fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes

  
 
steamtrain
Offline
Details
p.2 #1My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
kakomu wrote:
steamtrain wroteThe 28mm f/1.8 needed a big and clunky body, and the IQ is outdated. It's f/1.8, but it's not a very usable f/1.8 if you want a decent IQ. I think there is a reason the EF 28mm IS USM was only f/2.8 >> to get a good IQ to size/weight ratio.
I disagree.

That's o.k.
kakomu wrote:
I shot that lens almost exclusively at f/1.8-f/2.8. I loved having all of the weird optical effects that came with a wide open lens. Very rarely did a picture suck because of the lens. The lens and its image quality weren't what held me back.

If you really love it you should just adapt it imo.
I'm adapting the EF 28mm f/2.8 IS USM sometimes. In a car museum I needed the drop in filter adapter for a polarizer + best possible image stabilization + a not too thin DOF. The RF pancake can't be combined with the adapter and the Sigma Art doesn't have IS and it's heavy. Just a small lens + adapter isn't that bad for total size and weight.
Sep 24, 2024 at 10:50 AM
Toothwalker
Offline
Details
p.2 #2My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
tkbslc wrote:
50mm - the 35mm is better in every way


That is a dangerous statement to make, when there are so many aspects to lens performance. The 35 mm is certainly better corrected for close-focus applications, but in f/5.6 landscape scenarios the 50 mm is vastly superior in terms of resolution and contrast across the frame.


My main complaint with these lenses is I keep buying them at full MSRP and they have bad resale value. Could have save at 30-50% by going used a year later.


I have experience with the 28, 35, and 50 mm. My main complaint with these lenses is their relatively poor flare resistance, resulting in a low contrast in backlit situations. Apart from that, I don't really have complaints. You can't expect miracles in this price class, but you can get close once you know the strengths and weaknesses of these lenses.

Sep 24, 2024 at 01:51 PM
snegron7
Offline
Details
p.2 #3My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes


kakomu wrote:
I now own or have owned all of Canon's non-L RF prime lenses:


  1. 16mm f/2.8 STM
  2. 24mm f/1.8 IS STM Macro
  3. 28mm f/2.8 STM
  4. 35mm f/1.8 IS STM Macro
  5. 50mm f/1.8 STM
  6. 85mm f/2 IS STM Macro


I've used them all enough to have formed some opinions on them from regular use. Here's my completely subjective opinions on each one. Ask me anything.

RF 16mm f/2.8 STM
This lens is probably one of the more amazing prime lenses I've ever used. Back in the days of yore, the widest (non-fisheye) primes that Canon released were the EF 20mm f/2.8 and the EF 14mm f/2.8. The former was an OK
...Show more →


I currently own the:

- RF 16mm f2.8 STM

-RF 24mm f1.8 Macro (just arrived today)

- RF 28mm f2.8 STM

- RF 35mm f1.8 Macro

- RF 50mm f1.8 STM

I disagree with the RF 24mm feeling "heavy". It feels very light (too light), to the point of feeling like a cheap, plastic lens.

The one thing all these lenses have in common (at least my copies) is that they are not tack sharp at their largest aperture. They all perform better at around f4.0. That being said, they are much sharper at their respective focal lengths (minus the 16mm of course) than the RF 24-105mm F4L that I returned.

Personally, I think the RF 24mm f1.8 and RF 35mm f1.8 are overpriced for what you get. They have the build quality and performance of the cheap Tamron primes I used for my Sony A7c.

While they are less expensive alternatives to the RF-L lenses, they provide roughly the same IQ that typical kit lenses provide. Having faster apertures is useless if the lens performs better only at two f-stops smaller.

It's not that I dislike my RF primes, it's more like I'm unimpressed by them.
Sep 27, 2024 at 01:26 PM
numbertwo
Offline
Details
p.2 #4My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
I think the RF 35 1.8 IQ is great, almost on par with my Tamron 35 1.4 (but with worse LoCA/LaCA).
The problem is that the AF is inconsistent, and in servo mode maybe 50% of the pictures are in focus, and the other 50% are slightly off (Canon R5).
I tested two copies and were indistinguishable
Canon RF 50 1.8 is better than EF versions but not as good as the RF 35 at wide apertures. But stepped down, it’s true that it might have an edge in resolution over the 35, especially because it has lass CA.
I had a first copy slightly tilted that never focused accurately in half of the frame, my second copy is good.
I tested one RF 16 from a friend and it’s quite nice and small, but less sharp than my Tamron 17-35 f2.8-4 at 17mm. But I’m considering to get this one for the convenience.
Sep 27, 2024 at 07:51 PM
Ulff
Offline
Details
p.2 #5My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
I like the RF 28 f2.8. It's the best 28 f2.8 I ever had. The IQ is indistinguishable from that of the 14-35L at shared apertures (although flare-control is better in the L). I'm impressed by its size, weight and sharpness in the edges and corners. It's better than Nikons 26 f2.8 and 28 f2.8 over the whole frame, even stopped down. It's also the only RF lens which converts the R5 into something remotely pocketable (for very large pockets of course). If you need what the 28 has to offer, it won't disappoint!

The RF 50 f1.8 is okay for its price and very sharp over most of the frame. I'm a bit disappointed although, that it it's less sharp, especially in the edges and corners between f4 and f8, than my old FD 50 f1.8, which I bought almost 40 years ago and which it replaces, because I needed AF and even less weight. I use the lens for high-res panos, for which it is perfect because of its size. Very sharp corners also don't matter for this application. The bokeh is also not very good (compared to other 50mm-lenses) - but if the alternatives which made it in the daily photo bag are f4-zooms, it is very welcome nonetheless...
Sep 28, 2024 at 02:35 AM
Z250SA
Offline
Details
p.2 #6My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
Very relevant is this thread! I have the 16 and 28 and had the 85 but switched to the 100 for actual makro.

I was a prime fanboy back in the days, with ZEs as my main optics. But now I find myself using the STM zooms with a select ZE for special occasions only. And yes, the AF of the present bodies has made me very lazy. With that and some focus stacking as the reasons (to cover up for some GAS...) I have looked into the other non-L primes. So this thread is interesting for sure.

But with experience of the non-L zooms, when reading the opinions on corners, sharpness, chromatic aberrations a question pops up frequently: As /almost/ forced correction is part of the lens design, should lens correction be an integral part of the image when we judge the lenses? Maybe not correction of flare, contrast, colour and those that are more a part of the composition and not the optics. But e.g. longitudinal chromatic aberration, who cares? DPP (in my case) fixes that.
Sep 28, 2024 at 11:57 AM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.2 #7My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
The RF 16/2.8, RF 24/1.8, RF 28/2.8 and RF 50/1.8 all use PMO molded aspherical lenses. Like phones. They appear as alien to our understanding of camera lenses, rectangular oddities with wavy profiles.

So if you have some reservations but can't quite put your finger on why, this may be it. Many find the process perfectly acceptable, largely because they like the images. Can't say as I'm a fan of plastic lenses, but I guess the raw materials are pretty cheap, so there's that. Video at this page, at 4:30:

https://petapixel.com/2023/06/27/teardown-shows-odd-elements-in-canon-rf-28mm-f-2-8-pancake-lens/
Sep 28, 2024 at 11:22 PM
steamtrain
Offline
Details
p.2 #8My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
philip_pj wrote:
The RF 16/2.8, RF 24/1.8, RF 28/2.8 and RF 50/1.8 all use PMO molded aspherical lenses. Like phones. They appear as alien to our understanding of camera lenses, rectangular oddities with wavy profiles.

So the 35&85mm are the exceptions here?

The profile of the 85mm isn't wavy at all. Don't know about the 35mm.
philip_pj wrote:
So if you have some reservations but can't quite put your finger on why, this may be it. Many find the process perfectly acceptable, largely because they like the images. Can't say as I'm a fan of plastic lenses, but I guess the raw materials are pretty cheap, so there's that. Video at this page, at 4:30:

https://petapixel.com/2023/06/27/teardown-shows-odd-elements-in-canon-rf-28mm-f-2-8-pancake-lens/


I think the 16mm and 28mm are fine for what they are. Compactness + a relatively low price are the design goals here, and I think Canon created nice and fun options here. The 24 and 50mm need 500-600g better options next to it. The 24-240, 24-105mm stm, 24-50mm stm, 28-70mm f/2.8 all lack a non distorted 24mm. It's disappointing the 24mm prime has quite some distortion as well.
Sep 29, 2024 at 01:38 PM
c102690
Offline
Details
p.2 #9My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
My experience has been with the RF 35 & 50. I love the 35 and use it often. For the 50, I just don't like the quality of images from this lens (wide open at 1.8) compared to Sigma EF 50 1.4. I ended up selling the RF 50 1.8 and kept my Sigma lens. Hope to get the 50 L version when I can but I'm happy with the Sigma for now.
Sep 29, 2024 at 02:51 PM
steamtrain
Offline
Details
p.2 #10My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
c102690 wrote:
My experience has been with the RF 35 & 50. I love the 35 and use it often. For the 50, I just don't like the quality of images from this lens (wide open at 1.8) compared to Sigma EF 50 1.4. I ended up selling the RF 50 1.8 and kept my Sigma lens. Hope to get the 50 L version when I can but I'm happy with the Sigma for now.


The Sigma 50mm f/1.4 Art is a much better lens, and it's a shame Canon isn't providing a light weight RF f/1.4 version.
Sep 30, 2024 at 10:15 AM
BigBabyMoses06
Online
Details
p.2 #11My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
My only issues with all of these, and the non L zoom STM lenses, is how horrible the chatter/pulsing/micro adjusting they are on servo mode focus. Borderline unusable.One shot focus is fine, works well, but I primarily only shoot with servo.
Sep 30, 2024 at 11:06 PM
kakomu
Offline
Details
p.2 #12My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
Z250SA wrote:
Very relevant is this thread! I have the 16 and 28 and had the 85 but switched to the 100 for actual makro.

I was a prime fanboy back in the days, with ZEs as my main optics. But now I find myself using the STM zooms with a select ZE for special occasions only. And yes, the AF of the present bodies has made me very lazy. With that and some focus stacking as the reasons (to cover up for some GAS...) I have looked into the other non-L primes. So this thread is interesting for sure.

But with experience
...Show more →

I think most concerns about image quality, distortion, corner sharpness, CA (of all stripes and varieties) for our modern mirrorless cameras are way overblown, along with the hand wringing about in-camera corrections and lens profiles. When I look back on the images I produced with my Rebel XTi (My first DSLR) or anything I shot with 35mm, I can see a marked increase in quality across the board.

I've printed many of my photographs in the past and I find that the optical defects rarely detract from the photo. One of my favorite prints was a defished photograph taken with a Soviet-era Zenitar fisheye (You want to talk LOCA?). Several others were taken with the (currently maligned, but previously adored) EF 17-40 f/4L.

I know where I'm posting this, but sometimes us gear heads need to stop fetishizing ultimate IQ and work toward the artistic pursuits that photography is all about. We're living in a golden age of cheap, high quality, photographic gear. I think nitpicking IQ in the gear is a distraction. For me, the only things that matter are: How easily can I use this? and How annoying is this to carry? Small, light-weight, easy to pack, easy to carry and convenient are what matters. Anything else is secondary.

Remember, as the old saying goes: "f/8 and be there".

Edited on Oct 01, 2024 at 08:44 AM · View previous versions
Oct 01, 2024 at 08:37 AM
kakomu
Offline
Details
p.2 #13My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
BigBabyMoses06 wrote:
My only issues with all of these, and the non L zoom STM lenses, is how horrible the chatter/pulsing/micro adjusting they are on servo mode focus. Borderline unusable.One shot focus is fine, works well, but I primarily only shoot with servo.


I can't say that I've encountered any of those problems. The STM motors are only marginally louder than the 2000-2010s era USM that I've had the most experience with (probably quieter than 90s era USM). It's probably slower than higher end USM, but I can't say it's any more or less decisive than, say, the EF 24-70 f/2.8L.
Oct 01, 2024 at 08:43 AM
snegron7
Offline
Details
p.2 #14My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes

kakomu wrote:
Z250SA wroteVery relevant is this thread! I have the 16 and 28 and had the 85 but switched to the 100 for actual makro.

I was a prime fanboy back in the days, with ZEs as my main optics. But now I find myself using the STM zooms with a select ZE for special occasions only. And yes, the AF of the present bodies has made me very lazy. With that and some focus stacking as the reasons (to cover up for some GAS...) I have looked into the other non-L primes. So this thread is interesting for sure.

