p.3 #1My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
steamtrain wrote: Gochugogi wroteBigBabyMoses06 wroteI really really really want to love them, and want to buy them again, but I can't because of this, and I've never seen Canon address it. If you plan to shoot one shot focus, they're great. Or if you're lucky enough to not experience this, they're great.Save for sports and moving critters, I rarely bothered with servo when I shot SLR and DSLRs. I continued those habits with mirrorless. If I need servo it's a button press away. I'm in one-shot or MF most of the time. I figured the RF 35 1.8 Macro IS STM was designed as a one-shot lens since it is aimed at macro, low light and wide views.What a nonsense. It's not aimed at macro, it's just a general purpose lens with a 0.5x magnification, but there's no 1x magnification.
Furthermore, there's no reason to make such a lens with the poor AF Canon gave it. You can make a low light lens with fast AF in servo, you can make a wide view lens with fast AF in servo, and you can make a lens with 0.5x magnification with fast AF in servo, and you can make a lens doing it all WITH fast AF in servo. There's zero relationship between the design goals of this lens and the poor AF it has.
Canon should probably focus a bit more on what these lenses should have been designed for. A bright 85mm is very useful for sports. Sony has the f/1.4 GMII. Canon has the DSRL EF 85mm f/1.4 IS USM lens. That one is designed to focus fast enough for your sport shoots. The RF 85mm lenses are not. The DSLR lens is designed to fringe a lot, to be quite heavy, to need an adapter, but hey, that all fits it's design goals, so who cares.
The best f/1.4 sports lens for Canon shooters is still the Sigma 105mm f/1.4 Art. It's not designed for sports, it's designed for portraits of the bride on a wedding, and yet it's AF is fast enough on Canon RF bodies to shoot sports with it, better than native first brand RF 85mm lenses, despite all the blah blah about extra electronic contacts that came with the RF mount for extra good AF etc etc. Maybe Canon should realise design goals isn't about cr*ppling, but about enabling. ...Show more →Gochugogi wroteNot really a sports and critter lens. But, yeah, it and the RF 85 2.0 Macro IS STM are utter crap in AI servo mode and yet they do well what they were designed for.
The 85 1.2 Does Just fine at sports IMO- Taken Sunday-
Canon EOS R5m2RF85mm F1.2 L USM lens85mmf/1.41/16000s160 ISO0.0 EV
p.3 #3My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
BigBabyMoses06 wrote:
Interesting! I've seen people say what I'm saying, and some of what you're saying. Most of my research parots my servo focus issues (or maybe those are the issues I see because I'm searching for them). Here is the issue, exactly as I've experienced. The 50 is the worst culprit of this, but I've experienced it on all 3 50mm copies I've tried, my rf 35 1.8, and even a sigma 50 art to a much lesser extent. I've gotten the same results on various bodies too. Rp, R6, R5, and R6ii. All updated firmware, all kinds of lighting scenarios, indoors, outdoors. Etc.
I really really really want to love them, and want to buy them again, but I can't because of this, and I've never seen Canon address it. If you plan to shoot one shot focus, they're great. Or if you're lucky enough to not experience this, they're great.
...Show more →kakomu wroteBigBabyMoses06 wroteMy only issues with all of these, and the non L zoom STM lenses, is how horrible the chatter/pulsing/micro adjusting they are on servo mode focus. Borderline unusable.One shot focus is fine, works well, but I primarily only shoot with servo.I can't say that I've encountered any of those problems. The STM motors are only marginally louder than the 2000-2010s era USM that I've had the most experience with (probably quieter than 90s era USM). It's probably slower than higher end USM, but I can't say it's any more or less decisive than, say, the EF 24-70 f/2.8L.
That's a pretty funky video. The worst I've encountered with STM lenses tends to be full rack hunting and then a handful of steps to focus, but most of the time it functions similarly to USM (but with a hum instead of a whoosh sound)
p.3 #4My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
Gochugogi wrote:
I figured the RF 35 1.8 Macro IS STM was designed as a one-shot lens since it is aimed at macro, low light and wide views.
steamtrain wrote:
What a nonsense. It's not aimed at macro, it's just a general purpose lens with a 0.5x magnification, but there's no 1x magnification. Furthermore, there's no reason to make such a lens with the poor AF Canon gave it.
What nonsense! The 35 f1.8 macro does everything I'd want it to. It's sharp, fast and accurate AF, doesn't weigh too much and is a handy closeup lens. I've used it for night sky, deep jungle closeups of fungi and interior people pictures. Does well at all of that. If you can't track skateboarders doing loop de loops then I'd suggest you are using the wrong lens. I'm sure Canon makes one, you'll just have to pay for it. My main lens is the 24-105 f4L, it is magnificent, and what it doesn't do well the 35 does. Don't whine, pick the correct tool. Doesn't have to be Canon.
p.3 #5My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
Jeff Nolten wrote: Gochugogi wroteI figured the RF 35 1.8 Macro IS STM was designed as a one-shot lens since it is aimed at macro, low light and wide views.steamtrain wroteWhat a nonsense. It's not aimed at macro, it's just a general purpose lens with a 0.5x magnification, but there's no 1x magnification. Furthermore, there's no reason to make such a lens with the poor AF Canon gave it.What nonsense! The 35 f1.8 macro does everything I'd want it to.
That's because you don't want it to AF fast.
Jeff Nolten wrote:
It's sharp, fast and accurate AF, doesn't weigh too much and is a handy closeup lens. I've used it for night sky, deep jungle closeups of fungi and interior people pictures. Does well at all of that. If you can't track skateboarders doing loop de loops then I'd suggest you are using the wrong lens.
With Canon the 40mm f/1.4 Art does the job. The old EF 35mm f/2.0 IS USM does it as well. On my Sony 50mm f/1.2 GM is great. I can use the 28mm f/1.4 Art on the Canon. It might even focus fast enough on the Sony via MC11, but I never tried it for fast action on the Sony.
Jeff Nolten wrote:
I'm sure Canon makes one, you'll just have to pay for it. Jeff Nolten wroteRF 35mm f/1.4 USM will do it, but that's not as compact as the f/1.8 IS stm. The GM is even more compact, and for FE there is at least a fast focusing mirrorless 85mm, although, like the RF 35mm f/1.4, it was late to the party.My main lens is the 24-105 f4L, it is magnificent, and what it doesn't do well the 35 does. Don't whine, pick the correct tool. Doesn't have to be Canon.
So for you it's either f/4.0 only for freezing action or bringing an extra lens next to the compact 35mm. Bringing extra lenses isn't compact. It's great you don't need fast AF, but for those who do it's disappointing Canon didn't come up with compact fast focusing options, especially in the context the old EF primes did have it (EF 35mm f/2.0 IS USM, EF 85mm f/1.8 USM, EF 100mm f/2.0 USM, EF 85mm f/1.4 IS USM).
p.3 #6My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
That's a great shot, and the IQ is top notch.
However, one picture doesn't tell a lot about keeper rate. It's also not crazy challenging as the movement is pretty predictable. For that kind of sports you can almost use manual focusing, pre-focus, shoot a burst, and pick the pictures in focus. Almost. Not entirely, but the adjustments AF has to made using that technique are pretty minor.
There are sports where the movements are less predictable though.
p.3 #7My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
steamtrain wrote: Gochugogi wroteBigBabyMoses06 wroteI really really really want to love them, and want to buy them again, but I can't because of this, and I've never seen Canon address it. If you plan to shoot one shot focus, they're great. Or if you're lucky enough to not experience this, they're great.Save for sports and moving critters, I rarely bothered with servo when I shot SLR and DSLRs. I continued those habits with mirrorless. If I need servo it's a button press away. I'm in one-shot or MF most of the time. I figured the RF 35 1.8 Macro IS STM was designed as a one-shot lens since it is aimed at macro, low light and wide views.What a nonsense. It's not aimed at macro, it's just a general purpose lens with a 0.5x magnification, but there's no 1x magnification.
Furthermore, there's no reason to make such a lens with the poor AF Canon gave it. You can make a low light lens with fast AF in servo, you can make a wide view lens with fast AF in servo, and you can make a lens with 0.5x magnification with fast AF in servo, and you can make a lens doing it all WITH fast AF in servo. There's zero relationship between the design goals of this lens and the poor AF it has.
Canon should probably focus a bit more on what these lenses should have been designed for. A bright 85mm is very useful for sports. Sony has the f/1.4 GMII. Canon has the DSRL EF 85mm f/1.4 IS USM lens. That one is designed to focus fast enough for your sport shoots. The RF 85mm lenses are not. The DSLR lens is designed to fringe a lot, to be quite heavy, to need an adapter, but hey, that all fits it's design goals, so who cares.
The best f/1.4 sports lens for Canon shooters is still the Sigma 105mm f/1.4 Art. It's not designed for sports, it's designed for portraits of the bride on a wedding, and yet it's AF is fast enough on Canon RF bodies to shoot sports with it, better than native first brand RF 85mm lenses, despite all the blah blah about extra electronic contacts that came with the RF mount for extra good AF etc etc. Maybe Canon should realise design goals isn't about cr*ppling, but about enabling. ...Show more →Gochugogi wroteNot really a sports and critter lens. But, yeah, it and the RF 85 2.0 Macro IS STM are utter crap in AI servo mode and yet they do well what they were designed for.
Well duh, the RF 35 1.8 Macro IS STM moniker includes the word "Macro." I'm sure Canon knows more about what a macro lens is than you do. Unlike non-macro designs, the RF 35 1.8 Macro IS STM is well corrected at macro distances, features a hybrid macro style IS (angular and shift camera shake) and a ring light mount on the front of the barrel (that's why it can't take a dedicated hood). My prior macro lens, the EF 50 2.5 Compact Macro, was also .5X (as was my Nikkor 50 3.5 AI). I had to use MF at .5X since AF wasn't practical. You could have 1X on a 50mm or 35mm lens but it would be useless since you'd be so close no light would fall on your subject. 1X on a 35mm would only be practical for copying slides and negs. Nevertheless, the RF 35 1.8 Macro IS USM is a brilliant lens for small products, flowers, art objects and documents. And it focuses perfectly and plenty fast for what it was designed to do. It was only $320 new at Adorama and I was pleased with performance. If you want a nano USM macro lens with inner element focus and F1.4 aperture you'll have to pay at 4 or 5 times more.
Incidentally, the Oxford Dictionary defines macro lens as "a lens suitable for taking photographs unusually close to the subject." It's not a particular magnification made popular by internet pundits, AF ability or compatibility with bellows. It just focuses close.
p.3 #8My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
Gochugogi wrote: steamtrain wroteGochugogi wroteBigBabyMoses06 wroteI really really really want to love them, and want to buy them again, but I can't because of this, and I've never seen Canon address it. If you plan to shoot one shot focus, they're great. Or if you're lucky enough to not experience this, they're great.Save for sports and moving critters, I rarely bothered with servo when I shot SLR and DSLRs. I continued those habits with mirrorless. If I need servo it's a button press away. I'm in one-shot or MF most of the time. I figured the RF 35 1.8 Macro IS STM was designed as a one-shot lens since it is aimed at macro, low light and wide views.What a nonsense. It's not aimed at macro, it's just a general purpose lens with a 0.5x magnification, but there's no 1x magnification.
Furthermore, there's no reason to make such a lens with the poor AF Canon gave it. You can make a low light lens with fast AF in servo, you can make a wide view lens with fast AF in servo, and you can make a lens with 0.5x magnification with fast AF in servo, and you can make a lens doing it all WITH fast AF in servo. There's zero relationship between the design goals of this lens and the poor AF it has.
Gochugogi wroteNot really a sports and critter lens. But, yeah, it and the RF 85 2.0 Macro IS STM are utter crap in AI servo mode and yet they do well what they were designed for.Canon should probably focus a bit more on what these lenses should have been designed for. A bright 85mm is very useful for sports. Sony has the f/1.4 GMII. Canon has the DSRL EF 85mm f/1.4 IS USM lens. That one is designed to focus fast enough for your sport shoots. The RF 85mm lenses are not. The DSLR lens is designed to fringe a lot, to be quite heavy, to need an adapter, but hey, that all fits it's design goals, so who cares.
The best f/1.4 sports lens for Canon shooters is still the Sigma 105mm f/1.4 Art. It's not designed for sports, it's designed for portraits of the bride on a wedding, and yet it's AF is fast enough on Canon RF bodies to shoot sports with it, better than native first brand RF 85mm lenses, despite all the blah blah about extra electronic contacts that came with the RF mount for extra good AF etc etc. Maybe Canon should realise design goals isn't about cr*ppling, but about enabling.Well duh, the RF 35 1.8 Macro IS STM moniker includes the word "Macro." I'm sure Canon knows more about
Marketing. To be fair: the Zeiss 50mm f/2.0 carries the "macro" moniker as well.
Gochugogi wrote:
what a macro lens is than you do. Unlike non-macro designs, the RF 35 1.8 Macro IS STM is well corrected at macro distances, features a hybrid macro style IS (angular and shift camera shake) and a ring light mount on the front of the barrel (that's why it can't take a dedicated hood). My prior macro lens, the EF 50 2.5 Compact Macro, was also .5X (as was my Nikkor 50 3.5 AI). I had to use MF at .5X since AF wasn't practical. You could have 1X on a 50mm or 35mm lens but it would be useless since you'd be so close no light would fall on your subject. ...Show more →
The EF-s 35mm f/2.8 IS stm had those build in led lights, and so did the ef-m 28mm f/3.5 IS stm. The latter on crop is 45mm equivalent and has even an 1.2 times magnification which shows it should be doable at 50mm on full frame as well. You'll need to bring in light, however, that's not impossible, and it's true for a lot of macro shooting anyway.
Gochugogi wrote:
1X on a 35mm would only be practical for copying slides and negs. Nevertheless, the RF 35 1.8 Macro IS USM is a brilliant lens for small products, flowers, art objects and documents. And it focuses perfectly and plenty fast for what it was designed to do.
Using that logic design flaws can logically not exist by definition. If that makes you happy that's fine, but it doesn't give us a fast focusing compact RF 35mm option.
Gochugogi wrote:
It was only $320 new at Adorama and I was pleased with performance. If you want a nano USM macro lens with inner element focus and F1.4 aperture you'll have to pay at 4 or 5 times more.
Incidentally, the Oxford Dictionary defines macro lens as "a lens suitable for taking photographs unusually close to the subject." It's not a particular magnification made popular by internet pundits, AF ability or compatibility with bellows. It just focuses close.
That's fine, but it's just a general purpose lens so there's no reason to leave out fast AF, especially in the context of no other compact RF lens giving it. It's fine to give macro or "macro" options, but that's no excuse for not giving compact fast focusing options. Now at the 35mm focal length the new RF f/1.4 USM might be doable for size and weight for some, but it took Canon very long to bring this lens. The situations is still problematic at the 85mm focal length, and the same is true for 50mm. Either compact of huge, there's simply no RF fast focusing prime option there.
Of course there's the logic "If Canon doesn't make it you shouldn't need it" but my photographical needs aren't dictated by Canons unambitiousness in design goals.
p.3 #9My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
steamtrain wrote:
So for you it's either f/4.0 only for freezing action or bringing an extra lens next to the compact 35mm. Bringing extra lenses isn't compact. It's great you don't need fast AF, but for those who do it's disappointing Canon didn't come up with compact fast focusing options, especially in the context the old EF primes did have it (EF 35mm f/2.0 IS USM, EF 85mm f/1.8 USM, EF 100mm f/2.0 USM, EF 85mm f/1.4 IS USM).
Your applications are clearly different than mine. I do travel and wildlife photography. I never do sports or other "action" photography requiring both fast aperture and high speed. If I did I would buy the appropriate lens - probably one of the f2.8 L zooms that I've never felt the need for. I like getting closeups of flowers, bugs, poison dart frogs, fungi, etc. and 1:2 magnification is sufficient. If you need 1:1 or better I suggest the 100L macro which does 1.4:1 in the RF mount and is nano-USM.
My main travel kit is an R5 + 16 f2.8, 24-105L, 35 f1.8, 100-500 L. It is heavy but I can manage it and it covers all my needs. This year I've photographed birds in flight in Baja and Costa Rica with the R5 and 100-500 and found it filled my needs well enough that I'm passing on the R5 II. For your sports I figure you'd better spend the money.
I've been using the 24-105 as my main lens since my original 5D days and find it covers my needs excellently. f2.8 is nice for auroras and night sky but the ISO capability of digital cameras and post processing noise correction replaces the need for faster apertures for standard use. IMHO. I've never been a fan of one eyeball in focus shallow DOF and often now use focus stacking for closeup work. YMMV. Canon releases what Canon releases and no point whining about what they should've done. Another brand may suite you better.
BTW, I have the EF 35 f2 and find its USM AF drive very nervous and noisy when mounted on the R5. Sounds like the RF 85 f2. It was a good lens on the DSLR but I like the RF version much better.
p.3 #10My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
Jeff Nolten wrote:
BTW, I have the EF 35 f2 and find its USM AF drive very nervous and noisy when mounted on the R5. Sounds like the RF 85 f2. It was a good lens on the DSLR but I like the RF version much better.
Yes, the sound isn't great, but the nervousness is in the sound only, the results are accurate and the focusing fast. The RF 85mm lens has a harder job to do of course as the focal length is longer.
I'm not using the EF 35mm that often. As long as weight isn't a problem I pick the 40 Art or the 50 GM though. I love to use those large apertures to freeze the action. The EF 35mm is nice, but the RF 35mm is more compact without the adapter, and the RF is a hair sharper and a little brighter, and the ILIS is better. So there is definitely some ointment there around the aforementioned fly.
p.3 #11My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
Jeff Nolten wrote: steamtrain wroteSo for you it's either f/4.0 only for freezing action or bringing an extra lens next to the compact 35mm. Bringing extra lenses isn't compact. It's great you don't need fast AF, but for those who do it's disappointing Canon didn't come up with compact fast focusing options, especially in the context the old EF primes did have it (EF 35mm f/2.0 IS USM, EF 85mm f/1.8 USM, EF 100mm f/2.0 USM, EF 85mm f/1.4 IS USM).Your applications are clearly different than mine. I do travel and wildlife photography. I never do sports or other "action" photography requiring both fast aperture and high speed. If I did I would buy the appropriate lens - probably one of the f2.8 L zooms that I've never felt the need for. I like getting closeups of flowers, bugs, poison dart frogs, fungi, etc. and 1:2 magnification is sufficient. If you need 1:1 or better I suggest the 100L macro which does 1.4:1 in the RF mount and is nano-USM.
My main travel kit is an R5 + 16 f2.8, 24-105L, 35 f1.8, 100-500 L. It is heavy but I can manage it and it covers all my needs. This year I've photographed birds in flight in Baja and Costa Rica with the R5 and 100-500 and found it filled my needs well enough that I'm passing on the R5 II. For your sports I figure you'd better spend the money. ...Show more →
I'm skipping the mkII as well. The R5mkI body performs adequate for me, also for my sports shooting. I'm also not sure if I want to stick with Canon. I love my 787g 50mm f/1.2 GM, my 630g Sigma 85mm f/1.4 DN, my Tamron 35-150mm f/2.0-2.8, and the 230g Samyang 75mm f/1.8.
Leaving anything longer than 105mm or 150mm at home is my great weight saver. And a 157g 20mm prime can do the wide stuff for me (like the RF 16mm a nice just in case wide angle).
Jeff Nolten wrote:
I've been using the 24-105 as my main lens since my original 5D days and find it covers my needs excellently. f2.8 is nice for auroras and night sky but the ISO capability of digital cameras and post processing noise correction replaces the need for faster apertures for standard use. IMHO. I've never been a fan of one eyeball in focus shallow DOF and often now use focus stacking for closeup work. YMMV.
For sports the distance to the camera is pretty large. You're shooting quite environmental portraits when shooting sports so the DOF is generally large enough anyway.
Shooting portraits from the waist up let alone head and shoulders can't be done wide open. That's not a problem, as you can stop down. :-)
Jeff Nolten wrote:
Canon releases what Canon releases and no point whining about what they should've done. Another brand may suite you better.
I'm shooting both Canon and Sony, but I would prefer to shoot one brand. It's impossible though given the unsatisfying RF glass situation.
p.3 #12My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
steamtrain wrote:
It's impossible though given the unsatisfying RF glass situation.
I think your standards are far too high. Canon has produced top tier lenses used around the world by professionals for just about any application. Astonishing photographs able to evoke strong emotions and wow people have been made using canon lenses and bodies since the birth of modern SLR camera autofocus.
If you can't get the shot with a Canon, I think your expectations are unreasonable.
Though, only Nikon and Hasselblad get to talk about photographing from space, I suppose.
p.3 #13My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
steamtrain wrote: Gochugogi wroteWell duh, the RF 35 1.8 Macro IS STM moniker includes the word "Macro." I'm sure Canon knows more aboutMarketing. To be fair: the Zeiss 50mm f/2.0 carries the "macro" moniker as well.
I have that one and the Zeiss 100mm f/2 Makro Planar ZE as well. I’m looking at a photo of a bee in a flower zoomed 300% in another window, taken with the 100mm Makro Planar on a 21Mpx camera, and I can see all the bee’s parts with detail of the hairs; the bee is around 10cm across on my Retina screen. This absolutely is macro by any reasonable definition, even though I only set out to get a shot of a California Poppy in bloom.
A 100mm f/2 lens with 1:2 magnification is extremely useful, and I would expect an 85mm f/2 with 1:2 to also be extremely useful, especially since it also has AF. The only question would be about its quality, which is the subject of this thread.
A “macro” lens never had to be 1:1. Tamron’s huge-selling 90mm macro of the manual focus era was 1:2 and came in a kit with an extension tube to get to 1:1 (I still have this in a cupboard). Canon’s own TS-E macros are 1:2, if you can still find one.
p.3 #14My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
melcat wrote: steamtrain wroteGochugogi wroteWell duh, the RF 35 1.8 Macro IS STM moniker includes the word "Macro." I'm sure Canon knows more aboutMarketing. To be fair: the Zeiss 50mm f/2.0 carries the "macro" moniker as well.I have that one and the Zeiss 100mm f/2 Makro Planar ZE as well.
I've been thinking about a used copy of that 50mm, but I don't think it's for me. It weights less than my Samyang f/1.2 XP at least.
melcat wrote:
I’m looking at a photo of a bee in a flower zoomed 300% in another window, taken with the 100mm Makro Planar on a 21Mpx camera, and I can see all the bee’s parts with detail of the hairs; the bee is around 10cm across on my Retina screen. This absolutely is macro by any reasonable
That depends on the definition of the descriptor reasonable.
melcat wrote:
definition, even though I only set out to get a shot of a California Poppy in bloom.
A 100mm f/2 lens with 1:2 magnification is extremely useful, and I would expect an 85mm f/2 with 1:2 to also be extremely useful, especially since it also has AF. The only question would be about its quality, which is the subject of this thread.
Yup.
melcat wrote:
A “macro” lens never had
Well, that depends on the definition used for the word macro, and definitions being reasonable for some might be unreasonable for others and vice versa. Whatever the definition, a 0.5x magnification isn't a 1x magnification. There are enough lenses out there with a 1x magnification focusing faster and more accurate than the RF 85mm f/2.0 IS stm. I don't care the thing doesn't what I want it to do, the real problem is the lack of an option which does. The RF 85mm f/2.0 IS stm simply has to be the general purpose 85mm, as there's no other native option under 1200g, 3300 euro, and in fact, no other fast focusing option being capable of tracking fast erratic movement at all.
melcat wrote:
to be 1:1. Tamron’s huge-selling 90mm macro of the manual focus era was 1:2 and came in a kit with an extension tube to get to 1:1 (I still have this in a cupboard). Canon’s own TS-E macros are 1:2, if you can still find one.
Compared to a 0.1x magnification a lens with 0.25 magnification can be called a macro lens. However, you can call a lens with a 0.1x magnification a macro lens as well, and you can also use the descriptor exclusively for a 2.0x or 5.0x magnification. Sometimes some people draw a line somewhere, even though others will draw lines elsewhere.
p.3 #15My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
steamtrain wrote:
There are enough lenses out there with a 1x magnification focusing faster and more accurate than the RF 85mm f/2.0 IS stm.
Any with f/2?
Compared to a 0.1x magnification a lens with 0.25 magnification can be called a macro lens. However, you can call a lens with a 0.1x magnification a macro lens as well, and you can also use the descriptor exclusively for a 2.0x or 5.0x magnification.
General usage going back 40 or more years is clear. If we go back farther than that people didn’t use “macro lenses” as such, they usually mounted enlarger lenses or reversed 50mm kit lenses on a bellows.
0.1× means the smallest object to fill the frame vertically on full frame is 24cm high. No-one would call that high magnification (and around 0.3 is typical for short teles anyway).
p.3 #16My opinion on all of Canon's non-L RF primes
melcat wrote: steamtrain wroteThere are enough lenses out there with a 1x magnification focusing faster and more accurate than the RF 85mm f/2.0 IS stm.Any with f/2?