fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!

  
 
phinix
Offline
Details
p.4 #1Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Now they MUST do Z mount !
Dec 15, 2024 at 04:32 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
OscarF wrote:
nehemiahphoto wroteNot sure--but I do know, the optical formulae of lenses that are ported from m-mount to e, like the CV's that are in FE mount, tend to have smoother bokeh and a slightly different more diffuse draw. Fred found that, and I found that as well with the only FE CV I owned in both mounts (40/1.2). I also know the 80 Lux and 75 Lux have identical formula, but they present differently, even though the only "difference" is physical spacing as R mount was for SLR versus M.

I know spacing is important, and even very minor tweaks can change imaging performance. I am not knowledgable enough about optics to understand why/how from looking at a diagram.

Edit: Upon further reflection, in conjunction with spacing, I wonder if the larger diameter of the elements for E versus M as well as the size of the rear element are also a factor in the rendering qualities, even though the optical formulas the same.
So you're saying with the two CV 40mm f/1.2 lenses you have in both E and M mounts - the E mount version has larger diameter glass elements than the M mount version? If the lens design truly stays the same but all the glass elements are made larger diameter for the E mount, then the element thickness would also have to increase - and that would increase the focal length of the lens and also increase the size of the projected image circle...wouldn't it?

The filter size difference between the M and E 28mm f/1.5 lenses is only 3mm
...Show more →

It may not be the diameter of the optical elements, although the diameter of the rear element may change and may matter without affecting the focal length of the lens. What may matter is vignetting and especially for the bokeh. Vignetting does affect how bokeh balls are cut off and can lead to greater perceived DOF in the periphery and swirl.

Nehemiah is right that the Leica M 75 f/1.4 and the Leica R 80 f/1.4 had the same optical formula, but have distinctly different looks. In that case, the Leica R version does have larger diameter elements (and the slightly longer focal length) and that is no doubt part of the reason the rendering is not the same.
Dec 15, 2024 at 05:24 AM
Knut.
Offline
Details
p.4 #3Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
OscarF wrote:
nehemiahphoto wroteIf they tweak one thing, I hope it’s coma correction or midzone sharpness wide open at portrait distance.
The E mount and VM lens diagrams look identical - no added ED glass elements or changed element shapes - so Cosina just adjusted the element spacing. I don't think that's enough to improve E results above VM results.

Unless - Cosina just used the VM diagram for convenience and the actual E lens formula is different? But what the chances of that?


The thick sensor glas of the Sony sensor is an optical element in itself, changing any calculations of the lenses aligned in front of this element. There are designs wwhich might improve if this element is taken into consideration and there are designs for which this thick sonsor glas is detrimental. It is really completely unknown what effect the adaptation from Leica M to Sony-E will have.
In any case, I‘m sure Cosina will tweak the lens spacing and the calculations of the radii to get the best out of the lens. It is up for a toss, if it will be better, worse or the same as Leica-M calculation (how much difference even small changes can make can be seen in the sample varation of the 15mm III…).
Dec 15, 2024 at 05:33 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Knut. wrote:
OscarF wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteIf they tweak one thing, I hope it’s coma correction or midzone sharpness wide open at portrait distance.
The E mount and VM lens diagrams look identical - no added ED glass elements or changed element shapes - so Cosina just adjusted the element spacing. I don't think that's enough to improve E results above VM results.

Unless - Cosina just used the VM diagram for convenience and the actual E lens formula is different? But what the chances of that?
The thick sensor glas of the Sony sensor is an optical element in itself, changing any calculations of the lenses aligned in front of this element. There are designs wwhich might improve if this element is taken into consideration and there are designs for which this thick sonsor glas is detrimental. It is really completely unknown what effect the adaptation from Leica M to Sony-E will have.
In any case, I‘m sure Cosina will tweak the lens spacing and the calculations of the radii to get the best out of the lens. It is up for a toss, if it
...Show more →

There have been 14 lenses now that have been offered by Voigtlander in a version for Leica M mount and a version for Sony E mount. I don't believe any of the Sony E mount lenses performed worse on Sony E mount than the Leica M mount versions performed on Leica M mount. Almost all of them had similar performance on the camera for which they were designed. The only notable exception seems to be the 50 f/2 APO which the Sony E mount version seems to perform just a tiny bit better on Sony E mount than the Leica M version does on a Leica M camera and has a different optical design on the two mounts, but I currently have the Sony E mount version and I previously had the Leica M version and used it on a Leica M camera and I can say the differences are small. In fact, there is probably more differences between copies of these lenses than between mounts. Maybe I had a really good Leica M mount and a weak Sony E mount, but both lenses were well centered. I fully expect the Sony E mount version of the 28 f/1.5 to perform on a Sony camera a lot like the Leica M mount version performs on a Leica M mount camera.
Dec 15, 2024 at 05:29 PM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Again, I don't know.

You are making assumptions, but I actually don't know how optics work to be intelligent here. I don't know why glass elements would have to increase in thickness--why not just expand to the barrel size? Maybe they only increase the size of certain elements, or a group of elements, or the spacing between elements to accommodate the longer helicoid needed for closer MFD.

Perhaps differently spaced elements change vignetting but don't affect IQ much. I know in terms of bokeh, the rear elements is particularly important for circular bokeh balls. I also note, from this old post, that even though the CV 40/1.2 has the same front and rear element across the VM and FE versions, the bokeh is bit more abstracted on the FE and it gets more light. It's explained here as "pixel vignetting." And, I was wrong above--I didn't realize the 40/1.2 front and rear elements are the same size--that surprised me.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1520348/1/

Even though the VM and FE 40/1.2 have the same front and rear element diameter, the both are optimized for their respective mount despite the identical formula. Not sure what tweak they change to optimize the sensor stacks.

When the 28/1.5 FE arrives, I'll be very curious to see and measure if the front and rear elements are the same. And to what, if any differences, we see beyond MFD and optimization for the native mount sensor stack. I have and like the VM 28/1.5, and I will purchase a FE 28/1.5, and I can do a strict apples-to-apple comp


Edited on Dec 15, 2024 at 06:34 PM · View previous versions
Dec 15, 2024 at 06:11 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.4 #6Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Outside the CV 15 with corner smearing I never ran into a Sony FE mount that did not work perfectly on our Sonys. I had M lenses that there problematic and we even used from front filters on them for our Sony bodies. Not sure where all this fear is coming from to be honest it has not hit the streets yet until than just relax and waitt for it. I may grab one myself. I have always wanted a 28mm prime that was far better than Sonys 28mm which frankly sucks. Sorry
Dec 15, 2024 at 06:15 PM
Juha Kannisto
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
I've also been very happy with Cosina's Sony sensor stack optimization with all of their native E-mount lenses that I've had. I've had 16 out of 17 E-mount lenses that they've released so far, including the 2 versions of 40/1.2 and 50/1.2 in the count. I only skipped the 12mm.

I know the 15mm had a lot of variance issues with corner IQ on both the E-mount version as well as VM version III but luckily I had great copies of both on first try.

Nowadays I still keep 11 of their E-mount lenses and this 28/1.5 will be my 12th. Been really missing a 28mm option from them for E-mount as that's one of my favorite focal lengths and we've had serious lack of native options for E-mount with electronic contacts.

I traded away my 10mm, 65/2, 110/2.5 due to limited use as I'm not much of a macro shooter and I prefer smaller lenses, and the 10mm is wider than I never really need, plus the original versions of 40/1.2 & 50/1.2 (after getting SE versions). Still keeping all the others.

Really looking forward to this one. I guess Cosina might announce the official release date around 27th of December, just before Japan goes to New Year holidays. Release date will probably be at the very earliest around 10th of January since Japan is pretty much closed for New Year holidays until 6th, but it could well be later in the month. Since they have 2 new releases for January (including 90/2 VM), one of those may take an earlier slot and the other would likely be late in the month.

I place my pre-order at Map Camera already on Friday.
Dec 15, 2024 at 07:36 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.4 #8Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
For folks in the US Camerquest is the west coast distribution. They do sell on Amazon. Photo Village is the east coast distribution and of course you can get at BH and so on

I lost count how many CV lenses I have had but it’s a lot
Dec 15, 2024 at 07:46 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.4 #9Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
'The only notable exception seems to be the 50 f/2 APO which the Sony E mount version seems to perform just a tiny bit better on Sony E mount than the Leica M version does on a Leica M camera and has a different optical design on the two mounts'

The two 50/2 APOs (VM and E/Z) are quite different designs actually, and the block chart makes this clear - the E/Z lens features three more APD elements, and that buys a lot more correction - this is indeed reflected in the MTF charts provided. At f2 at least, they even up by f4. The elements themselves are also arranged differently and have differnt thicknesses and curves. See it here:

https://www.cosina.co.jp/voigtlander/en/vm-mount/apo-lanthar-50mm-f2-aspherical/
https://www.cosina.co.jp/voigtlander/en/e-mount/apo-lanthar-50mm-f2-aspherical/

Many may feel the 35/2 APOs are also notable. For them, the E/Z mount lenses are more than 5% better for fine/moderate detail (40 and 30 lpmm) than the VM version, at f2 where it does matter. See it here:

https://www.cosina.co.jp/voigtlander/en/vm-mount/apo-lanthar-35mm-f2-aspherical/
https://www.cosina.co.jp/voigtlander/en/e-mount/apo-lanthar-35mm-f2-aspherical/

If you open these two 35/2 APO links on adjacent tabs and click back and forth, you will see that there is no evidence from Cosina that even a tiny diffference is seen in their 'lens cuts' (block charts), and yet the MTF differs as I outlined above.

These findings do raise doubts about all the other common-mount lenses for which no MTF are provided by Cosina. If and when evidence becomes available, we can have more certainty. Until then, it's an open question, something of a mystery in my mind at least.

It's one of those issues where there are strongly held opinions about 'optimization', but no credible evidence as to how this is done. People like to say it, however, as it has a certain sense to it.

At the risk of upsetting their major market of M-mount users, Cosina could have talked up the E/Z mount versions of these key APOs as superior optics, their best ever at these major focal lengths. But that didn't happen, for obvious reasons.

From memory, these were the last lenses that were produced for E-mount first, ahead of the lower performance VM editions. After that time, Cosina had a change of heart and became 'Leica first', at least for the lenses they later deigned to offer to E/Z users, like this 28/1.5. For so many other lenses, they are 'Leica only'.
Dec 15, 2024 at 08:48 PM
Juha Kannisto
Offline
Details
p.4 #10Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
There are also 65/2 and 110/2.5 that were never released in M-mount so the designs were driven by Sony E-mount from the start.

After 35/2 Cosina didn't release anything for E-mount for almost 3 years (re-started this year with 50/1, 75/1.5 and 28/1.5 on the pipeline next). This seemed to be mostly because they were too busy ramping up their new X-mount, Z-mount, RF-mount lines at the same time, trying to make their presence on those other mirrorless mounts at the right/early timing.

Currently it seems that they want to utilize their M-mount lens designs as baseline and work out E-mount, Z-mount and RF-mount optimized versions based on the same design at least for the Nokton lenses. With APO lenses the same approach might not work as well.

I don't know if they will continue to have 'Leica first' policy in the future, I think it always depends on what is the best-selling mount at the time and what is the most efficient strategy for them. They've also enjoyed good sales with their X-mount APS-C lenses that have been designed for X-mount from the ground up, but also in some cases based on some existing M-mount designs.

It will be interesting to see what they plan to release next in FF mirrorless mounts, perhaps there will be some interesting new announcement at next CP+ (end of February) regarding that. I think they are starting to have enough fast Noktons there (esp. in E-mount) and they might be shifting the focus to something else again, e.g. more compact lenses (some pancakes like their X-mount 27/2 & 18/2.8 but for FF?) or some new APO-Lanthars.
Dec 15, 2024 at 09:20 PM
Robin Smith
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
It's actually a pity that they decided to make huge lenses for MFT. It defeats the whole purpose of the system IMO.Would have made a lot more sense to design as small lenses as possible, just like they do for Leica M.

MFT users also want options just like anyone else. They may want a small system a lot of the time, but other times they want fast lenses. Just like other photographers with other systems.
Dec 15, 2024 at 09:38 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
philip_pj wrote:
'The only notable exception seems to be the 50 f/2 APO which the Sony E mount version seems to perform just a tiny bit better on Sony E mount than the Leica M version does on a Leica M camera and has a different optical design on the two mounts'

The two 50/2 APOs (VM and E/Z) are quite different designs actually, and the block chart makes this clear - the E/Z lens features three more APD elements, and that buys a lot more correction - this is indeed reflected in the MTF charts provided. At f2 at least, they even
...Show more →

Phillip as usual I appreciate your comments, but I think we need to keep in mind that lenses vary from copy to copy. On average the E mount versions of the 35 f/2 APO and 50 f/2 APO might have a bit higher MTFs, but if you remember when lens rentals tested actual lenses they often found more than 5% difference in contrast between copies of the same lens for 40 lp/mm, so the differences between the E mount lenses and the M mount lenses aren't likely to be any bigger than the difference within E mount lenses and M mount lenses. That is why I am not surprised that I don't really see any difference between my individual copies of my E mount 50 f/2 APO and my M mount 50 f/2 APO. Both are excellent optics even if the design for the E mount is a bit more advanced.

As to whether Voigtlander is Leica first, I agree in some ways they are, but they clearly have a Sony strategy. They currently make 30 different Leica M mount lenses (if you don't count different types as different lenses). Twelve of those lenses will now be offered in Sony E mount, and three used to be offered for Sony E mount. So about half, but we see that of the lenses offered on Sony E mount there is an emphasis on three types, Noktons, APO Lanthars, and ultra wide Heliars. So far, no Ultrons and only one Color Skopar that was discontinued have been offered on Sony E mount. They clearly think these three types of lenses are what make sense on Sony: very fast apertures, very highly corrected lenses, and small ultra wides. With Leica they seem to make almost every type of lens and have a comprehensive catalog, but they don't for Sony. Just like for m4/3rds they primarily only built one type of lens, ultra wide aperture lenses. It is less clear what they will build for Z mount and RF mount, but fhey have already made three wide aperture lenses for both and three highly corrected APO lenses and one small ultra wide lens for Z mount. Their plans for APS-C lenses are less clear for both Fuji X and Nikon Z. For Nikon Z they have 2 wide aperture APS-C lenses and 1 APO lens, and on Fuji X mount they have these three lenses plus two pancake lenses.

Suffice it to say they seem to strive to develop a comprehensive set of lenses for Leica M, but for other mounts they adopt a clear strategy of only developing a certain type of lens or several types of lenses but not a comprehensive set. For those of us that shoot Sony E mount, I guess we can consider the glass either half full or half empty. They make a lot of lenses for Sony E mount, but they will probably never build a comprehensive set of lenses even though we have pretty good focal length coverage at this point. Of course predicting what Cosina will do is notoriously difficult. I am on the record saying I didn't think they would build a 28 f/1.5 or a 75 f/1.5 for Sony E mount and yet they did. So today I am trying to see the glass as half full and it certainly is fuller than I expected it to be.
Dec 15, 2024 at 09:55 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Alik Griffin made a telling remark about Cosina recently when he said they appear to make prototypes and then move on to the next idea they have for a lens, he was referring to the casual way they discontinue very capable and even beloved lenses. A lot of buyers want a new lens, many users knock their lenses around.

In his case, it was the VM 35/1.7 but there are many others, like the 21/3.5 in E-mount. They just disappear, with no reason given for why. Much of their production appears to be designed to show what they can do rather than to deliver a coherent range for the brands/mounts they support. The m43 range is ludicrous in weight, if I may say.
Dec 15, 2024 at 10:21 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.4 #14Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Robin Smith wrote:
Earlier quoteIt's actually a pity that they decided to make huge lenses for MFT. It defeats the whole purpose of the system IMO.Would have made a lot more sense to design as small lenses as possible, just like they do for Leica M.
MFT users also want options just like anyone else. They may want a small system a lot of the time, but other times they want fast lenses. Just like other photographers with other systems.


I think it is important to keep in mind that when Cosina built the ultra fast m4/3rds lenses, they were also building Zeiss ZE/ZF and Milvus lenses and I see the similarity in the approach. Hi quality manual focus lenses without really regard to size at all. Maybe not what some people want, but a clear and in my view interesting strategy. Personally, I decided that if I want the shallow depth of field these lenses provided I would use a larger sensor system, but if I was committed to the m4/3rds system more I might have picked some of these up.
Dec 16, 2024 at 05:15 AM
Viramati
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
I have been waiting for years for a decent 28mm lens for Sony and this looks great and could be just what I need for street photography if I didn't have the Leica Q2 monochrom already. Will consider it anyway
Dec 16, 2024 at 06:10 AM
Viramati
Offline
Details
Dec 16, 2024 at 06:15 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.4 #17Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
philip_pj wrote:
Alik Griffin made a telling remark about Cosina recently when he said they appear to make prototypes and then move on to the next idea they have for a lens, he was referring to the casual way they discontinue very capable and even beloved lenses. A lot of buyers want a new lens, many users knock their lenses around.

In his case, it was the VM 35/1.7 but there are many others, like the 21/3.5 in E-mount. They just disappear, with no reason given for why. Much of their production appears to be designed to show what they can do
...Show more →

Cosina certainly drops lenses from production more often than most other manufacturers and the reasons why are often a mystery. In time with their Leica M mount lenses, you can often see a strategy of why they dropped a given lens. I had and really liked the optical qualities of the CV 35 f/1.7, but not the ergonomics of it. It seemed to cry out for a redesign with a different approach to the focus ring, which frankly sucked IMO, and perhaps less viewfinder blockage. What Cosina seems to have done now that we can look back is that they created two lenses instead of redesigning the 35 f/1.7. They made a 35 f/2 with beautiful ergonomics (the ultron) and they made a slightly faster and also smaller with better ergonomics 35 f/1.5. They now have a 35 f/1.2, 35 f/1.4 (classic character lens), 35 f/1.5, 35 f/2, 35 f/2 APO, and 35 f/2.5. I don't really see room for a 35 f/1.7 in that line up as it certainly is a comprehensive set of lens at 35mm. So it seems to me with hindsight they had a plan and the 35 f/1.7 just didn't fit in that plan.

I don't know why Cosina discontinued the 21 f/3.5 for Sony E mount or why they discontinued the 35, 40, & 50 f/1.2 SE lenses for Sony E mount. They also frustrate me in that with their Nokton lenses I would love to see floating element designs and a few more APD elements to better control axial CA in general and purple fringing in particular. My favorite Nokton is the 21 f/1.4 that has an FLE and 3 APD elements and controls axial CA pretty well, but it is a bit bigger and that seems to make the lens at least somewhat unpopular. The 75 f/1.5 added 3 APD elements, but no FLE. It still has quite good close up performance, however, so it is my second favorite Nokton. I don't know why the E mount version is so much bigger than the M mount version (10mm bigger diameter and 165g heavier), but it doesn't matter to me as it adapts well and I can use the M version on my Sony E mount cameras.

This new 28 f/1.5 looks promising to me. It doesn't have an FLE, but does have a couple of APD elements. They have also kept it small and the M version has good close up performance even without an FLE. I do wish it had better bokeh and controlled CA better, but for a 28 I value the small size and the excellent stopped down performance it provides. I basically consider it an excellent 28 f/2.8 lens that also has a wider aperture that works well for close up performance or at least I think that is what it will be.

I like all the APO Lanthars even if I wish they could have made them differently. I wish the 35 and 50 f/2 APO lens traded a bit of sharpness for slightly better bokeh, which would probably mean leaving at least a little uncorrected spherical aberrations, and I wish the 65 and 110 macros had circular aperture blades as I often stop down with these lenses and at close distances the bokeh balls are often prominent and I dislike the polygonal shapes of the stopped down bokeh balls of these lenses. In almost every other way, I think these lenses are close to perfect, but that aperture blade shape I see as an unforced error by Cosina. So, I don't see any of their lenses as perfect, but I generally really like the lenses they provide.
Dec 16, 2024 at 06:36 AM
TakenWild
Offline
Details
p.4 #18Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Very tempting lens. I just trying to work out how it will fit into my kit and use cases.
Probably the Voightlander APO 35/2 is one of my favourites and I don’t go without it much. Will I use this lens for landscape with the 35 in my kit? I’m not sure. But sometimes I’d like a 28 walking around. Hmm…
Dec 16, 2024 at 10:40 AM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.4 #19Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Fred really gave the 28/1.5 a thorough workout and yes, it's a fine lens. Cosina seems to be selecting the faster lenses for the mirrorless versions. So M-mount is a kind of high end proving ground. And they feel the lens bodies should be bigger too, as some misguided attempt to match them to those cameras. Anyway, we got another fast 28mm, just had to wait a couple of decades..
Dec 16, 2024 at 01:02 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.4 #20Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Heck I may buy it because I waited so long for it.
Dec 16, 2024 at 01:28 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister