p.10 #1Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
gear-nut wrote: A74me wrotegear-nut wroteA74me wrotegear-nut wroteA74me wroteive been researching and direct comparisons of tonal separation from the 25yo old canon d30 3meg sensor 11um pixels no current camera can match it. no one wants to hear the facts these days they are to rapped up in more is better. im actually chasing one at the moment to have a play with.Been there, done that, have the tee-shirt. There is a more organic look from fat pixels that perhaps someone uninitiated assumes is enhanced tonal range but it’s not — it’s probably the relative lack of noise. Smaller pixels deliver smoother and broader tonality, at least at or near base ISO’s.totally incorrect larger pixels record more accurate voltage/charge, download any of the test charts from cameras of the stepped chart used for measuring DR and look at the how well the steps are recorded, the d30 can record perfect steps of tone, in fact no other camera can towards the ends. also download a sample image from the d30 and push the near black shadows and the tones/detail are recovered absolutely amazing.Yes. And No. I am taking tonality across the image, not per-pixel accuracy. Fat pixels record more accurately, but they’re averaging the tonal range held within them. By contrast, pixels ⅓ the size are recording perhaps slightly less accurately individually, but combined they give you up to 9 shades within the same area as the 3x fatter pixel, in turn rendering more tonality across the image.i disagree as ive shot with m43 system for 5 years with smaller pixels and the images always looked "Blocky/muddy" shooting my daughters outdoor netball with my em1mk2 compared to my then a7r2 the images from the a7r2 were life like and beautiful smooth transitions of colours compared to the olympus that were digital looking , so when it came to buying a portrait studio camera i chose the sony a74 as the best compromise on pixel size /sensor size and im not dissapointed. in fact its the best camera i have used ever for extreme macro work to 10x mag as the 5um pixels are perfect for shooting 10x objectives as smaller pixels show diffraction and loss of detail as well as low iso noise that is stacked into blobs.We’re talking smaller pixels across the same sensor size, not m43 or cell phones. Sheesh.
here is a test image from DPR gx100ii and the a7iv ,as you can see the a7iv image on the left clearly can show better graduation detail as the fuji has not been able to record the transition.
p.10 #2Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
A74me wrote: gear-nut wroteA74me wrotegear-nut wroteA74me wrotegear-nut wroteBeen there, done that, have the tee-shirt. There is a more organic look from fat pixels that perhaps someone uninitiated assumes is enhanced tonal range but it’s not — it’s probably the relative lack of noise. Smaller pixels deliver smoother and broader tonality, at least at or near base ISO’s.totally incorrect larger pixels record more accurate voltage/charge, download any of the test charts from cameras of the stepped chart used for measuring DR and look at the how well the steps are recorded, the d30 can record perfect steps of tone, in fact no other camera can towards the ends. also download a sample image from the d30 and push the near black shadows and the tones/detail are recovered absolutely amazing.Yes. And No. I am taking tonality across the image, not per-pixel accuracy. Fat pixels record more accurately, but they’re averaging the tonal range held within them. By contrast, pixels ⅓ the size are recording perhaps slightly less accurately individually, but combined they give you up to 9 shades within the same area as the 3x fatter pixel, in turn rendering more tonality across the image.i disagree as ive shot with m43 system for 5 years with smaller pixels and the images always looked "Blocky/muddy" shooting my daughters outdoor netball with my em1mk2 compared to my then a7r2 the images from the a7r2 were life like and beautiful smooth transitions of colours compared to the olympus that were digital looking , so when it came to buying a portrait studio camera i chose the sony a74 as the best compromise on pixel size /sensor size and im not dissapointed. in fact its the best camera i have used ever for extreme macro work to 10x mag as the 5um pixels are perfect for shooting 10x objectives as smaller pixels show diffraction and loss of detail as well as low iso noise that is stacked into blobs.We’re talking smaller pixels across the same sensor size, not m43 or cell phones. Sheesh.here is a test image from DPR gx100ii and the a7iv ,as you can see the a7iv image on the left clearly can show better graduation detail as the fuji has not been able to record the transition.
OMG! You clearly don’t understand even basics. You can’t tell squat from a jpeg! First M43, now jpegs, are you really serious? Compare identical high latitude images, identically exposed and lit, then provide the raws, and maybe we can talk. Until then, I’m done with you.
p.10 #3Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
gear-nut wrote: A74me wrotegear-nut wroteA74me wrotegear-nut wroteA74me wrotetotally incorrect larger pixels record more accurate voltage/charge, download any of the test charts from cameras of the stepped chart used for measuring DR and look at the how well the steps are recorded, the d30 can record perfect steps of tone, in fact no other camera can towards the ends. also download a sample image from the d30 and push the near black shadows and the tones/detail are recovered absolutely amazing.Yes. And No. I am taking tonality across the image, not per-pixel accuracy. Fat pixels record more accurately, but they’re averaging the tonal range held within them. By contrast, pixels ⅓ the size are recording perhaps slightly less accurately individually, but combined they give you up to 9 shades within the same area as the 3x fatter pixel, in turn rendering more tonality across the image.i disagree as ive shot with m43 system for 5 years with smaller pixels and the images always looked "Blocky/muddy" shooting my daughters outdoor netball with my em1mk2 compared to my then a7r2 the images from the a7r2 were life like and beautiful smooth transitions of colours compared to the olympus that were digital looking , so when it came to buying a portrait studio camera i chose the sony a74 as the best compromise on pixel size /sensor size and im not dissapointed. in fact its the best camera i have used ever for extreme macro work to 10x mag as the 5um pixels are perfect for shooting 10x objectives as smaller pixels show diffraction and loss of detail as well as low iso noise that is stacked into blobs.We’re talking smaller pixels across the same sensor size, not m43 or cell phones. Sheesh.here is a test image from DPR gx100ii and the a7iv ,as you can see the a7iv image on the left clearly can show better graduation detail as the fuji has not been able to record the transition.
Dustin abbots samples show the same.OMG! You clearly don’t understand even basics. You can’t tell squat from a jpeg! First M43, now jpegs, are you really serious? Compare identical high latitude images, identically exposed and lit, then provide the raws, and maybe we can talk. Until then, I’m done with you.
Its a hard one to swallow isnt it. the raws are available just use your imagination.
p.10 #4Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
m4/3 has always been a joke from an IQ perspective. Those that claim it's competitive up to full frame are the first people I stop paying attention to
Yeah M4/3 is a joke except for about 95 per cent of situations people shoot in and 99 per cent of means by which people view images.
I can't see a difference between my A7RIII and my EM10 mark 2 on a 4k 28inch screen for photos taken in reasonable light, but don't listen to me because clearly my A7RIII is better even if I can't see it.
p.10 #5Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Geoff D F wrote: RoamingScott wrotem4/3 has always been a joke from an IQ perspective. Those that claim it's competitive up to full frame are the first people I stop paying attention to Yeah M4/3 is a joke except for about 95 per cent of situations people shoot in and 99 per cent of means by which people view images.
I can't see a difference between my A7RIII and my EM10 mark 2 on a 4k 28inch screen for photos taken in reasonable light, but don't listen to me because clearly my A7RIII is better even if I can't see it.
I have sold 4000 images from my m43 gear back in the day. i especially liked the em52, and shooting in a studio the em52 was the first camera to ever stream live via hdmi to my live monitors. pro photographer's were so far behind the 8 ball then when productivity came into play, im not surprised most went broke.
**DEEP POCKETS**Pockets ain't that deep, and relearning a post app is not on my current to-do
I love my X2D's but I don't think they'll suit. There's only one zoom. It's spectacular but has a small range and is huge. You'll end up with a larger kit than you want.
p.10 #8Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
gear-nut wrote:
There ya go @RoamingScott@! The experts have arrived and informed us all that M43 is all you need!!!
Hey! I shoot m43 and gfx together. There is no denying m43 is way behind if you pixel peeping. But for reasonably large prints, web, social media it is more than enough. m43 is a pure magic. I also maintain an idea that em1.3/om1 are the best designed cameras of all times!
A dance studio recently printed my images (portraits of dancers) from more than 10 years ago taken with panasonic gh2 on window size paper, and they looked fine to my surprise.
p.10 #9Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
A74me wrote: gear-nut wroteA74me wrotegear-nut wroteDaran wroterdeloe wroteIt's difficult to compare sharpness, but it's only redundant if you don't care about it. I don't think it's unreasonable as a comparison point if we're comparing high end systems like these.If you shoot high resolution sensors through a low resolving optic, the predictable result is that the higher resolution sensor gains you rather little. So using that to evaluate the actual relative merits of those sensors is pointless.
Of course another great leveler is aperture. For landscapes you'd usually wana shoot closed up apertures for it's larger DOF, but that will also limit the achievable resolution. And this effect is independent of sensor size: as you close the larger and the smaller sensor systems to equivalent apertures, the limiting effect of diffraction will also be equivalent.Yes but. Even with a lesser optic, more mp almost always gives you smoother tonality, which frankly is what I think gives MF the “look” edge over Fx capture in the first place — this in turn adds to gentler transitions into the oof areas, also adding to that MF look. Then add any higher contrast edge, and even the poorer lenses can resolve it on the high mp sensor, and it’s smoother due to the higher mp count, and this in turn adds to the impression of greater overall “sharpness” even though there is lower micro contrast. Finally, lesser lenses usually have other optical imperfections, like a little more flare which can open up shadows in high contrast scenes, again enhancing the impression of smoothness, albeit at the expense of micro detail. But combine all that, and now getting a unique look to the images AND/OR the best resolution (when using best glass) is the reign of MF capture — but almost always at the cost of flexibility…
Now whether those subtleties are worth the loss of flexibility in weight gain, focal limitation and cost to the individual photographer are arguable, and ultimately up to that individual as to how they want to create their art or want it to “look.”smoother tonality is a direct effect of larger pixels not higher resolution.Uh no.ive been researching and direct comparisons of tonal separation from the 25yo old canon d30 3meg sensor 11um pixels no current camera can match it. no one wants to hear the facts these days they are to rapped up in more is better. im actually chasing one at the moment to have a play with.
I had a pair of EOS D30's from release day. Prepare for dissapointment. If you want fat pixels then the original 5G is the camera to get. It won't come real close to a modern 16 bit sensor with lots of resolution but the 5D files are still very pleasant.
Tonal transitions are really about bit depth with a dose of resolution thrown in if possible. A hasselblad H6D or Phase is ideal but the GFX100 or X2D is the closest most of us will get, The pliability and tones of the GFX100x files are very very nice indeed.
p.10 #10Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Back to the topic.
Which GF has the better rendering, the 45/2.8 or the 50/3.5? Most things I’ve read about the 45 are that’s is super clinical and that most people sell theirs for some reason or another.
p.10 #11Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
Back to the topic.
Which GF has the better rendering, the 45/2.8 or the 50/3.5? Most things I’ve read about the 45 are that’s is super clinical and that most people sell theirs for some reason or another.
When I had the 45 and 50 I didn't care for the rendering of either. I would give a slight nod to the 45, but that's me. I would ud my old Minolta 55 f1.7. I now have neither. I just have the GF55 f1.7 and GF20-35 and that's all that I need. For me.
p.10 #12Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
fotografur wrote: RoamingScott wroteBack to the topic.
Which GF has the better rendering, the 45/2.8 or the 50/3.5? Most things I’ve read about the 45 are that’s is super clinical and that most people sell theirs for some reason or another.When I had the 45 and 50 I didn't care for the rendering of either. I would give a slight nod to the 45, but that's me. I would ud my old Minolta 55 f1.7. I now have neither. I just have the GF55 f1.7 and GF20-35 and that's all that I need. For me.
Was it the bokeh that you didn't care for? Or just overly clinical and sharp?
My thought being is that, if 40ishmm is a commonly used landscape length for me, the 50/3.5 might make some sense being so tiny and double as the walk around lens. It seems like the reasons people tend to poo poo it for portraits is what would make it an appealing landscape optic.
I'm not sure I see enough pluses with the 45mm for this use case...both could be used to do multishot stitching if needed and the 45 doesn't seem to have much better bokeh for the occasional portrait type use than the 50 does.
p.10 #13Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I'm sure my opinion will be completely dismissed and that's fine. Having owned ALL brands and many models in everything from Mft (OM-1) to FF A7RV and beyond, I've not shot with Fuji's larger format offerings. But that said, the ONE huge deal breaker for me with Mft has been and continues to be it's lack of dynamic range. The A6700 I've been working with alone trounces the output of the OM-1 I had some time ago. And the Z9 tops them all. You can't make up for shear sensor size let alone the modern processing they are provided with. I have no doubt the Fuji takes DR up a notch as well should that be important to one's shooting. It doesn't take a huge variety of shooting to trip up a Mft setup is all I'm saying.
p.10 #14Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote: fotografur wroteRoamingScott wroteBack to the topic.
Which GF has the better rendering, the 45/2.8 or the 50/3.5? Most things I’ve read about the 45 are that’s is super clinical and that most people sell theirs for some reason or another.When I had the 45 and 50 I didn't care for the rendering of either. I would give a slight nod to the 45, but that's me. I would ud my old Minolta 55 f1.7. I now have neither. I just have the GF55 f1.7 and GF20-35 and that's all that I need. For me.Was it the bokeh that you didn't care for? Or just overly clinical and sharp?
My thought being is that, if 40ishmm is a commonly used landscape length for me, the 50/3.5 might make some sense being so tiny and double as the walk around lens. It seems like the reasons people tend to poo poo it for portraits is what would make it an appealing landscape optic.
I'm not sure I see enough pluses with the 45mm for this use case...both could be used to do multishot stitching if needed and the 45 doesn't seem to have much better bokeh for the occasional portrait type use than the 50 does....Show more →
It wasn't the bokeh, not that there is much at mid distance but it was just boring rendering to me. Kind of like the Sony 35mm f2.8 if you know what I mean. My feelings are you might just as well shoot the cheap GF 35-70. Now if you are looking for a compact set-up yeah the GF50 f3.5 will do fine, again nothing special but a good small cheap travel lens.Not for me though. YMMV.
p.10 #15Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Hmmm. I’ve never owned the 45 so can’t speak to it directly, but am actually impressed by how well the little 50 does corner to corner, even at its wider apertures. At f8 it, or at least my copy is as good as any other gf glass. I will generally use my 32-64 for landscapes, but wouldn’t hesitate to take the 50 if I knew it was going to be good for the image I wanted to make.
p.10 #16Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
gear-nut wrote:
Hmmm. I’ve never owned the 45 so can’t speak to it directly, but am actually impressed by how well the little 50 does corner to corner, even at its wider apertures. At f8 it, or at least my copy is as good as any other gf glass. I will generally use my 32-64 for landscapes, but wouldn’t hesitate to take the 50 if I knew it was going to be good for the image I wanted to make.
Yep the GF50 is a sharp little lens, just like the ZONY 35 f2.8, like I said.
But the rendering is not something special. Again many like it YMMV
p.10 #17Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
fotografur wrote: gear-nut wroteHmmm. I’ve never owned the 45 so can’t speak to it directly, but am actually impressed by how well the little 50 does corner to corner, even at its wider apertures. At f8 it, or at least my copy is as good as any other gf glass. I will generally use my 32-64 for landscapes, but wouldn’t hesitate to take the 50 if I knew it was going to be good for the image I wanted to make.Yep the GF50 is a sharp little lens, just like the ZONY 35 f2.8, like I said.
But the rendering is not something special. Again many like it YMMV
Got it. Yes have to agree, rendering is sharp with good contrast and color, nothing objectionable and nothing special; just really good vanilla . I just adapted a Sigma EF ART 50, and it has a little character and works surprisingly well wide open, so I’ll probably keep it—but it's more of a specialty lifestyle lens, so I’d grab the gf 50 for landscape over it 8 days a week.
p.10 #19Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
Back to the topic.
Which GF has the better rendering, the 45/2.8 or the 50/3.5? Most things I’ve read about the 45 are that’s is super clinical and that most people sell theirs for some reason or another.
GF 50 has a very smooth transitions from in to out of focus at distances that trip up the GF 45 and GF 63. The GF 50’s weakness IMO is its longer minimum focus distance. No GF lens has a clinical rendering (also IMO). The GF 45 would be my choice for landscape and portraits if you prefer the 35mm full frame FOV. Google search portrait photography by Chris Dodkin. He made extensive use of the GF 45 for outdoor model shoots.
I would make your decision based on FOV and weight/size rather than rendering. Either lens can be make wonderful photos.
p.10 #20Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I think it's more important how you use your lens than whether it's a 45, 50 or 55mm, or whatever. Back in the days of shooting location portraits for top music magazines on film with RB and RZ67's, no one ever mentioned, let alone heard of bokeh or transition zones. We just shot and whether the shot was great or sucked depended more on your ability or light or recognize light and how well you interacted with your subject. Never once said to myself looking at images of George Harrison, "Gee, I wish I had used a lens with a smoother mid field transition" or whatever. Never. Not once.
For a lens in the normal focal length range, the GF55mm f/1.7 seems to hit the nail on the head for me. Images so far just look fab.