While I don't know exactly what manufacturers do to adjust for sensor stack thickness, it does seem to play a critical factor for some lenses. Otherwise, companies like Kolari Vision would not be performing sensor stack conversions as there would be no advantage to changing your sensor stack.
Modern optics are made to very high tolerance, we have seen when adapting lenses how an adapter being off by hundredths of a millimeter can make a lens perform much worse.
p.5 #2Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
philip_pj wrote:
Fred really gave the 28/1.5 a thorough workout and yes, it's a fine lens. Cosina seems to be selecting the faster lenses for the mirrorless versions. So M-mount is a kind of high end proving ground. And they feel the lens bodies should be bigger too, as some misguided attempt to match them to those cameras. Anyway, we got another fast 28mm, just had to wait a couple of decades..
I agree Cosina tends to make their fast lenses (Noktons) for mirrorless, but let's look at the Leica M versions vs. the Sony versions:
21 f/1.4 Nokton Leica M version: 480g, 69.5mm diameter, 69.7mm length
21 f/1.4 Nokton Sony E version: 540g, 70.5mm diameter, 79.5mm length
If you consider an adapter would add about 40g in weight and should add 9.8 mm in length an adapted Leica M mount 21 f/1.4 Nokton would only weigh about 20g less, only have 1mm narrower diameter, and would be exactly the same length as the Sony E version. We see the E mount lens really is not much at all bigger in size
28 f/1.5 Nokton Leica M Type 1: 250g, 55mm diameter, 45.5mm length
28 f/1.5 Nokton Sony E version: 320g, 62.6mm diameter, 55mm length
If you consider an adapter would add about 40g in weight and should add 9.8 mm in length an adapted Leica M mount 28 f/1.5 Nokton would only weigh 30g less, but would have a narrower diameter by 7.6mm, and would be a tiny bit (.3mm) longer than the Sony E version. Again we see the E mount lens really isn't that much bigger and really just fatter.
35 f/1.4 Nokton Leica M version: 189g, 55mm diameter, 28.5mm length
35 f/1.4 Nokton Sony E version: 262g, 67mm diameter, 39.6mm length
If you consider an adapter would add about 40g in weight and should add 9.8 mm in length an adapted Leica M mount 35 f/1.4 Nokton would only weigh 32g less, but would have a narrower diameter by 12mm, and would be just 1.3mm shorter. Again we see the M mount lens is really not much smaller and mainly just skinnier.
35 f/1.2 III Leica M version: 332g, 60.8mm diameter, 50.5mm length
35 f/1.2 Sony E SE version: 387g, 66.5mm diameter, 59.9mm length
If you consider an adapter would add about 40g in weight and should add 9.8 mm in length an adapted Leica M mount 35 f/1.2 III Nokton would only weigh 15g less, but would have a 5.7mm narrower diameter, and would be .4mm longer than the 35 f/1.2 Sony E SE version. Again we see the M mount lens is really not much smaller and mainly just skinnier.
40 f/1.2 Nokton Leica M version: 315g, 60.8mm diameter, 43.3mm length
40 f/1.2 Nokton Sony E regular version: 410g, 70.1 diameter, 59.3mm length
40 f/1.2 Nokton Sony E SE version: 340g, 66.5mm diameter, 51.9mm length
If you consider an adapter would add about 40g in weight and should add 9.8 mm in length an adapted Leica M mount 40 f/1.2 Nokton would be about the same size as the SE version (actually about 15g heavier and 1.2mm longer, but with a 5.7mm narrower diameter) but notably smaller than the regular Sony version: 55g lighter, 9.3mm narrower in diameter, and 6.2mm shorter.
50 f/1.2 Nokton Leica M version: 347g, 63.3mm diameter, 49.0 length
50 f/1.2 Nokton Sony E regular version: 434g, 70.1mm diameter, 58.8mm length
50 f/1.2 Nokton Sony E SE version: 383g, 66.5mm diameter, 58.5mm length
If you consider an adapter would add about 40g in weight and should add 9.8 mm in length an adapted Leica M mount 50 f/1.2 Nokton would be about the same size as the SE version (actually just 4g heavier, .3mm longer, but with a 3.2mm narrower diameter) but noticeably smaller than the regular Sony version: 47g lighter, 6.8mm narrower in diameter, and the same length.
50 f/1 Nokton Leica M version: 484g, 73.6mm diameter, 55mm length
50 f/1 Nokton Sony E version: 590g, 79.3mm diameter, 69.3mm length
If you consider an adapter would add about 40g in weight and should add 9.8 mm in length an adapted Leica M mount 50 f/1 Nokton would be 66g lighter, 5.7mm narrower in diameter, and 4.5mm shorter than the Sony E mount version. Again smaller but not that much smaller.
75 f/1.5 Nokton Leica M version: 350g, 62.8mm diameter, 63.3mm length
75 f/1.5 Nokton Sony E version: 515g, 74mm diameter, 73.9mm length
If you consider an adapter would add about 40g in weight and should add 9.8 mm in length an adapted Leica M mount 75 f/1.5 Nokton would be a whopping 125g lighter, 11.2mm narrower in diameter, but just .8mm longer than the Sony E mount version.
Looking at these comparisons we see that the Sony E mount versions are mostly wider in diameter and most a just a little heavier by 20 to 50g, but almost never much longer with the only exception being the 40 f/1.2. The big outlier is the new 75 f/1.5 which for some reason is a lot heavier and a lot wider in diameter. We also see that when Cosina made the SE versions of the 35, 40, & 50 Noktons they made them basically as small as the Leica M versions.
From my perspective this slightly bigger size of the Sony versions is fine except the 75 f/1.5 which is just too much bigger, IMO. I do wish they made more lenses like the SE lenses that were closer to Leica M size, but I find it hard to be too concerned about the modest increase in size and weight for almost all their lenses as it comes with full electronic reporting, and shorter MFD, and an aperture that can be declicked for video.
p.5 #3Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
It makes sense that the E version of an M lens would have to be longer. Without making major changes to the optical formula an E lens will need to be longer to maintain infinity focus.
For the Width of E vs M lenses, we would need to know if any of the lens elements are wider to understand if the wider lenses are a stylistic choice or an optical advantage. I have not used an M camera but I know the width of a lense is important not to block the range finder.
As for sensor stack optimizations, I doubt we would see any differences in a lenses physical dimensions. My best guess is the optimizations are sub mm differences in optical spacing or a small differences in a lens element shape.
p.5 #4Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
From tearing apart a CV lens I remember they use shims . Forget the lens I tore apart but I certainly remember shims being used . That might be for sensor stack reasons but hey im not an optical engineer either. Im after IQ and if I test a lens and it's stellar is all I really care about if not it goes back. Im not married to any lens if it stinks it's not in my bag. I try to keep it simple. Been using CV glass for years and really like more the look than anything . But I hate bad egos and why I sold all my Loxia glass and went all CV which I love the egos on. I love having the aperture ring out front and also there focusing rings.
p.5 #5Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Yes, it's all about the images, always. I'd like to see reviews start out with 20-30 well crafted but normally processed images. The lens is a tool for making images. If reviewers couldn't be bothered going outside, we can stop right there. They can also spare us the personality cults, especially the face-to-camera people.
On why Cosina does what they do, we can't complain too much as they have done so much for MF lenses' growing popularity. I do think they should settle on the styling and stick to it for every mount. The M lenses ergo might have been carried over to the MILC mounts, it would have made them more recognizable and distinctive. The diameter gains are in no one's interest.
And there is the issue of the optimal weight range and upper threshold. Once over a certain weight, the lens is out, or you really have to want it. Sadly, the longer lenses suffer the most.
On adapters, many users are dual with Sony/Nikon and Leica M. They might be the same people who would consider adapters to be the source of pure evil. So going from their M CV lens to the Sony/Nikon version is a straight swap optically, but the lenses share very little physically. And the adapter doesn't enter the picture, so to speak, for the mount purists.
A further issue is filter sizes, if you have the M lenses worked out, you need quite different filters. 43-49mm on the 28/1.5; 52-58mm for the 40/1.2; 52-58mm for the 50/1.2; 62-67mm for the 50/1; 58-62mm for the 75/1.5. It all accumulates, a lot of little things add up.
Finally, they could have saved themselves all the effort simply by duplicating the M lenses with a new mount attached. So it's an opportunity cost as well as a series of small retrograde steps in the wrong direction.
p.5 #8Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
GMPhotography wrote:
From tearing apart a CV lens I remember they use shims . Forget the lens I tore apart but I certainly remember shims being used . That might be for sensor stack reasons but hey im not an optical engineer either. Im after IQ and if I test a lens and it's stellar is all I really care about if not it goes back. Im not married to any lens if it stinks it's not in my bag. I try to keep it simple. Been using CV glass for years and really like more the look than anything . But I hate bad egos and why I sold all my Loxia glass and went all CV which I love the egos on. I love having the aperture ring out front and also there focusing rings. ...Show more →
Knowing your tastes a bit Guy, I don’t think you’ll like this lens as much given it’s not great WO.
p.5 #9Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
philip_pj wrote:
Alik Griffin made a telling remark about Cosina recently when he said they appear to make prototypes and then move on to the next idea they have for a lens, he was referring to the casual way they discontinue very capable and even beloved lenses. A lot of buyers want a new lens, many users knock their lenses around.
In his case, it was the VM 35/1.7 but there are many others, like the 21/3.5 in E-mount. They just disappear, with no reason given for why. Much of their production appears to be designed to show what they can do rather than to deliver a coherent range for the brands/mounts they support. The m43 range is ludicrous in weight, if I may say. ...Show more →
As I read somewhere the CEO of Cosina is a lens aficionado himself. Who knows which lenses were made on a whim, disregarding market research. Many of their lenses fill certain market niches or take up certain properties of old lenses of lore and bring their performance up to date on all other optical aspects.
Another hunch I have, is that their lenses are made in batches and when a batch is gone, it is gone (21mm/f3.5 for example). A second batch is then only released if there is REALY strong market demand and if the lens can still be made at a competitive price. This didn‘t seem to be the case for the SLR 125 macro or the SLR 180mm.
18mm and 180mm are really two lenses that I yearn for from Voigtländer.
p.5 #10Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Well it takes time to make the glass as they need to cure and such than coatings . I was told this on a Leica tour in Germany. I got an amazing tour there and learned a lot but more important im sure they do this in batches and im sure they run out as well . Than they may drop a lens line as well. I have the 21mm 1.4 which may sell better than the F3.5. So they simply will go with the best sellers in the market
Today I have the CV 15/ Cv 21mm 1.4 and I may add this one even though I have the Sony 24-50 but that's more a work lens. Im a old school manual focus guy so I love these Cv lenses and as I am retiring and my needs have changed
p.5 #14Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
GMPhotography wrote:
Don't forget you get a crop factor as well which is a 42mm which on the 60mpx sensors its more like 26mpx
And if you just crop 1.25X (you can't do this in the EVF, but it isn't too hard to estimate) then you have a 35mm perspective with the equivalent of f/1.9 depth of field and about a 40mpx file if you have a 60mpx sensor. Having a 28 f/1.5 at 60mpx, a 35 f/1.9 at 40mpx, and a 40 f/2.3 at 26mpx provides a lot of coverage.
p.5 #15Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Steve Spencer wrote: GMPhotography wroteDon't forget you get a crop factor as well which is a 42mm which on the 60mpx sensors its more like 26mpxAnd if you just crop 1.25X (you can't do this in the EVF, but it isn't too hard to estimate) then you have a 35mm perspective with the equivalent of f/1.9 depth of field and about a 40mpx file if you have a 60mpx sensor. Having a 28 f/1.5 at 60mpx, a 35 f/1.9 at 40mpx, and a 40 f/2.3 at 26mpx provides a lot of coverage.
And if you start cropping, you are ridding yourself of the weaker mid and outter frame. Which I think is a considerable plus for many shooters. The inner parts of the frame are pretty strong (LoCal witthstanding)
p.5 #16Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Steve Spencer wrote: GMPhotography wroteDon't forget you get a crop factor as well which is a 42mm which on the 60mpx sensors its more like 26mpxAnd if you just crop 1.25X (you can't do this in the EVF, but it isn't too hard to estimate) then you have a 35mm perspective with the equivalent of f/1.9 depth of field and about a 40mpx file if you have a 60mpx sensor. Having a 28 f/1.5 at 60mpx, a 35 f/1.9 at 40mpx, and a 40 f/2.3 at 26mpx provides a lot of coverage.
So is the crop mode not just a digital zoom that retains the f1.5 depth of field but the depth of field actually changes similar to a crop sensor camera (i.e. f1.5 to f1.9/2.x in this example)? I'm new to Sony and learning the a7RV.
p.5 #17Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
'I think the 28mm Nokton will be a winner for them.'
The company will be well aware of the level of interest in this lens from sales data compiled in from the 11 months it has already been produced for Leica M users. There are not a lot of well-regarded competing lenses in the manual focus 28mm niche for the non-M mounts, least of all from Cosina themselves.
In that mount, they offer four different styles of the 28/1.5: silver or black in both aluminum and brass. Also at 28mm for Leica, they offer no fewer than seven more 28mm lenses in different styles, spread over two more optical designs (Ultron and Color-Skopar). And this frenzied production schedule (eleven lenses in three max apertures) has all happened since mid-2021.
If you look across their made-for-Sony lens lineup, you see:
. four APO-Lanthars, lenses that put them on the map (in modern times);
. seven Nokton lenses; and
. two old ultra wide angles they kicked off with in 2016.
What they do not make for you are the many Color-Skopars, Ultrons and Heliars - these are M-mount only. Many of them are very good, by any standard.
There are currently 34 Cosina VM lenses. All but a handful were released in the 2020s - a few older VM lenses date from as far back as 2004/2007.
This 28/1.5 will be their fourth lens for Sony users since 2019.
p.5 #18Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
jeffro wrote: Steve Spencer wroteGMPhotography wroteDon't forget you get a crop factor as well which is a 42mm which on the 60mpx sensors its more like 26mpxAnd if you just crop 1.25X (you can't do this in the EVF, but it isn't too hard to estimate) then you have a 35mm perspective with the equivalent of f/1.9 depth of field and about a 40mpx file if you have a 60mpx sensor. Having a 28 f/1.5 at 60mpx, a 35 f/1.9 at 40mpx, and a 40 f/2.3 at 26mpx provides a lot of coverage.So is the crop mode not just a digital zoom that retains the f1.5 depth of field but the depth of field actually changes similar to a crop sensor camera (i.e. f1.5 to f1.9/2.x in this example)? I'm new to Sony and learning the a7RV.
With the crop mode you are using a part of the sensor that is exactly the size of an APS-C sensor and with a 60mpx FF sensor that means in effect you are using a 26mpx APS-C sensor. It really is no different. Any time you crop that is what you are doing, using a smaller sensor. When you use that smaller sensor you are magnifying the image if you print it or project it on a screen at the same size which increases the apparent depth of field--magnification always does that. So a 28mm shot at f/1.5 and cropped so that you are using an APS-C sized part of the sensor will look like a 42mm lens shot at f/2.3 looks when you don't crop (i.e., when shot FF 35mm).
p.5 #19Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
Steve Spencer wrote: jeffro wroteSteve Spencer wroteGMPhotography wroteDon't forget you get a crop factor as well which is a 42mm which on the 60mpx sensors its more like 26mpxAnd if you just crop 1.25X (you can't do this in the EVF, but it isn't too hard to estimate) then you have a 35mm perspective with the equivalent of f/1.9 depth of field and about a 40mpx file if you have a 60mpx sensor. Having a 28 f/1.5 at 60mpx, a 35 f/1.9 at 40mpx, and a 40 f/2.3 at 26mpx provides a lot of coverage.So is the crop mode not just a digital zoom that retains the f1.5 depth of field but the depth of field actually changes similar to a crop sensor camera (i.e. f1.5 to f1.9/2.x in this example)? I'm new to Sony and learning the a7RV.With the crop mode you are using a part of the sensor that is exactly the size of an APS-C sensor and with a 60mpx FF sensor that means in effect you are using a 26mpx APS-C sensor. It really is no different. Any time you crop that is what you are doing, using a smaller sensor. When you use that smaller sensor you are magnifying the image if you print it or project it on a screen at the same size which increases the apparent depth of field--magnification always does that. So a 28mm shot at f/1.5 and cropped so that you are using an APS-C sized part of the sensor will look like a 42mm lens shot at f/2.3 looks when you don't crop (i.e., when shot FF 35mm)....Show more →
And I shoot in crop mode a lot for the shows I shoot and those images really are lacking in nothing. So a 42mm is not a bad trade off
p.5 #20Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for E-mount got announced!
ratherfish wrote:
I'll be buying this one! Slots in between my 21/3.5 and my 40/1.2. I also have the 10 and 15. I love my Voigt's! Steve
Me too. Exactly about the slotting in between 21 and 40 bit. But, sheesh. Being a space cadet, when I saw Juha's original post, I figured that the announcement was just a model announcement, and that Map Camera wouldn't take preorders until the actual production product release data announcement.
So I missed being near (not at, no one beats Juha at that) the top of the Map Camera's preorder list. (They didn't take 75/1.5 preorders until loooooooooong after the original product announcement.) Sheesh. But my preorder's in now.
(Translation: Hey Juha, thanks!)
Unlike ratherfish, I passed on the 10 and got a mushy corner copy of the 15. Sigh.
Unlike one commenter in this thread, I've been happy with the corner performance of the Noktons. Sure, they sometimes need to be stopped down to get the corners sharp, but it's near impossible to get subject matter actually on the plane of focus at the corners at wider apertures (at wider apertures, one is usually look for bokeh in the corners). Amusingly, my copy of the 75/1.5 is actually quite sharp in the corners wide open at medium-short focus distances. To see this phenomenon requires a tripod and extremely careful focusing. And the 21/1.4 isn't too shabby in the corners stopped down to f/2.0, which you want for the sunstars.
Also amusingly, Pier (sp?) manages to get gorgeous corners on his interior shots with Noktons. But Pier's a magician.