fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024R5 II vs. A1

  
 
swldstn
Offline
Details
p.8 #1R5 II vs. A1
artsupreme wrote:
swldstn wrote
Jazzgear296 wrote
swldstn wrote
Jazzgear296 wrote
trippalhealick wroteFlaghship to flagship, the A1 II blows the R1 out of the water as far as (proven and objective) feature sets go. The reason Sony priced the A1 and A1 II at $6500 US is because....well, because they can. Look back at the Canon 1DX III. It was $6500, and how many years ago was it released? The simple fact is, neither of the other two major manufacturers have a camera that meets the A1 in specs. Close, very close, but not 100% when measured side-by-side. So, I wouldn't call the A1 II overpriced. I'd call the Canon R5 II EXTREMELY competitively priced. A value buy if you're just getting in and don't already have a bunch invested in a system. I consider switching back to Canon frequently, but I have to remind myself why I switched away from them years ago. Their stagnation of innovation. Sony brought a LOT of that when they started this mirrorless market, and continue to lead, IMO.

Edit: Anyone looking for a used A1 can thank me for the soon-to-be lowered used prices, because I pre-ordered the A1 II about 15 seconds into it being live on B&H. lol
Again, I’ll try to type it slower….this is not a flagship to flagship comparison. Because what each company calls their flagship cameras, differ in the use cases they’re intended for. Sony’s Flagship camera feature set aligns more with the non flagship R5 II. vis a vis….. and despite your consternation with that reality, both cameras produce great photos to meet the intended use case requirements. If two photographers go out to shoot their cameras one Canon R5II and the other Sony A1II for the same use case, the only limiting factor is gonna be between each of their ears, and not the cameras. So again, anyway you want to frame it — the A1II is overpriced, but Sony knows that if you’re only invested in their lens ecosystem, you have to pay whatever they’re charging. I have about the same amount of cameras and lenses from both companies, so I have the freedom to choose the better value, the R5II
So I also own quite a few Canon RF lenses and Sony GM/GMII lenses and haven’t chosen the EOS R5 Mark II or the Sony A1 II yet. I currently own A1’s and a a Caon R5. If I go Canon I really have to add 24/1,4, 35/1.4 RF L lenses and possible others to give me the range of primes I have covered with Sony already. This will cost me over $2000, so I’m still trying to decide which way I go. What are you considering?
Well, I did a 180 and purchased the R5II when I swore I wasn’t going to upgrade. The clincher for me was the 20% discount from Canon direct, and the relatively high price I got for my used R5 ($2800). I was watching closely the release of the A1II ..hoping it’d trump the R5II, so I can finally retire/sell off my ancient A9, and my workhorse ARIV…. But like I’ve been saying in all these threads, for me since I am in both camps and have the R5II, the A1II doesn’t offer enough from what I already have in the R5II. Now I do -lan somewhere down the road to upgrade my current Sonys…but it’ll be once the A1II comes down about $1000-$1500, or used a year or so down the road.
Thanks for the update. I’ve seen some very nice pricing on the R5 Mark II. If I get one I will probably sell my R5 but I’m sure I would never get $2800 for it even though it’s very lightly used. If I only shot Canon I would definitely hold on to it because I hate not having a backup body. For Sony my two A1’s are in great shape so there is really no rush to trade up.
Someone really clueless must have bought his R5 for $2800 considering that’s what you can buy them for new. I think the most you might get is 2k. I plan on selling mine for $1800 or less.


Yes, I was planning to sell my R5 mark I , with the battery grip and L-bracket for ~ $2100 and maybe even its batteries since you really need P versions if you want to take advantage of pre-capture.
Nov 23, 2024 at 11:43 AM
nmerc_photos
Online
Details
p.8 #2R5 II vs. A1
artsupreme wrote:
swldstn wrote
Jazzgear296 wrote
swldstn wrote
Jazzgear296 wrote
trippalhealick wroteFlaghship to flagship, the A1 II blows the R1 out of the water as far as (proven and objective) feature sets go. The reason Sony priced the A1 and A1 II at $6500 US is because....well, because they can. Look back at the Canon 1DX III. It was $6500, and how many years ago was it released? The simple fact is, neither of the other two major manufacturers have a camera that meets the A1 in specs. Close, very close, but not 100% when measured side-by-side. So, I wouldn't call the A1 II overpriced. I'd call the Canon R5 II EXTREMELY competitively priced. A value buy if you're just getting in and don't already have a bunch invested in a system. I consider switching back to Canon frequently, but I have to remind myself why I switched away from them years ago. Their stagnation of innovation. Sony brought a LOT of that when they started this mirrorless market, and continue to lead, IMO.

Edit: Anyone looking for a used A1 can thank me for the soon-to-be lowered used prices, because I pre-ordered the A1 II about 15 seconds into it being live on B&H. lol
Again, I’ll try to type it slower….this is not a flagship to flagship comparison. Because what each company calls their flagship cameras, differ in the use cases they’re intended for. Sony’s Flagship camera feature set aligns more with the non flagship R5 II. vis a vis….. and despite your consternation with that reality, both cameras produce great photos to meet the intended use case requirements. If two photographers go out to shoot their cameras one Canon R5II and the other Sony A1II for the same use case, the only limiting factor is gonna be between each of their ears, and not the cameras. So again, anyway you want to frame it — the A1II is overpriced, but Sony knows that if you’re only invested in their lens ecosystem, you have to pay whatever they’re charging. I have about the same amount of cameras and lenses from both companies, so I have the freedom to choose the better value, the R5II
So I also own quite a few Canon RF lenses and Sony GM/GMII lenses and haven’t chosen the EOS R5 Mark II or the Sony A1 II yet. I currently own A1’s and a a Caon R5. If I go Canon I really have to add 24/1,4, 35/1.4 RF L lenses and possible others to give me the range of primes I have covered with Sony already. This will cost me over $2000, so I’m still trying to decide which way I go. What are you considering?
Well, I did a 180 and purchased the R5II when I swore I wasn’t going to upgrade. The clincher for me was the 20% discount from Canon direct, and the relatively high price I got for my used R5 ($2800). I was watching closely the release of the A1II ..hoping it’d trump the R5II, so I can finally retire/sell off my ancient A9, and my workhorse ARIV…. But like I’ve been saying in all these threads, for me since I am in both camps and have the R5II, the A1II doesn’t offer enough from what I already have in the R5II. Now I do -lan somewhere down the road to upgrade my current Sonys…but it’ll be once the A1II comes down about $1000-$1500, or used a year or so down the road.
Thanks for the update. I’ve seen some very nice pricing on the R5 Mark II. If I get one I will probably sell my R5 but I’m sure I would never get $2800 for it even though it’s very lightly used. If I only shot Canon I would definitely hold on to it because I hate not having a backup body. For Sony my two A1’s are in great shape so there is really no rush to trade up.
Someone really clueless must have bought his R5 for $2800 considering that’s what you can buy them for new. I think the most you might get is 2k. I plan on selling mine for $1800 or less.


that's what I was thinking

I sold my 3x R5 back in mid 2023 for around $2200 each. To get $2800 a year and a half later is incredible
Nov 23, 2024 at 12:21 PM
patotts
Offline
Details
p.8 #3R5 II vs. A1
n/t

Edited on Nov 23, 2024 at 04:55 PM · View previous versions
Nov 23, 2024 at 01:05 PM
Jazzgear296
Offline
Details
p.8 #4R5 II vs. A1
artsupreme wrote:
Jazzgear296 wrote]

Well, I did a 180 and purchased the R5II when I swore I wasn’t going to upgrade. The clincher for me was the 20% discount from Canon direct, and the relatively high price I got for my used R5 ($2800). I was watching closely the release of the A1II ..hoping it’d trump the R5II, so I can finally retire/sell off my ancient A9, and my workhorse ARIV…. But like I’ve been saying in all these threads, for me since I am in both camps and have the R5II, the A1II doesn’t offer enough from what I already have in the R5II. Now I do -lan somewhere down the road to upgrade my current Sonys…but it’ll be once the A1II comes down about $1000-$1500, or used a year or so down the road.
Canon sold you an R5II FOR $3440?


Yes indeed, and also the battery grip and 2 extra batteries for 20% off. Part of the upgrade program. I used my old relic paper weight 30D as my upgrade target
Nov 23, 2024 at 01:58 PM
artsupreme
Offline
Details
p.8 #5R5 II vs. A1
Jazzgear296 wrote:
artsupreme wrote
Jazzgear296 wrote]

Well, I did a 180 and purchased the R5II when I swore I wasn’t going to upgrade. The clincher for me was the 20% discount from Canon direct, and the relatively high price I got for my used R5 ($2800). I was watching closely the release of the A1II ..hoping it’d trump the R5II, so I can finally retire/sell off my ancient A9, and my workhorse ARIV…. But like I’ve been saying in all these threads, for me since I am in both camps and have the R5II, the A1II doesn’t offer enough from what I already have in the R5II. Now I do -lan somewhere down the road to upgrade my current Sonys…but it’ll be once the A1II comes down about $1000-$1500, or used a year or so down the road.
Canon sold you an R5II FOR $3440?
Yes indeed, and also the battery grip and 2 extra batteries for 20% off. Part of the upgrade program. I used my old relic paper weight 30D as my upgrade target


I think this is news to a lot of people here. I don't think many realize the R5II is part of the loyalty program or whatever program you are referring to. Can you post how you got this deal for anyone else looking?
Nov 23, 2024 at 02:07 PM
Jazzgear296
Offline
Details
p.8 #6R5 II vs. A1
swldstn wrote:
Jazzgear296 wrote
swldstn wrote
Jazzgear296 wrote
trippalhealick wroteFlaghship to flagship, the A1 II blows the R1 out of the water as far as (proven and objective) feature sets go. The reason Sony priced the A1 and A1 II at $6500 US is because....well, because they can. Look back at the Canon 1DX III. It was $6500, and how many years ago was it released? The simple fact is, neither of the other two major manufacturers have a camera that meets the A1 in specs. Close, very close, but not 100% when measured side-by-side. So, I wouldn't call the A1 II overpriced. I'd call the Canon R5 II EXTREMELY competitively priced. A value buy if you're just getting in and don't already have a bunch invested in a system. I consider switching back to Canon frequently, but I have to remind myself why I switched away from them years ago. Their stagnation of innovation. Sony brought a LOT of that when they started this mirrorless market, and continue to lead, IMO.

Edit: Anyone looking for a used A1 can thank me for the soon-to-be lowered used prices, because I pre-ordered the A1 II about 15 seconds into it being live on B&H. lol
Again, I’ll try to type it slower….this is not a flagship to flagship comparison. Because what each company calls their flagship cameras, differ in the use cases they’re intended for. Sony’s Flagship camera feature set aligns more with the non flagship R5 II. vis a vis….. and despite your consternation with that reality, both cameras produce great photos to meet the intended use case requirements. If two photographers go out to shoot their cameras one Canon R5II and the other Sony A1II for the same use case, the only limiting factor is gonna be between each of their ears, and not the cameras. So again, anyway you want to frame it — the A1II is overpriced, but Sony knows that if you’re only invested in their lens ecosystem, you have to pay whatever they’re charging. I have about the same amount of cameras and lenses from both companies, so I have the freedom to choose the better value, the R5II
So I also own quite a few Canon RF lenses and Sony GM/GMII lenses and haven’t chosen the EOS R5 Mark II or the Sony A1 II yet. I currently own A1’s and a a Caon R5. If I go Canon I really have to add 24/1,4, 35/1.4 RF L lenses and possible others to give me the range of primes I have covered with Sony already. This will cost me over $2000, so I’m still trying to decide which way I go. What are you considering?
Well, I did a 180 and purchased the R5II when I swore I wasn’t going to upgrade. The clincher for me was the 20% discount from Canon direct, and the relatively high price I got for my used R5 ($2800). I was watching closely the release of the A1II ..hoping it’d trump the R5II, so I can finally retire/sell off my ancient A9, and my workhorse ARIV…. But like I’ve been saying in all these threads, for me since I am in both camps and have the R5II, the A1II doesn’t offer enough from what I already have in the R5II. Now I do -lan somewhere down the road to upgrade my current Sonys…but it’ll be once the A1II comes down about $1000-$1500, or used a year or so down the road.
Thanks for the update. I’ve seen some very nice pricing on the R5 Mark II. If I get one I will probably sell my R5 but I’m sure I would never get $2800 for it even though it’s very lightly used. If I only shot Canon I would definitely hold on to it because I hate not having a backup body. For Sony my two A1’s are in great shape so there is really no rush to trade up.


---------------------------------------------

artsupreme wrote:
swldstn wrote
Jazzgear296 wrote
swldstn wrote
Jazzgear296 wrote
trippalhealick wroteFlaghship to flagship, the A1 II blows the R1 out of the water as far as (proven and objective) feature sets go. The reason Sony priced the A1 and A1 II at $6500 US is because....well, because they can. Look back at the Canon 1DX III. It was $6500, and how many years ago was it released? The simple fact is, neither of the other two major manufacturers have a camera that meets the A1 in specs. Close, very close, but not 100% when measured side-by-side. So, I wouldn't call the A1 II overpriced. I'd call the Canon R5 II EXTREMELY competitively priced. A value buy if you're just getting in and don't already have a bunch invested in a system. I consider switching back to Canon frequently, but I have to remind myself why I switched away from them years ago. Their stagnation of innovation. Sony brought a LOT of that when they started this mirrorless market, and continue to lead, IMO.

