lenses (other than Otus) faster than I predicted and in completely different order (after skipping April). Probably APO 28/2 will be pushed later though since they have the 3 other VMs lined up for May and June release already. I'm hoping that the Portrait Heliar 75/1.5 in E-mount will find a release slot sometime soonish, e.g. June in the best possible case (they could announce in May) or in July.
Ripolini wrote: costa44 wroteIt seems like the APO is a little way off still so I’ll have to pick something else up for my trip.Thypoch Simera 28/1.4?
I can’t decide. All of a sudden the options are plentiful at 28mm. I no doubt will want the APO on release so maybe a complimentary lens is the way to go.