This thread is an interesting read.
But even without having used either camera, I would blindly go for the Canon (based on camera alone).
Fact is that mirrorless is still maturing, and a second fact is that Sony of late has been doing literally nothing to improve their cameras after release, only bug fixes and perhaps app support.
The A1 is 3,5 yrs old and frozen in time performance wise, so the Canon R5II has 3,5 yrs of mirrorless maturing over the Sony A1, which is at this time still a lót.
I have the A1 and love the camera, and have no plans whatsoever to get the Canon R5II, but starting new, there is no way I would get a Sony A1 new at the price it currently is at, and I would not recommend it. Ibis wise, video AF wise, AF subject detection wise, it has become seriously dated.
It is still a great camera, but i.m.o. should be sold at 4000,- by now.