Thanks for your input. Personally, I am not in love with the rendering of the 50 f/1.4 GM. I actually think that the Sony 35 f/1.4 GM, the 50 f/1.4 GM, and the 85 f/1.4 GM II are all very similar lenses. They are uber sharp, very compact, and they have excellent AF. I can see why people like them, but they are not my cup of tea. I actually don't want quite the level of wide open sharpness they produce, for portraits at least, and I don't need that level of AF--my camera only shoots 10 fps, so that they can shoot 120 fps just doesn't matter to me. My AF needs are almost always quite modest.
The really kicker, however, is that I don't really like the bokeh of any of these lenses. ...Show more →
I have owned the 35 and 50 of those. The 85 never tempted me. The two former ones, well, I bought, tried and sold them. This for the same reason you mentioned plus my usual problem with size and weight.
]
Here is how currently use my 50mm lenses:
My two lens kit that I take when I might want to shoot, but I am not planning on any particular photography outing is my Voigtlander 21 f/1.4 and my 50 f/2 APO. This simple two lens kit covers a huge range if I am flexible with cropping and has a ton of capability. The 21 when cropped by 1.33 still has about 30 MP and makes a really nice 28mm f/1.8 alternative. Crop a bit more to a 1.67 crop and it still has 19 MP and it makes a quite decent 35mm f/2.5 alternative. It really is a great 3 in one lens and handles close ups really well. The 50 f/2 APO is pretty versatile too. A 1.17 crop gives you 39 MP and a very nice 58 f/2.4 alternative, a 1.5 crop gives you about 24 MP and a 75 f/3.0 alternative, and a 1.67 crop give you a usable 85 f/3.4 alternative, and the lens also handles close up really well. That is a great range with just two lenses. That said, part of what makes me excited about the Otus 50 f/1.4 ML is that in this two lens kit it provides virtually everything the 50 f/2 APO does, but I think I would find a 50 f/1.4, 58 f/1.6 alternative, 75 f/2.1 alternative and 85 f/2.4 alternative a lot more useful than the 50 f/2. 58 f/2.4, 75 f/3.0, and 85 f/3.4 capabilities the 50 f/2 APO provides. And in a two lens kit even though the Voigtlander 21 f/1.4 and the Otus 50 f/1.4 ML are not small lenses, the total kit is still acceptable to me coming in at less that 2,000 g/4.5 lbs. including the camera. ...Show more →
Here i have two optins, depending on my own mode. I can either bring camera and one lens only (40G) or I mount the Sigma 50/2 and place the FE PZ 16-35/4 in the bag.
For more serious trips when I focus on photography, however, I want to crop less and take a different set of lenses and one of those sets of lenses is a four lens kit. In that four lens kit, I take an 18 f/2.8, a 28 f/1.5, the Voigtlander 50 f/1.2, and an 85 f/4. For this set of lenses, I want the 50mm to be both small (to keep the weight down on a kit with more lenses) and to be versatile. I want it to be capable for portraits and to be capable as a landscape and architecture lens when stopped down. Here is where I think the Voigtlander 50 f/1.2 excels and you can see that in Fred's current review. For E-mount you can get the SE version and it weighs just 383g, and it is a very nice portrait lens with nice bokeh, but stopped down to f/4 or narrower it is a quite nice landscape and architecture lens as well. It can't do close ups that well and it doesn't have the rendering that the Otus 50 ML or the sharp clean rendering of the Voigtlander 50 f/2 APO, but it is really versatile and it is reasonably small enough to make the 4 lens kit work. ...Show more →
CV 50/2 APO (or again the Sigma 50/2 depending on the trip) and the PZ16-35.
Then there are other times that I focus on portraits. For those times my primary lens is the Sony 85 f/1.4 GM original version and I really like the rendering of that lens. It is my primary lens when I focus on portraits. That said, I might pick up the Sony/Zeiss 50 f/1.4 FE as another lens with a different look that I also like. You can get this lens pretty cheap these days so adding it for that type of shooting seems like it would be worth it to me.
Those are my thoughts for right now. Thanks for sharing yours.
Obviously the Sirui Aurora 85/1.4 for me.
It's interesting to see how my own preferences have changed over time. Well, for me it's interesting... There are some wonderful, or in other ways great, lenses I thought I would keep forever that is of little interest to me now. The C/Y-mount Zeiss 35/1.4, the 35GM, the 50GM, the Leica Summilux-R 80/1.4, the CV 35/1.2, the Summilux-M 50/1.4 ASPH and the Lux 35/1.4 pre-FLE and some more that once made me happy are these days not important (and all sold).
The first thing to notice is that my lenses, except for the CV 50/2 APO, are AF lenses. I have come to enjoy a kind of faster and more spontaneous photography.
EDIT: image removed
Pro secundo; I have gone from being a junkie for fast primes to a lover of moderately fast lenses with other features. Image quality of course, other important parameters are weight and size. maybe age is driving me towards a more minimalistic style?
Hmm, maybe we should go back to discuss the 50mm Otus.
Ditto, thanks for explaining your current choices!
Thank you for sharing these examples, Zeiss is well and truly back! The color and 3d/spatial presentation is the differentiator here and I suspect that aspect is what was lost in the early marketing and reviews. The rendering feels transparent like the C/Y mounts we love but with resolution for modern sensors.
I wonder though how it will manage portraiture with the level of contrast wide open. My milvus 50 and 85 both are dual character, with portrait rendering wide open that resolves into high fidelity a stop down (by design). My milvus 135 is full contrast wide open and not my first choice for portraits, which feels more analogous to the drawing style of this otus lens.
Spoiled for choice and I suspect this will be in my lens bag at some point in the future.
Lens designers working in the cine and photographic fields relentlessly pursue what you call '3D pop', as a matter of course.
It's a difficult conversation to have with the rather large percentage of people who say they do not perceive this critical visual phenomenon. Virtually all written material on the highest tier lenses makes mention of the presence of 3D (or image depth or dimensionality or immersiveness or spatial volume).
Perception is qualitative, it's neither quantitative nor measurable. So it's beyond 'proof', I'm afraid. It varies with eye performance, acuity and health, age, life experience (sport, driving/riding, flying (pilots), some outdoor occupations) but I believe it is mostly genetic. More:
'Perceiving image depth, or depth perception, is the ability to see objects in three dimensions, including their size and how far away they are from you.'
'This ability relies on the complex interactions between our eyes, brain, and visual cues from the environment.'
'..young animals from various species generally avoided the deep side of the cliff, suggesting that depth perception is not solely a learned behavior but also has innate components.' 'By 2 years of age, a child's eye-hand coordination and depth perception should be well developed.'
'Can you have 20/20 vision but bad depth perception?
Depends on how well both eyes work together to judge distances and spatial relationships. Even with 20/20 vision, depth perception can still be off. Having sharp vision doesn't guarantee strong depth perception.'
'Can you teach depth perception? Can You Improve Depth Perception?
The good news is that you can improve depth perception and make those daily tasks a little less daunting. Several exercises and techniques can help improve depth perception, such as focus exercises, activities that require hand-eye coordination, and vision therapy.'
'Can lack of depth perception be corrected?
Fortunately, there are ways to improve depth perception through practice and training. Some tips to improve your depth perception include: Determine with and eye doctor if you're using both eyes at the same time. Practicing visual exercises prescribed by your doctor.'
The ML Otus 50mm will do just fine for portraiture because its wide open MTF is typically Zeiss, in that it holds back fine detail by design while delivering high levels of low to medium spatial frequency data. It's very different to what Leica is doing. It's a wise move in the digital era, to take the edge off the 'sandpaper look' that digital produces.
It's what I call a '60-80-90 lens' this being approximately the on-axis lens contrast for 40-20-10 lpmm. My CY Sonnar 100/3.5 is almost exactly the same, but at f3.5.
Zeiss ML 50/1.4 Otus at f1.4 - see left axis for on-axis MTF : ~63-84-93%, bottom to top
philip_pj wrote:
Perception is qualitative, it's neither quantitative nor measurable. So it's beyond 'proof', I'm afraid.'
It's not beyond 'proof', it's trivial just like with any other visible phenomena. Just post two images taken within a minute of each other, of the same subject and same light, but with two different lenses: one with 3D pop and another without. If this perception is subjective, you will get some people react with "I see it" or "I do not see it", that's ok. But I am yet to see anyone even attempt to show this obvious experiment online, and I've been looking since 1992, which tells me that even the fans of 3D pop haven't seen it themselves. It's like with UFOs: it's possible to be a hardline believer with zero evidence.
Maybe I should do it even though I don't see and don't believe in 3D pop? I have the trio of the Zeiss Milvus line: 35-50-80 and have other manufacturers of these focal lenghts. The only difference I see is the character of OOF areas.
philip_pj wrote:
The ML Otus 50mm will do just fine for portraiture because its wide open MTF is typically Zeiss, in that it holds back fine detail by design while delivering high levels of low to medium spatial frequency data. It's very different to what Leica is doing. It's a wise move in the digital era, to take the edge off the 'sandpaper look' that digital produces.
It's what I call a '60-80-90 lens' this being approximately the on-axis lens contrast for 40-20-10 lpmm. My CY Sonnar 100/3.5 is almost exactly the same, but at f3.5.
I too like 60-80-90 lenses for portraits and from the samples I have seen of this Otus 50 ML, it lives up to what I expect from such a lens. Sharp, but not too sharp at the point of focus. I also like the bokeh of the samples I have seen a lot, and although the lens has more axial CA than I expected it seems to diminish nicely even if stopped down to f/2.
I think it also has an interesting and nice set of 10 rounded aperture blades, if I am seeing the samples correctly. So not the 10 straight blades in many Cosina lenses, but 10 blades with a rounded aperture. I am liking 10 and 14 bladed rounded apertures that both leave round bokeh circles and 10 or 14 pointed sunstars when stopped down to f/5.6 or narrower. In that way I think the aperture blades in this lens share a lot with the aperture blades in the shorter focal length Thypoch Simera lenses. My favorite aperture blade arrangement is still what Cosina did with the Voigtlander 35 f/2 APO, the 50 f/2 APO, and the 90 f/2.8 APO where they made the aperture round at some apertures and straight at other apertures, but what Thypoch has done and Cosina has done for Zeiss here I like almost as much.
burningheart wrote:
Stumbled upon these. The 2nd was from a totally unexpected genre.
The Slanted Lens video is very well done comparison Sony GM 1.2 vs Zeiss ML 50. Thank you for posting! I will see the second video soon.
In a couple of the comparison images I think the Zeiss advantage was fairly evident, under close scrutiny.
*The massive Zeiss Otus ML 50 260mm focus throw. Too bad the Zeiss Otus ML lenses are not offered in L-Mount. The Leica SL cameras have a feature to tame or unleash lens focus throw from a very quick 90, 120, 150 degrees etc. all the way to massive 360 degrees. AKA as needed.
LBJ2 wrote:
The Slanted Lens video is very well done comparison Sony GM 1.2 vs Zeiss ML 50. Thank you for posting! [...]
I think the opposite, except for thank you for posting of course! I enjoyed the second video, it was like a feel good movie.
The first "Slanted Lens" video was a disappointment. The guy talked and showed images and what he said didn't match what he showed. It's hard to take such presentations seriously.
"The Zeiss skin tone pops." "There is more information in the Zeiss image" (at 14:44, I saw the opposite or no practical difference). He compared images of the girl taken at similar angles towards a brick wall but not at the same distance and then concluded the girl popped out from the wall more in one of the images.It continued the same sloppy way, for example when comparing flare and the colors.
@LBJ2@: To my understanding the Leica SL feature won't work when mounting a manual lens. It is a great feature i wish Sony had as well bu it surely works only with focus by wire lenses.
Jonas B wrote: LBJ2 wroteThe Slanted Lens video is very well done comparison Sony GM 1.2 vs Zeiss ML 50. Thank you for posting! [...]I think the opposite, except for thank you for posting of course! I enjoyed the second video, it was like a feel good movie.
The first "Slanted Lens" video was a disappointment. The guy talked and showed images and what he said didn't match what he showed. It's hard to take such presentations seriously.
"The Zeiss skin tone pops." "There is more information in the Zeiss image" (at 14:44, I saw the opposite or no practical difference). He compared images of the girl taken at similar angles towards a brick wall but not at the same distance and then concluded the girl popped out from the wall more in one of the images.It continued the same sloppy way, for example when comparing flare and the colors.
To my understanding the Leica SL feature won't work when mounting a manual lens. It is a great feature i wish Sony had as well bu it surely works only with focus by wire lenses. ...Show more →
I don't own any non-Leica L-mount lenses to test, but makes sense about the SL cameras focus throw feature for SL/Lmount AF lenses only. Regardless, I would still like to see the Zeiss Otus ML lenses in Lmount--I think it would be a very good IQ and system balance match. But I personally, wouldn't want to be stuck at 260mm focus throw only...all the time. I typically set my SL lenses at 90-120 throw, for photography.
Jonas B wrote: LBJ2 wroteThe Slanted Lens video is very well done comparison Sony GM 1.2 vs Zeiss ML 50. Thank you for posting! [...]I think the opposite, except for thank you for posting of course! I enjoyed the second video, it was like a feel good movie.
The first "Slanted Lens" video was a disappointment. The guy talked and showed images and what he said didn't match what he showed. It's hard to take such presentations seriously.
"The Zeiss skin tone pops." "There is more information in the Zeiss image" (at 14:44, I saw the opposite or no practical difference). He compared images of the girl taken at similar angles towards a brick wall but not at the same distance and then concluded the girl popped out from the wall more in one of the images.It continued the same sloppy way, for example when comparing flare and the colors.
@LBJ2@@: To my understanding the Leica SL feature won't work when mounting a manual lens. It is a great feature i wish Sony had as well bu it surely works only with focus by wire lenses. ...Show more →
Yeah, it's a bit sloppy comparison (for photography forums at least). The lenses have different field of views (as he says), but it's impossible to say how much the differences in test pictures are about that or just sloppy subject positioning. Regarding contrast & sharpness, it's impossible to verify what he's saying from youtube-compression. Regarding colors, the Zeiss definitely looks better - in a way I've used to perceive Zeiss color rendition. Bokeh looks very good on the Zeiss, there's no doubt about it.
So yeah, it's a bit sloppy comparison, but it definitely shows that the Zeiss is a competent lens, no doubt about it. And so is Sony as well, for that matter. If one is looking for 'a winner', I'm not sure if that's relevant (other than for forum 'brand wars', of course).
I had a chance to try one very briefly against my 50mm f1.2 GM, i'm yet to do an IQ comparison but handling wise the Zeiss performed very very well. Both the aperture and focus rings were very smooth.
*Side note- The Zeiss rep that I spoke to said the 85mm f1.4 ML Otus should be out within 6 months from now.
Originally the Z-mount version was planned to be released in May 2025 same time as E-mount and RF-mount versions but for some reason Cosina had to postpone the Z version to July.
Ted Forbes has just released an interesting video suggesting his full production OTUS ML 50mm f1.4 doesn't have the fringing problems at f1.4 that the initial pre production sample that he had, did.
Created an account just to reply to this. Guess I'm no longer a lurker.
I just received my copy of the Otus ML 50mm E-Mount from B&H. Took it out for a quick test around the yard this morning and I can confirm that my copy does still exhibit the aberration, so perhaps it is just copy variation.