Bokehddicted wrote:
Do we have any early indication about the remaining planned focal length?
21,25,35,50,85
or
21,28,50,85
Or any other pattern if derivable from other Zeiss family roll-out experience both in photo and/or movie habitats?
Makes a difference to me. Any insight? Speculation?
Nothing but speculation. If they follow the same pattern as the SLR Otuses, we'll get a 28 and 100 over the next few years. Or, if no one buys these two, they could be the end of the line. Who knows?
freaklikeme wrote: philip_pj wroteIt's a question of interpretation, isn't it? We have the difference between the truth of the matter, and the lived reality, as generally experienced and as understood. The seemingly innocuous but magical term has the ability to induce many to expect perfection in color correction, no matter the technical minutiae on the subject. And it becomes a binary proposition: APO or not APO, with no measurable nuance in the usage.
Ironically, the new ML 50mm is saddled with fringing which though not technically an issue (we hope it corrects well in post), it's worse than most late 20th century Zeiss lenses, and not what is expected in such a complex design in regular usage.If it's open to interpretation, then it is just marketing and managing your own expectations in spite of it. An apochromat is a thing with a definition. For example, I wouldn't call the CV APO-Lanthar 35 any less deserving of the APO label than the 50, even though it's prone to a great deal more spherocromatism, particularly in backlit shots. It's the same with the APO-Skopar 90 and the APO-Lanthar 90. One of them is a superior overall performer, but they both maintain the promise of APO.
Which late 20th century lenses are we talking about? The Contax fast fifties were CA machines and the Planar 50/1.4 design didn't do any better when Cosina dropped in the ZF/ZS housing. From what I've seen in the videos, the test chart shots make me wonder if they were focusing for the corners and not respecting the mild field curvature it looks like the Otus 50 has (and the Otus 55 also has). Yes, it has more fringing than the 55, and more distortion and looks to be a bit more prone to veiling flare and breathes a bit more, and I understand why those problems would be deal breakers for some on such a pricey lens, but I see it this way: There's nothing I've seen in the video overviews that makes me think the lens isn't very competitive with the fast fifty offerings from any other major brand, and that may be enough for me. It offers something they can't; a beautiful, fully manual shooting experience. They get to upcharge for addressing my niche market and I'm not going to complain about that because no one's rushing in with any better offers....Show more →
This is exactly how I feel about this lens. I would also add that by f/2 the color correction seems to get really good, perhaps not perfect but really good. That puts it ahead of many lenses but not all. For me it would be a lens that competes well with the Voigtlander 50 f/2 APO from f/2 and at narrower apertures, and it also opens up to f/1.4 with some limitations at f/1.4 that if you understand and know how to work around them will be useful in many situations.
Steve Spencer wrote:
This is exactly how I feel about this lens. I would also add that by f/2 the color correction seems to get really good, perhaps not perfect but really good. That puts it ahead of many lenses but not all. For me it would be a lens that competes well with the Voigtlander 50 f/2 APO from f/2 and at narrower apertures, and it also opens up to f/1.4 with some limitations at f/1.4 that if you understand and know how to work around them will be useful in many situations.
For me it is the exact opposite. Having seen several "reviews" and presentations of the Otus 50/1.4 my choice is to stay away. I was interested at first as i always have been a sucker for fast primes.
But really, when is f/1.4 so important or so superior that it is worth the extra money, weight and size over the Voigtländer 50/2.0 APO I already have and like?
Too seldom, almost never.
I'm also not at all sure the new Otus 50 will compete well with the CV50APO.
It's all preferences for the look they each impart, hopefully, rather than the infrequent appearance of intrusive color error. In general, people want an 'APO' for its near-perfect correction, and they want f1.4 lenses for wide open usage. Designers certainly design for these primo lens usage protocols.
Ergo, you have to like what an f1.4 delivers at that setting. To be facetious, it's a battle for the soul of photography right now. Will the hyper complex 'green screen background' Type 1 lenses prevail over the more worldly 'subjects embedded in the photo' Type 2 lenses.
At present, the high end offerings are the first kind, Otus and GM and the rather poor f1.2 lot from C/N. It will take some time to turn this ship around.
A lot of abstraction can be too much of it, for its own sake. A lot of people just want intimate photos of real life with smoothly retained image motifs, ahead of highly artificial blur patterns. It's in all I've seen so far. Below lniked is a good summary of the 50/1.4 ML is from Chris Frost.
I'm obviously more interested in steady linear connections between subject and background; as opposed to the two frames in one you get with Type 1 lenses. Why is it important? Because you have to really like your subject solely, to deprived it of the context in which you photograph it. It's reductive.
Looking for good examples of this bokeh style, I did stumble across Mr Frost pointing out that LoCA is not gone until f4 in the 50mm ML. He also has plenty of the disappearing backgrounds there.
Steve Spencer wrote: freaklikeme wrotephilip_pj wroteIt's a question of interpretation, isn't it? We have the difference between the truth of the matter, and the lived reality, as generally experienced and as understood. The seemingly innocuous but magical term has the ability to induce many to expect perfection in color correction, no matter the technical minutiae on the subject. And it becomes a binary proposition: APO or not APO, with no measurable nuance in the usage.
Ironically, the new ML 50mm is saddled with fringing which though not technically an issue (we hope it corrects well in post), it's worse than most late 20th century Zeiss lenses, and not what is expected in such a complex design in regular usage.If it's open to interpretation, then it is just marketing and managing your own expectations in spite of it. An apochromat is a thing with a definition. For example, I wouldn't call the CV APO-Lanthar 35 any less deserving of the APO label than the 50, even though it's prone to a great deal more spherocromatism, particularly in backlit shots. It's the same with the APO-Skopar 90 and the APO-Lanthar 90. One of them is a superior overall performer, but they both maintain the promise of APO.
Which late 20th century lenses are we talking about? The Contax fast fifties were CA machines and the Planar 50/1.4 design didn't do any better when Cosina dropped in the ZF/ZS housing. From what I've seen in the videos, the test chart shots make me wonder if they were focusing for the corners and not respecting the mild field curvature it looks like the Otus 50 has (and the Otus 55 also has). Yes, it has more fringing than the 55, and more distortion and looks to be a bit more prone to veiling flare and breathes a bit more, and I understand why those problems would be deal breakers for some on such a pricey lens, but I see it this way: There's nothing I've seen in the video overviews that makes me think the lens isn't very competitive with the fast fifty offerings from any other major brand, and that may be enough for me. It offers something they can't; a beautiful, fully manual shooting experience. They get to upcharge for addressing my niche market and I'm not going to complain about that because no one's rushing in with any better offers.This is exactly how I feel about this lens. I would also add that by f/2 the color correction seems to get really good, perhaps not perfect but really good. That puts it ahead of many lenses but not all. For me it would be a lens that competes well with the Voigtlander 50 f/2 APO from f/2 and at narrower apertures, and it also opens up to f/1.4 with some limitations at f/1.4 that if you understand and know how to work around them will be useful in many situations.
My hope is that it shares the Otus 55's slow focus roll off at mid distances, where, if you look closely, you can tell you're losing focus, but at normal viewing distances on prints up to 16x20, all you see is a light loss of detail, making it look like it's got more depth than it should for an f/1.4. That makes a big difference when you're going for full body and group shots in failing or low light. What I feel positive about is that it will give the 55's consistency of performance regardless of focus distance with a few small compromises that look easy to overcome in post in a much more travel-friendly package, and I do find that idea very attractive.
I'm glad someone else sees the potential in the lens.
I am so eager to get mine. The series certainly seems custom build to my taste.
Doubts:
- Does it have the aperture jitter zoomed focus bug of the Loxias on modern bodies?
- Is the CA and especially LoCA a problem in my practical shooting?
- Is the slightest bokeh ball outline gone by 1.6 or 1.8 already? (like the Loxia 35mm Biogon 2/35 where it is much better at 2.2 already, gone by 2.5)
Interesting to see how it holds up to my:
- Sony 50gm 1.4
- Sony 50gm 1.2
- Loxia 50
- Sony 2470 GM2 @50
- Batis 40 cropped
Bokehddicted wrote:
I am so eager to get mine. The series certainly seems custom build to my taste.
Doubts:
- Does it have the aperture jitter zoomed focus bug of the Loxias on modern bodies?
- Is the CA and especially LoCA a problem in my practical shooting?
- Is the slightest bokeh ball outline gone by 1.6 or 1.8 already? (like the Loxia 35mm Biogon 2/35 where it is much better at 2.2 already, gone by 2.5)
Interesting to see how it holds up to my:
- Sony 50gm 1.4
- Sony 50gm 1.2
- Loxia 50
- Sony 2470 GM2 @50
- Batis 40 cropped
I would be utterly shocked if it had that nervous aperture problem. I mean they had to have some photographers shoot it before release.
The Issue with the Loxias came with later cameras.
B&H have the Sony E-mount version of the ML 50/1.4 in stock; Nikon Z and Canon RF versions are 'coming soon'.
Probably not a concern, but the little (lens top) window for DOF hides the long throw and has no f2.8 index mark; and I hope there are seals inside the windows (aperture seems to have one too). 680 grams.
B&H's intro video makes a point of the lens being capable of cine usage, with an example of this included.
I love the promotion material. "Compact design for easy portability" for example. The B&H staff also try to help by answering questions and by then claiming "The ZEISS Otus ML 50mm f/1.4 Lens has the highest optical quality, the least chromatic aberration and the least distortion of any 50mm lens currently."
More seriously: As Zeiss can provide geared rings for the cinema people - does that mean they will release at least three or four more Otus lenses?
Photographers are addicts. Loads flock to the newest lens like dung beetles! It likely isn’t worth the high cost in comparison to the 50/2 you already have. Negligible difference I’d guess (aside from weight & cost)
Addiction is great for business! That’s why there are soooo many third party lenses of focal lengths everybody already has!
Jonas B wrote: Steve Spencer wroteThis is exactly how I feel about this lens. I would also add that by f/2 the color correction seems to get really good, perhaps not perfect but really good. That puts it ahead of many lenses but not all. For me it would be a lens that competes well with the Voigtlander 50 f/2 APO from f/2 and at narrower apertures, and it also opens up to f/1.4 with some limitations at f/1.4 that if you understand and know how to work around them will be useful in many situations.For me it is the exact opposite. Having seen several "reviews" and presentations of the Otus 50/1.4 my choice is to stay away. I was interested at first as i always have been a sucker for fast primes.
But really, when is f/1.4 so important or so superior that it is worth the extra money, weight and size over the Voigtländer 50/2.0 APO I already have and like?
Too seldom, almost never.
I'm also not at all sure the new Otus 50 will compete well with the CV50APO.
KarmaKramer wrote:
Photographers are addicts. Loads flock to the newest lens like dung beetles! It likely isn’t worth the high cost in comparison to the 50/2 you already have. Negligible difference I’d guess (aside from weight & cost)
Addiction is great for business! That’s why there are soooo many third party lenses of focal lengths everybody already has!
Trust me, I'm not in the market for any Otus lens. Somewhere earlier in this thread I wrote But really, when is f/1.4 so important or so superior that it is worth the extra money, weight and size over the Voigtländer 50/2.0 APO I already have and like?
Too seldom, almost never.
I'm also not at all sure the new Otus 50 will compete well with the CV50APO.
I have very split feelings about Zeiss these days. I really liked my old Zeiss C/Y mount 35/1.4. But, with today's market I don't see Zeiss as competitive at all. it's fun (and sad at the same time) seeing the hype from all directions. The staff at B&H as I mentioned above for example.
An f/1.4 and an f/2 lens is not the same thing but there is no way I would exchange my Voigtländer 50 APO to an Otus 50ML.
Jonas B wrote:
I love the promotion material. "Compact design for easy portability" for example. The B&H staff also try to help by answering questions and by then claiming "The ZEISS Otus ML 50mm f/1.4 Lens has the highest optical quality, the least chromatic aberration and the least distortion of any 50mm lens currently."
More seriously: As Zeiss can provide geared rings for the cinema people - does that mean they will release at least three or four more Otus lenses?
Well, it is compact... when compared to the original Otus and Milvus lenses.
While I think every lens is marketed with the idea of hybrid use, I'd be surprised if we saw a line as complete as the Nanos in the Otus MLs. I wouldn't hold my breath for it, anyway, but who knows?
freaklikeme wrote:
[...]
While I think every lens is marketed with the idea of hybrid use, I'd be surprised if we saw a line as complete as the Nanos in the Otus MLs. I wouldn't hold my breath for it, anyway, but who knows?
I would be very surprised and I'm afraid we'll see an Otus failure coming. With the CA demonstrated in the influencer's marketing material I don't think the lens will be a success at all.
Jonas B wrote: freaklikeme wrote[...]
While I think every lens is marketed with the idea of hybrid use, I'd be surprised if we saw a line as complete as the Nanos in the Otus MLs. I wouldn't hold my breath for it, anyway, but who knows?I would be very surprised and I'm afraid we'll see an Otus failure coming. With the CA demonstrated in the influencer's marketing material I don't think the lens will be a success at all.
I doubt it'll fail. I don't think it was ever destined to be a "fly off the shelves" item, but it will find an audience. The branding, focal length, speed, and positive performance metrics along with the build quality and long focus throw makes it an attractive proposition. We'll see the 85 and likely a 28, but it wouldn't surprise me if it ends there.
It WOULD NOT surpise you if it ends there? Or it WOULD surprise you..
I think it will very likely be a 5-6 lens set
freaklikeme wrote: Jonas B wrotefreaklikeme wrote[...]
While I think every lens is marketed with the idea of hybrid use, I'd be surprised if we saw a line as complete as the Nanos in the Otus MLs. I wouldn't hold my breath for it, anyway, but who knows?I would be very surprised and I'm afraid we'll see an Otus failure coming. With the CA demonstrated in the influencer's marketing material I don't think the lens will be a success at all.I doubt it'll fail. I don't think it was ever destined to be a "fly off the shelves" item, but it will find an audience. The branding, focal length, speed, and positive performance metrics along with the build quality and long focus throw makes it an attractive proposition. We'll see the 85 and likely a 28, but it wouldn't surprise me if it ends there.
Bokehddicted wrote:
It WOULD NOT surpise you if it ends there? Or it WOULD surprise you..
I think it will very likely be a 5-6 lens set
freaklikeme wroteJonas B wrotefreaklikeme wrote[...]
While I think every lens is marketed with the idea of hybrid use, I'd be surprised if we saw a line as complete as the Nanos in the Otus MLs. I wouldn't hold my breath for it, anyway, but who knows?I would be very surprised and I'm afraid we'll see an Otus failure coming. With the CA demonstrated in the influencer's marketing material I don't think the lens will be a success at all.I doubt it'll fail. I don't think it was ever destined to be a "fly off the shelves" item, but it will find an audience. The branding, focal length, speed, and positive performance metrics along with the build quality and long focus throw makes it an attractive proposition. We'll see the 85 and likely a 28, but it wouldn't surprise me if it ends there.
Would not, but I'm no oracle and not in on their go-forward strategy. It may well be a set like that.
Interesting. Is there precedence in the photo or cine business for such a limited range (28,50,85) from Zeiss or similar vendor?
I personally wouldnt complain. I would keep my loved Lox85 and combine it with the ML50 and ML28.
If the ML28mm 1.4 would have as much depth (3D pop) as the incredibly tempting Thypoch 28mm, i would be in heaven. Likely my dream manual kit!
freaklikeme wrote: Bokehddicted wroteIt WOULD NOT surpise you if it ends there? Or it WOULD surprise you..
I think it will very likely be a 5-6 lens set
freaklikeme wroteJonas B wrotefreaklikeme wrote[...]
While I think every lens is marketed with the idea of hybrid use, I'd be surprised if we saw a line as complete as the Nanos in the Otus MLs. I wouldn't hold my breath for it, anyway, but who knows?I would be very surprised and I'm afraid we'll see an Otus failure coming. With the CA demonstrated in the influencer's marketing material I don't think the lens will be a success at all.I doubt it'll fail. I don't think it was ever destined to be a "fly off the shelves" item, but it will find an audience. The branding, focal length, speed, and positive performance metrics along with the build quality and long focus throw makes it an attractive proposition. We'll see the 85 and likely a 28, but it wouldn't surprise me if it ends there.Would not, but I'm no oracle and not in on their go-forward strategy. It may well be a set like that.
Jonas B wrote: freaklikeme wrote[...]and positive performance metrics along with the build quality and long focus throw makes it an attractive proposition.It's clear we think differently about the 50ML. That aside, what are the "positive performance metrics" you have noted?
My expectations as set by the influencers is a for a lighter, better overall corrected Zony FE 50/1.4 with higher resolution central and mid-frame because it reduces the FC and pushes it out of the mid-frame and into the corners, and significantly better mid-to-close resolution because of more consistent SA correction throughout the range. Rather than speculate based on info from people I wouldn't trust with a manual lens anyway, I'll let you know next week after I've had some time with the lens. Nothing better than practical experience, after all.
This entire thread reminds me of a couple lines from Bastian's review of the APO-Lanthar 35 that turned me from a curiosity lurker into a real fan of his work on PR.
"Expectations are a strange thing, aren’t they? If something does not meet our (maybe too high) expectations we are easily disappointed, no matter how good the product actually is." https://phillipreeve.net/blog/voigtlander-35mm-2-0-e-review/