p.2 #1New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
The M-mount-version weights 350g the E-mount-version weights 515g. Even adding an adapter makes only 400g. I dont know why the E-mount-version will weights 115g more (with added adapter weight)? Sad, that they choose to add so much weight!
p.2 #2New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
dieterson wrote:
The M-mount-version weights 350g the E-mount-version weights 515g. Even adding an adapter makes only 400g. I dont know why the E-mount-version will weights 115g more (with added adapter weight)? Sad, that they choose to add so much weight!
Part of the extra weight may be they included the switch to declick the aperture for video. This apparently adds some weight as the 40 f/1.2 and the 50 f/1.2 SE versions that did not have this switch weighed quite a bit less (80g less in the case of the 40, and 51g less in the case of the 50) than the standard versions with the switch. Add to that the Sony version has a bit wider filter thread--62mm instead of 58m--and has a bit closer focus distance--55mm instead of 70mm--and I think you have the difference in weight.
They discontinued the SE versions of the 35 f/1.2, 40 f/1.2, and 50 f/1.2 just a couple years after introducing them. Apparently reducing the weight by removing the declick aperture switch was not something Voigtlander saw as successful. Perhaps those lenses just didn't sell well. They have not introduced a lens without the switch since so it isn't a surprise this lens has one.
p.2 #3New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Steve Spencer wrote: dieterson wroteThe M-mount-version weights 350g the E-mount-version weights 515g. Even adding an adapter makes only 400g. I dont know why the E-mount-version will weights 115g more (with added adapter weight)? Sad, that they choose to add so much weight!Part of the extra weight may be they included the switch to declick the aperture for video. This apparently adds some weight as the 40 f/1.2 and the 50 f/1.2 SE versions that did not have this switch weighed quite a bit less (80g less in the case of the 40, and 51g less in the case of the 50) than the standard versions with the switch. Add to that the Sony version has a bit wider filter thread--62mm instead of 58m--and has a bit closer focus distance--55mm instead of 70mm--and I think you have the difference in weight.
They discontinued the SE versions of the 35 f/1.2, 40 f/1.2, and 50 f/1.2 just a couple years after introducing them. Apparently reducing the weight by removing the declick aperture switch was not something Voigtlander saw as successful. Perhaps those lenses just didn't sell well. They have not introduced a lens without the switch since so it isn't a surprise this lens has one....Show more →
In the case of this 75/1.5, Nikon Z version doesn't seem to have declickable aperture (this seems to be the case with all CV Z-mount lenses) while Canon and Sony versions have it, but the Nikon Z is 530g vs. 525 for Canon and 515 for Sony. I think the declickable aperture might not add so much weight here although it could contribute a little. I suppose the SE versions of 40/1.2 and 50/1.2 lost more of their size and weight due to other optimizations and the loss of declickable aperture was probably not the main contributor to it.
For some reason the weight differences are bigger with 75/1.5, e.g. Sony E (515g) and VM (350g) than for example with 50/1 where Sony E-mount is 590g and VM is 484g. I still prefer having the mirrorless versions to adapting VM versions to get EXIF, full optimization for the sensor stack, closer focusing capability etc. though but I also wish the mirrorless versions could be a little lighter (if that was possible without compromising any important capabilities).
p.2 #4New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Juha Kannisto wrote: Steve Spencer wrotedieterson wroteThe M-mount-version weights 350g the E-mount-version weights 515g. Even adding an adapter makes only 400g. I dont know why the E-mount-version will weights 115g more (with added adapter weight)? Sad, that they choose to add so much weight!Part of the extra weight may be they included the switch to declick the aperture for video. This apparently adds some weight as the 40 f/1.2 and the 50 f/1.2 SE versions that did not have this switch weighed quite a bit less (80g less in the case of the 40, and 51g less in the case of the 50) than the standard versions with the switch. Add to that the Sony version has a bit wider filter thread--62mm instead of 58m--and has a bit closer focus distance--55mm instead of 70mm--and I think you have the difference in weight.
They discontinued the SE versions of the 35 f/1.2, 40 f/1.2, and 50 f/1.2 just a couple years after introducing them. Apparently reducing the weight by removing the declick aperture switch was not something Voigtlander saw as successful. Perhaps those lenses just didn't sell well. They have not introduced a lens without the switch since so it isn't a surprise this lens has one.In the case of this 75/1.5, Nikon Z version doesn't seem to have declickable aperture (this seems to be the case with all CV Z-mount lenses) while Canon and Sony versions have it, but the Nikon Z is 530g vs. 525 for Canon and 515 for Sony. I think the declickable aperture might not add so much weight here although it could contribute a little. I suppose the SE versions of 40/1.2 and 50/1.2 lost more of their size and weight due to other optimizations and the loss of declickable aperture was probably not the main contributor to it.
For some reason the weight differences are bigger with 75/1.5, e.g. Sony E (515g) and VM (350g) than for example with 50/1 where Sony E-mount is 590g and VM is 484g. I still prefer having the mirrorless versions to adapting VM versions to get EXIF, full optimization for the sensor stack, closer focusing capability etc. though but I also wish the mirrorless versions could be a little lighter (if that was possible without compromising any important capabilities)....Show more →
Regardless of exactly how the SE versions of the 35 f/1.2, 40 f/1.2, and 50 f/1.2 weighed less than the standard versions, that Voigtlander discontinued these lenses so soon after introducing them suggests that Cosina/Voigtlander did not find the weight reduction for E mount lenses to be a very important feature. Perhaps they didn't sell well. Perhaps they just think that weight reduction is more important for Leica M mount lenses. Whatever the reason, it seems pretty clear that Cosina/Voigtlander prefers to make mirrorless lenses (Sony E, Nikon Z, and Canon RF anyway) a little heavier than they make their Leica M mount lenses.
I agree with you Juha, I prefer Sony E-mount lenses on Sony cameras and I would like to see Cosina/Voigtlander make them a little lighter. I also thought the SE lenses were a good idea, but it seems pretty clear at this point that Cosina/Voigtlander is not making E-mount (or Z or RF mount) lenses with the goal of keeping them as light as possible in mind.
It is also an interesting design decision not to include the declickable aperture for Nikon Z lenses. That might have made sense when Cosina/Voigtlander first introduced Z mount lenses, but now that Nikon has acquired RED it might be a decision they regret. It seems at least possible that Nikon Z mount might be offered on some RED cameras and Nikon cameras might introduce some RED technology making them better video/hybrid cameras. If those things happen, it might be nice for the Voigtlander Z mount lenses to be more video friendly.
p.2 #5New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
'wish the mirrorless versions could be a little lighter'
Recalling who manufactured the chonkers in the Milvus and Otus ranges, it seems some rogue strands of 21st century Zeiss DNA remained as a residue that lodged in Cosina's 'thinking'.
'Give me a heavier version of that lens, up to 50% more weight please' - said no photographer ever. And throw in a cross-hatch ring finish like you don't use for any other Sony lens. That'll do wonders for muscle memory habit forming.
385g or 515g with larger dimensions, larger odd filter size, tougher resale (Sony-only MF users, not a giant market niche there, and getting smaller by the month) - these are all reasons to use the adapted VM lens over the new chubby. And these factors all feed into whether the lens comes along or stays at home to do duty as a strictly urban lens. Does it really have an f32 aperture? How useful is that.
p.2 #6New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Just some random thinking here. I’d be very interested to see how the CV 50/1 in crop mode (75/1.4) compares to this lens. Twenty-six megapixels on an r5 is more than enough for most purposes I’d use this lens for. I would probably rather get the 50/1 and use it as a 75/1.4 occasionally than buy this lens. Again, just a random thought.
p.2 #7New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
I would find this lens compelling as something more compact than my 65mm APO. But from the weight and the look of those pics, it's not that much smaller/lighter. I'd rather they produce an 85mm to differentiate from that as well. The speed game is not something I'm interested in so that's not compelling to me. Since I own the 50mm APO it does give me the same thoughts @mudlake is thinking.
p.2 #8New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
I guess a lot of the extra weight comes from the extended helicoid that allows the closer minimum focus distance compared to the M version. And of course they were always going to be a bit heavier because of the extra length needed to cover the flange distance difference. Still unfortunate that they couldn’t keep it below 500g.
I think the 75mm Ultron might have been the better lens convert to E/Z/RF. But maybe an f1.9 is not exciting enough to convince people to buy a manual focus lens and so they went with the fancier f1.5 option.
p.2 #9New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
fjablo wrote:
I guess a lot of the extra weight comes from the extended helicoid that allows the closer minimum focus distance compared to the M version. And of course they were always going to be a bit heavier because of the extra length needed to cover the flange distance difference. Still unfortunate that they couldn’t keep it below 500g.
I think the 75mm Ultron might have been the better lens convert to E/Z/RF. But maybe an f1.9 is not exciting enough to convince people to buy a manual focus lens and so they went with the fancier f1.5 option.
Voigtlander has mostly made Notkton and APO Lanthars for mirrorless mounts. They have made slower wide angle lenses as well. They have made exactly zero ultrons for FF mirrorless. I think as you suggest they just don't find these more moderate aperture and less corrected lenses exciting enough.
p.2 #11New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Ha! I was feeling silly about checking every day, so decided to wait till Monday on the grounds that any 15th of the month announcement wouldn't happen until after the falling-on-a-weekend 15th, but they surprised me.
But, oops. It seems the 35/1.2 no longer exists in any form (at least it's not this* page). Sigh.
Whatever. Looking forward to an all-Nokton kit (21/1.4, 40/1.2, 75/1.5). Yay!
p.2 #13New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
philip_pj wrote:
They want to load you up with a 515g lens, when the current VM plus Novoflex adapter is a very tidy and attractive 386g and will be very easy to resell to MF-only Leicaists.
The VM already works superbly on E cameras, and comes minus the lead in the saddle bags. But looking on the brighter (if not lighter) side, you could get extra utility from the new lens's Canonesque focus ring as a parmesan cheese grater.
Moving on to smaller and better things (that may also work fine on FE), how about a 150/250 gram APO-LANTHAR 50mm F3.5 VM? Now we're talking. Look forward to seeing more about that (8/6) one....Show more →
I get you point concerning weight.
But looking at it from the bright side of life: my hiking kit now contains the Voigtländer 21/3.5; the 35/2 Apo and the 65/2 Apo.
Exchanging the 65 Apo for the 75/1.5 gives me 10mm more reach (while preventing the gap to the 35 from becoming too large compared to an 85mm lens) and saves me ~100g of weight.
I‘m going to get one.
PS:
btw. 21/3.5 + 40/1.2 + 75/1.5 is a very nice set as well!
p.2 #14New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Knut. wrote:
PS:
btw. 21/3.5 + 40/1.2 + 75/1.5 is a very nice set as well!
Just getting back the 21/3.5 to pair up with my 40mm Nokton. I've owned it years ago but now getting it again as I'm focusing on only Voigtländers with my Sony (sold my 24GM already). And this new 75mm will join them. Size/weight/performance ratio with these are phenomenal together. I just enjoy shooting with these more than with any AF lenses.
p.2 #15New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
I'm curious to see how this lens performs. That said, I'm still trolling for a mint silver copy of the original LTM CV75mm f/2.5. I have a lovely Yeenon close focus adapter, so even if I was going f/1.5, I'd probably look at the M version.
p.2 #16New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Hard to leave the 65/2 at home, I imagine. But you do gain with the 75/1.5, as you say, and the flexibility really matters for our kits, it can crop to 85-90mm at workable apertures (f8-f11). Without meaning to, I have assembled the 'Vintage line' 75/1.5, 21/3.5 and 50/3.5 - it covers a lot of ground (literally). Some (most?) of their more endearing VM lenses are 'Vintage Line'.
I am curious about the 75's performance at f22-f32, if one of us can do a quick check - no need for photos.
'One final notable difference is that unlike the Nokton 75mm f/1.5 in VM mount, which stops down to f/16, the new version for RF/Z/E’s minimum aperture is f/32.'
In the back of my mind is this factoid: the only CV lenses we have MTF for are the four E-mount APO-Lanthars and the two M-mount lenses - the 35/50 pair. The larger 35/50s are different, in favour of the E/Z-mount pair, a little better wide open than their offering for Leica. Now, wouldn't it be nice of the E/Z/RF 75s were similarly improved? Zeiss were adamant that larger = better. Are the elements identical in size?
p.2 #17New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
phili_pj theorizes: "Now, wouldn't it be nice of the E/Z/RF 75s were similarly improved?"
Yes. Cosina claims they twiddle the optical design, so we can always hope. I was being irritated with the 40/1.2 in that the corners at infinity need at least f/8, so as a joke, I tested the other lenses at hand. Just at f/4.0.
The 21/1.4, Loxia 25, and (well, Doh!) 35/2.0 APO are all lovely sharp in all four corners at f/4.0.
The 21/1.4 is one seriously amazing lens.
I'm not expecting the 75/1.5 to be as good as the 21/1.4. But I can hope...
Speaking of failed hopes and MTF charts, I bought the 65/2.0 to "scan" my 6x6 B&W negs. Both the stuff from around 1970 and my recently acquired 50/4.0 Distagon. The 65/2.0 is fine, but the Distagon is as much of a dog as Zeiss's published MTF charts indicate. The corners never sharpen up. At any f stop. My 75/3.5 Tessar 1953 'flex is fine in the corners at smaller f stops, though. I checked the MTFs for the 60/4.0 Distagon on the hopes that I should have looked first, but the 60/4.0 is the same story as the 50/4.0 Sigh. (The 100/3.5 is one sweet lens, though.)
p.2 #18New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
We tend to think they can do no wrong - Zeiss that is - but your experience does not surprise me. Have not met anyone saying the 21/1.4 is anything but wonderful. Good luck with the 75/1.5 if you go that way. I'm far from impartial about it so I should be a little more quiet. We might see some decent reviews after release.
p.2 #19New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Dave Sanders wrote:
I'm curious to see how this lens performs. That said, I'm still trolling for a mint silver copy of the original LTM CV75mm f/2.5. I have a lovely Yeenon close focus adapter, so even if I was going f/1.5, I'd probably look at the M version.
But I still await Juha's tests and experiences.
I have the silver LTM CV75mm. It is a nice lens and a joy to shoot with on my A7R4. They are out there if you hunt for them.
p.2 #20New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
I had the LTM CV 75mm f2.5 Color-Heliar few years back. Just like now, it was paired with CV21/3.5 and CV40/1.2, but I found it's coatings weren't quite up to modern standards and it wasn't easy to match it's less contrasty look to the 21mm & 40mm. Otherwise I really loved it. Small, light, sharp and really nice rendering.
Now I'm really waiting for the new 75mm Nokton. Although it's strange that the CV75/1.5 E-mount got so heavy. With the 40mm I never ever used the declick-thingy and I find it even more pointless on a 75mm portrait/landscape lens. So I switched to SE version immediately when it was available and have zero regrets about it.
Because of the weight, I sometimes wonder if it would make more sense to buy the 75mm Ultron VM instead, so that I could adapt it to both my Sony A7III and Fuji X-T30 II. Could be a nice 110mm eqv. with crop sensor... But losing exif might be something I'm not willing to do anymore. So 75/1.5 it will be.