I have not owned either, but have used both. I would take the R5II all day long.
I think I am in the minority in that I just plain do not like Sony body sizes and ergonomics. The options menus feel far less intuitive than Nikon/Canon.
I loved my original R5, and the R5II is better in most ways than the original was. The A1 was also released over 3 years ago at this point. So from an economic value, I'd much rather have the newer piece of gear if I'm paying the same price.
The only things I value from Sony are the 300GM and their third party E Mount options (tamron, sigma, etc.)
I also would never choose a system based on a camera body, as I feel it's the least important part.. buy based on lens choices, the ecosystem, customer service, ease of repair, etc.
For AF, I find R5II > A1 > R5 > Z8/Z9.
I do not bother with the R3, A9III, etc. because for my work - spending all that money on sub 40MP cameras is silly.
bernardl wrote:
The real question is more R5II vs Z8 IMHO.
AF and image quality being super close it boils down to lenses (native ones, 3rd party and adapted ones).
If you need a 28-70mm f2.0 or 24-105mm f2.8 go Canon, otherwise go Nikon.
Cheers,
Bernard
in my experience, I don't find the AF of the R5II and Z8 to be close at all lol.
adding onto what Arbitrage said, if you want PF lenses, TC lenses, or the ability to use Sony E and third party options - go Nikon, but for all other reasons - go Canon or Sony.
technologically and body wise - I find Nikon is in dead last right now.
that being said - I shoot Nikon, and I have no problem getting what I consider great shots while using "dead last" technological bodies. all the gear nowadays is so dang good that if you can't get the picture you want, something is wrong with how you're shooting.
for me - I miss far less shots with Nikon's AF than I ever missed when shooting the R5 and Canon RF 600 F4 without a built in TC. for that reason, the choice of a built in TC is the most important to me.