p.1 #1Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
I own a Nikon ZF and recently bought the Voigtländer 40mm 1.2, and with the ability to use eye detect and focus confirmation, I have found shooting with it to be a revelation. I’m now hooked on manual focus lenses for their weight to brightness ratio… the sizing feels just right on the ZF body.
I’ve watched numerous videos about the Thypoch Simera 28mm and have been impressed enough to order one through B&H. I ordered the new version for Z mount and it is scheduled to arrived tomorrow.
I’ve since realized that because it is a non-CPU lens, I won’t be able to benefit from the Zf’s focus confirmation… I think it should provide either full or partial IBIS, but the focus confirmation is what has made me a manual-focus convert.
I’m considering swapping the Z-mount lens for an M-mount version. There seems to be a handful of smart-ish adapters that will allow the Simera to benefit from both IBIS and focus confirmation.
Is anyone here using a version of the 28mm Simera on your Nikon Zf?
If using the M-mount version, are you able to use both focus confirmation and IBIS? If so, which M to Z adapter allows you to do this?
The two that seem to come up on Youtube the most are the Techart M to Z Pro adapter with AF (I don’t really care about being able to autofocus) and the TTArtisan M-Z 6bit adapter ring, which also seems to support IBIS and focus confirmation.
There seems to be a lot of mixed information out there about what works and what doesn’t.
The best bet seems to be the Techart AF adapter, but it’s quite expensive… almost the price of another lens, so I’d prefer to find something less expensive.
p.1 #2Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
The TTA 6 bit will work just fine, there are select focal lengths you can choose on a dial to send the correct info to the camera and 28mm happens to be one of them. That's your cheapest solution. What I like about this adapter is if you match the aperture on the body with the command dial to whatever your lens is at, you will have the correct data in exif. Just gotta remember that extra step.
p.1 #3Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
Thank you very much for your reply! The z-mount Simera just arrived and, as expected, does not allow for focus confirmation and only limited IBIS.
Luckily ordered through B&H, so an exchange won’t be an issue.
I appreciate your confirmation re: the TTArtisan adapter’s functionality and also the trick re: using aperture priority. The ZF’s focus confirmation has been a game changer for me. I briefly tried focusing on the Z Simera using focus peaking and it’s a lot more difficult to get things correct with at 1.4.
The few images I took with the lens confirmed for me that the Simera is as good as advertised though, so now just the wait for the adapter and M-Mount version.
p.1 #4Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
I'm a little shocked that a lens like this would be made without the IBIS and exif data coming through natively. I'm not up to speed on the tech so this may be a stupid question, but could this be fixed with a firmware update? It might be worth reaching out out to Thypoch or Nikon perhaps? This lens interests me but not at the cost of buying it in a different mount and adapting.
p.1 #5Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
What you should bear in mind is that due to differences in the filter stacks of the respective manufacturers/camera models, there can be significantly divergent performance when adapting lenses.
Phillipreeve.net recently published a very informative article on this topic/problem, including direct comparisons of M-mount lenses on a Sony A7 III, Z6, M10, Sony A7rII UT (Kolari UT mod).
The differences, particularly in the wide-angle range, are drastic, especially in the peripheral areas.
Corner performance may not be as significant with the basic orientation of a Thypoch Simera 28mm as it is with other lenses, but I would still be careful here and would not exchange the native Z-mount version until I had compared it with the adapted M-mount version.
In the worst case, the differences are serious, see review where various M-mount lenses (primarily wide-angle lenses) show ugly corner performance adapted to Nikon Z and even worse on Sony-E, which performs significantly worse in this respect compared to Z-bodys.
Small example from the excellent article using the example of a Voigtlander 21/1.4 VM.
In the worst case scenario, a "dream lens" like the CV VM 21/1.4 Nokton becomes a "nightmare lens" in the corners.
p.1 #6Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
Wow… thank you for sharing that. I’ve come across a handful of people who have been using the M-mount version on their ZF, but no feedback as to how being adapted effects IQ.
If the Voigtlander 28 1.5 had bokeh performance in the ballpark of the Simera, I’d probably wait a bit to see if they release a version in Z-mount. But I read the phillipreeve 28mm shootout and the OOF rendering is surprisingly poor on the 1.5.
Ideally, Thypoch would release a chipped version of the Simera. Having the lens in-hand, the build quality seems excellent… the clicky-ness of the aperture ring is wonderful…
The other thing giving me pause are the less-than ideal ergonomics of the M-mount version… the handling on the Z-mount has zero issues for me… although I didn’t shoot many frames with it.
p.1 #8Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
Raptor_Fan76 wrote:
Wow… thank you for sharing that. I’ve come across a handful of people who have been using the M-mount version on their ZF, but no feedback as to how being adapted effects IQ.
If the Voigtlander 28 1.5 had bokeh performance in the ballpark of the Simera, I’d probably wait a bit to see if they release a version in Z-mount. But I read the phillipreeve 28mm shootout and the OOF rendering is surprisingly poor on the 1.5.
Ideally, Thypoch would release a chipped version of the Simera. Having the lens in-hand, the build quality seems excellent… the clicky-ness of the aperture ring is wonderful…
The other thing giving me pause are the less-than ideal ergonomics of the M-mount version… the handling on the Z-mount has zero issues for me… although I didn’t shoot many frames with it....Show more →
It’s bad for what Bastian likes in bokeh-
If you look at Fred’s review- The Voigtlander 28 1.5 is identical to the bokeh of the 28 Summilux. More structured and harder edges, which I much prefer in OOF areas.
So I wouldn’t take anyone’s word as gospel on Bokeh- It’s really what you prefer. Both are just different-
p.1 #9Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
urbanwild wrote:
I'm a little shocked that a lens like this would be made without the IBIS and exif data coming through natively. I'm not up to speed on the tech so this may be a stupid question, but could this be fixed with a firmware update? It might be worth reaching out out to Thypoch or Nikon perhaps? This lens interests me but not at the cost of buying it in a different mount and adapting.
Looking forward to seeing some shots!
I believe that it doesn't have the electronic contacts which is why it can't communicate this information.
p.1 #10Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
thenoilif wrote: urbanwild wroteI'm a little shocked that a lens like this would be made without the IBIS and exif data coming through natively. I'm not up to speed on the tech so this may be a stupid question, but could this be fixed with a firmware update? It might be worth reaching out out to Thypoch or Nikon perhaps? This lens interests me but not at the cost of buying it in a different mount and adapting.
Looking forward to seeing some shots!I believe that it doesn't have the electronic contacts which is why it can't communicate this information.
Interesting....why bother making a Z version then?!!! I just lost most interest in this lens which is too bad.
p.1 #11Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
urbanwild wrote: thenoilif wroteurbanwild wroteI'm a little shocked that a lens like this would be made without the IBIS and exif data coming through natively. I'm not up to speed on the tech so this may be a stupid question, but could this be fixed with a firmware update? It might be worth reaching out out to Thypoch or Nikon perhaps? This lens interests me but not at the cost of buying it in a different mount and adapting.
Looking forward to seeing some shots!I believe that it doesn't have the electronic contacts which is why it can't communicate this information.Interesting....why bother making a Z version then?!!! I just lost most interest in this lens which is too bad.
There are several budget z mount manual focus lenses that don't have electronic contacts. It helps keep the price down.
p.1 #12Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
The Z-mount version arrived yesterday. Interestingly, eye/subject detect actually works with the lens attached. As does a lesser version of IBIS, after inputting the lens data into the camera.
What doesn’t work is actual focus confirmation… the box will hover over the eye, but doesn’t turn green when in focus. This might work for photogs who have a good amount of experience with manual focus lenses, since when you punch in to 100/200% it zooms into the eye.
I was able to connect with someone last night who is using a setup of the Zf and a TechArt AF adapter and focus confirmation works perfectly for that duo… as does full IBIS.
I’ll be swapping my Z-mount for an M-mount version plus adapter… focus confirmation makes a big difference for me… no need to zoom in, so you can concentrate on the composition.
Thanks to everyone for their input. I’ll be sure to share my experience here once the lens and adapter arrive (I’m going with the 6-bit TTArtisan for now, as the Techart is sold out everywhere).
p.1 #13Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
thenoilif wrote: urbanwild wrotethenoilif wroteurbanwild wroteI'm a little shocked that a lens like this would be made without the IBIS and exif data coming through natively. I'm not up to speed on the tech so this may be a stupid question, but could this be fixed with a firmware update? It might be worth reaching out out to Thypoch or Nikon perhaps? This lens interests me but not at the cost of buying it in a different mount and adapting.
Looking forward to seeing some shots!I believe that it doesn't have the electronic contacts which is why it can't communicate this information.Interesting....why bother making a Z version then?!!! I just lost most interest in this lens which is too bad.There are several budget z mount manual focus lenses that don't have electronic contacts. It helps keep the price down.
Fair but the draw for me is to have a small, sharp manual focus lens that I can still use IBIS and the eye-AF auto-detect feature with. I also like the exif info.....who wouldn't? These lenses are not crazy expensive, but still not cheap. If a $200 CAD f-mount lens has it, why not a $900 CAD lens?
p.1 #15Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
urbanwild wrote:
@Raptor_Fan76@ did you end up making the change to the M-mount version? I'll be curious of the results.
Cheers!
It arrived, along with the 6-bit TTArtisan adapter yesterday. Unfortunately, I received a copy which had clearly been used before… dust all over the front and rear elements, the box had many signs of wear, and the focus ring was loose (any time you change focus direction there is a little give before it clicks in and it wobbles a bit from the barrel).
I didn’t discover the focus ring issue until I took it out to shoot, so I only took a couple of quick snapshots.
My initial impressions are that the lens produces lovely bokeh, as advertised, and I quite like the colour of SOOC images with the Zf’s sensor. Focus confirmation works perfectly with the 6-bit adapter.
p.1 #17Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
Raptor_Fan76 wrote:
Thank you very much for your reply! The z-mount Simera just arrived and, as expected, does not allow for focus confirmation and only limited IBIS.
Luckily ordered through B&H, so an exchange won’t be an issue.
I appreciate your confirmation re: the TTArtisan adapter’s functionality and also the trick re: using aperture priority. The ZF’s focus confirmation has been a game changer for me. I briefly tried focusing on the Z Simera using focus peaking and it’s a lot more difficult to get things correct with at 1.4.
The few images I took with the lens confirmed for me that the Simera is as good as advertised though, so now just the wait for the adapter and M-Mount version....Show more →
Thanks for reporting. I was mulling over getting a Zf to use just with these lenses. Clearly not.
Am I correct in understanding that the Voigtlander Z mounts do allow you to use the focus confirmation on the Zf, as well as IBIS? But not so with the Z-mount Thypochs?
If so, I will be waiting for a fast Voigtlander 28. Or even better, if Nikon decides to make a fast 28...
p.1 #18Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
littleego wrote:
Am I correct in understanding that the Voigtlander Z mounts do allow you to use the focus confirmation on the Zf, as well as IBIS? But not so with the Z-mount Thypochs?
Yes, the Voigtlander Z mounts have electronics and support EXIF, focus confirmation and automatic setting of IBIS focal length.
The Z-mount Thypochs, just like all the other unchipped "dumb" lenses for Z-mount have no electrical connections and thus no EXIF or focus confirmation, but you can use IBIS if you manually set the focal length on the camera.
p.1 #19Anyone shooting with the 28mm Thypoch Simera?
littleego wrote: Raptor_Fan76 wroteThank you very much for your reply! The z-mount Simera just arrived and, as expected, does not allow for focus confirmation and only limited IBIS.
Luckily ordered through B&H, so an exchange won’t be an issue.
I appreciate your confirmation re: the TTArtisan adapter’s functionality and also the trick re: using aperture priority. The ZF’s focus confirmation has been a game changer for me. I briefly tried focusing on the Z Simera using focus peaking and it’s a lot more difficult to get things correct with at 1.4.
The few images I took with the lens confirmed for me that the Simera is as good as advertised though, so now just the wait for the adapter and M-Mount version.Thanks for reporting. I was mulling over getting a Zf to use just with these lenses. Clearly not.
Am I correct in understanding that the Voigtlander Z mounts do allow you to use the focus confirmation on the Zf, as well as IBIS? But not so with the Z-mount Thypochs?
If so, I will be waiting for a fast Voigtlander 28. Or even better, if Nikon decides to make a fast 28...
If you purchase the TTaritisan 6 bit adapter- M mount version will work with focus confirmation.
I have tons of Leica glass I am starting to use with the Z6iii. It works really well so far for me but just starting to test out the M glass with it.