letchhausen wrote: rdeloe wroteUnfortunately the Hasselblad CFV 100C has a major limitation for that use case. The wide technical lenses produce strong banding when shifted. Owners who bought it to use on technical cameras and digital view cameras are not happy, especially now that it's been documented that Hasselblad knew about the issue.
This is really unfortunate because it is otherwise a great option. There's no timeline from Hasselblad on a fix (firmware or Phocus).So, are these people using Phase backs? Not that I can afford that either. Yeah, Hasselblad's plans over the last 8 years would be called...diplomatically, I would say....mystifying.
At one time, I was interested in the Arca Swiss F Universalis (DSLR) with the Sony Rotofoot thinking I could be using my 4x5 lenses and get some movements. I noticed that you had some experience with that using Fuji. Was reading your report yesterday. If I could rent that system to see how well it works...I might be in trouble.
What I'm seeing is that a lot of people waited for the CFV 100C with great excitement, and grabbed it as soon as it came out. People using it with the 907X and native lenses, and people sticking it on the back of their Hasselblad film bodies in place of the film holder, are delighted because there are no issues. But Hasselblad in its advertising explicitly pitched it as being an option for tech cameras instead of much more expensive backs. Those people are not happy. There's a long thread here on GetDPI: https://www.getdpi.com/forum/index.php?threads/hasselblad-100c-and-35xl.75781/ Warren Diggles, who started that thread, has come up with a way of cleaning up the banding, but it's a lot of work and technically a bit tricky. Discovering evidence that Hasselblad knew this was a problem before it started selling the backs is particularly irritating to people who bought it for technical cameras.
People who had Phase One backs are not experiencing the issue. I'm not experiencing any banding when I shift wide technical lenses on my GFX 100S with F-Universalis. I use the APO-Digitar 35/5.6 L-88, which is the one that revealed the problem to Warren, and it's fine within the 8mm I can move it.
If Hasselblad can just fix this with firmware or a change in Phocus, everyone will settle down. They could certainly do a much better job on the communication front. A concerted "Mea Culpa" with a promise to fix the problem and a timeline would make a lot of sense. But crickets is what people are hearing.
FWIW to the Hassy/Phase discussion -- Phase has a built-in "LCC" correction frame inside C1 for their backs on tech cameras to correct the color-shifts imparted by lens movements relative to the back (these do not occur with a lens centered and parallel to the sensor). You basically set up your image with the movements as you want, take the frame, then reasonably soon afterward in the same light take the LCC frame by placing a translucent filter over your lens and snapping. This generates the color-cast projection file that the LCC toggle negates. It works perfectly, albeit requiring two frames for every image you take unless they are all at the same camera and lens settings under the same light. The other nit when you're in low light doing long exposures, you will have long exposure NR on, which doubles the exposure time, and same for the LCC which all in all requires 4x the total exposure time to complete. So in that regard it was a total PITA. By contrast, TS/PC lenses on a camera like the Fuji are a breeze relatively speaking.
Notes:
-The best way to compare is to upscale *both* to either a common long edge or common short edge. The difference between formats is much greater if you compare at 4:3 than it is at 3:2. Then try to equalize contrast and exposure as much as possible. Turn off all sharpening, since it's usually per-pixel, and the pixels are not equal.
-All are prime versus zoom. We go to war with the army we have--what I was testing then is not quite the topic of this thread. If we ever see a higher res z7.3, I'll probably shoot new comparisons between my proposed landscape kits.
-The biggest difference I see is the lack of aliasing in the GFX files. Especially with the CV 65, we see that the Z can keep up with premium sharp glass, but it starts aliasing like crazy.
-The Fuji 45-100 focus locus starts curling at the edges at 45mm as it's stopped down. I like shooting it in forests, but I wouldn't take it on an open-country landscape hike.
gear-nut wrote:
FWIW to the Hassy/Phase discussion -- Phase has a built-in "LCC" correction frame inside C1 for their backs on tech cameras to correct the color-shifts imparted by lens movements relative to the back (these do not occur with a lens centered and parallel to the sensor). You basically set up your image with the movements as you want, take the frame, then reasonably soon afterward in the same light take the LCC frame by placing a translucent filter over your lens and snapping. This generates the color-cast projection file that the LCC toggle negates. It works perfectly, albeit requiring two frames for every image you take unless they are all at the same camera and lens settings under the same light. The other nit when you're in low light doing long exposures, you will have long exposure NR on, which doubles the exposure time, and same for the LCC which all in all requires 4x the total exposure time to complete. So in that regard it was a total PITA. By contrast, TS/PC lenses on a camera like the Fuji are a breeze relatively speaking. ...Show more →
I have to use an LCC frame with the APO-Digitar 35/5.6. It has enormous light falloff, which is corrected using the LCC frame. It sounds worse than it is. I shoot the image and then shoot the LCC frame. In LR, I select the two and apply Flat Field Correction.
This would correct colour shift if there was any, but there's nothing that bothers me because the GFX 100S is a BSI sensor.
Tilt-shift lenses for systems like Canon and Nikon don't have this issue because they are retrofocus designs. It's the symmetrical wide angle lenses that require(d) LCC frames.
Why bother you might ask? The lens is extremely small and light, very sharp, shifts nicely for 8mm, and is almost completely free of distortion. Retrofocus wide angle lenses like my SMC Pentax-A 645 35/5.6 have moustache distortion; it's the price for the design.
Sorry for the huge tangent Scott! I think we've reached the point in the thread where you got where you're going to get, and now we're just roaming around.
A good primer on what to look for in my testing of the 20-70. The more I read on this lens, the more I don't think the impressions I've heard from users mesh with the technical gotchas of the lens.
Overall, of course it's a highly software corrected lens, but it seems like it was designed more for bloggers and run and gun shooters. Not sure that this lens will come close to maximize the A7R5 sensor, and that the 24-70 GM II seems like the more obvious choice if I'm trying to avoid medium format. And yet...20-70 users almost unanimously say it's a great lens, even up to landscape use. Perhaps it's just a prosumer lens getting high marks from middling users.
Then, on the other side of the spectrum, you have the 35-70 which looks, frankly, embarrassing wide open in Dustin's review. It doesn't seem to adequately clean up until f8. Even the midframe of this lens is visibly weak until f8, which...doesn't at all jive with impressions in this thread.
Both of these reviews make you appreciate what Nikon was able to pull off with the Z 24-120. Maybe I've just lost the plot Make me think the weight of the Z9 + 24-120 is perhaps still the better option for FF shooting. We'll see.
What I'm seeing is that a lot of people waited for the CFV 100C with great excitement, and grabbed it as soon as it came out. People using it with the 907X and native lenses, and people sticking it on the back of their Hasselblad film bodies in place of the film holder, are delighted because there are no issues.
What happened to me was that I had talked to a Hasselblad rep wanting a back (I think the 50mp was the deal at that point) and instead of releasing a back for us film body owners, they took forever and finally launched the 907X which, for me, killed the deal. I didn't want their crappy "camera" part of their insanely expensive lenses. At that point, I was not using a digital camera, I was shooting 4x5 and 6x6. When the pandemic hit, I bought an A7RIV here on FM for various low impact life in the new world type travel. And the system is just compact enough that I take on trips with my significant other where I'm not really doing photography. I know others that were similarly disheartened by Hassy's decision and also moved into other systems, a couple ended up in Fuji-land.
I would still like that LF experience via something like the Universalis, but not sure pairing that up with my Sony makes sense. Arca was at a store here, but didn't really get the info I needed so I let it drop.
letchhausen wrote: rdeloe wroteWhat I'm seeing is that a lot of people waited for the CFV 100C with great excitement, and grabbed it as soon as it came out. People using it with the 907X and native lenses, and people sticking it on the back of their Hasselblad film bodies in place of the film holder, are delighted because there are no issues.
What happened to me was that I had talked to a Hasselblad rep wanting a back (I think the 50mp was the deal at that point) and instead of releasing a back for us film body owners, they took forever and finally launched the 907X which, for me, killed the deal. I didn't want their crappy "camera" part of their insanely expensive lenses. At that point, I was not using a digital camera, I was shooting 4x5 and 6x6. When the pandemic hit, I bought an A7RIV here on FM for various low impact life in the new world type travel. And the system is just compact enough that I take on trips with my significant other where I'm not really doing photography. I know others that were similarly disheartened by Hassy's decision and also moved into other systems, a couple ended up in Fuji-land.
I would still like that LF experience via something like the Universalis, but not sure pairing that up with my Sony makes sense. Arca was at a store here, but didn't really get the info I needed so I let it drop.
The reason I use GFX on my digital medium format has nothing to do with resolution. I was quite happy shooting a 50 MP GFX 50R on digital view cameras. I only switched to the 100S because of the BSI sensor. The reason 33mm x 44mm sensors are a good choice for me is that the widest lens that could shift well with good image quality and reach infinity was the Pentax-A 645 35mm. On a GFX sensor, that lens gives me a field of view that is about as wide as I ever need. A 35mm lens is also the widest medium format lens that could be used with a full frame sensor, on which it has a narrower field of view. So the sweet spot is 33mm x 44mm, or spend a lot more money and get a medium format back; that opens up the wide technical camera lenses.
If you don't need wide fields of view, a full frame camera on an F-Universalis or Cambo Actus would work just fine. There are some relatively inexpensive options as wide as 50mm that work well.
Wider is always the problem unless you use a medium format back. I could just use tilt-shift lenses on full frame or GFX to get wider fields of view, but I don't like tilt-shift lenses. I come from 4x5 view cameras, and really prefer that style of working. It's a shame that if I needed wider than 35mm, I'd have to buy the GF 30mm Tilt-Shift, which is unmatched. I would put it ahead of even comparable Rodenstock technical lenses on medium format backs -- it's that good. It's also a huge lens that I'd rarely use, so I make do with 35mm as my widest.
I wasn't thinking of resolution as much as the size of the sensor vis a vis the movements. My wide on 4x5 is a rarely used 135mm so no issues there. Looking at the Actus, I see that it has Copal 1 attachments, so I could use my LF lenses I presume?
Though wandering afield from OP's thread opening, I think some of what we're discussing is relevant. To me, putting aside hair-splitting "resolution" thoughts, a lot of the real deal in photography is the logistics of whatever system you're using, size, weight, controls, etc.
If I still had access to a color darkroom, I would not be shooting digital at all. Nothing makes me want to poke my eyes out like opening C1 or PS and working my images in software. I do appreciate digital cameras as photographic tools, but would like to replicate the LF physical aspect of photography.
letchhausen wrote:
I wasn't thinking of resolution as much as the size of the sensor vis a vis the movements. My wide on 4x5 is a rarely used 135mm so no issues there. Looking at the Actus, I see that it has Copal 1 attachments, so I could use my LF lenses I presume?
Though wandering afield from OP's thread opening, I think some of what we're discussing is relevant. To me, putting aside hair-splitting "resolution" thoughts, a lot of the real deal in photography is the logistics of whatever system you're using, size, weight, controls, etc.
If I still had access to a color darkroom, I would not be shooting digital at all. Nothing makes me want to poke my eyes out like opening C1 or PS and working my images in software. I do appreciate digital cameras as photographic tools, but would like to replicate the LF physical aspect of photography. ...Show more →
This probably needs a new thread, but I don't know if enough people on FM would be interested. This is the kind of conversation I generally have on other sites.
Anyway, if 135mm on 4x5 was as wide as you liked, then a 47mm on GFX, or a 35mm lens on full frame, would be a good choice. There is a 47mm you could use on GFX (the APO-Digitar 47/5.6, which is just a rebadged Super-Angulon 47mm MC), but it's not a good performer.
If you can live with the moustache distortion (which is only noticeable in architecture and interior photography) then the Pentax-A 645 35/3.5 would be a strong option on full frame. It was my mainstay wide lens on all three digital view cameras I used with GFX and when I used tilt-shift adapters and a Sony A7R. The only reason I switched to the APO-Digitar 35mm is the lighter weight, lack of distortion, and most importantly, ability to focus by rail. On my GFX 100S, at f/8, the Pentax-A is as sharp as the GF 35-70mm at 35mm and f/8.
On a full frame camera, you can shift the Pentax 15mm on the long side. A 15mm shift on full frame is the equivalent of shifting your 135mm 75mm on 4x5. There are some interesting full frame options that are very small and light, like the Sigma FP-L.
p.7 #10Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
You use a Z9 for two and a half years and suddenly picking up a sony is like picking up a small brick...all right angles. Forgot about the days where my pinky was left high and dry under the body
p.7 #11Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
You use a Z9 for two and a half years and suddenly picking up a sony is like picking up a small brick...all right angles. Forgot about the days where my pinky was left high and dry under the body
I think I might have mentioned a time or three I couldn’t jive with Sony ergos
p.7 #12Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
gear-nut wrote: RoamingScott wroteYou use a Z9 for two and a half years and suddenly picking up a sony is like picking up a small brick...all right angles. Forgot about the days where my pinky was left high and dry under the body I think I might have mentioned a time or three I couldn’t jive with Sony ergos
Turns out your opinion isn't the one that matters
Forgot I used to have a baseplate on my A7R4 for this reason, it really helps a lot to keep the whole hand in place.
p.7 #13Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote: gear-nut wroteRoamingScott wroteYou use a Z9 for two and a half years and suddenly picking up a sony is like picking up a small brick...all right angles. Forgot about the days where my pinky was left high and dry under the body I think I might have mentioned a time or three I couldn’t jive with Sony ergos Turns out your opinion isn't the one that matters
Forgot I used to have a baseplate on my A7R4 for this reason, it really helps a lot to keep the whole hand in place.
Yeah, well, after adding the baseplate the Sony is almost the same size as the gfx100s 🤣🤣🤣
p.7 #14Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
You use a Z9 for two and a half years and suddenly picking up a sony is like picking up a small brick...all right angles. Forgot about the days where my pinky was left high and dry under the body
I guess I'm the only person that uses the pinky underneath routine to support the camera....
p.7 #15Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
OK, I just returned from three weeks traveling in northern Vietnam to photograph the hill tribes up near the border with China. I took an A7R5 and a FE 70-200 F2.8 GM II, along with my Fuji system. The Fuji gear was the GFX 100ii, GF 20-35 F4, GF 32-64 F4, and GF 45-100 F4. I used both systems about equally.
I've only been back a couple of days so haven't had time to process images. My use case for the Sony was street photography and tele landscapes, where the Fuji gear was used for landscapes and environmental portraiture. I found the Sony system to be much more usable, but that was probably because of my familiarity with it. I've only had the Fuji system for about a month, so this trip was a bit of a learning experience. Other than weight and lack of higher speed optics I don't have much negative to say about the Fuji gear. I had no technical problems with the Fuji system (Flawless), though I did have problems with sporadic corrupt files with the A7R5 (has anyone else seen this?). I'll post more after I have a chance to see the images in LR.
p.7 #16Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
letchhausen wrote: RoamingScott wroteYou use a Z9 for two and a half years and suddenly picking up a sony is like picking up a small brick...all right angles. Forgot about the days where my pinky was left high and dry under the body I guess I'm the only person that uses the pinky underneath routine to support the camera....
I did that for many years when shooting Sony. It's terrible for your long term joint health, I came to find out. Wish I hadn't.
p.7 #17Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote: letchhausen wroteI guess I'm the only person that uses the pinky underneath routine to support the camera....I did that for many years when shooting Sony. It's terrible for your long term joint health, I came to find out. Wish I hadn't.
Yikes! That had not occurred to me, dude. Thanks for the pro tip!
p.7 #18Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Some A/B of a favorite setup that I like to use to test near-ish focus with lots of different elements in play. I left AWB on for both since I was curious how the Sony's "new" AWB system works.
You can view any of these full size if you open them in a new tab. I immediately noticed how "bubbly" the 20-70 bokeh is compared to the 24-120. The Nikon is, in general keeping things held together in the background better.
The corners are also a pretty stark difference at almost all focal lengths, as the 20-70's correct distortion is still readily apparent where the Nikon remains rather flat looking.
I see no tangible detail advantages on the Sony files.
Immediate takeaway: if I'm potentially willing to carry a Fuji with far less range than the 24-120, why am I unwilling to carry the Z9 and 24-120, which is a world class optic in this category. Food for thought I don't see the Sony 20-70 being a serious competitor for this particular lens range for me.
p.7 #20Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I have the GFX100II and A7R5. I don't have a Z8 (just a Z7), so I can't comment on that. But I can on the other two. I also print to over 60 inches. I just finished setting up my new 44" printer last week.
My personal preference is to carry the extra of the GFX for when I'm shooting to print. When it's more than 10kms, I'll switch to a Sony (A7CR with 20-70 and 70-200). I'll accept the small IQ differences. The 16 bit files of the GFX make them *slightly* more pliable in post than the 14 bit Sony's. Bite is lens based. I shoot the 20-70 from 5.6 for maximum detail and the 70-200 needs only about a half stop. I don't shoot landscapes wide open so it's not a big deal to me.
I look at the GFX this way. It's both a 100MP and 60MP system. If I carry the Sony I'm always at 61MP. If I carry the GFX, sometimes I'm at 61MP. But not often. So my 32-64, I treat like a 25-64mm lens. I'll also carry the 100-200. That's my two lens kit. If I want more I switch out to the 20-35, 45-100, 100-200 and TC but that's for short hikes only.
I use magnetic filters so I have adaptor rings and magnetic lens caps on the lenses. That means one filter set. I use a card rather than lens hoods. I do use a tripod a lot. Maybe 50/50. Can't seem to drop that habit.
Another advantage of the GFX is cropping. The XPan format is 50MP. 1:1 is 80MP. 2:1 is 80MP.