But with experience of the non-L zooms, when reading the opinions on corners, sharpness, chromatic aberrations a question pops up frequently: As /almost/ forced correction is part of the lens design, should lens correction be an integral part of the image when we judge the lenses? Maybe not correction of flare, contrast, colour and those that are more a part of the composition and not the optics. But e.g. longitudinal chromatic aberration, who cares? DPP (in my case) fixes that.
I think most concerns about image quality, distortion, corner sharpness, CA (of all stripes and varieties) for our modern mirrorless cameras are way overblown, along with the hand wringing about in-camera corrections and lens profiles. When I look back on the images I produced with my Rebel XTi (My first DSLR) or anything I shot with 35mm, I can see a marked increase in quality across the board.

I've printed many of my photographs in the past and I find that the optical defects rarely detract from the photo. One of my favorite prints was a defished photograph taken with
...Show more →


I am glad for you and respect your opinion. On the other hand, I have been taking pictures since the late 1970's, and I still remember when lenses and cameras were built to last using high quality materials.

I still have manual focus Nikon, Canon Pentax, and Mamiya lenses that can outperform many of these newer "plastic fantastic" lenses made for mirrorless cameras.

Prices for new gear are considerably more expensive today than they were back in the old days, even factoring for inflation (the exception being the 50mm f1.8).

If a ribbon or contact goes bad on your modern day lens, it becomes a useless paperweight.

These RF primes sold by Canon are a "bargain" when compared to L series lenses, with the exception of the RF 24mm f1.8 Macro and the RF 35mm f1.8 Macro. These two lenses cost almost double of what the RF 16mm f2.8 STM, RF 28mm f2.8 STM and RF 50mm f1.8 STM cost. For almost double the price you get IS and closer focusing. Canon seems to be focusing more on the cool little tricks these lenses can do instead of their optical quality. Some folks like myself care more about the image quality than what neat little tricks the lens can do. The idea (for me at least) is that prime lenses are supposed to offer two major advantages over zoom lenses: sharper/better IQ than zooms and a smaller footprint. The idea of using lesser expensive primes is that you can obtain excellent IQ images with the inconvenience of a single focal length and no weather resistance. I believe Canon has failed, and as a person who spent $2,000+ on an R6II, I am disappointed that Canon has gone this route.
Oct 01, 2024 at 09:02 AM
johnvanr
Offline
Details
p.2 #15My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
Just realize I’ve had or have all of these lenses as well, except for the 24mm.

Sold the 16mm. Too wide, esp. since Canon isn’t my main system.

Sold the 35mm. Too large and I’m not really a 35mm shooter.

Have the 28 and 50 as walk-around lenses when I take my Canon gear for actually walking round, which rare, but the lenses are decent, small and affordable.

Have the 85 because it’s part of my Canon as my model and portrait setup, together with some L glass. Haven’t used it much, though.

Oct 01, 2024 at 09:10 AM
Pixelpuffin
Offline
Details
p.2 #16My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes


steamtrain wrote:
c102690 wroteMy experience has been with the RF 35 & 50. I love the 35 and use it often. For the 50, I just don't like the quality of images from this lens (wide open at 1.8) compared to Sigma EF 50 1.4. I ended up selling the RF 50 1.8 and kept my Sigma lens. Hope to get the 50 L version when I can but I'm happy with the Sigma for now.
The Sigma 50mm f/1.4 Art is a much better lens, and it's a shame Canon isn't providing a light weight RF f/1.4 version.


Well even if they did make a RF 50/1.4 chances are it would be too expensive for most to afford

Oct 01, 2024 at 11:28 AM
kakomu
Offline
Details
p.2 #17My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
snegron7 wrote:
The idea of using lesser expensive primes is that you can obtain excellent IQ images with the inconvenience of a single focal length and no weather resistance. I believe Canon has failed


I can't imagine how you came to that conclusion. For instance, if you compare the RF 35mm f/1.8 to the RF 24-70mm f/2.8, the 35mm is cheaper, smaller, lighter and focuses closer. At f/2.8, the 35mm appears to have better image quality than the 24-70mm, plus the 35mm goes to f/1.8.
Oct 01, 2024 at 12:39 PM
BigBabyMoses06
Online
Details
p.2 #18My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
Interesting! I've seen people say what I'm saying, and some of what you're saying. Most of my research parots my servo focus issues (or maybe those are the issues I see because I'm searching for them). Here is the issue, exactly as I've experienced. The 50 is the worst culprit of this, but I've experienced it on all 3 50mm copies I've tried, my rf 35 1.8, and even a sigma 50 art to a much lesser extent. I've gotten the same results on various bodies too. Rp, R6, R5, and R6ii. All updated firmware, all kinds of lighting scenarios, indoors, outdoors. Etc.

https://youtu.be/2jptIxwwyv8?si=RHCuXT0jf575-jy-

I really really really want to love them, and want to buy them again, but I can't because of this, and I've never seen Canon address it. If you plan to shoot one shot focus, they're great. Or if you're lucky enough to not experience this, they're great.

kakomu wrote:
BigBabyMoses06 wroteMy only issues with all of these, and the non L zoom STM lenses, is how horrible the chatter/pulsing/micro adjusting they are on servo mode focus. Borderline unusable.One shot focus is fine, works well, but I primarily only shoot with servo.
I can't say that I've encountered any of those problems. The STM motors are only marginally louder than the 2000-2010s era USM that I've had the most experience with (probably quieter than 90s era USM). It's probably slower than higher end USM, but I can't say it's any more or less decisive than, say, the EF 24-70 f/2.8L.

Oct 01, 2024 at 12:45 PM
Gochugogi
Offline
Details
p.2 #19My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
BigBabyMoses06 wrote:
I really really really want to love them, and want to buy them again, but I can't because of this, and I've never seen Canon address it. If you plan to shoot one shot focus, they're great. Or if you're lucky enough to not experience this, they're great.



Save for sports and moving critters, I rarely bothered with servo when I shot SLR and DSLRs. I continued those habits with mirrorless. If I need servo it's a button press away. I'm in one-shot or MF most of the time. I figured the RF 35 1.8 Macro IS STM was designed as a one-shot lens since it is aimed at macro, low light and wide views. Not really a sports and critter lens. But, yeah, it and the RF 85 2.0 Macro IS STM are utter crap in AI servo mode and yet they do well what they were designed for.
Oct 01, 2024 at 02:00 PM
steamtrain
Offline
Details
p.2 #20My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
Gochugogi wrote:
BigBabyMoses06 wroteI really really really want to love them, and want to buy them again, but I can't because of this, and I've never seen Canon address it. If you plan to shoot one shot focus, they're great. Or if you're lucky enough to not experience this, they're great.
Save for sports and moving critters, I rarely bothered with servo when I shot SLR and DSLRs. I continued those habits with mirrorless. If I need servo it's a button press away. I'm in one-shot or MF most of the time. I figured the RF 35 1.8 Macro IS STM was designed as a one-shot lens since it is aimed at macro, low light and wide views.

What a nonsense. It's not aimed at macro, it's just a general purpose lens with a 0.5x magnification, but there's no 1x magnification.
Furthermore, there's no reason to make such a lens with the poor AF Canon gave it. You can make a low light lens with fast AF in servo, you can make a wide view lens with fast AF in servo, and you can make a lens with 0.5x magnification with fast AF in servo, and you can make a lens doing it all WITH fast AF in servo. There's zero relationship between the design goals of this lens and the poor AF it has.

Gochugogi wrote:
Not really a sports and critter lens. But, yeah, it and the RF 85 2.0 Macro IS STM are utter crap in AI servo mode and yet they do well what they were designed for.

Canon should probably focus a bit more on what these lenses should have been designed for. A bright 85mm is very useful for sports. Sony has the f/1.4 GMII. Canon has the DSRL EF 85mm f/1.4 IS USM lens. That one is designed to focus fast enough for your sport shoots. The RF 85mm lenses are not. The DSLR lens is designed to fringe a lot, to be quite heavy, to need an adapter, but hey, that all fits it's design goals, so who cares.

The best f/1.4 sports lens for Canon shooters is still the Sigma 105mm f/1.4 Art. It's not designed for sports, it's designed for portraits of the bride on a wedding, and yet it's AF is fast enough on Canon RF bodies to shoot sports with it, better than native first brand RF 85mm lenses, despite all the blah blah about extra electronic contacts that came with the RF mount for extra good AF etc etc. Maybe Canon should realise design goals isn't about cr*ppling, but about enabling.
Oct 01, 2024 at 02:46 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister