fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Dynamic Range R5ii vs R5

  
 
matejphoto
Offline
Details
p.3 #1Dynamic Range R5ii vs R5
So after 4 months of the camera in people's hands. What is the summary?

From this thread I gather:
R5 is about 1/3 stop better in DR at ISO100 than R5II. This is measurable but pretty much insignificant in the real world.
Did anyone observe a real world difference in favor of R5.
i.e. If money is no object, is there any scenario where people should not get R5ii over R5?
Dec 16, 2024 at 11:06 AM
artsupreme
Offline
Details
p.3 #2Dynamic Range R5ii vs R5
matejphoto wrote:
So after 4 months of the camera in people's hands. What is the summary?

From this thread I gather:
R5 is about 1/3 stop better in DR at ISO100 than R5II. This is measurable but pretty much insignificant in the real world.
Did anyone observe a real world difference in favor of R5.
i.e. If money is no object, is there any scenario where people should not get R5ii over R5?


If money is no object, get the R5II. If money can be better spent somewhere or the R5II is a stretch, get a used R5. I was shooting yesterday with a big lens and some guy walked by and started asking questions. He asked me if the R5II is worth the upgrade and I told him only if you shoot video or the most difficult of situations that require the better AF. He said he just shoots portraits and landscape so I told him to get a used R5 as the R5II would be no benefit.
Dec 16, 2024 at 11:59 AM
matejphoto
Offline
Details
p.3 #3Dynamic Range R5ii vs R5
artsupreme wrote:
matejphoto wroteSo after 4 months of the camera in people's hands. What is the summary?

From this thread I gather:
R5 is about 1/3 stop better in DR at ISO100 than R5II. This is measurable but pretty much insignificant in the real world.
Did anyone observe a real world difference in favor of R5.
i.e. If money is no object, is there any scenario where people should not get R5ii over R5?
If money is no object, get the R5II. If money can be better spent somewhere or the R5II is a stretch, get a used R5. I was shooting yesterday with a big lens and some guy walked by and started asking questions. He asked me if the R5II is worth the upgrade and I told him only if you shoot video or the most difficult of situations that require the better AF. He said he just shoots portraits and landscape so I told him to get a used R5 as the R5II would be no benefit.


Thanks! I have the R5 and I find the AF sufficient. I don't use R5 for video much.
I guess I will wait for the mythical R5s or R5iii. If something would happen to my R5 (e.g. lost/broken) I guess I would move to R5ii.
Dec 16, 2024 at 12:58 PM
thedutt
Offline
Details
p.3 #4Dynamic Range R5ii vs R5
matejphoto wrote:
artsupreme wrote
matejphoto wroteSo after 4 months of the camera in people's hands. What is the summary?

From this thread I gather:
R5 is about 1/3 stop better in DR at ISO100 than R5II. This is measurable but pretty much insignificant in the real world.
Did anyone observe a real world difference in favor of R5.
i.e. If money is no object, is there any scenario where people should not get R5ii over R5?
If money is no object, get the R5II. If money can be better spent somewhere or the R5II is a stretch, get a used R5. I was shooting yesterday with a big lens and some guy walked by and started asking questions. He asked me if the R5II is worth the upgrade and I told him only if you shoot video or the most difficult of situations that require the better AF. He said he just shoots portraits and landscape so I told him to get a used R5 as the R5II would be no benefit.
Thanks! I have the R5 and I find the AF sufficient. I don't use R5 for video much.
I guess I will wait for the mythical R5s or R5iii. If something would happen to my R5 (e.g. lost/broken) I guess I would move to R5ii.


For my shooting (Wildlife) the biggest upgrades in order are: precapture, 30FPS, AF.

I run a 2 body system; Upgraded one to R5II and left the other at R5, dont really see the need to do both.




Dec 16, 2024 at 10:58 PM
evertdoorn
Offline
Details
p.3 #5Dynamic Range R5ii vs R5
Since we're comparing anyway, can anyone tell how big (if any) the difference is in ability to focus in (very) low light versus the orginal R5 and the II?

Seems like the impact on dynamic range is limited
Dec 17, 2024 at 01:44 AM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.3 #6Dynamic Range R5ii vs R5
matejphoto wrote:
So after 4 months of the camera in people's hands. What is the summary?

From this thread I gather:
R5 is about 1/3 stop better in DR at ISO100 than R5II. This is measurable but pretty much insignificant in the real world.
Did anyone observe a real world difference in favor of R5.
i.e. If money is no object, is there any scenario where people should not get R5ii over R5?

artsupreme wrote:
If money is no object, get the R5II. If money can be better spent somewhere or the R5II is a stretch, get a used R5. I was shooting yesterday with a big lens and some guy walked by and started asking questions. He asked me if the R5II is worth the upgrade and I told him only if you shoot video or the most difficult of situations that require the better AF. He said he just shoots portraits and landscape so I told him to get a used R5 as the R5II would be no benefit.

matejphoto wrote:
Thanks! I have the R5 and I find the AF sufficient. I don't use R5 for video much.
I guess I will wait for the mythical R5s or R5iii. If something would happen to my R5 (e.g. lost/broken) I guess I would move to R5ii.

thedutt wrote:
For my shooting (Wildlife) the biggest upgrades in order are: precapture, 30FPS, AF.

I run a 2 body system; Upgraded one to R5II and left the other at R5, dont really see the need to do both.


If you use two cameras together then the differences can be annoying. The ability to use a whole range of FPS is huge. I often switch between 15/20/30. The fixed 20 FPS of the R5 was more of a hindrance than not having 30FPS. The audio feedback makes it more clear when you hit the RAW buffer, which will happen sooner at 30.

EBH
Dec 17, 2024 at 08:59 AM
Scott Stoness
Offline
Details
p.3 #7Dynamic Range R5ii vs R5
matejphoto wrote:
So after 4 months of the camera in people's hands. What is the summary?

From this thread I gather:
R5 is about 1/3 stop better in DR at ISO100 than R5II. This is measurable but pretty much insignificant in the real world.
Did anyone observe a real world difference in favor of R5.
i.e. If money is no object, is there any scenario where people should not get R5ii over R5?


In summary, ignoring costs:
Landscape on Tripod - R5 (>dynamic range) [I have not noticed the difference]
Portrait work on Tripod - R5 (>dynamic range) [I have not noticed the difference]
Not busy animals/people - R5 (>dynamic range at 12k, 25k iso) [ I see the difference. My processing time has increased and culling effort. Distinguishing between keeper vs helpless is greater]
Busy animals/sports - R5II (focus, faster read speed, fps, settable fps, 14 bit electronic...)
Video Centric - R5II (clog 2)
Generalist - R5II (sometimes busy, sometimes video, sometimes landscape, sometimes Portrait - see above and get out your noise reduction software at high iso even before culling)

Considering costs, R5 can do most everything except faster read out speed and CLOG 2 and precapture. So more skill is required for BIF/Video/Action with R5. But the R5 is good enough that the only people that will notice the difference are other pixel peepers. Only you can decide $$$ savings vs impressing your brethren.
Dec 17, 2024 at 06:15 PM
artsupreme
Offline
Details
p.3 #8Dynamic Range R5ii vs R5
EB-1 wrote:
matejphoto wroteSo after 4 months of the camera in people's hands. What is the summary?

From this thread I gather:
R5 is about 1/3 stop better in DR at ISO100 than R5II. This is measurable but pretty much insignificant in the real world.
Did anyone observe a real world difference in favor of R5.
i.e. If money is no object, is there any scenario where people should not get R5ii over R5?
artsupreme wroteIf money is no object, get the R5II. If money can be better spent somewhere or the R5II is a stretch, get a used R5. I was shooting yesterday with a big lens and some guy walked by and started asking questions. He asked me if the R5II is worth the upgrade and I told him only if you shoot video or the most difficult of situations that require the better AF. He said he just shoots portraits and landscape so I told him to get a used R5 as the R5II would be no benefit.
matejphoto wroteThanks! I have the R5 and I find the AF sufficient. I don't use R5 for video much.
I guess I will wait for the mythical R5s or R5iii. If something would happen to my R5 (e.g. lost/broken) I guess I would move to R5ii.
thedutt wroteFor my shooting (Wildlife) the biggest upgrades in order are: precapture, 30FPS, AF.

I run a 2 body system; Upgraded one to R5II and left the other at R5, dont really see the need to do both.
If you use two cameras together then the differences can be annoying. The ability to use a whole range of FPS is huge. I often switch between 15/20/30. The fixed 20 FPS of the R5 was more of a hindrance than not having 30FPS. The audio feedback makes it more clear when you hit the RAW buffer, which will happen sooner at 30.

EBH


I'm so used to the power switch on the R5's for the last several years of heavy use that I keep flicking the switch to video on my R5II's. So carrying one of each would get a little annoying but the upgrade to the R5II is really not needed for most people. If it wasn't for Clog2 I probably would just keep rocking the R5's for several more years as the AF is plenty good for all the fast action I shoot.
Dec 17, 2024 at 07:00 PM
lighthound
Offline
Details
p.3 #9Dynamic Range R5ii vs R5
The other day I was clicking on an F16 fighter jet buzzing our shop using my R5.
It wasn't flying terribly fast but watching the jet snap back and forth in the EVF from one side to the other between each frame as I was panning was distracting to say the very least. It made it difficult to keep the damn thing in the frame and not very enjoyable. Trying to stay on a fast moving BIF is extremely difficult without falling behind or in front of the bird.

It's my understanding that this "jitter" thing while panning has been eliminated (or at least not noticable) in the R5II. Can anyone comment on their experiences with this on the R5II?
Dec 18, 2024 at 09:35 AM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.3 #10Dynamic Range R5ii vs R5
matejphoto wrote:
So after 4 months of the camera in people's hands. What is the summary?

From this thread I gather:
R5 is about 1/3 stop better in DR at ISO100 than R5II. This is measurable but pretty much insignificant in the real world.
Did anyone observe a real world difference in favor of R5.
i.e. If money is no object, is there any scenario where people should not get R5ii over R5?

artsupreme wrote:
If money is no object, get the R5II. If money can be better spent somewhere or the R5II is a stretch, get a used R5. I was shooting yesterday with a big lens and some guy walked by and started asking questions. He asked me if the R5II is worth the upgrade and I told him only if you shoot video or the most difficult of situations that require the better AF. He said he just shoots portraits and landscape so I told him to get a used R5 as the R5II would be no benefit.

matejphoto wrote:
Thanks! I have the R5 and I find the AF sufficient. I don't use R5 for video much.
I guess I will wait for the mythical R5s or R5iii. If something would happen to my R5 (e.g. lost/broken) I guess I would move to R5ii.

thedutt wrote:
For my shooting (Wildlife) the biggest upgrades in order are: precapture, 30FPS, AF.

I run a 2 body system; Upgraded one to R5II and left the other at R5, dont really see the need to do both.

EB-1 wrote:
If you use two cameras together then the differences can be annoying. The ability to use a whole range of FPS is huge. I often switch between 15/20/30. The fixed 20 FPS of the R5 was more of a hindrance than not having 30FPS. The audio feedback makes it more clear when you hit the RAW buffer, which will happen sooner at 30.

EBH

artsupreme wrote:
I'm so used to the power switch on the R5's for the last several years of heavy use that I keep flicking the switch to video on my R5II's. So carrying one of each would get a little annoying but the upgrade to the R5II is really not needed for most people. If it wasn't for Clog2 I probably would just keep rocking the R5's for several more years as the AF is plenty good for all the fast action I shoot.


Yes, that switch is annoying. It's like Canon designs every camera body in a vacuum and does not consider that people use a variety of cameras together. R5, R7, R5 II.

EBH
Dec 23, 2024 at 01:30 AM
ronno
Offline
Details
p.3 #11Dynamic Range R5ii vs R5


lighthound wrote:
The other day I was clicking on an F16 fighter jet buzzing our shop using my R5.
It wasn't flying terribly fast but watching the jet snap back and forth in the EVF from one side to the other between each frame as I was panning was distracting to say the very least. It made it difficult to keep the damn thing in the frame and not very enjoyable. Trying to stay on a fast moving BIF is extremely difficult without falling behind or in front of the bird.

It's my understanding that this "jitter" thing while panning has been
...Show more →

In my experience, the R5II has worse image stabilization. Jitters and lurching and generally unstable. My footage with the original R5 is far superior as to smoothness.
Dec 23, 2024 at 02:28 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister