Steve Spencer wrote: Chris_88 wroteThanks, but no thanks.
Assuming the rumors are correct, these new Oti weigh 677g and 1040g, respectively. The Otus 55 and 85 weigh 1kg and 1.2kg, so they have managed to shave off some weight.
However, despite the AF motors, even the corresponding GMs weigh less, clocking in at 520g and 640g, respectively. If you compare apples to apples (kinda) and look at Cosina's MF lenses, the comparison gets even more striking: Even the heaviest 50mm lens in Cosina's e-mount line-up, the faster 50 1.0 at 590g weighs less, the 50 1.2 weighs 434g, and the APO Lanthar 364g.
Sure, the faster two lenses aren't APO and the Lanthar is "only" f2, but are you willing to add 50% in weight and probably 50-100% in cost for that APO performance at f1.4? I wouldn't, but that's just me.APO correction at f/1.4 is a lot harder than APO correction at f/2. As aperture widens the difficulty of making a lens well corrected increases exponentially. Said more mathematically, it isn't twice as hard to make a lens APO when you widen the lens from f/2 to f/1.4, I believe it is something like eight or nine times as hard. There is a reason there are very few APO lens with an aperture as wide as f/1.4. That said, you may or may not care whether a lens is APO at f/1.4 or any aperture. We all have to weigh what matters to us personally.
There is more these new mirrorless Otus lenses can bring to the table besides just being APO and f/1.4, however. What will the bokeh be like is one important and interesting question. Almost all APO lenses have had at best pretty average bokeh. Nothing to write home about with transition zones that can be pretty harsh, football shaped out of focus highlights that extend pretty far into the frame, and sometimes (like in the original Otus lenses) onion rings in the out of focus highlights. For me one big advantage of APO lenses is the elimination or near elimination of CA in the bokeh, but that isn't very useful in my view if the bokeh cleans up that problem but leaves other problems that are at least as distracting. Will these lenses clean up CA in the bokeh, onion rings in the bokeh, have smooth transition zones, and have round OOF highlights even towards the edges and corners? That is a lot to ask and they probably won't do all of that, but how much? Until I know I can't say how much they would be worth to me.
Lenses are always going to have compromises and each of us has to decide what compromises matter most to us. For me personally, I want one set of lenses that is small for travel, but I am willing to have a second set of lenses that brings other things to the table and isn't small. Right now my second set of lenses has autofocus and nice rendering and aren't small, but I would consider giving up AF for these lenses if I like the way they render better than my current larger lenses (these are much the same size). Most won't consider these lenses because they don't want to give up AF and that is fine. Others won't want these lenses because they prefer smaller lenses and that is fine. Others, however, like me will consider giving up those two things if the lenses perform well enough in other ways. For me that will require a rendering that I really like and we obviously don't know yet anything about that.
If the rumors are true, what we know is these lenses have a wide aperture, they will have very low CA, they will be significantly cheaper than the original Otus lenses and about the price of other premium lenses like the Sony 50 f/1.2 GM, the Sony 85 f/1.4 GM II, the Nikon 50 f/1.2S, the Nikon 85 f/1.2S, the Canon RF 50 f/1.2L and the Canon RF 85 f/1.2L. They will also be lighter than the original Otus lenses and lighter than some of these lenses, but heavier than others. Depending on what matters to you it could make total sense not to consider these lenses, or--as I will--to consider them carefully, but we are still missing a lot of important information that we will only get once the lenses are available and we see the images they make....Show more →
Steve, don't get me wrong, I respect your opinion and as mentioned in my post above, "I wouldn't buy them, but that's just me". I get the difficulty of getting an APO design right at f1.4, while offering a pleasant OOF rendering, etc. Apart from me having little interest in fast 50 and 85mm primes with or without AF and caring less about OOF rendering than most people here on FM, the penalty in weight and most likely price tag over lenses from Sony, Sigma or Cosina is just not worth it for me.
Steve Spencer wrote:
APO correction at f/1.4 is a lot harder than APO correction at f/2. As aperture widens the difficulty of making a lens well corrected increases exponentially. Said more mathematically, it isn't twice as hard to make a lens APO when you widen the lens from f/2 to f/1.4, I believe it is something like eight or nine times as hard. There is a reason there are very few APO lens with an aperture as wide as f/1.4. That said, you may or may not care whether a lens is APO at f/1.4 or any aperture. We all have to weigh what matters to us personally. ...Show more →
For modern lenses, APO is nothing but a marketing term. We will have to see how much chromatic aberration Otus ML lenses have. Lenses like 50 F1.2 GM or 135 F1.8 GM are one of the best corrected lenses in terms of longitudinal CA out there, but they don't carry the APO title in their names.
For example, here is a zemax simulation based on 50 F1.2 GM's patent, showing it has < 40 nm LoCA:
moyang_mm wrote: Steve Spencer wroteAPO correction at f/1.4 is a lot harder than APO correction at f/2. As aperture widens the difficulty of making a lens well corrected increases exponentially. Said more mathematically, it isn't twice as hard to make a lens APO when you widen the lens from f/2 to f/1.4, I believe it is something like eight or nine times as hard. There is a reason there are very few APO lens with an aperture as wide as f/1.4. That said, you may or may not care whether a lens is APO at f/1.4 or any aperture. We all have to weigh what matters to us personally.For modern lenses, APO is nothing but a marketing term. We will have to see how much chromatic aberration Otus ML lenses have. Lenses like 50 F1.2 GM or 135 F1.8 GM are one of the best corrected lenses in terms of longitudinal CA out there, but they don't carry the APO title in their names.
For example, here is a zemax simulation based on 50 F1.2 GM's patent, showing it has < 40 nm LoCA:
You wrote: "For modern lenses, APO is nothing but a marketing term."
I know first-hand modern Leica APO technology has resulted in some of the finest full frame SL APO primes overall, ever made. I think the same can be said about the Leica Summilux-M 35/APO( but I don't own that lens) I will however agree and have experienced APO applied by various manufacturers does not always result in equal results under similar conditions.
Just this morning with APO top of mind thanks to the new Zess Otus ML lenses, I did a quick retest of the Sony GM 50 f1,2 with a bit of chrome. As I remembered, this Sony GM lens does indeed perform very well in this regard even though Sony did not label this as an APO lens.
'For modern lenses, APO is nothing but a marketing term.'
The use of the term is to invite all manner of tests pointing out color errors. It's a huge area of concern in the cine world where people just hate LoCA with a passion, given some of their lenses costs over $20,000 and it is so hard to eradicate in post.
Given that you cannot ever entirely remove it, I kind of wish for a 'near-APO' label so we can get back to looking at what really matters in lens expression - great imagery.
LBJ2 wrote:
I will however agree and have experienced APO applied by various manufacturers does not always result in equal results under similar conditions.
Exactly. APO as in Sigma 70-300mm F4-5.6 APO DG Macro is quite different from APO in Leica's APO-Summicron
Based on Zeiss and Cosina's track record, I am quite confident that Otus ML 1.4/50 will be a very well corrected lens. However, given how good both versions of 50GM are, I doubt the new Otus ML will be competitive.
moyang_mm wrote: LBJ2 wroteI will however agree and have experienced APO applied by various manufacturers does not always result in equal results under similar conditions.Exactly. APO as in Sigma 70-300mm F4-5.6 APO DG Macro is quite different from APO in Leica's APO-Summicron
Based on Zeiss and Cosina's track record, I am quite confident that Otus ML 1.4/50 will be a very well corrected lens. However, given how good both versions of 50GM are, I doubt the new Otus ML will be competitive.
Check out the brief comparison video a few comments up. Otus ML 50 vs GM 50 1,2. BTW, Sony GM 35 appears to be a secret achromatic too. Now I need to test the GM 24!
LBJ2 wrote:
Check out the brief comparison video a few comments up. Otus ML 50 vs GM 50 1,2. BTW, Sony GM 35 appears to be a secret achromatic too. Now I need to test the GM 24!
I own 20G, 24GM, 35GM, and 50 F1.2GM. In terms of CA correction, 24GM is the weakest among them in my opinion. Look forward to your test results.
LBJ2 wrote: moyang_mm wroteLBJ2 wroteI will however agree and have experienced APO applied by various manufacturers does not always result in equal results under similar conditions.Exactly. APO as in Sigma 70-300mm F4-5.6 APO DG Macro is quite different from APO in Leica's APO-Summicron
Based on Zeiss and Cosina's track record, I am quite confident that Otus ML 1.4/50 will be a very well corrected lens. However, given how good both versions of 50GM are, I doubt the new Otus ML will be competitive.Check out the brief comparison video a few comments up. Otus ML 50 vs GM 50 1,2. BTW, Sony GM 35 appears to be a secret achromatic too. Now I need to test the GM 24!
Just to clarify, I believe he compares the Zeiss to the Sony 50/1.4 GM, not the 50/1.2 GM.
mudlake wrote: LBJ2 wrotemoyang_mm wroteLBJ2 wroteI will however agree and have experienced APO applied by various manufacturers does not always result in equal results under similar conditions.Exactly. APO as in Sigma 70-300mm F4-5.6 APO DG Macro is quite different from APO in Leica's APO-Summicron
Based on Zeiss and Cosina's track record, I am quite confident that Otus ML 1.4/50 will be a very well corrected lens. However, given how good both versions of 50GM are, I doubt the new Otus ML will be competitive.Check out the brief comparison video a few comments up. Otus ML 50 vs GM 50 1,2. BTW, Sony GM 35 appears to be a secret achromatic too. Now I need to test the GM 24!Just to clarify, I believe he compares the Zeiss to the Sony 50/1.4 GM, not the 50/1.2 GM.
mudlake wrote: LBJ2 wrotemoyang_mm wroteLBJ2 wroteI will however agree and have experienced APO applied by various manufacturers does not always result in equal results under similar conditions.Exactly. APO as in Sigma 70-300mm F4-5.6 APO DG Macro is quite different from APO in Leica's APO-Summicron
Based on Zeiss and Cosina's track record, I am quite confident that Otus ML 1.4/50 will be a very well corrected lens. However, given how good both versions of 50GM are, I doubt the new Otus ML will be competitive.Check out the brief comparison video a few comments up. Otus ML 50 vs GM 50 1,2. BTW, Sony GM 35 appears to be a secret achromatic too. Now I need to test the GM 24!Just to clarify, I believe he compares the Zeiss to the Sony 50/1.4 GM, not the 50/1.2 GM.
Correct. Too bad there's no comparison to Sony's 50/1.2 GM.
I found that comparison to Sony's 50/1.4 GM to be very uncompelling. Seems like a very fine Cosina lens, but the Zeiss badge doubles the price, and the lack of autofocus makes it much less useful than any Sony 50mm GM.
philip_pj wrote:
'For modern lenses, APO is nothing but a marketing term.'
The use of the term is to invite all manner of tests pointing out color errors. It's a huge area of concern in the cine world where people just hate LoCA with a passion, given some of their lenses costs over $20,000 and it is so hard to eradicate in post.
Given that you cannot ever entirely remove it, I kind of wish for a 'near-APO' label so we can get back to looking at what really matters in lens expression - great imagery.
I don't think the problem is in the label itself. All APO is intended to mean is the lens can focus our three colors on the same plane of focus. The use of the label rose to prominence in the mass market as a way to differentiate older teles and super-teles that were plagued with transverse CA, the color spread that occurs in the plane of focus on high-contrast objects that gets worse the further you move away from the center and the more you stop down, and the newer models that were free of the issue. The label itself isn't an indication of correction outside the focus plane, so even those wonders and our new ones are still prone to spherochromatism and PF outside of the focus plane. Fortunately, you can stop down and make those problems go away.
I think everyone needs to remember that mirror lenses are also APO. They're low contrast and prone to other issues, but the label still applies. APO is one measure of quality, not a blessing from the gods of optics.
I love the look of the design and am anxious to get my hands on it. For me, 50 is probably not the right focal length for such a big spend on a fast lens. I'll rent it when it's available, because I'm always open to Zeiss changing my mind about it, but I suspect I'll have a good week with it and then let it go.
I'm much more excited about the 85. A solid manual all-arounder with that finish at that focal length is very attractive to me.
It's a question of interpretation, isn't it? We have the difference between the truth of the matter, and the lived reality, as generally experienced and as understood. The seemingly innocuous but magical term has the ability to induce many to expect perfection in color correction, no matter the technical minutiae on the subject. And it becomes a binary proposition: APO or not APO, with no measurable nuance in the usage.
Ironically, the new ML 50mm is saddled with fringing which though not technically an issue (we hope it corrects well in post), it's worse than most late 20th century Zeiss lenses, and not what is expected in such a complex design in regular usage.
philip_pj wrote:
It's a question of interpretation, isn't it? We have the difference between the truth of the matter, and the lived reality, as generally experienced and as understood. The seemingly innocuous but magical term has the ability to induce many to expect perfection in color correction, no matter the technical minutiae on the subject. And it becomes a binary proposition: APO or not APO, with no measurable nuance in the usage.
Ironically, the new ML 50mm is saddled with fringing which though not technically an issue (we hope it corrects well in post), it's worse than most late 20th century Zeiss lenses, and not what is expected in such a complex design in regular usage....Show more →
If it's open to interpretation, then it is just marketing and managing your own expectations in spite of it. An apochromat is a thing with a definition. For example, I wouldn't call the CV APO-Lanthar 35 any less deserving of the APO label than the 50, even though it's prone to a great deal more spherocromatism, particularly in backlit shots. It's the same with the APO-Skopar 90 and the APO-Lanthar 90. One of them is a superior overall performer, but they both maintain the promise of APO.
Which late 20th century lenses are we talking about? The Contax fast fifties were CA machines and the Planar 50/1.4 design didn't do any better when Cosina dropped in the ZF/ZS housing. From what I've seen in the videos, the test chart shots make me wonder if they were focusing for the corners and not respecting the mild field curvature it looks like the Otus 50 has (and the Otus 55 also has). Yes, it has more fringing than the 55, and more distortion and looks to be a bit more prone to veiling flare and breathes a bit more, and I understand why those problems would be deal breakers for some on such a pricey lens, but I see it this way: There's nothing I've seen in the video overviews that makes me think the lens isn't very competitive with the fast fifty offerings from any other major brand, and that may be enough for me. It offers something they can't; a beautiful, fully manual shooting experience. They get to upcharge for addressing my niche market and I'm not going to complain about that because no one's rushing in with any better offers.