p.11 #3Official Canon EOS R1 Images and Specifications
arbitrage wrote: lighthound wroteartsupreme wroteardvorak wroteDunno whether or not you’re in the minority, but I am right with you. I had so wanted to be excited over the R1 and I’m sure that, in some minor of my particular circumstances, I’d even like the files better. But the 24mp removes the camera from any consideration for me. Will stick with the R5 II for now.
YMMV.
gkinard1952 wroteTony5787 wroteIf your goal is shooting tight portraits of birds on sticks then yes you’re correct. If you like to include environment and your main concern isn’t just filling the frame with the bird then resolution honestly doesn’t matter that much. I’ve owned the R3 and R5 since they both were released and after getting the R3 I barely ever used the R5 and basically all I shoot are birds.
Upscaling software also continues to get better and better, I’d like to see comparisons between low light shots from the R5 II and the R1 upscaled to 45MP.Fair enough, I tried the R1 at the local store when Canon was there giving it the push. I would not have one, but I am interested in detail more than anything. I want a record of the bird with as much info as I can extract. I am clearly in the minority here I guess.The A1 II just might make the R1 look like a sad joke next week. I expect the A1 II to perform very closely or better to the R1 at double the MP. I think Canon really shit the bed with the R1 at 24MP but their saving grace is the R5II which should be good enough for most people.Perhaps your post should be over in this thread not this R1 image thread. https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1870614/
Oh wait, I see you already trolled that one as well.
But I do agree with you. Sony's flagship A1 II might be able to compete with Canon's 2nd tier R5II.
Can you say Quad pixel AF? The A1 II AF won't be able to compete with the R1 let alone the DR and high ISO capabilities mentioned above.
But I digress. Let's keep this thread about the R1 images and specs.I'm still waiting for one of the reviewers to do some testing and see if the QPAF is really making a difference. I thought Jan would touch on it but he didn't. Granted Jan's sequences he showed like the Peregrine in flight was impressive so the AF looks top notch. Just wondering if the QPAF has helped the notorious MILC issue of driving the lens back to a grossly OOF near subject from infinity??
I don't believe the R1 has QPAF; rather, Canon simply rotated every other line of the AF pixels 90 degrees. They're just calling it "cross type" AF.
p.11 #7Official Canon EOS R1 Images and Specifications
artsupreme wrote: lighthound wroteartsupreme wrotelighthound wroteartsupreme wroteardvorak wroteDunno whether or not you’re in the minority, but I am right with you. I had so wanted to be excited over the R1 and I’m sure that, in some minor of my particular circumstances, I’d even like the files better. But the 24mp removes the camera from any consideration for me. Will stick with the R5 II for now.
YMMV.The A1 II just might make the R1 look like a sad joke next week. I expect the A1 II to perform very closely or better to the R1 at double the MP. I think Canon really shit the bed with the R1 at 24MP but their saving grace is the R5II which should be good enough for most people.Perhaps your post should be over in this thread not this R1 image thread. https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1870614/
Oh wait, I see you already trolled that one as well.
But I do agree with you. Sony's flagship A1 II might be able to compete with Canon's 2nd tier R5II.
Can you say Quad pixel AF? The A1 II AF won't be able to compete with the R1 let alone the DR and high ISO capabilities mentioned above.
But I digress. Let's keep this thread about the R1 images and specs.Lighthound,
This is a gear forum where gear is discussed and compared. The title of this thread includes the word "Specifications". One of the R1's specifications is that it has a 24MP sensor. I'm sorry you are triggered by people who don't like this R1 specification, or any other specification of other Canon gear. Usually a troll is someone who doesn't use the gear being discussed, or maybe a hater from another brand. I happen to shoot Canon gear, and a lot of it. If you look around you'll see I give praise to a lot of the Canon gear I shoot with, in just the last few days that being the RF 70-200, EF 200-400, R5, R5II, R3, and 35 vcm. I'm not some Canon hater spouting off who doesn't use the gear being discussed, and I'm not someone discussing a body here who's not in the market for it. I'm in the market for every new high end body and lens that Canon makes. However, some of it has no value to me, and it is my opinion Canon missed the mark with the R1 being a flagship body at 24MP in 2024. You don't have to like it, but that is my opinion along with a ton of other Canon shooters who don't frequent this little forum. If the R1 had more resolution, I and many others would have been all over it as it would have been a very well rounded tool at its price point. But as it is, I don't shoot in the dark 90% of the time, and the current AF systems Canon has delivered since the R5/R6 are plenty good to capture just about anything nowadays. The R3/R5II/R6II were a step up and a bonus, but we are dealing with some serious diminishing returns in the AF department and R1 AF system are not necessary to most people unless one is trying to capture very specialized shots, or shooting in the dark. A lot of people are now very content with the current generation AF systems and are looking at other things like resolution, video, size, weight, lens options, etc. So even if the A1II doesn't completely match the AF performance of the R1, it will still be very close, and with double the resolution. So for me, that's why I say the R1 is a joke for a flagship, just as I could say the same about my R5II's when comparing to the R1. This is my opinion on a tool given its intended use at a price point in time (value), and it's not intended to attack or insult you or any R1 owners. It's perfectly fine if you don't like it, but I have to wonder why you get so triggered when someone doesn't like a feature or spec of a Canon product. I don't believe you've ever been in the market for top tier bodies, so why is it that you always get so defensive and make trolling claims to Canon users who actually buy and use the gear in this category? I don't get it, this it's a gear forum to discuss and compare gear, and these are just simple tools.Quite simple as I already stated. This is a thread for R1 images and specs. People want to read this thread based on it's title.
If you want to talk up another brand while referring to the R1 as a "sad joke" then perhaps starting your own thread with that in it's title would be more appropriate rather than cluttering up a dedicated image thread with non related crap.
I and everyone else click on this thread to read about and view images from the R1. It's not that complicated.Lighthound, do you not understand what specs are? Read what you typed above, "specs". This is not just a dedicated image only thread as you are failing to acknowledge. All specs are open for discussion in a gear forum, especially in a thread that specifically calls for an open discussion on the R1 specifications.
I'm sorry you don't like my opinions on a body that I would normally buy, but feel free to skip over them or maybe try to reply in an ordinary manner like Tony did above who kindly disagreed and spoke his opinion instead of calling out trolling. Feel free to start your own "R1 image only discussion" thread and see how that goes, but this one calls for an open discussion on R1 specifications, i.e. a 24mp sensor. Since you decided to carry on further, if anything is "crap" or thread cluttering, it's someone who constantly jumps in to defend gear they never buy, use, or own.
I said the same thing about the 1DXIII when it was released back when I was using the 1DXII. It was a joke for me at that point in time at the price point, but I eventually owned it when it got down to a value I thought was appropriate and as expected, it didn't give me much over the 1DXII. So now I have the same opinion on the R1. It's an R3 mark II @ 24MP and a current price of $6300 and I'm sorry you don't like that I think it's a joke right now. I wouldn't be calling it that if it had a 45-50MP+ sensor. I'm not the only one who feels this way about the R1, I hear it everywhere. So maybe you can just accept it and ignore it when you read opinions like mine, or you'll be the one causing more thread cluttering. Just because I don't like the R1 spec at this price point doesn't mean other people won't buy it and enjoy the camera. It's okay to have differing opinions on a tool.
...Show more →
You can talk any brand about anything, if
This is 2014, or
R1 is 60MP running at 60fps
p.11 #8Official Canon EOS R1 Images and Specifications
My Canon R1 shows up yesterday and I am impressed. As others have noted the EVF is amazing and I also find the grip is improved relative to the R3.
I am also pleasantly surprised at the buffer performance. At 40 fps in full RAW using Program Cobalt v4.0 cards with pre-capture enabled the camera does not pause until about 12 seconds, which gives me in theory a ~500 frame buffer.
p.11 #9Official Canon EOS R1 Images and Specifications
Does it matter if using a CFexpress 4 vs 2 cards?
The camera only supports CFexpress 2.0. Let me know if you have both type of cards to compare. I assume the benefit is only when using a compatible card reader.
john1970 wrote:
My Canon R1 shows up yesterday and I am impressed. As others have noted the EVF is amazing and I also find the grip is improved relative to the R3.
I am also pleasantly surprised at the buffer performance. At 40 fps in full RAW using Program Cobalt v4.0 cards with pre-capture enabled the camera does not pause until about 12 seconds, which gives me in theory a ~500 frame buffer.
p.11 #10Official Canon EOS R1 Images and Specifications
john1970 wrote:
I am also pleasantly surprised at the buffer performance. At 40 fps in full RAW using Program Cobalt v4.0 cards with pre-capture enabled the camera does not pause until about 12 seconds, which gives me in theory a ~500 frame buffer.
That's interesting because the manual indicates 230 regular RAW and 410 in CRAW. Did you actually shoot something with a lens on the camera, or was the test just black frames?
p.11 #13Official Canon EOS R1 Images and Specifications
Jonesy wrote:
That combo looks so nice. What's your thought on the R1 and 70-200 compared to the R3?
The R1 feels better in the hand for me. It’s a little bit wider than the R3 so there’s more room between your fingers and the lens. I pulled out the R5II last night after shooting ion the R1 for a bit and immediately felt cramped.
The EVF is incredible and has a few magnification options in the menu. So if you wear glasses and can’t get a tight squeeze to the rubber, you can lessen the magnification to see it all. I wear contacts and glasses so it’s nice to be able to quickly adjust it depending on how I’m outfitted at the time.
AF is solid. I had no issues with the R3, I shot almost exclusively with it for 2 plus years. I was playing fetch with my dog and she’s the best test for AF being a black lab. It finds her eye running directly at camera and tracks it perfectly. Even when its hard for me to see her eyes the camera can find them and tracks. The R3 did this well and better than both the Sony and Nikons I had but the R1 is noticeably better at staying on the eye once it finds it.
The 70-200 is beautiful! It’s light and lightning quick on the AF. It reminds me a lot of the Sony GM II that I had. I have the 24-105 2.8 so I knew what to expect for size and build quality but this one is lighter and noticeably so. The two lenses are completely identical in chassis. I got the white 70-200 just to easily know which is which.
I’ve been all over the place in the last year with systems. I shot with Canon for a long while from 2020-late 2023 with the R5 and R3. Then picked up some Sony gear here and there to play with and then a Nikon or two. I sold off all the Sony gear to just roll with Nikon and now I’m back to having two systems again The R1 is the best feeling camera to date. More comfortable and lighter than the Z9 and gripped A9III, Sonys best body to date.
I had two locations on pre-order for the R1 and my second one is coming on Monday. I’m going to sell it on here or just return it if no one buys it.
p.11 #15Official Canon EOS R1 Images and Specifications
I received my R1 today. I had about 20 minutes to take picture of mostly House Sparrows coming to our feeders out an open window. I really was most interested in how the AF compares with the R5II. My initial impression is that it’s tracking songbird takeoffs notably better than the R5ii. I am not sure if it’s going to be worth and extra $2K for bird photography, but have literally only shot out my window thus far. Everything else you’ve read is true. The EVF is great. It’s much snappier than the R5ii in focusing, and perhaps this is what is allowing for better tracking of takeoffs.
Regarding QPAF and the camera stuck focusing on the background, I did not find the QPAF making any difference in the one test I did at home.
Oh wait, I see you already trolled that one as well.
But I do agree with you. Sony's flagship A1 II might be able to compete with Canon's 2nd tier R5II.
Can you say Quad pixel AF? The A1 II AF won't be able to compete with the R1 let alone the DR and high ISO capabilities mentioned above.
But I digress. Let's keep this thread about the R1 images and specs....Show more →
I can say "Quad Pixel AF".
I can't find Canon saying it though.
Could you help me out with a link?
p.11 #17Official Canon EOS R1 Images and Specifications
Choderboy wrote: lighthound wroteFair enough, I tried the R1 at the local store when Canon was there giving it the push. I would not have one, but I am in
Oh wait, I see you already trolled that one as well.
But I do agree with you. Sony's flagship A1 II might be able to compete with Canon's 2nd tier R5II.
Can you say Quad pixel AF? The A1 II AF won't be able to compete with the R1 let alone the DR and high ISO capabilities mentioned above.
But I digress. Let's keep this thread about the R1 images and specs.I can say "Quad Pixel AF".
I can't find Canon saying it though.
Could you help me out with a link?
QPAF: a micro lens covers four pixels
DPAF: a micro lens covers two pixels
R1: a micro lens covers two pixels
R1 is DPAF, not QPAF.
p.11 #18Official Canon EOS R1 Images and Specifications
nimrazer wrote: Choderboy wrotelighthound wroteFair enough, I tried the R1 at the local store when Canon was there giving it the push. I would not have one, but I am in
Oh wait, I see you already trolled that one as well.
But I do agree with you. Sony's flagship A1 II might be able to compete with Canon's 2nd tier R5II.
Can you say Quad pixel AF? The A1 II AF won't be able to compete with the R1 let alone the DR and high ISO capabilities mentioned above.
But I digress. Let's keep this thread about the R1 images and specs.I can say "Quad Pixel AF".
I can't find Canon saying it though.
Could you help me out with a link?QPAF: a micro lens covers four pixels
DPAF: a micro lens covers two pixels
R1: a micro lens covers two pixels
R1 is DPAF, not QPAF.
Yes, I found these two mentions from Canon:
Cross-type AF is included for the first time on an EOS R series body
AF System Dual Pixel Intelligent AF
I assume lighthound just a little too emotionally involved.
Thanks for this. Yes, the term QPAF (which I'm guilty of using also) isn't what is really going on with the R1.
As the article does a great job of showing it is just alternating the orientation of the DPAF sensors. We shall see if this helps with the drive from infinity to near object or not. It will surely help with horizontal lines compared to R5II but whether that translates into any differences driving to a grossly OOF bird close by when focused close to infinity remains to be seen.