It’s not the new Otus, but in terms of brilliant tonal rendition and loads of depth the ZA 50/1.4 is a largely forgotten but still excellent option at a more than reasonable price IMO nowadays used.
It does have bokeh personality (good), AF with linear MF (very good) and more Axial CA (bad) but I find it manageable except in extreme circumstances. The images are much preferred to the 50 GM’s IMO for the same reason as this new Otus.
Just to plant a seed for this looking for GM or Sammy or Sigma alternatives
I’d like to see real world shots of the new Otus and ZA 50/1.4 for rendering purposes
@Juha Kannisto thank you for the sample photos, they look great!! They look more Zeiss like than most of the sample photos shown around the announcement. Hopefully, this lens will prove to be better than we thought it would be as it gets into the hands of more photographers 🤞It would be great to be able to say Zeiss is back.
I am definitely hoping the next Otus ML will be a wider angle lens.
Keunish wrote: Juha Kannisto wroteLots of samples from both days, esp. today: https://photos.app.goo.gl/4SuHhP1FWyZZhShr6Honestly these samples look fantastic. Much better that what I've seen when using the 50mm GM f1.2.
The lens reminds me the Lumix 50mm f1.4, I see the same 3D effect and sense of volume.
But this effect on the Zeiss is even more impressive, maybe because the lens looks insanely sharp, have you added some extra sharpening on C1 ?
Thanks very much! I used default sharpening in C1 Pro (which depends on camera, so the default for A7CII). Didn't change that and the presets I use don't modify those sharpening settings.
Maximilian wrote: Juha Kannisto wroteThanks very much Tim! Fingers crossed that they would release a 28mm next Keeping my fingers crossed too!
By the way, has anyone heard something about the Apo Lanthar 2,0/28mm which Cosina announced over 3 months ago?
It was only pre-announced at CP+ at end of February along with the other new CV lenses (the new versions of their VM f1.2 trio and Portrait Heliar 75/1.8 for E-mount as well as the Otus ML lenses).
They are all coming out gradually with official announcements & release schedule info coming out in following months after CP+ as usual with CV.
From the new CV lineup, everything else got officially announced afterwards already with May and June release targets, but 28/2 Apo VM is the last one in the queue and it's still waiting for official announcement and release schedule info. The earliest possibility now would be June 13th (since 15th is a Sunday) announcement and July release schedule. They might also skip a month here and there so it's not certain yet it'll come out in July or a bit later.
Personally I'm looking forward to E-mount version of that 28/2 as Cosina hinted in personal discussions at CP+ that they may well release that lens in mirrorless mounts as well (though nothing has been announced about that). The schedule for potential mirrorless versions would be later, but I hope they might get to it already before end of the year or at least early next year.
That doesn' stop me from wanting an Otus ML 28/1.4 as well 28mm is one of my top favorite focal lengths and there's always been a bit of shortage of native E-mount options so I'm still motivated to get more.
I would probably go the Lanthar 28mm E mount direction if it materializes, over a Zeiss Otus, but trying not to get too excited. Until it's announced, it doesn't exist.
And since Zeiss went with 50 instead of 55, it makes me worry the WA will be a 25 and not a 28. But I guess we'll see eventually....
Juha Kannisto wrote:
I managed to do some shooting with my new Otus ML 50/1.4 (Sony E version) on both days this weekend. [...]
Thank you Juha! These images look better than those I have seen earlier. I noticed some LoCA but that was minor and not jumping out of the image at you. Do you have more cables against the sky but at f/1.4 and f/2?
Jonas B wrote: Juha Kannisto wroteI managed to do some shooting with my new Otus ML 50/1.4 (Sony E version) on both days this weekend. [...]Thank you Juha! These images look better than those I have seen earlier. I noticed some LoCA but that was minor and not jumping out of the image at you. Do you have more cables against the sky but at f/1.4 and f/2?
Thanks Jonas! I didn't particularly test for LoCA or LaCA as I'm not that sensitive about CA and I don't usually pay attention to it unless it really jumps out. The lens being APO wasn't one of the main motivators for me to get it.
My original samples were the usual kind of shots I'd normally take without any special effort to test for one thing or another. I usually like to take subject isolation / bokeh type of shots wide open or close to it and when I shoot some street or city scenery I usually stop down to somewhere between f4 and f8 to get enough depth of field across the whole scene. Shots with cables against the sky would usually fall into the latter category.