Edit: Anyone looking for a used A1 can thank me for the soon-to-be lowered used prices, because I pre-ordered the A1 II about 15 seconds into it being live on B&H. lol
Again, I’ll try to type it slower….this is not a flagship to flagship comparison. Because what each company calls their flagship cameras, differ in the use cases they’re intended for. Sony’s Flagship camera feature set aligns more with the non flagship R5 II. vis a vis….. and despite your consternation with that reality, both cameras produce great photos to meet the intended use case requirements. If two photographers go out to shoot their cameras one Canon R5II and the other Sony A1II for the same use case, the only limiting factor is gonna be between each of their ears, and not the cameras. So again, anyway you want to frame it — the A1II is overpriced, but Sony knows that if you’re only invested in their lens ecosystem, you have to pay whatever they’re charging. I have about the same amount of cameras and lenses from both companies, so I have the freedom to choose the better value, the R5II
So I also own quite a few Canon RF lenses and Sony GM/GMII lenses and haven’t chosen the EOS R5 Mark II or the Sony A1 II yet. I currently own A1’s and a a Caon R5. If I go Canon I really have to add 24/1,4, 35/1.4 RF L lenses and possible others to give me the range of primes I have covered with Sony already. This will cost me over $2000, so I’m still trying to decide which way I go. What are you considering?
Well, I did a 180 and purchased the R5II when I swore I wasn’t going to upgrade. The clincher for me was the 20% discount from Canon direct, and the relatively high price I got for my used R5 ($2800). I was watching closely the release of the A1II ..hoping it’d trump the R5II, so I can finally retire/sell off my ancient A9, and my workhorse ARIV…. But like I’ve been saying in all these threads, for me since I am in both camps and have the R5II, the A1II doesn’t offer enough from what I already have in the R5II. Now I do -lan somewhere down the road to upgrade my current Sonys…but it’ll be once the A1II comes down about $1000-$1500, or used a year or so down the road.
Thanks for the update. I’ve seen some very nice pricing on the R5 Mark II. If I get one I will probably sell my R5 but I’m sure I would never get $2800 for it even though it’s very lightly used. If I only shot Canon I would definitely hold on to it because I hate not having a backup body. For Sony my two A1’s are in great shape so there is really no rush to trade up.
Someone really clueless must have bought his R5 for $2800 considering that’s what you can buy them for new. I think the most you might get is 2k. I plan on selling mine for $1800 or less.


It did include a lot of accessories, like the grip and 8 OEM batteries and, other stuff. I priced it high, expecting to drop the price, but to my surprise no haggle and cash money. Sometimes you get lucky. Lord knows a I’ve lost a bundle doing trade ins with the KEHs, Adorama and B&H
Nov 23, 2024 at 02:07 PM
Jazzgear296
Offline
Details
p.8 #7R5 II vs. A1
artsupreme wrote:
Jazzgear296 wrote
artsupreme wrote
Jazzgear296 wrote]

Well, I did a 180 and purchased the R5II when I swore I wasn’t going to upgrade. The clincher for me was the 20% discount from Canon direct, and the relatively high price I got for my used R5 ($2800). I was watching closely the release of the A1II ..hoping it’d trump the R5II, so I can finally retire/sell off my ancient A9, and my workhorse ARIV…. But like I’ve been saying in all these threads, for me since I am in both camps and have the R5II, the A1II doesn’t offer enough from what I already have in the R5II. Now I do -lan somewhere down the road to upgrade my current Sonys…but it’ll be once the A1II comes down about $1000-$1500, or used a year or so down the road.
Canon sold you an R5II FOR $3440?
Yes indeed, and also the battery grip and 2 extra batteries for 20% off. Part of the upgrade program. I used my old relic paper weight 30D as my upgrade target
I think this is news to a lot of people here. I don't think many realize the R5II is part of the loyalty program or whatever program you are referring to. Can you post how you got this deal for anyone else looking?



I called canon direct and asked about it and they said it was part of the Upgrade (not the Loyalty) program. You have to have a defective camera that can’t be repaired or a really old one, like my 30D that I’ve kept for nostalgia as it’s not worth anything to sell….come to think of it with the 20% discount I essentially got $800 for it 😃







Edited on Nov 23, 2024 at 02:21 PM · View previous versions
Nov 23, 2024 at 02:10 PM
artsupreme
Offline
Details
p.8 #8R5 II vs. A1
Jazzgear296 wrote:
artsupreme wrote
Jazzgear296 wrote
artsupreme wrote
Jazzgear296 wrote]

Well, I did a 180 and purchased the R5II when I swore I wasn’t going to upgrade. The clincher for me was the 20% discount from Canon direct, and the relatively high price I got for my used R5 ($2800). I was watching closely the release of the A1II ..hoping it’d trump the R5II, so I can finally retire/sell off my ancient A9, and my workhorse ARIV…. But like I’ve been saying in all these threads, for me since I am in both camps and have the R5II, the A1II doesn’t offer enough from what I already have in the R5II. Now I do -lan somewhere down the road to upgrade my current Sonys…but it’ll be once the A1II comes down about $1000-$1500, or used a year or so down the road.
Canon sold you an R5II FOR $3440?
Yes indeed, and also the battery grip and 2 extra batteries for 20% off. Part of the upgrade program. I used my old relic paper weight 30D as my upgrade target
I think this is news to a lot of people here. I don't think many realize the R5II is part of the loyalty program or whatever program you are referring to. Can you post how you got this deal for anyone else looking?
I called canon direct and asked about it and they said it was part of the Upgrade (not the Loyalty) program. You have to have a defective camera that can’t be repaired or a really old one, like my 30D that I’ve kept for nostalgia as it’s not worth anything to sell….come to think of it with the 20% discount I essentially got $800 for it 😃


So did they just ask for the serial number of the old camera like the old loyalty program? You obviously didn't have to send in your old 30D correct? I already have my R5II's but I'm sure a lot of people were not aware of this and you can save some FM'ers a lot of money. I find it hard to believe they included the R5II for an upgrade price of $3440 but if that's the case that's a great deal.
Nov 23, 2024 at 02:12 PM
Jazzgear296
Offline
Details
p.8 #9R5 II vs. A1
artsupreme wrote:
Jazzgear296 wrote
artsupreme wrote
Jazzgear296 wrote
artsupreme wrote
Jazzgear296 wrote]

Well, I did a 180 and purchased the R5II when I swore I wasn’t going to upgrade. The clincher for me was the 20% discount from Canon direct, and the relatively high price I got for my used R5 ($2800). I was watching closely the release of the A1II ..hoping it’d trump the R5II, so I can finally retire/sell off my ancient A9, and my workhorse ARIV…. But like I’ve been saying in all these threads, for me since I am in both camps and have the R5II, the A1II doesn’t offer enough from what I already have in the R5II. Now I do -lan somewhere down the road to upgrade my current Sonys…but it’ll be once the A1II comes down about $1000-$1500, or used a year or so down the road.
Canon sold you an R5II FOR $3440?
Yes indeed, and also the battery grip and 2 extra batteries for 20% off. Part of the upgrade program. I used my old relic paper weight 30D as my upgrade target
I think this is news to a lot of people here. I don't think many realize the R5II is part of the loyalty program or whatever program you are referring to. Can you post how you got this deal for anyone else looking?
I called canon direct and asked about it and they said it was part of the Upgrade (not the Loyalty) program. You have to have a defective camera that can’t be repaired or a really old one, like my 30D that I’ve kept for nostalgia as it’s not worth anything to sell….come to think of it with the 20% discount I essentially got $800 for it 😃
So did they just ask for the serial number of the old camera like the old loyalty program? You obviously didn't have to send in your old 30D correct? I already have my R5II's but I'm sure a lot of people were not aware of this and you can save some FM'ers a lot of money. I find it hard to believe they included the R5II for an upgrade price of $3440 but if that's the case that's a great deal.


Yes, oddly enough I still had my 30D registered in the database and they were able to confirm it that way. And no I didn’t need to send it in. I just updated my previous post with the purchase invoice, I digitally removed/obscured my personal info
Nov 23, 2024 at 02:24 PM
artsupreme
Offline
Details
p.8 #10R5 II vs. A1
Jazzgear296 wrote:
artsupreme wrote
Jazzgear296 wrote
artsupreme wrote
Jazzgear296 wrote
artsupreme wroteCanon sold you an R5II FOR $3440?
Yes indeed, and also the battery grip and 2 extra batteries for 20% off. Part of the upgrade program. I used my old relic paper weight 30D as my upgrade target
I think this is news to a lot of people here. I don't think many realize the R5II is part of the loyalty program or whatever program you are referring to. Can you post how you got this deal for anyone else looking?
I called canon direct and asked about it and they said it was part of the Upgrade (not the Loyalty) program. You have to have a defective camera that can’t be repaired or a really old one, like my 30D that I’ve kept for nostalgia as it’s not worth anything to sell….come to think of it with the 20% discount I essentially got $800 for it 😃
So did they just ask for the serial number of the old camera like the old loyalty program? You obviously didn't have to send in your old 30D correct? I already have my R5II's but I'm sure a lot of people were not aware of this and you can save some FM'ers a lot of money. I find it hard to believe they included the R5II for an upgrade price of $3440 but if that's the case that's a great deal.
Yes, oddly enough I still had my 30D registered in the database and they were able to confirm it that way. And no I didn’t need to send it in. I just updated my previous post with the purchase invoice, I digitally removed/obscured my personal info


That's great, they usually just include the lower end bodies in that program like R8/R7 etc. That's going to be a great deal for a lot of people who haven't upgraded yet.
Nov 23, 2024 at 02:29 PM
Jazzgear296
Offline
Details
p.8 #11R5 II vs. A1
artsupreme wrote:
Jazzgear296 wrote
artsupreme wrote
Jazzgear296 wrote
artsupreme wrote
Jazzgear296 wroteYes indeed, and also the battery grip and 2 extra batteries for 20% off. Part of the upgrade program. I used my old relic paper weight 30D as my upgrade target
I think this is news to a lot of people here. I don't think many realize the R5II is part of the loyalty program or whatever program you are referring to. Can you post how you got this deal for anyone else looking?
I called canon direct and asked about it and they said it was part of the Upgrade (not the Loyalty) program. You have to have a defective camera that can’t be repaired or a really old one, like my 30D that I’ve kept for nostalgia as it’s not worth anything to sell….come to think of it with the 20% discount I essentially got $800 for it 😃
So did they just ask for the serial number of the old camera like the old loyalty program? You obviously didn't have to send in your old 30D correct? I already have my R5II's but I'm sure a lot of people were not aware of this and you can save some FM'ers a lot of money. I find it hard to believe they included the R5II for an upgrade price of $3440 but if that's the case that's a great deal.
Yes, oddly enough I still had my 30D registered in the database and they were able to confirm it that way. And no I didn’t need to send it in. I just updated my previous post with the purchase invoice, I digitally removed/obscured my personal info
That's great, they usually just include the lower end bodies in that program like R8/R7 etc. That's going to be a great deal for a lot of people who haven't upgraded yet.


I actually feel guilty not having posted about this sooner as I just assumed this was public knowledge. Hopefully they’re still offering the discount…I know from prior experience that the discounts can change or cancelled at any time. So folks should inquire ASAP!!!!
Nov 23, 2024 at 02:35 PM
artsupreme
Offline
Details
p.8 #12R5 II vs. A1
Jazzgear296 wrote:
artsupreme wrote
Jazzgear296 wrote
artsupreme wrote
Jazzgear296 wrote
artsupreme wroteI think this is news to a lot of people here. I don't think many realize the R5II is part of the loyalty program or whatever program you are referring to. Can you post how you got this deal for anyone else looking?
I called canon direct and asked about it and they said it was part of the Upgrade (not the Loyalty) program. You have to have a defective camera that can’t be repaired or a really old one, like my 30D that I’ve kept for nostalgia as it’s not worth anything to sell….come to think of it with the 20% discount I essentially got $800 for it 😃
So did they just ask for the serial number of the old camera like the old loyalty program? You obviously didn't have to send in your old 30D correct? I already have my R5II's but I'm sure a lot of people were not aware of this and you can save some FM'ers a lot of money. I find it hard to believe they included the R5II for an upgrade price of $3440 but if that's the case that's a great deal.
Yes, oddly enough I still had my 30D registered in the database and they were able to confirm it that way. And no I didn’t need to send it in. I just updated my previous post with the purchase invoice, I digitally removed/obscured my personal info
That's great, they usually just include the lower end bodies in that program like R8/R7 etc. That's going to be a great deal for a lot of people who haven't upgraded yet.
I actually feel guilty not having posted about this sooner as I just assumed this was public knowledge. Hopefully they’re still offering the discount…I know from prior experience that the discounts can change or cancelled at any time. So folks should inquire ASAP!!!!


Exactly, I have not seen the top end bodies included in this but maybe they aren't selling well. Who knows, but it's a great way to get a discount on one - approx $3715 with tax where I live.
Nov 23, 2024 at 02:39 PM
artsupreme
Offline
Details
p.8 #13R5 II vs. A1
trippalhealick wrote:
arbitrage wrote
Jazzgear296 wrote
artsupreme wrote
molson wrote
artsupreme wroteYou made it sound like the 4 year old R5 is better than the A1 II in your post above.
A lot of the improvements featured in the A1 II are only just catching up to where the R5 was four years ago... and probably could have been added to the original A1 (A1 Classic?) via firmware. There's nothing in those marginal upgrades that moves the needle for me, except maybe the pre-capture - although I've never really used that on any of my cameras that had it.

In any case, it's pointless to debate "on paper" performance, which at this point is purely marketing hype. Until you've owned the camera for a few months, you don't really know what it can - or can't - do.
What improvements are just catching up to the 4 year old R5? Based on feedback from friends who shoot both systems the A1 has always been better than the R5 in a lot of ways, and now the A1II will be ahead of the R5II but not by a mile. Give specifics on how Sony is just catching up to the 4 year old R5 so other users of both systems can chime in.
Well let’s turn the tables on you and ask, in what ways is the A1II better than the R5II? And I will stipulate to the faster sensor readout, EVF, and flash sync on the A1II. But that’s hardly enough to make it better considering it costs > $2K more

Some advantages of the R5II just off the top of my head:

- Better Ergonomics, menu
- Eye Control Autofocus
- In Camera Focus Stacking
- Dual Pixel Autofocus
- Faster Mechanical FPS 12 vs 10
- Higher Frame Rate: 8K 60 vs 8K 30
- $2200 less expensive in the USA than the A1II
- Higher Native ISO
- 5940 vs 759 Focus Points
- Better Min Focus Sensitivity Min: EV -6.5vs EV -4
And there’s more that I’m sure I’m forgetting
Here is my take on your points having used R5II, used the new Sony body design/menus in A9III.
- Better Ergonomics, menu
This is always going to be subjective. IMO the A1II has much better ergonomics dominated by the buttons, wheels and controls. The R5II has pathetic back buttons that are so tiny and soft. These are on par with the original A9 buttons which were also garbage. The latest Sony bodies put the R5II buttons to shame. The menus are on par (Nikon is terrible in comparison to both Canon/Sony) but after I setup my Canon and Sony cameras the only menu I've ever gone back to is my custom My Menu page for both cameras.

- Eye Control Autofocus
Next to useless for what I do with BIF. It calibrates well to my eye but didn't find it useful at all...more of a hindrance.

- In Camera Focus Stacking
I haven't tried this so don't know if Canon has any disadvantages doing it in camera vs Sony using an external program

- Dual Pixel Autofocus
This makes no difference to AF. As far as I can tell the AF differences come down to backbone AF algorithms and the AI database.

- Faster Mechanical FPS 12 vs 10
These are stacked sensor, high readout cameras so MS isn't really an important point anymore.

- Higher Frame Rate: 8K 60 vs 8K 30
Yes. For those that need 8K60 this is a clear R5II advantage.

- $2200 less expensive in the USA than the A1II
Probably the 2nd biggest advantage (ironically you didn't even list the biggest one but I'll talk about it below)

- Higher Native ISO
I wouldn't go anywhere close to the highest ISO limits on either camera. If I need those sort of ISOs I'm better off packing up and going home.

- 5940 vs 759 Focus Points
This has no bearing on anything IME. It is just marketing BS from both companies.

- Better Min Focus Sensitivity Min: EV -6.5vs EV -4
They are measured with different aperture lenses so can't be compared. Canon uses a much faster f-stop to get this number so it will be a lower value. See the Sony presentation for the value they use compared to Canons.

Now if you want to know the #1 advantage of the R5II over the A1II at least for my bird photography is that the subject/eye recognition is well ahead of Sony (and Nikon). You can see one example of this in Jan's A1II video at the PF nest. I've always said that even the original R5 had better BEAF for non-BIF than the A1 and A9III and Jan shows the A1II hasn't really changed this at least against the A9III.

Now for my list of the key features the A1II has over the R5II. Whether they are worth the $$ is up to the individual user and what they shoot.
1) Better AF for BIF. Canon and Nikon still haven't caught up to the original A1 in this and the A9III/A1II take it up a notch. Maybe the R1 will be on par but I haven't shot one yet. Jan's video on the R1 was looking in the same ballpark.
2) Better overall control over what you want to do with AF modes, tracking on/off
3) Zebras in stills...this is probably the thing most Sony shooters can't live without once you have it
4) Faster scanning sensor. The R5II is A9/A9II speeds. Good enough for birds wings but you can still get leaning lines in the backgrounds with rapid BIF pans and that can be shot ruining. Still this isn't a big advantage in my mind.
5) Better EVF...sort of...A1II better on paper but in reality it isn't much difference as it drops resolution if you max out the 240Hz refresh and during active AF. Still the drop is just down to what the R5II starts with.
6) Matching card slots and maximum card slot versatility. Granted Type B vs Type A $$ differences have always favoured the type B cameras. Things are improving...curently 1TB Pergear Type A on BF sale for $379USD. That is less $$ than the Pergear 1TB Type B card (although that isn't on BF sale).
7) Much better pre-capture implementation which allows customization of the time, mapping an on/off toggle and activating with either AF-ON or shutter or both.
Dangit. I don't need to see this stuff. The value proposition of the A1 II is abysmal vs the R5 II, and the memory card prices and Sony's choice of CFE Type A has always pissed me off. lol


Nice little clip from the A1 II. The eye AF looks impressive on the leopard walking through the bush:


Nov 26, 2024 at 11:22 PM
artsupreme
Offline
Details
p.8 #14R5 II vs. A1
tester_V wrote:
The A1ii improvements are insignificant and probably 90% of them could be added by a FW.
The fully articulated screen --- Adds nothing to the camera/photographer performance.
Better screen resolution ------- Don't care about it... I'm not using it to do picture editing
Pre capture --------------------- Great to have but again not a major improvement
Better menu -------------------- Nobody is using it every minute, kind of nice improvement, can live without it...
Better ergonomics ------------- Well, now camera body is 2mm bigger...
New processor ----------------- A1ii will add %2 of keepers
3 stops of image stabilization - good to have for sure
8K video ------------------------
...Show more →

Looking pretty good:







Nov 26, 2024 at 11:32 PM
action99
Offline
Details
p.8 #15R5 II vs. A1
artsupreme wrote:
tester_V wroteThe A1ii improvements are insignificant and probably 90% of them could be added by a FW.
The fully articulated screen --- Adds nothing to the camera/photographer performance.
Better screen resolution ------- Don't care about it... I'm not using it to do picture editing
Pre capture --------------------- Great to have but again not a major improvement
Better menu -------------------- Nobody is using it every minute, kind of nice improvement, can live without it...
Better ergonomics ------------- Well, now camera body is 2mm bigger...
New processor ----------------- A1ii will add %2 of keepers
3 stops of image stabilization - good to have for sure
8K video ------------------------ Could be added by a FW, nice to have. Every one had it already

What we have? 4 years old A1 (still amazing camera) camera repackaged with the slight $ increase.
Good job $ony!


Looking pretty good:





The AF in Video here is so bad it ruins an amazing sequence

(time at 1:05), not only it continues to lose focus, but the focus adjustment is super distracting....

I know is not apple to apple but here a sequence that I took with the R5 mk1

(time at 2:50)



Nov 27, 2024 at 02:37 AM
artsupreme
Offline
Details
p.8 #16R5 II vs. A1
action99 wrote:
artsupreme wrote
tester_V wroteThe A1ii improvements are insignificant and probably 90% of them could be added by a FW.
The fully articulated screen --- Adds nothing to the camera/photographer performance.
Better screen resolution ------- Don't care about it... I'm not using it to do picture editing
Pre capture --------------------- Great to have but again not a major improvement
Better menu -------------------- Nobody is using it every minute, kind of nice improvement, can live without it...
Better ergonomics ------------- Well, now camera body is 2mm bigger...
New processor ----------------- A1ii will add %2 of keepers
3 stops of image stabilization - good to have for sure
8K video ------------------------ Could be added by a FW, nice to have. Every one had it already

What we have? 4 years old A1 (still amazing camera) camera repackaged with the slight $ increase.
Good job $ony!


Looking pretty good:

The AF in Video here is so bad it ruins an amazing sequence

(time at 1:05), not only it continues to lose focus, but the focus adjustment is super distracting....

I know is not apple to apple but here a sequence that I took with the R5 mk1

(time at 2:50)



Yeah because the photographer missed that shot since it was lightning fast when they suddenly appeared from the bush and it was the take down shot so he decided to include it in his video. You can see them running away into the bush and then they surprisingly came back out and he wasn’t ready, so that’s not the cameras fault.

And he was at a much longer focal length than yours as well. Not really a comparison between the two. You know how fast this can happen so I’m surprised you are even making the claim of the camera having bad AF for that shot.
Nov 27, 2024 at 03:37 AM
action99
Offline
Details
p.8 #17R5 II vs. A1
artsupreme wrote:
action99 wrote
artsupreme wrote
tester_V wroteThe A1ii improvements are insignificant and probably 90% of them could be added by a FW.
The fully articulated screen --- Adds nothing to the camera/photographer performance.
Better screen resolution ------- Don't care about it... I'm not using it to do picture editing
Pre capture --------------------- Great to have but again not a major improvement
Better menu -------------------- Nobody is using it every minute, kind of nice improvement, can live without it...
Better ergonomics ------------- Well, now camera body is 2mm bigger...
New processor ----------------- A1ii will add %2 of keepers
3 stops of image stabilization - good to have for sure
8K video ------------------------ Could be added by a FW, nice to have. Every one had it already

What we have? 4 years old A1 (still amazing camera) camera repackaged with the slight $ increase.
Good job $ony!


Looking pretty good:

The AF in Video here is so bad it ruins an amazing sequence

(time at 1:05), not only it continues to lose focus, but the focus adjustment is super distracting....

I know is not apple to apple but here a sequence that I took with the R5 mk1

(time at 2:50)
Yeah because the photographer missed that shot since it was lightning fast when they suddenly appeared from the bush and it was the take down shot so he decided to include it in his video. You can see them running away into the bush and then they surprisingly came back out and he wasn’t ready, so that’s not the cameras fault.

And he was at a much longer focal length than yours as well. Not really a comparison between the two. You know how fast this can happen so I’m surprised you are even making the claim of the camera
...Show more →

Mine was 500mm, handheld and they also go on very bushy parts, again not apple to apple but not impressed at all
Nov 27, 2024 at 04:01 AM
action99
Offline
Details
p.8 #18R5 II vs. A1
A1 original and A1 II they are both amazing camera for photo, for video Nikon Z8, Z9 and R5 II are a better choice.

RAW, 8k 60, oversampled 4k, no strange crops in HFR, waveform, etc...

I'm very surprised that Sony did not invest more in the video side of the A1 II for that price, probably protecting their FX series.
Nov 27, 2024 at 04:53 AM
Howie4life
Offline
Details
p.8 #19R5 II vs. A1
action99 wrote:
A1 original and A1 II they are both amazing camera for photo, for video Nikon Z8, Z9 and R5 II are a better choice.

RAW, 8k 60, oversampled 4k, no strange crops in HFR, waveform, etc...

I'm very surprised that Sony did not invest more in the video side of the A1 II for that price, probably protecting their FX series.


That's my problem with Sony and why I am still in 2 systems and am considering getting rid of my A7RV. All these systems have compromises though. Sony has great lenses and great technology, but they want you to always buy their latest cameras for updates and they want you to have to own two cameras for the best stills and video capabilities.
Nov 27, 2024 at 10:01 AM
Getheshot
Offline
Details
p.8 #20R5 II vs. A1
I found the IBIS to be the opposite with the A1 having much better IBIS compared to the R5II. In fact Canon treats IBIS very differently than Sony with the A1 being able to lock IBIS after you settle down your movement. No wobble corners or jello effect.

How much did you compare Slog3 dynamic range to Canon's Clog2? I love all the setting inside Slog3 that Sony gives you like manually adjusting Knee which adjust your highlight curve. I still can't get used to Sony color.
Jan 22, 2025 at 11:26 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister