The VM 28/1.5 is one of my most used lenses, but the weak portions outside of the central frame from f1.5 - f2 until longer distances is the one thing that is limiting.
p.10 #2Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Since we're all talking about preferences here, there should be no insinuation thats someone is wrong. Maybe it's just that I'm getting older, but I swear it seems like more and more people present preference differences in the form of rightness/wrongness.
Personally, I would find the gap between 20/21 and 50 too large.....personally. Would I care if someone else doesn't share that thought? No. Would I think they are wrong? No.
I happen to love 28mm. It gives that hint of wide that allows you to often put some foreground interest in a shot....but doesn't require it. Often with a 20/21 I'm thinking of including foreground interest. With a 50, there's more compression and it has a much different perspective than a 28. There is a huge perspective difference between 20 and 50, and 28 to me is a good middle ground between the 2.
Is any of what I said "right" or "wrong" above? Maybe. Do I care? No. It's my preference.
So be happy with your preferences, and give insight as to why you have that preference. But try to respect other peoples preferences. Life is too short to get hung up on stuff like this. If you find what works for you and you are happy, be happy that someone else finds that happiness...even if they chose a different path.
And that last post Makten is really is a good way to explain your thoughts as to the reasoning why you might think differently.
Anyway....don't beat me up too much for my post. I'm super sensitive lately, hence my reduced number of posts here. And I'm not trying to beat anyone else up with this post either. It's more just to try to allow discussion where people talk about their preferences and the reasons why, and not be made to feel wrong about them.
p.10 #3Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
tsdevine wrote:
Since we're all talking about preferences here, there should be no insinuation thats someone is wrong. Maybe it's just that I'm getting older, but I swear it seems like more and more people present preference differences in the form of rightness/wrongness.
Personally, I would find the gap between 20/21 and 50 too large.....personally. Would I care if someone else doesn't share that thought? No. Would I think they are wrong? No.
I happen to love 28mm. It gives that hint of wide that allows you to often put some foreground interest in a shot....but doesn't require it. Often with a 20/21 I'm thinking of including foreground interest. With a 50, there's more compression and it has a much different perspective than a 28. There is a huge perspective difference between 20 and 50, and 28 to me is a good middle ground between the 2.
Is any of what I said "right" or "wrong" above? Maybe. Do I care? No. It's my preference.
So be happy with your preferences, and give insight as to why you have that preference. But try to respect other peoples preferences. Life is too short to get hung up on stuff like this. If you find what works for you and you are happy, be happy that someone else finds that happiness...even if they chose a different path.
And that last post Makten is really is a good way to explain your thoughts as to the reasoning why you might think differently.
Anyway....don't beat me up too much for my post. I'm super sensitive lately, hence my reduced number of posts here. And I'm not trying to beat anyone else up with this post either. It's more just to try to allow discussion where people talk about their preferences and the reasons why, and not be made to feel wrong about them. ...Show more →
Tim thank you for your very thoughtful post. You capture what I was trying to say better than I did. And darbo, I am not questioning your choices and I tried to make that clear, but I may have failed miserably at that. I am sorry if I came off as condescending or critical. I don't want to be doing that. I was just describing how I think about these things and offered my perspective hoping it was helpful as looking at this from multiple perspectives I find helpful.
And Tim do continue to post here as I always appreciate your contribution.
p.10 #5Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
For those who have the lens, does it really look like this as per BHphoto website? It’s not as compact as the design we have seen from COSINA and camera quest.
I have pre-ordered before bhphoto uploaded their visual and hopefully it won’t be this huge haha!
p.10 #6Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
G3RALD wrote:
For those who have the lens, does it really look like this as per BHphoto website? It’s not as compact as the design we have seen from COSINA and camera quest.
p.10 #7Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Juha Kannisto wrote: G3RALD wroteFor those who have the lens, does it really look like this as per BHphoto website? It’s not as compact as the design we have seen from COSINA and camera quest.
Thank you Juha, that’s reassuring to know as I am not familiar which other f1.5 lenses COSINA has.
The website image almost caused to be rage cancel, glad I asked people who are in the know first
p.10 #8Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
My 28 is in transit and may be delivered today, but more likely tomorrow. I live in Italy and buy from the Italian distributor Fotoimpot.
After putting in a lot of thought around building a manual prime kit (I prefer manual lenses over AF because they help to slow me down), I will have 21 (coming next week), 28 and 50.
p.10 #9Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
tsdevine wrote:
With a 50, there's more compression and it has a much different perspective than a 28. There is a huge perspective difference between 20 and 50, and 28 to me is a good middle ground between the 2.
Tim,
I agree with your reasoning however we should speak about field of view instead of "perspective".
Actually, a lens does not offer a perspective. The perspective is solely determined by the viewpoint taken by the photographer, not by the lens choice. More strictly, the viewpoint corresponds to the center of the lens entrance pupil. If this viewpoint is kept constant, the lens focal length has no influence whatsoever on the perspective. If we take a picture with a 28 mm and then crop it to get the same field of view as with a 50 mm lens, we get the same image we would have taken with a 50 mm lens, the number of pixels being the only difference. Of course, the photographer may deliberately look for a dramatic wideangle effect by choosing a close viewpoint to exaggerate the size of foreground details. Still this effect is due to the deliberate close viewpoint.
p.10 #12Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Ripolini wrote: tsdevine wroteWith a 50, there's more compression and it has a much different perspective than a 28. There is a huge perspective difference between 20 and 50, and 28 to me is a good middle ground between the 2.Tim,
I agree with your reasoning however we should speak about field of view instead of "perspective".
Actually, a lens does not offer a perspective. The perspective is solely determined by the viewpoint taken by the photographer, not by the lens choice. More strictly, the viewpoint corresponds to the center of the lens entrance pupil. If this viewpoint is kept constant, the lens focal length has no influence whatsoever on the perspective. If we take a picture with a 28 mm and then crop it to get the same field of view as with a 50 mm lens, we get the same image we would have taken with a 50 mm lens, the number of pixels being the only difference. Of course, the photographer may deliberately look for a dramatic wideangle effect by choosing a close viewpoint to exaggerate the size of foreground details. Still this effect is due to the deliberate close viewpoint.
I guess I should have qualified my statement in much, much greater detail, although that wasn't really the focus of my post. If you are framing a scene to include certain elements, choosing different focal lengths to include the same elements will generally require you to move. Like if I want to take a picture of a waterfall with a cascade in front. To frame similarly with a 20mm, I'll be closer in order to fill the frame, than I would be with a 28mm. Same with 28mm vs 50mm. I will move to form that composition. When I do that, the perspective between the foreground cascade and the waterfall behind it changes. I mean you quoted one line in my post...ignoring how I was talking about 20mm can accentuate foreground elements, 28mm can but doesn't require it, and 50 you end up with more compression. I'm talking about composing a shot with 3 different lenses, and describing the perspective change. In that, I'm inherently moving to try to include the same elements in the shot.
I generally choose a focal length that best provides the composition and perspective I'm looking for. If you are just blindly changing lenses, oblivious to any thought as to what you are actually trying to capture, without moving.....yes, perspective won't change. I just don't shoot that way. So when shooting a scene, I am generally choosing a focal length that gives me the composition and perspective I'm looking for. It's also why "zoom with your feet" doesn't work for me. I generally am putting some thought into composition, and perspective is part of that. It also drives the focal length I choose.
I guess I wasn't detailed enough in my writing to fully provide the descriptive depth in order to not be called out as incorrect. And I'm paranoid now that the above will be nitpicked. When I say composition and perspective. Maybe what I'm trying to say field of view (what I want in the frame) and perspective (how those elements are placed in space).
Sorry if there is a tone in my reply, it's more just the frustration with the reality that anything I say will be parsed for flaws. Even if they are by omission.
I guess it's back to regretting my posting. I will train myself over time to not post......but every once in a while, I have a relapse.
p.10 #13Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
tsdevine wrote: Ripolini wrotetsdevine wroteWith a 50, there's more compression and it has a much different perspective than a 28. There is a huge perspective difference between 20 and 50, and 28 to me is a good middle ground between the 2.Tim,
I agree with your reasoning however we should speak about field of view instead of "perspective".
Actually, a lens does not offer a perspective. The perspective is solely determined by the viewpoint taken by the photographer, not by the lens choice. More strictly, the viewpoint corresponds to the center of the lens entrance pupil. If this viewpoint is kept constant, the lens focal length has no influence whatsoever on the perspective. If we take a picture with a 28 mm and then crop it to get the same field of view as with a 50 mm lens, we get the same image we would have taken with a 50 mm lens, the number of pixels being the only difference. Of course, the photographer may deliberately look for a dramatic wideangle effect by choosing a close viewpoint to exaggerate the size of foreground details. Still this effect is due to the deliberate close viewpoint.
Cheers,
RiccardoI guess I should have qualified my statement in much, much greater detail, although that wasn't really the focus of my post. If you are framing a scene to include certain elements. Choosing different focal lengths to include the same elements will often require you to move. Like if I want to take a picture of a waterfall with a cascade in front. To frame similarly with a 20mm, I'll be closer in order to fill the frame, than I would be with a 28mm. Same with 28mm vs 50mm. I will move to form that composition. When I do that, the perspective between the foreground cascade and the waterfall behind it changes. I mean you quoted one line in my post...ignoring how I was talking about 20mm can accentuate foreground elements, 28mm can but doesn't require it, and 50 you end up with more compression. I'm talking about composing a shot with 3 different lenses, and describing the perspective change. In that, I'm inherently moving to try to include the same elements in the shot.
I generally choose a focal length that best provides the composition and perspective I'm looking for. If you are just blindly changing lenses, oblivious to any thought as to what you are actually trying to capture, without moving.....yes, perspective won't change. I just don't shoot that way. So when shooting a scene, I am generally choosing a focal length that gives me the composition and perspective I'm looking for. It's also why "zoom with your feet" doesn't work for me. I generally am putting some thought into composition, and perspective is part of that. It also drives the focal length I choose.
I guess I wasn't detailed enough in my writing to fully provide the detail in order to not be called out as incorrect.
Sorry if there is a tone in my reply, it's more just the frustration with the reality that anything I say will be parsed for flaws. Even if they are by omission.
I guess it's back to regretting my posting. I will train myself over time to not post......but every once in a while, I have a relapse....Show more →
Tim, no worries. Both your previous post and this one is very helpful. Both you and Ricardo have relevant and noteworthy points to add as you think about shooting different focal lengths. Your approach of moving with different focal lengths is how many people think about shooting different focal lengths. They want to keep the same elements in the frame and then different focal lengths give you very different images because you have to move to get those elements in the frame. Ricardo's point, however, is also useful. Sometimes instead of moving you can use the same lens and crop to effectively use a different focal length and this also means that the same lens if you move can give you two very different perspectives if you keep the same elements in the frame.
For example, one of the things I really like about my CV 21 f/1.4 is that if I keep the same elements in the frame I get a 21mm wide angle look in terms of compression, but if I take a few steps back and crop to keep the same elements in the frame I can create a 28mm look from the same lens. My CV 21 f/1.4 with a 1.3X crop turns into what looks like a 28 f/1.8 lens. Of course I have less pixels when I do that but on my A7r V, I still have 35ish MP, so I am typically happy with that.
Your approach makes tons of sense and you will get to use all of the full frame sensor by taking both lenses, but my approach gets me images with all of the full frame sensor when I use the CV 21 f/1.4 uncropped, and still quite good images when I use the lens cropped to f/1.3X, and I get to carry just one lens. Your approach will optimize IQ, but my approach I find comes in handy when I want to carry one less lens, which is especially helpful when I want to reduce the weight of my kit like when traveling. I actually use both approaches. Yours when I am not worried about weight or how much I am carrying and what I am calling my approach when I want to carry fewer lenses. Thanks for your input. I don't think you were wrong, just there is also another way to do it that some might appreciate.
p.10 #14Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
I am sorry. My post was probably not clear enough. Please accept my apologies if it was perceived as rude. My comment was not aimed at Tim (I totally understood what he meant, and I agree with EVERYTHING he wrote, including the first two paragraphs of his last post).
There are several misconceptions in photography that are worth mentioning from time to time in a technical section of the forum.
My previous post had an educational purpose for those who read the forum and don't post.
If I didn't value education (and scientific research) I wouldn't be doing the work I do. And maybe I would earn more money. But I love what I do and I wouldn't trade my job for any other job in the world.
tsdevine wrote:
So when shooting a scene, I am generally choosing a focal length that gives me the composition and perspective I'm looking for. It's also why "zoom with your feet" doesn't work for me. I generally am putting some thought into composition, and perspective is part of that. It also drives the focal length I choose.
I use the same approach, even when using a zoom lens. I consider a zoom not a variable focal length lens, but a set of fixed focal length lenses.
Last but not least, I will always be happy to see Tim's posts and photos.
p.10 #15Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Ripolini wrote:
I am sorry. My post was probably not clear enough. Please accept my apologies if it was perceived as rude. My comment was not aimed at Tim (I totally understood what he meant, and I agree with EVERYTHING he wrote, including the first two paragraphs of his last post).
There are several misconceptions in photography that are worth mentioning from time to time in a technical section of the forum.
My previous post had an educational purpose for those who read the forum and don't post.
If I didn't value education (and scientific research) I wouldn't be doing the work I do. And maybe I would earn more money. But I love what I do and I wouldn't trade my job for any other job in the world.
I use the same approach, even when using a zoom lens. I consider a zoom not a variable focal length lens, but a set of fixed focal length lenses.
Last but not least, I will always be happy to see Tim's posts and photos.
Cheers,
Riccardo ...Show more →tsdevine wroteSo when shooting a scene, I am generally choosing a focal length that gives me the composition and perspective I'm looking for. It's also why "zoom with your feet" doesn't work for me. I generally am putting some thought into composition, and perspective is part of that. It also drives the focal length I choose.
Sorry for my overreaction Riccardo. We are very like minded in our approach. And you were correct in terms of pointing out a lenses focal length really just affects field of view.
In any case, I want to extend an apology to you as well.
p.10 #18Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Malick80 wrote:
What the heck is this place, a civil disagreement that resulted in respect and apologies!!! I'm not familiar with this kind of internet behavior.
I know...it's crazy.
(and it's part of what makes this the best place on the internet.)
p.10 #19Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Hey everyone!
I just joined and have never posted on the forum before, but I've been waiting for this 28mm since it was announced and thought it would be nice to share a few shots I took with it today. These are just 10 shots taken during a work break and on my way back from the office (in Chicago with an A7CR). I made minimal changes here—some tonality corrections and a Provia-inspired profile, with minor crops on a couple of shots. I'm not aiming to share technical photos, as many will share better ones, but I thought I'd drop the few snaps I took during the short walk after I received the lens. I usually develop in bw 80% of the time, but I thought that would not be as useful here.
N.B. I am not allowed to add links directly here in the first 24 hours, so the embeds won't work and I had to remove the https. Sorry, I wish they didn't have to be visited manually.