I'll try to get some cables against the sky type of shots in bright weather at wide apertures on my next outings with the lens and I'll keep posting more samples as soon as I've had a chance to go out for some more outings
tsdevine wrote:
I would probably go the Lanthar 28mm E mount direction if it materializes, over a Zeiss Otus, but trying not to get too excited. Until it's announced, it doesn't exist.
And since Zeiss went with 50 instead of 55, it makes me worry the WA will be a 25 and not a 28. But I guess we'll see eventually....
I'm also a bit worried that they might go for 25mm rather than 28mm. When I talked to Zeiss manager at CP+ and encouraged them to make a 28mm Otus ML next, she asked why 28mm would be preferable to 24mm or 25mm. That also made me wonder if they had already made some plans for a ~25mm instead. Or it could be that all options were still open.
Like Steve wrote, it might also depend on how many lenses they plan to have in the series. E.g. one possible route could include both 25 mm and 35mm in the wider side (like Loxia line).
Juha Kannisto wrote:
[...]. Shots with cables against the sky would usually fall into the latter category.
I'll try to get some cables against the sky type of shots in bright weather at wide apertures on my next outings with the lens and I'll keep posting more samples as soon as I've had a chance to go out for some more outings
Hey Juha, I understand. I was thinking about outtakes where there happened to be this kind of stark contrast in the background. You don't need to go look for this sort of thing, I take what I get by time...
Also congrats to your new lenses, I understand you get busy learning them!
nehemiahphoto wrote:
It’s not the new Otus, but in terms of brilliant tonal rendition and loads of depth the ZA 50/1.4 is a largely forgotten but still excellent option at a more than reasonable price IMO nowadays used.
It does have bokeh personality (good), AF with linear MF (very good) and more Axial CA (bad) but I find it manageable except in extreme circumstances. The images are much preferred to the 50 GM’s IMO for the same reason as this new Otus.
Just to plant a seed for this looking for GM or Sammy or Sigma alternatives
I’d like to see real world shots of the new Otus and ZA 50/1.4 for rendering purposes...Show more →
I am glad you still like the ZA 50 f/1.4 that I sold you. I agree it is an under appreciated gem. I too really liked its rendering and it is my favorite auto focus 50. I will probably get it again for when I want AF. I think it would pair nicely with the Otus 50 ML as it can be used when there isn't enough time to manually focus. The Otus 50 ML with its long focus throw is exactly what I want for most of my shooting when I have time to set focus exactly where I want it to be, but I would probably want another 50 for times when I can't be so deliberative. Of course I would also want a smaller 50mm lens than either the Otus or the ZA 50 f/1.4, so in the end I will probably have at least 3 50s, and I count it a very good thing that we now have so many good 50s as options.
Like you I won't be getting the Otus 50 ML for a couple of years until the price comes down. I expect it will, however, and when/if it does then I am pretty sure I will rearrange my 50s to make room for it. I am thinking right now that the Otus 50 ML, the ZA 50 f/1.4, and the Voigtlander 50 f/1.2 SE would make a really nice and versatile set of 50s.
That line of thinking does leave me with a question, however: Does anyone know how the Otus 50 ML performs on a camera with a thin sensor modification? If someone has that experience I would like to know the answer as it might affect whether I modify my camera sensor.
Steve Spencer wrote: nehemiahphoto wroteIt’s not the new Otus, but in terms of brilliant tonal rendition and loads of depth the ZA 50/1.4 is a largely forgotten but still excellent option at a more than reasonable price IMO nowadays used.
It does have bokeh personality (good), AF with linear MF (very good) and more Axial CA (bad) but I find it manageable except in extreme circumstances. The images are much preferred to the 50 GM’s IMO for the same reason as this new Otus.
Just to plant a seed for this looking for GM or Sammy or Sigma alternatives
I’d like to see real world shots of the new Otus and ZA 50/1.4 for rendering purposesI am glad you still like the ZA 50 f/1.4 that I sold you. I agree it is an under appreciated gem. I too really liked its rendering and it is my favorite auto focus 50. I will probably get it again for when I want AF. I think it would pair nicely with the Otus 50 ML as it can be used when there isn't enough time to manually focus. The Otus 50 ML with its long focus throw is exactly what I want for most of my shooting when I have time to set focus exactly where I want it to be, but I would probably want another 50 for times when I can't be so deliberative. Of course I would also want a smaller 50mm lens than either the Otus or the ZA 50 f/1.4, so in the end I will probably have at least 3 50s, and I count it a very good thing that we now have so many good 50s as options.
Like you I won't be getting the Otus 50 ML for a couple of years until the price comes down. I expect it will, however, and when/if it does then I am pretty sure I will rearrange my 50s to make room for it. I am thinking right now that the Otus 50 ML, the ZA 50 f/1.4, and the Voigtlander 50 f/1.2 SE would make a really nice and versatile set of 50s.
That line of thinking does leave me with a question, however: Does anyone know how the Otus 50 ML performs on a camera with a thin sensor modification? If someone has that experience I would like to know the answer as it might affect whether I modify my camera sensor....Show more →
It's been great--thank you much. I don't use often as I just don't really every shoot large lenses, but for music shows, smaller walks, some portraits and video work, I like it a great deal. But, due to the size, I am always on the look for a smaller 50.
The two I really like, the 50 Lux and ZA 50/1.5 are both crappy on a Stock sony. I had a CV 50/1.2 a while back and maybe I should try that again. The Thypoch didn't do it for me. All those little RF lenses are compromised when not on a Leica to some degree. I also have had a Syptoptic 50/1.1 but it is rarely used as it's a boring lens for me.
The AF options, a 55/1.8 or Samy 45/1.8 are both fine but both have their faults for my preferences and I am not really that crazy about either. The only other real AF 50 on my list would be the Sigma, but it's larger than I would like for an F2. I guess I am too picky.
I always try to work my kit backwards--for me it all starts with a Noct 50/1. I'd love to have one very compact option, like a CV 50/1.5 and than an AF option to compliment it. Oh well. I am down for rec's if anybody has one. Not trying to derail the thread!
Steve Spencer wrote: nehemiahphoto wroteIt’s not the new Otus, but in terms of brilliant tonal rendition and loads of depth the ZA 50/1.4 is a largely forgotten but still excellent option at a more than reasonable price IMO nowadays used.
It does have bokeh personality (good), AF with linear MF (very good) and more Axial CA (bad) but I find it manageable except in extreme circumstances. The images are much preferred to the 50 GM’s IMO for the same reason as this new Otus.
Just to plant a seed for this looking for GM or Sammy or Sigma alternatives
I’d like to see real world shots of the new Otus and ZA 50/1.4 for rendering purposesI am glad you still like the ZA 50 f/1.4 that I sold you. I agree it is an under appreciated gem. I too really liked its rendering and it is my favorite auto focus 50. I will probably get it again for when I want AF. [...], and the Voigtlander 50 f/1.2 SE would make a really nice and versatile set of 50s.
Hmm, that's fast, heavy and expensive.
Do you really use the 50mm wide open that much? I would have gone a slower route and ended up with the (hypothetical n.b.) Otus 50/1.4, the Sigma 50/2 DG DN (buy at Adorama now before they adjust the price) and the Voigtländer 50/2 APO.
Cheaper, very good and less weight. If you already guess I have the two latter of the three you are right. In reality the most use lens is the 40/2.5 G thanks to size, weight and features.
Please note that the 40G has become an expensive connoisseur lens these days! ;-)
Jonas B wrote: Steve Spencer wrotenehemiahphoto wroteIt’s not the new Otus, but in terms of brilliant tonal rendition and loads of depth the ZA 50/1.4 is a largely forgotten but still excellent option at a more than reasonable price IMO nowadays used.
It does have bokeh personality (good), AF with linear MF (very good) and more Axial CA (bad) but I find it manageable except in extreme circumstances. The images are much preferred to the 50 GM’s IMO for the same reason as this new Otus.
Just to plant a seed for this looking for GM or Sammy or Sigma alternatives
I’d like to see real world shots of the new Otus and ZA 50/1.4 for rendering purposesI am glad you still like the ZA 50 f/1.4 that I sold you. I agree it is an under appreciated gem. I too really liked its rendering and it is my favorite auto focus 50. I will probably get it again for when I want AF. [...], and the Voigtlander 50 f/1.2 SE would make a really nice and versatile set of 50s.Hmm, that's fast, heavy and expensive.
Do you really use the 50mm wide open that much? I would have gone a slower route and ended up with the (hypothetical n.b.) Otus 50/1.4, the Sigma 50/2 DG DN (buy at Adorama now before they adjust the price) and the Voigtländer 50/2 APO.
Cheaper, very good and less weight. If you already guess I have the two latter of the three you are right. In reality the most use lens is the 40/2.5 G thanks to size, weight and features.
Please note that the 40G has become an expensive connoisseur lens these days! ;-)
Hi Jonas,
I too have the Voigtlander 50 f/2 APO--it is a wonderful lens--and I also have the Voigtlander 50 f/1.2. I do use f/1.4 and even f/1.2 on the Voigtlander for portraits, and especially so when I crop. With my A7r V even a 1.7X crop, which gives the perspective of an 85mm FF 35mm lens, leaves plenty of megapixels (18 to 20 depending on the aspect ratio). When I crop like that I like having the wider aperture.
The Sigma f/2 DG DN i series lens is an interesting and small option, but for me when I use AF I don't need small so much. When I travel I usually take manual focus lenses and when I use AF, I typically have just one lens or two so I worry less about weight. It is the rendering that draws me to the ZA 50 f/1.4 as I really like the images that lens produces. Surprisingly here in North America it is pretty cheap used. I got my copy for something like $450 US, and I believe I sold it to Nehemiah for even a bit less than that. So, here in North America, on the used market it is not an overly expensive lens. The Sigma i series would not doubt be a lot smaller, however.
Hey Juha, the rendering of the Otus feels very clean and lush! Great sample images, as usual!
Jonas B wrote:
Thank you Juha! These images look better than those I have seen earlier. I noticed some LoCA but that was minor and not jumping out of the image at you. Do you have more cables against the sky but at f/1.4 and f/2?
From what I recall from the Otus v2 announcement, Zeiss indicated these wouldn't be as super-corrected as the first versions. There is definitely LoCA/color fringing, particularly in out of focus areas with higher contrast transitions, such as the black bicycle with bike rack and the door covered in stickers, photographed from an angle that better reveals the color fringing as blur increases from the very sharp plane of focus fore and aft.
Also the Honda scooter on the second day: the wall along the left side shows a fair amount of green fringing as blur increases in the background. Or the Piaggio scooter on the first day, where the out of focus chrome in front of the plane of focus shows some red/magenta fringing
There are other photos that reveal some fringing/LoCA, but you have to look for it most of the time and view these at 100% to really notice it. And what I think impresses me is that the lens does not exhibit noticeable fringing in the actual plane of focus. For example, again the Honda and Piaggio scooters. Both have some highly reflective areas in the plane of focus that show no LoCA. Or at least, not like a lot of less corrected fast 50s that tend to have hints of magenta/purple fringing in the plane of focus at wide apertures.
There's also the backlit statue on a stone pedestal on the second day with very busy foliage background that controls LoCA very well. Fringing is still there, but it's not obnoxious.
For such a well corrected lens, the bokeh is surprisingly calm and pleasing with a nice transition out of the plane of focus, both foreground and background. This is unlike many lenses that are smoother in one direction, like background blur, but not the other, for example, foreground blur. It's not perfectly Gaussian though, which means it still has a touch of 'character.' It's not revealing much double-line edginess seen with many other fast lenses. Nor is there really any sign of swirl, which adds to the overall calm feeling of how the lens renders. This is likely a benefit of the size of the lens if optical vignetting has been effectively controlled.
I'm also impressed how well the camera's IBIS managed at fairly marginal shutter speeds in the ones I checked that were around 1/50.
rscheffler wrote:
Hey Juha, the rendering of the Otus feels very clean and lush! Great sample images, as usual!
Jonas B wroteThank you Juha! These images look better than those I have seen earlier. I noticed some LoCA but that was minor and not jumping out of the image at you. Do you have more cables against the sky but at f/1.4 and f/2?From what I recall from the Otus v2 announcement, Zeiss indicated these wouldn't be as super-corrected as the first versions. There is definitely LoCA/color fringing, particularly in out of focus areas with higher contrast transitions, such as the black bicycle with bike rack and the door covered in stickers, photographed from an angle that better reveals the color fringing as blur increases from the very sharp plane of focus fore and aft.
Also the Honda scooter on the second day: the wall along the left side shows a fair amount of green fringing as blur increases in the background. Or the Piaggio scooter on the first day, where the out of focus chrome in front of the plane of focus shows some red/magenta fringing
There are other photos that reveal some fringing/LoCA, but you have to look for it most of the time and view these at 100% to really notice it. And what I think impresses me is that the lens does not exhibit noticeable fringing in the actual plane of focus. For example, again the Honda and Piaggio scooters. Both have some highly reflective areas in the plane of focus that show no LoCA. Or at least, not like a lot of less corrected fast 50s that tend to have hints of magenta/purple fringing in the plane of focus at wide apertures.
There's also the backlit statue on a stone pedestal on the second day with very busy foliage background that controls LoCA very well. Fringing is still there, but it's not obnoxious.
For such a well corrected lens, the bokeh is surprisingly calm and pleasing with a nice transition out of the plane of focus, both foreground and background. This is unlike many lenses that are smoother in one direction, like background blur, but not the other, for example, foreground blur. It's not perfectly Gaussian though, which means it still has a touch of 'character.' It's not revealing much double-line edginess seen with many other fast lenses. Nor is there really any sign of swirl, which adds to the overall calm feeling of how the lens renders. This is likely a benefit of the size of the lens if optical vignetting has been effectively controlled.
I'm also impressed how well the camera's IBIS managed at fairly marginal shutter speeds in the ones I checked that were around 1/50. ...Show more →
Thanks Ron! I also like the rendering a lot so far. It's very nice for shooting flowers and greenery at close range as well as stopped down cityscapes and lots of other subjects too. The bokeh rendering is quite pleasing to me, and much more so than with some other APO lenses I've been using earlier (for example CV 65/2 where the bokeh was sometimes quite jarring).
A7CII IBIS is officially good for 7 stops, whereas my previous Sony Alpha cameras were usually 5 stops. I've noticed a clear improvement, even up to 1s exposures can be acceptable though perhaps not 100% at pixel level and it might take a couple of tries. 1/50 is easily achievable I think. I usually just use ISO100 all the time without worrying about exposure times unless I'm trying to freeze motion or when shooting in pretty dark environment and starting to get noticeably blurred shots.
While I was shooting with the Otus at Tenno-ji Temple I must have looked like a pro as I was approached by a group of around 15 people in funeral suits and they wanted me to take their group photo with one of their smartphones. I took a few takes and they seemed to be quite pleased with the results. I accidentally called out the usual Japanese "chiizu" phrase when taking the first shot, which is supposed to make the subjects smile. In hindisight it might not be approriate for a funeral group photo... Nobody seemed to mind though and they were genrerally in good spirits.
Juha Kannisto wrote: tsdevine wroteI would probably go the Lanthar 28mm E mount direction if it materializes, over a Zeiss Otus, but trying not to get too excited. Until it's announced, it doesn't exist.
And since Zeiss went with 50 instead of 55, it makes me worry the WA will be a 25 and not a 28. But I guess we'll see eventually....I'm also a bit worried that they might go for 25mm rather than 28mm. When I talked to Zeiss manager at CP+ and encouraged them to make a 28mm Otus ML next, she asked why 28mm would be preferable to 24mm or 25mm. That also made me wonder if they had already made some plans for a ~25mm instead. Or it could be that all options were still open.
Like Steve wrote, it might also depend on how many lenses they plan to have in the series. E.g. one possible route could include both 25 mm and 35mm in the wider side (like Loxia line).
Juha, thanks for your shots as they cover a lot of the types of things I would like to use the lens for and I really like the look it provides. It is for me a nice balance of features. It is sharp enough even wide open. It has decent color correction even though that could be better, and it has bokeh that I like very much.
To me the lens' rendering reminds me more of the ZM 35 f/1.4 than the original Otus 55, and although I liked both those lenses I don't consider that a bad thing. I did like the Otus 55 color correction, but I always appreciated the overall rendering of the ZM 35 f/1.4. That lens also occupied a pretty unique space for Zeiss ZM lenses. It came much later than most of the rest of the line and IMO was a more modern lens, and used a lot more special glass than most of the other ZM lenses. I think it might provide a taste of what Zeiss might do with a wide angle Otus ML. If so, I don't think that would be a bad thing at all.
I would welcome an Otus 35 ML that was a lot like the ZM 35 f/1.4. It likely would be a bit bigger, but I would love to see them keep it under 500g, but making the filter thread bigger (67mm would be great) if it reduces swirl in the bokeh would be fine with me. I would also like to see a bit better color correction than the ZM 35 f/1.4, but I don't think such a lens would be that much of a stretch. The ZM 35 f/1.4 is 383g and costs $2,300 new at B & H, so a slightly bigger, say 500g, Otus 35 ML with a bit better color correction that costs $2,500 new seems like it would be possible.
I too have the Voigtlander 50 f/2 APO--it is a wonderful lens--and I also have the Voigtlander 50 f/1.2. I do use f/1.4 and even f/1.2 on the Voigtlander for portraits, and especially so when I crop. With my A7r V even a 1.7X crop, which gives the perspective of an 85mm FF 35mm lens, leaves plenty of megapixels (18 to 20 depending on the aspect ratio). When I crop like that I like having the wider aperture.
The Sigma f/2 DG DN i series lens is an interesting and small option, but for me when I use AF I don't need small so much. When I travel I usually take manual focus lenses and when I use AF, I typically have just one lens or two so I worry less about weight. It is the rendering that draws me to the ZA 50 f/1.4 as I really like the images that lens produces. Surprisingly here in North America it is pretty cheap used. I got my copy for something like $450 US, and I believe I sold it to Nehemiah for even a bit less than that. So, here in North America, on the used market it is not an overly expensive lens. The Sigma i series would not doubt be a lot smaller, however....Show more →
Hi Steve,
I'm sorry for the late reply.
I didn't know you already have the CV 50 APO and the 50/1.2... I have noticed I often agree with you about the logic behind lens choices. In this case we have to disagree. Instead of buying further two 50mm lenses you can sell the 50/1.2 and buy the 50/1.4 GM instead. One fast and AF and one APO for your more thoughtful work striving for perfection.
Then add a decent 85mm lens for your portraits and short tele needs. You'll get AF, you can get another kind of images compared to now and your subjects will be happier.
Maybe too simple. I guess you have ruled out such a simple solution... but why?
Jonas B wrote:
.
you can sell the 50/1.2 and buy the 50/1.4 GM instead.
The idea that a Nokton 1.2 50 can be replaced with a GM 1.4 50 is a fallacy. For those who love the rendering of the 1.2 Nokton, a 1.4 GM is of no use at all. The 1.2 GM is already more picturesque than the comparatively hard 1.4, and yet it would never occur to me that it could replace the Nokton (I have both).
Nifty Fifty wrote:
The idea that a Nokton 1.2 50 can be replaced with a GM 1.4 50 is a fallacy. For those who love the rendering of the 1.2 Nokton, a 1.4 GM is of no use at all. The 1.2 GM is already more picturesque than the comparatively hard 1.4, and yet it would never occur to me that it could replace the Nokton (I have both).
That was an example of simplifying things. I agree with you. After having read my own words after posting I thought I would get a reply like this (but from Steve).
The point I failed to make is that having not two, not three but at least four (five even?) 50mm lenses is beyond what's practical and even comes with a risk of paralysis. Should I bring the 750 gram AF lens, or the 50/1.2 if i want to make a portrait, or the heavy and faster APO? maybe just bring the CV 50 APO but thinking again and bringing the Otus 50 for its long focus throw.
I'm not at all sure this makes for more keepers in the end comparing to have two good lenses, for example one manual optically sound APO and one good AF.
I also think shooting portraits is better done using a decent 85mm AF lens than a 50mm f1.2 or 1.4 and crop.
I have sold my Noktons and my 50/1.4 GM. I enjoy the Sigma 50/2 DG DN and the Sirui Aurora 85/1.4 (new to me, still learning it) more. This, of course, means we are looking at the situation from different angles.
I too have the Voigtlander 50 f/2 APO--it is a wonderful lens--and I also have the Voigtlander 50 f/1.2. I do use f/1.4 and even f/1.2 on the Voigtlander for portraits, and especially so when I crop. With my A7r V even a 1.7X crop, which gives the perspective of an 85mm FF 35mm lens, leaves plenty of megapixels (18 to 20 depending on the aspect ratio). When I crop like that I like having the wider aperture.
The Sigma f/2 DG DN i series lens is an interesting and small option, but for me when I use AF I don't need small so much. When I travel I usually take manual focus lenses and when I use AF, I typically have just one lens or two so I worry less about weight. It is the rendering that draws me to the ZA 50 f/1.4 as I really like the images that lens produces. Surprisingly here in North America it is pretty cheap used. I got my copy for something like $450 US, and I believe I sold it to Nehemiah for even a bit less than that. So, here in North America, on the used market it is not an overly expensive lens. The Sigma i series would not doubt be a lot smaller, however.Hi Steve,
I'm sorry for the late reply.
I didn't know you already have the CV 50 APO and the 50/1.2... I have noticed I often agree with you about the logic behind lens choices. In this case we have to disagree. Instead of buying further two 50mm lenses you can sell the 50/1.2 and buy the 50/1.4 GM instead. One fast and AF and one APO for your more thoughtful work striving for perfection.
Then add a decent 85mm lens for your portraits and short tele needs. You'll get AF, you can get another kind of images compared to now and your subjects will be happier.
Maybe too simple. I guess you have ruled out such a simple solution... but why?
Thanks for your input. Personally, I am not in love with the rendering of the 50 f/1.4 GM. I actually think that the Sony 35 f/1.4 GM, the 50 f/1.4 GM, and the 85 f/1.4 GM II are all very similar lenses. They are uber sharp, very compact, and they have excellent AF. I can see why people like them, but they are not my cup of tea. I actually don't want quite the level of wide open sharpness they produce, for portraits at least, and I don't need that level of AF--my camera only shoots 10 fps, so that they can shoot 120 fps just doesn't matter to me. My AF needs are almost always quite modest.
The really kicker, however, is that I don't really like the bokeh of any of these lenses.
Here is how currently use my 50mm lenses:
My two lens kit that I take when I might want to shoot, but I am not planning on any particular photography outing is my Voigtlander 21 f/1.4 and my 50 f/2 APO. This simple two lens kit covers a huge range if I am flexible with cropping and has a ton of capability. The 21 when cropped by 1.33 still has about 30 MP and makes a really nice 28mm f/1.8 alternative. Crop a bit more to a 1.67 crop and it still has 19 MP and it makes a quite decent 35mm f/2.5 alternative. It really is a great 3 in one lens and handles close ups really well. The 50 f/2 APO is pretty versatile too. A 1.17 crop gives you 39 MP and a very nice 58 f/2.4 alternative, a 1.5 crop gives you about 24 MP and a 75 f/3.0 alternative, and a 1.67 crop give you a usable 85 f/3.4 alternative, and the lens also handles close up really well. That is a great range with just two lenses. That said, part of what makes me excited about the Otus 50 f/1.4 ML is that in this two lens kit it provides virtually everything the 50 f/2 APO does, but I think I would find a 50 f/1.4, 58 f/1.6 alternative, 75 f/2.1 alternative and 85 f/2.4 alternative a lot more useful than the 50 f/2. 58 f/2.4, 75 f/3.0, and 85 f/3.4 capabilities the 50 f/2 APO provides. And in a two lens kit even though the Voigtlander 21 f/1.4 and the Otus 50 f/1.4 ML are not small lenses, the total kit is still acceptable to me coming in at less that 2,000 g/4.5 lbs. including the camera.
For more serious trips when I focus on photography, however, I want to crop less and take a different set of lenses and one of those sets of lenses is a four lens kit. In that four lens kit, I take an 18 f/2.8, a 28 f/1.5, the Voigtlander 50 f/1.2, and an 85 f/4. For this set of lenses, I want the 50mm to be both small (to keep the weight down on a kit with more lenses) and to be versatile. I want it to be capable for portraits and to be capable as a landscape and architecture lens when stopped down. Here is where I think the Voigtlander 50 f/1.2 excels and you can see that in Fred's current review. For E-mount you can get the SE version and it weighs just 383g, and it is a very nice portrait lens with nice bokeh, but stopped down to f/4 or narrower it is a quite nice landscape and architecture lens as well. It can't do close ups that well and it doesn't have the rendering that the Otus 50 ML or the sharp clean rendering of the Voigtlander 50 f/2 APO, but it is really versatile and it is reasonably small enough to make the 4 lens kit work.
Then there are other times that I focus on portraits. For those times my primary lens is the Sony 85 f/1.4 GM original version and I really like the rendering of that lens. It is my primary lens when I focus on portraits. That said, I might pick up the Sony/Zeiss 50 f/1.4 FE as another lens with a different look that I also like. You can get this lens pretty cheap these days so adding it for that type of shooting seems like it would be worth it to me.
Those are my thoughts for right now. Thanks for sharing yours.