fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Voigtländer for e-mount, specifically 2.2/50 and 1.5/75

  
 
Wolfgang1756
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Voigtländer for e-mount, specifically 2.2/50 and 1.5/75
Juha, you were correct! There is the new 50mm F2.2 Color-Skopar! But sadly for me, no 50mm F3.5 Apo-Lanthar
Jun 14, 2024 at 12:15 AM
Wolfgang1756
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Voigtländer for e-mount, specifically 2.2/50 and 1.5/75
Jun 14, 2024 at 12:16 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.2 #3Voigtländer for e-mount, specifically 2.2/50 and 1.5/75
Good thing for E-mount users is that we got the 75/1.5 announced today too for July release:
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1846835/1#16571284
Jun 14, 2024 at 12:18 AM
Wolfgang1756
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Voigtländer for e-mount, specifically 2.2/50 and 1.5/75
Are the announcements every month? Or every quarter?
Jun 14, 2024 at 12:23 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.2 #5Voigtländer for e-mount, specifically 2.2/50 and 1.5/75
Wolfgang1756 wrote:
Are the announcements every month? Or every quarter?


When they release something new the next month, it is usually announced in the middle of previous month. They release something new almost every month but there are some months without anything new every now and then.
Jun 14, 2024 at 12:26 AM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Voigtländer for e-mount, specifically 2.2/50 and 1.5/75
It's a surprise that they may not consider any prime lens longer than 50mm to be a potential sufficient volume seller - macros excepted here. I've never encountered any lens range that was truncated in this way. Most makers are very proud of their people lenses and put a great effort into them, but it has taken five long years to release the (2019) 75/1.5 in other than their M-mount range.

I wonder if they use their M lens sales data as inputs to potential mirrorless lenses? Very different users, very different needs. Most M users struggle with focusing longer lenses.

If you do not believe light Otuses at 100mm and 135mm for $1500-2000 a lens would not be a great success for them, we must disagree about that. Being a Leica service house, they are masters of miniaturisation by necessity, but the M lens pathway is crimping their degrees of freedom in design terms.

A 100/1.4 would be a sensation, at say 700 grams. Many would enjoy a similarly lighter vsn of the Zeiss 135/2 APO which is 930g in Classic form and 1060 grams in Milvus. These are opportunities in areas they fear to tread.

More broadly, I foresee potential steady sales in mirrorless at 28mm (f1.5 and f3.5), 75mm (now done at f1.5), 90mm/100mm and 135mm, not forgetting the well-regarded 180/4. Some can be APO, some f3.5-f4 landscape-oriented (like the ZM 85/4), others more 'character-based' - as they do in M-mount. If they lavished attention to the same extent as for M-mount, we would see something like the Contax-Yashica range, which had three 85s and four 100s.

My observation is that they do not wish to produce dedicated mirrorless lenses that have no existing analog in M-mount, again the two macros excepted. There are 30 M-mount lenses and 15 E-mount lenses.

They clearly are happy to let the size and weight grow even in the same designs as the M users already had - as shown for the Z lenses and the promised Sony 75mm. They don't say why they have done this. Do they not believe mirrorless users also deserve light lenses?
Jun 14, 2024 at 12:31 AM
freaklikeme
Online
Details
p.2 #7Voigtländer for e-mount, specifically 2.2/50 and 1.5/75
philip_pj wrote:
Cosina's choice of lens releases in Z and RF may indeed reflect sales data but they also establish the way users will perceive them going forward. I don't see how adding 180 grams and a much larger barrel to the 75/1.5 compared with the premier version (VM) can assist this new beginning, at the delicate early stages of the new projections.

A multi-mount release would be an excellent idea. As for Sony users, most have given up on them and see this as the final arrangement, with them possibly being lucky to pick up some crumbs here and there, if
...Show more →

I think it's ridiculous, the idea that Cosina has somehow abandoned the E mount. Aside from the M mount, no other mount has as many lenses currently in production. E mount has twelve, plus, if I'm not mistaken, they also had the 12/5.6 and 35/1.2, and the SE's of all three f/1.2 lenses that were discontinued. We literally have more discontinued lenses than they have in production for Canon (three). Nikon has ten, but three of them are APS-C, and I'd be very surprised if anyone here but me is crying over their lack of E mount APS-C lenses. With the release of the 75, there's nothing the other FF mirrorless mounts have we don't.

Rangefinder based cameras and lenses were the bulk of the reason for them licensing the Voigtlander brand in the first place, and certainly where they found the most sustainable success, since they are, effectively, Leica's tier II, so it really shouldn't come as a surprise it's their priority. M-shooters may be niche in the overall market, but they're likely the largest addressable market for manual focus lenses. I doubt we'll ever see a 1:1 M-to-mirrorless release slate, because it wouldn't make a lot of sense to restrict their M mount designs with the idea that the element spacing can be rearranged to satisfy the performance expectations of mirrorless shooters. The macro lenses may be the only direct-designs we get, and I'm sure they made sense because macro shooters are an easily addressable market for manual lenses. The rest may be crumbs from the M mount designs where they make sense, but that's all it's been with the exception of the macro lenses. Why would you expect it to change? And how does it show a lack of commitment to the mount?

As for Zeiss, they didn't desert the E mount. They backed away from producing anything new for the stills market when the stills market was bottoming out. All of the Batis, Loxia, Touit, Milvus, Otus, a couple of the Classics (50 and 85) and quite a few ZMs remain available and currently on sale in the US. Production hasn't been halted since they let it slip that they were stepping back from the stills market. And they are most certainly not done with the E mount. I've got two sets of Nano Primes I'm pushing through acceptance testing at work as quickly as I can because our video team can't wait to get them in production. It one-hundred percent sucks that we're not getting anything new for stills, but, just like with Cosina, I can't fault them for focusing on the market that pays the bills.
Jun 14, 2024 at 02:38 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.2 #8Voigtländer for e-mount, specifically 2.2/50 and 1.5/75
Yeah, I also think E-mount has been supported quite well so far and it should continue. Including the new 75/1.5, there have been 17 lenses for E-mount (5 discontinued: 12/5.6, 21/3.5, 35/1.2 SE, 40/1.2 SE, 50/1.2 SE). And there was also the 40/2.8 as a first attempt at supporting E-mount that needed to be used with CV VM-E close focus adapter (also discontinued) and the biggest number of mount adapters from M and S/C to E-mount (with 2 M-mount adapters remaining in production).

Their E-mount lenses also continue selling well at a similar level as Z and X overall based on the Japanese rankings site. Over a long period 50/2, 65/2, 35/1.4, 40/1.2 (original and SE), 35/2 have been the biggest sellers among those. Recently 35/1.4 seems to be the most popular, possibly because 35/1.2 SE and 40/1.2 SE got discontinued which makes it the outstanding compact & reasonably priced pairing for A7C series from CV lineup. It has been out of stock / backordered a lot in recent months though.
Jun 14, 2024 at 03:57 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Voigtländer for e-mount, specifically 2.2/50 and 1.5/75
philip_pj wrote:
It's a surprise that they may not consider any prime lens longer than 50mm to be a potential sufficient volume seller - macros excepted here. I've never encountered any lens range that was truncated in this way. Most makers are very proud of their people lenses and put a great effort into them, but it has taken five long years to release the (2019) 75/1.5 in other than their M-mount range.

I wonder if they use their M lens sales data as inputs to potential mirrorless lenses? Very different users, very different needs. Most M users struggle with focusing longer
...Show more →

Hi Philip,

I share your frustration that Cosina doesn't make more lenses for mirrorless as I would love to see some of the lenses you mention. At the same time I see why they focus on Leica M mount lenses. Leica M shooters are going to be using manual focus lenses and they are going to be using primarily primes. In addition, the native mount lenses from Leica all (even decades old lenses) tend to be very expensive. In this Leica M ecosystem that gives Cosina a unique opportunity: they can create a lot of lenses that target exactly the type of lenses that are used most frequently on the mount and they can produce these lenses at a clear price advantage compared to Leica lenses.

These factors just aren't there for mirrorless lenses. On every mirrorless mount the vast majority of users primarily use autofocus zooms and if they don't use autofocus zooms they want and use autofocus primes. And the native mount lenses from the Sony, Nikon, and Canon in these autofocus primes are substantially cheaper than Leica M mount lenses from Leica. And Sony and Nikon have some very small and pretty competent and pretty cheap AF primes (think the small Sony G series primes, the small compact primes series from Nikon, and the i series primes from Sigma for Sony e mount). That is pretty tough competition for Cosina that just doesn't exist on Leica M mount and if you project into the future that competition just isn't going to be there on Leica M mount and it is only going to get more crowded on mirrorless mounts. So, although the user base might well be bigger on mirrorless mounts (I at least suspect that is true), the user base for manual focus primes might be a lot smaller on mirrorless mounts than on Leica M mounts and the competition both from the camera manufacturers and from third parties is likely to be a lot more fierce.

Personally, I am really happy that Cosina came out with the 75 f/1.5 in Sony E mount and I really like the Voigtlander lenses on Sony mirrorless cameras. The 17 lenses they have provide lots of coverage. For example, I will personally often use their 21 f/1.4, 35 f/2 APO, and 75 f/1.5 as my travel lenses and it will be a fantastic kit and although slightly bigger than a Leica M kit it will have some capabilities that a Leica M kit won't have and it will be much much cheaper. If Cosina never produces another Sony E mount lens I think they still have a wonderful set of lenses for Sony E mount.

That said I think there is hope for 2 more Sony E mount lenses at least that would help complete Cosina's offerings. First, as Juha has mentioned if the 75 f/1.5 (a non-standard aperture for mirrorless) does well, then a 28 f/1.5 for mirrorless would be a distinct possibility. This focal length and especially at that fast of an aperture has little competition and especially at the size it would be in the mirrorless ecosystem. I can see Cosina bringing out that lens, but if I play devil's advocate it is not clear that any 28mm lens sells well on mirrorless. All camera manufacturers seem to emphasize 24mm and 35mm lenses a lot more. I am not sure the market is there for 28mm on mirrorless. It is there on Leica M partly because 28mm is the widest focal length that can use the rangefinder, but on mirrorless this advantage isn't there and people seem to prefer going a bit wider or going with the more normal 35mm perspective.

Second, I could see the 90mm f/2.8 APO Skopar come out in a mirrorless version. I had this lens in Leica M mount and really liked it for its size and capability, but I am not sure it even sold well in Leica M mount and it was pretty heavily criticized. Still it might make more sense on a mirrorless camera which can handle focusing longer lenses easier. It faces some pretty stiff competition, however, from 85 f/1.8 camera brand AF lenses that tend to be good and pretty small, and especially from the Sigma i series 90 f/2.8 which is quite good, very small, and very cheap. I can see why Cosina might be reluctant to produce that lens for mirrorless.

So, although I would love to see an 18mm, 24 or 25mm, 28mm, 90 or 100mm, 135mm, 180mm (and I have their excellent 180 f/4 APO for DSLRs) from Cosina for mirrorless mounts I am pretty skeptical we will see anything in those focal lengths. I think there is a better than 50/50 chance we will see the 28 f/1.5 but even that may not ever happen and I think all the others are long shots. I prefer to see the glass as half-full, however, and I am very happy for what they have produced and I am very happy for this new 75 f/1.5 in particular.
Jun 14, 2024 at 04:34 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Voigtländer for e-mount, specifically 2.2/50 and 1.5/75
I might add that although Cosina no doubt could make the 75 f/1.5 a bit smaller like the Leica M version, the decision to make it a bit heavier and video capable is totally consistent with their decision to move away from the SE versions of their 35 f/1.2, 40 f/1.2, and 50 f/1.2 lenses for Sony E mount. Cosina made these lenses lighter, but apparently that did not generate the sales for these lenses for which they had hoped and they dropped all three SE versions. So perhaps they don't think that mirrorless shooters don't deserve lighter lenses, they just think that they get more sales with a heavier lens that is also video capable.

Personally, I too, would prefer the lighter lens but I am going to buy the heavier lens anyway and perhaps people like me plus the people who would only buy the heavier lens means more sales for the heavier lens than sales for the lighter lens. I don't know, but Cosina has tried the lighter lens approach and apparently decided that it didn't work.
Jun 14, 2024 at 06:16 AM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Voigtländer for e-mount, specifically 2.2/50 and 1.5/75
I'm not frustrated, more just asking why it is so? They make many moves that are odd. I see what you mean with the SE fast lenses, but there was only 55 grams in it, and they also used a less attractive exterior ring setup - lots of grooved rings a la Sigma, a cheap appearance. Aesthetics really matter, not just to me. We see people posting images of their lenses, showing this.

Must also put a counterpoint to the notion that mirrorless users are almost all AF transitioners from the DSLR world. It's more true of Canon, but my word, there are a healthy number of Nikon users with devotion to their earlier lenses - see the very active thread here for MF users, and many are interested in the new cameras superb MF aids and also E-M adapters.

Nikon kept the F mount and it shows, as much in the lack of FD interest as anything else. Vintage is making a big comeback. My point is that both Nikon and Sony users have very healthy and existing support by substantial numbers of long term and new MF users, Sony being the adaption king of 2013 onwards.

Cosina even gave the Nikon lens the lovely trad knurled ring design denied to Sony users in the 75mm, another inexplicable mistake. Sony is not Canon, and the other E lenses have this trad ring design already. So the look and feel is ensconced in the users' mindset as associated with the APOs etc. even if they are not aware of it consciously.

The chopping and changing does not help in the marketplace - recall what Sony used to do in its A mount days, same thing. I actually wrote a haptic design critique of the mistakes in the Sony vsn of the 75mm but decided it was too brutal to share, even expressed in non-emotive terms.

BTW, I wish nothing but the best for the Sony and other mount users of this 75/1.5 - it's my favourite lens and the fastest MF lens to focus I've ever used. It might have been made for EVF usage. We retain our harshest criticism for those we love the most.

I feel it is an important lens too, and might get Cosina to realise the level of support they have in the re-emergence of these fine manual instruments. Seeing the physical differences, it is also possible this new E/Z lens is stronger than the VM, a side-by-side would be good to see, at least on axis.

I feel at 90/100mm they need a top tier effort (APO) at some stage, that plus a longer version of this beauty we have now. Plus a landscape special at f4 or so. It's so easy for them to do all this, but they have to shake off the M first addiction somewhat.

I too was underwhelmed by the so-so 90/2.8, again an M lens made for the users' obsession with (and need for) tiny size and light weight. An APO at 500 grams would be welcomed with open arms in mirrorless, imagine a 13/11 with 5-6 APD and one asph. And you know - at some stage Leica will introduce an EVF camera, a proper one, not the bolt on idea. It might be soon. So they would be doing some preparation if they took my advice.
Jun 14, 2024 at 03:49 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister