p.2 #1Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
I used the Z-mount version on a ZF on my recent trip to Hungary. Was a joy and worked flawless. The only kinda annoying thing was the flaring when shot into the sun, but otherwise I'm very happy with it.
p.2 #2Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
rico_rico wrote:
The only kinda annoying thing was the flaring when shot into the sun, but otherwise I'm very happy with it.
Thanks Rico.
Nice pictures. "Sun sails" picture doesn't show flare though, so I guess flare occurs under more critical shooting conditions. Was "Cross" picture shot @ f/1.4?
Thanks.
p.2 #3Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
Ripolini wrote: rico_rico wroteThe only kinda annoying thing was the flaring when shot into the sun, but otherwise I'm very happy with it.Thanks Rico.
Nice pictures. "Sun sails" picture doesn't show flare though, so I guess flare occurs under more critical shooting conditions. Was "Cross" picture shot @ f/1.4?
Thanks.
I see! Uhmmm ... yes, really annoying ...
Your website provides quite good information (in the Geek Area) along with nice pictures! I noted that the 28/2 Ultron II VM works well when adapted on Z7.
rico_rico wrote:
Indeed, if I remember correctly, "Cross" was shoot @ f/1.4.
Thanks.
p.2 #5Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
rico_rico wrote:
I used the Z-mount version on a ZF on my recent trip to Hungary. Was a joy and worked flawless. The only kinda annoying thing was the flaring when shot into the sun, but otherwise I'm very happy with it.
p.2 #6Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
Ripolini wrote:
I see! Uhmmm ... yes, really annoying ...
Your website provides quite good information (in the Geek Area) along with nice pictures! I noted that the 28/2 Ultron II VM works well when adapted on Z7.
Yeah, the Ultron works very well. Of course wide open for landscapes not as good as on a Leica M but overall a very good performance.
---------------------------------------------
urbanwild wrote:
Agree with @Ripolini@ regarding your "geek area" page! I haven't reviewed a lot yet but the 50mm comparison is excellent! Thanks for sharing.
p.2 #8Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
Does anyone know if there is a significant difference between this Thypoch 28mm f1.4 z and the Nikon 28mm f2.8 SE in terms of sharpness, colour and contrast from f5.6 to f11? Looking for a street 28mm that's an improvement over the SE lens. The Thypoch is still piquing my interest but I can't find one locally.
@rico_rico - I think your link above shows pictures that would answer my question above with a resounding yes.....I assume the Thypoch is much sharper? Not sure how much editing you do though.
@fenged - click on rico_rico's link above and you'll see some low light shots at f1.4 that may help.
p.2 #9Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
The Thypochs are cine lens variants, and that explains the smooth focus fade, bokeh quality, 14 blade apertures and lack of CA. Stylish flares and ghosts like in rico's page are highly prized in the cine world. Over-sharp skin treatment is a no-no in the cine world, look elsewhere if this is what you want. Thypoch aims for real life portrayals of people.
There are many use cases for f1.4 lenses at 28mm. They include: night shooting, cafes, interiors, separation from in-focus subjects to bokeh, museums-churches-temples, and the ability to take advantage of the best light of the day - dusk.
This 28mm is a fine portrait lens (cine background again) and has truly excellent 3D. Bokeh is soft yet retains shapes of background objects. Foreground bokeh is excellent. By design, there is steady fall-off in the corners at wide apertures and low contrast bokeh there as well.
Light handling is a step up from most stills lenses, color palette is robust and easy to process, whites are pure and shadows are very clean. So far for me, it's the complete travel package. Corner vignette is a little strong at times, but fixable. And it's small and still light. And that is an achievement in itself, looking at the opposition in fast 28s.
p.2 #10Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
I shoot almost everything with this one. Here is a sample of different kinds of imagery, because nothing works like seeing plenty of images from a lens.
p.2 #11Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
philip_pj wrote:
I shoot almost everything with this one. Here is a sample of different kinds of imagery, because nothing works like seeing plenty of images from a lens.
p.2 #12Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
Just a heads up to anyone contemplating this lens. I just heard back from Thypoch and they are looking at releasing a new 28mm f1.4 lens for Nikon Z with contacts in place this year. I don't know the price.
I didn't hear back from them quickly enough before I ended up ordering a Z copy. I'll have to work on my patience next time but hopefully this saves other folks out there.
Will look forward to sharing images once it's in my hands.
p.2 #13Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
urbanwild wrote:
Just a heads up to anyone contemplating this lens. I just heard back from Thypoch and they are looking at releasing a new 28mm f1.4 lens for Nikon Z with contacts in place this year. I don't know the price.
I didn't hear back from them quickly enough before I ended up ordering a Z copy. I'll have to work on my patience next time but hopefully this saves other folks out there.
Will look forward to sharing images once it's in my hands.
That's pretty interesting. I was kinda disappointed with the general reaction to the CV 28/1.5, and there's no firm news/timeline for the CV 28/2 APO yet. This might just fill the void for me...
p.2 #14Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
urbanwild wrote:
Does anyone know if there is a significant difference between this Thypoch 28mm f1.4 z and the Nikon 28mm f2.8 SE in terms of sharpness, colour and contrast from f5.6 to f11? Looking for a street 28mm that's an improvement over the SE lens. The Thypoch is still piquing my interest but I can't find one locally.
@rico_rico@ - I think your link above shows pictures that would answer my question above with a resounding yes.....I assume the Thypoch is much sharper? Not sure how much editing you do though.
@fenged@ - click on rico_rico's link above and you'll see some low light shots at f1.4 that may help....Show more →
Sorry for the late answer 😅
I own the 28mm f2.8 SE but I didn't used it very much yet. I always grabbed the Thypoch so far.
What I can say is that the Nikon 28mm 2.8 is a nice lens, sharpness is quite good, especially when stepped down to landscape apertures. Wide open it's maybe ok, closeup performance I didn't liked so much though. But it has AF ...
On the other side the Thypoch while being a bit bigger and heavier goes to f1.4 ... Wide open not perfect but definitely very useable, especially due to the floating group.
Regarding the editing, yes, all pictures got the usual Lightroom treatment: LR de-noise if necessary, then LR sharpening. To get an idea, I usually use those LR values 40 - 0.7 - 45 - 35. The last slider, masking, depends quite a bit on the image and noise levels and therefore varies significantly between the images. The others are usually around that. I try to not oversharpen the images.
p.2 #15Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
rico_rico wrote: urbanwild wroteDoes anyone know if there is a significant difference between this Thypoch 28mm f1.4 z and the Nikon 28mm f2.8 SE in terms of sharpness, colour and contrast from f5.6 to f11? Looking for a street 28mm that's an improvement over the SE lens. The Thypoch is still piquing my interest but I can't find one locally.
@rico_rico@@ - I think your link above shows pictures that would answer my question above with a resounding yes.....I assume the Thypoch is much sharper? Not sure how much editing you do though.
@fenged@@ - click on rico_rico's link above and you'll see some low light shots at f1.4 that may help.Sorry for the late answer 😅
I own the 28mm f2.8 SE but I didn't used it very much yet. I always grabbed the Thypoch so far.
What I can say is that the Nikon 28mm 2.8 is a nice lens, sharpness is quite good, especially when stepped down to landscape apertures. Wide open it's maybe ok, closeup performance I didn't liked so much though. But it has AF ...
On the other side the Thypoch while being a bit bigger and heavier goes to f1.4 ... Wide open not perfect but definitely very useable, especially due to the floating group.
Regarding the editing, yes, all pictures got the usual Lightroom treatment: LR de-noise if necessary, then LR sharpening. To get an idea, I usually use those LR values 40 - 0.7 - 45 - 35. The last slider, masking, depends quite a bit on the image and noise levels and therefore varies significantly between the images. The others are usually around that. I try to not oversharpen the images....Show more →
Thanks! What I'm most interested in is the comparison between the two lenses at f5.6-f11 for street use.....I'm looking for a bit more clean & sharp monochrome image.....the f1.4 would just be a bonus if it's even close to the 1.4E Nikon. Now that I have a copy on its way I'll test and share some samples with the group. I'd be curious of additional experiences though too in case there's quality control issues (this is my first Thypoch lens).....especially during the return policy timeframe and knowing that there's a new version coming out.
p.2 #16Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
I received my Thypoch 28mm f1.4 Z this week. I'll have to wait for the weekend to try and find some shots outside to share, but so far with my early tests inside on a tripod I can say it appears to be as sharp as the 28mm f1.4E in the center and sharper on the outsides at f5.6 and f11. I'll have to retest outside with different distances (it's windy and rainy here these days so I must wait). The out of focus areas of the Nikon have that extra glow almost as if it's a 1.2, not a 1.4.....it's still king for portraits in my book even with MF / AF out of the equation. Center sharpness is the same at 1.4.
Barrel distortion is real and the vignetting is huge on the Thypoch, but again, I'll need to test outside with more consistent lighting. I often like vignetting, but for f8-11 street photography I'd prefer it to not be there. It took a +5 manual adjustment in LR to correct the barrel distortion.
I really enjoyed my Nikon 28mm f2.8 on my trip last year and have many images I love. But in comparison with the Thypoch at f11, it really shows that it's not an S-lens. The Thypoch image is crisp. I'm excited to try some street photography with the Thypoch.
As for not having the chip, The lack of focus confirmation issue has been less of a concern since the last firmware update. I've moved my ISO control from the record button over to the ISO dial that now allows auto-AF at C. I've then moved my zoom button over to the record button next to the shutter. With a half-press on the shutter, I've gone from the zoomed in view back to seeing my full image before actually taking the shot. This is a nice alternative workflow for not having the chip. With that said, not seeing the aperture on my files is frustrating. I had been warned, but the lure was too great and I wasn't aware of the new version coming out this year when I made my purchase.
Like the CV apo lanthars, this lens is enjoyable to use. I wished one of these manual street lenses would have weather sealing though!
p.2 #17Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
A quick update on this lens. It's very sharp, especially noticeable in the corners. We've had a lot of wind and on-and-off rain here, so it's been difficult to test, but I'm generally very pleased so far. I don't have portraits to share as I've only taken candids of my family in the house so far, but to punch in quickly with the zoom while using eye-AF takes some of the guessing out. It's not as quick as a chipped lens with focus confirmation, but it works.
My intended usage is range-focusing street / travel and for this purpose I think it will shine. To be able to have 1.4 on hand with a result that somewhat comes close to the 1.4E is a bonus for such a small lens in comparison.
If this lens does come out with the contacts for a similar price, I will highly recommend this lens. I should really return it given the frustration of not seeing my aperture in LR (and knowing focus confirmation could be not far away with a newer version coming), but part of me wonders if I should embrace the chaos a bit knowing that this lens is a decent copy. I will decide in the next week.
Here's some test shots to illustrate the sharpness. Images on Flickr as well for a bit.
p.2 #18Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
The Simeras are very different from any Voigtlander lens (I have about 8-9 of them). They are more lively, warmer in palette, have another dimension's worth of bokeh quality (14 blade apertures). I'm very low tech re contacts and aids, so much so I won't be going back to the Voigts once the Sim 21mm appears.
These above look quite stopped down to me (f4-f8 maybe), and that is how most people use a 28mm. But this is a cinematic lens designed for f1.4 to f2.8 use. It's intended to be soft in the corners and to vignette heavily (as does the CV 28.1.5), again this is a cine move to incorporate steady fall-off centre to corner. I also hope you can see the inherent 3D (dimensionality) in this one, it's very strong but surprisingly few photographers see it.
But what I want to say here is something very unusual - the global histos (RGB combined) in Photoshop for these lenses are very flat and smooth across the images' pixel distribution. My understanding is that this phenomenon indicates a finer spread of tonal data than I see with images from my other lenses in post. So the play of light is very different here.
If you lift your Black Point or shadows or overall bottom end exposure, you will see more grading in shadows of this kind. The BW image above hints at this tendency. (The optical 'Silicon Valley' of Shenzhen is already a powerhouse, featuring DJI, DZOGroup and Viltrox, and probably others we don't yet know about.)
Another thing - once you trust the bokeh in street work, it opens many doors for creative expression, I'll post a couple to illustrate. So I'm as happy as a clam with this one. It's become my most used street lens..
p.2 #19Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
And the absence of CA is greatly appreciated. Note the delicate focus fade and detail in far bokeh (i) and the presentation of fine detail and the light handling (ii). So it covers a lot of bases for the street shooter, well, my kind of story telling shooting anyway, where I want the different elements to connect front to back..
..(i)..
..(ii)..
May 20, 2025 at 09:18 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.2 #20Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
Give me a chipped lens and I’ll bite. I’ve been impressed with the images I’ve seen but no focus conf or EXIF is a non starter.