fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape

  
 
Jack Flesher
Online
Details
p.6 #1Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape


Daran wrote:
rdeloe wrote
Aztatlan wroteBy all means compare on factors like dynamic range, noise, etc, but testing sharpness is largely redundant.
It's difficult to compare sharpness, but it's only redundant if you don't care about it. I don't think it's unreasonable as a comparison point if we're comparing high end systems like these.
If you shoot high resolution sensors through a low resolving optic, the predictable result is that the higher resolution sensor gains you rather little. So using that to evaluate the actual relative merits of those sensors is pointless.

Of course another great leveler is aperture. For landscapes you'd usually wana shoot closed up apertures for it's larger DOF, but that will also limit the achievable resolution. And this effect is independent of sensor size: as you close the larger and the smaller sensor systems to equivalent apertures, the limiting effect of diffraction will also be equivalent.


Yes but. Even with a lesser optic, more mp almost always gives you smoother tonality, which frankly is what I think gives MF the “look” edge over Fx capture in the first place — this in turn adds to gentler transitions into the oof areas, also adding to that MF look. Then add any higher contrast edge, and even the poorer lenses can resolve it on the high mp sensor, and it’s smoother due to the higher mp count, and this in turn adds to the impression of greater overall “sharpness” even though there is lower micro contrast. Finally, lesser lenses usually have other optical imperfections, like a little more flare which can open up shadows in high contrast scenes, again enhancing the impression of smoothness, albeit at the expense of micro detail. But combine all that, and now getting a unique look to the images AND/OR the best resolution (when using best glass) is the reign of MF capture — but almost always at the cost of flexibility…

Now whether those subtleties are worth the loss of flexibility in weight gain, focal limitation and cost to the individual photographer are arguable, and ultimately up to that individual as to how they want to create their art or want it to “look.”
May 28, 2024 at 08:42 AM
rdeloe
Offline
Details
p.6 #2Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Daran wrote:
rdeloe wrote
Aztatlan wroteBy all means compare on factors like dynamic range, noise, etc, but testing sharpness is largely redundant.
It's difficult to compare sharpness, but it's only redundant if you don't care about it. I don't think it's unreasonable as a comparison point if we're comparing high end systems like these.
If you shoot high resolution sensors through a low resolving optic, the predictable result is that the higher resolution sensor gains you rather little. So using that to evaluate the actual relative merits of those sensors is pointless..


Yes, of course. And that's why I said the only meaningful comparison is based on using the same lens. I can do that on my setup, but most people don't have the tools to do that, so they pick lenses they think are comparable based on focal length, field of view, and perceptions about "quality". In reality two different lenses are not going to be the same, so the results of that kind of test remain questionable. But it's better than nothing.

Anyway, I think Scott knows all this already. A 60 MP sensor is more than enough, so I expect his choice is going to come down to how the camera feels in his hand, how much the whole system weighs, whether or not the lenses cover his desired focal lengths, etc. -- in other words, all the things that matter a lot more than sharpness.
May 28, 2024 at 08:42 AM
Jack Flesher
Online
Details
p.6 #3Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I’m going to add one more thing: in my experience selling larger prints, very few people bought them because they were perfectly sharp or technically excellent. In fact one of my most successful prints I took years ago on 35mm Velvia with the first generation Nikon af 24, which was by today’s standards a plastic POS. So poor optics on the shallowest latitude chrome film available. It was further a double exposure to capture sunset sky and moonlit building with a 2-1/2 hour post exposure, so ground vibrations and atmosphere effect negatively impacting IQ further. Anyway, printed to 16x24, a large print at the time, it looked very good — and was definitely “unique” even though it held about as much detail as a watercolor. But it was the uniqueness that made it art people wanted to buy…. FWIW.
May 28, 2024 at 08:50 AM
Peter Figen
Offline
Details
p.6 #4Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
rdeloe wrote:
RoamingScott wroteFYI Rob, he was adapting the old Canon TS-E to the Sony. Who knows what all that changes here.
Good to know that it was the Canon TS-E 24mm. I went straight for the RAW files and didn't read his text so I missed that. I haven't used that lens but the consensus among people who have used it on GFX is "good" but not top notch like the newer Canon TS-E designs.


I know that's the consensus concerning the Canon 24mm t/s-e II, but in my actual use this is not the case. My personal consensus is that most of the people who reached that consensus didn't know how to properly focus the lens. It's extremely sensitive to proper focusing, but when focused well, the results are really quite amazing. Not only that, I've also done careful comparisons between the Canon 24 t/s-e and the GF20-35 at approximately 24mm on both the 100s and the 100II cameras, more to see if there was anything to Fuji's claim of improved wide angle corner performance (yes, but barely) and found that the Canon actually outperforms the Fuji very slightly at the pixel level but in real world prints there would be no visible difference. What I saw in the corners was that at f/5.6 and f/8, the Canon was very slightly sharper than the Fuji but at f/11 they were virtually tied. Same thing for the supposedly improved wide angle corner performance of the 100II body. Any improvement that was barely visible was gone by f/11, where much landscape and almost all architectural interiors are shot.

I've shot lots of architectural interiors with the Canon 24 on the GFX and you can easily shift up to about 10mm vertically on a horizontal frame. I would not go that far horizontally on a horizontal frame but then I wouldn't on a Canon either. Yes, the GF30mm t/s is better, but it's not better if it's not wide enough for the shot you're making.

And last August on our annual eastern Sierras excursion, where I revisit the famous, well, infamous, Gene Autry Rock in the Alabama Hills, I shot it with both the Canon 24 and the GF 20-25 at around 22.5mm (shoot the 24 first and then match as close as possible with the zoom) and you literally cannot distinguish between the two - both very sharp and contrasty right out to the very corners of the GFX frame. You might argue that I somehow got a crappola 20-35, but I don't think so as it sure seems to be critically sharp everywhere at all focal lengths, or perhaps an extras creamy good copy of the Canon lens. Maybe, but how would one know other than that, between two photographers in my studio we have three of the Canon 24's (and 17's too) and all of the 24's are in line with each other. Only a sample of three, but that's all we have to work with.

May 28, 2024 at 08:57 AM
rdeloe
Offline
Details
p.6 #5Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Peter Figen wrote:
rdeloe wrote
RoamingScott wroteFYI Rob, he was adapting the old Canon TS-E to the Sony. Who knows what all that changes here.
Good to know that it was the Canon TS-E 24mm. I went straight for the RAW files and didn't read his text so I missed that. I haven't used that lens but the consensus among people who have used it on GFX is "good" but not top notch like the newer Canon TS-E designs.
I know that's the consensus concerning the Canon 24mm t/s-e II, but in my actual use this is not the case. My personal consensus is that most of the people who reached that consensus didn't know how to properly focus the lens. It's extremely sensitive to proper focusing, but when focused well, the results are really quite amazing. Not only that, I've also done careful comparisons between the Canon 24 t/s-e and the GF20-35 at approximately 24mm on both the 100s and the 100II cameras, more to see if there was anything to Fuji's claim of improved wide angle
...Show more →

That's good feedback. Without a doubt the ability of the user to focus the lens properly is a huge consideration. I see this all the time. Adaptation issues are also a major factor. I use adapted lenses exclusively on my setup, and have noticed that incredibly small errors in the construction or setup of the adapter can make a significant difference. The thick GFX cover glass adds a whole other challenge for wide symmetrical lenses.

Do you think there's also copy variation in play, and you have a really good one?
May 28, 2024 at 09:07 AM
Daran
Offline
Details
p.6 #6Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
rdeloe wrote:
Daran wrote
rdeloe wrote
Aztatlan wroteBy all means compare on factors like dynamic range, noise, etc, but testing sharpness is largely redundant.
It's difficult to compare sharpness, but it's only redundant if you don't care about it. I don't think it's unreasonable as a comparison point if we're comparing high end systems like these.
If you shoot high resolution sensors through a low resolving optic, the predictable result is that the higher resolution sensor gains you rather little. So using that to evaluate the actual relative merits of those sensors is pointless..
Yes, of course. And that's why I said the only meaningful comparison is based on using the same lens. I can do that on my setup, but most people don't have the tools to do that, so they pick lenses they think are comparable based on focal length, field of view, and perceptions about "quality". In reality two different lenses are not going to be the same, so the results of that kind of test remain questionable. But it's better than nothing.

I don't kno0w what you are shooting, but testing the same lens on different sensors isn't normally a meaningful option as the sharpest lenses on one system usually can't even be mounted on the other, or even if they can, sensor thickness or flange distance differences can easily spoil your party. I think your previous recommendation to directly compare the respective best lens options is a much more practical approach and less prone to confound things with irrelevant issues. The respecitve lens choice is likely going to have more influence on the resulting IQ than the sensor, anyway.
May 28, 2024 at 09:13 AM
rdeloe
Offline
Details
p.6 #7Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Daran wrote:
rdeloe wrote
Daran wrote
rdeloe wrote
Aztatlan wroteBy all means compare on factors like dynamic range, noise, etc, but testing sharpness is largely redundant.
It's difficult to compare sharpness, but it's only redundant if you don't care about it. I don't think it's unreasonable as a comparison point if we're comparing high end systems like these.
If you shoot high resolution sensors through a low resolving optic, the predictable result is that the higher resolution sensor gains you rather little. So using that to evaluate the actual relative merits of those sensors is pointless..
Yes, of course. And that's why I said the only meaningful comparison is based on using the same lens. I can do that on my setup, but most people don't have the tools to do that, so they pick lenses they think are comparable based on focal length, field of view, and perceptions about "quality". In reality two different lenses are not going to be the same, so the results of that kind of test remain questionable. But it's better than nothing.
I don't kno0w what you are shooting, but testing the same lens on different sensors isn't normally a meaningful option as the sharpest lenses on one system usually can't even be mounted on the other, or even if they can, sensor thickness or flange distance differences can easily spoil your party. I think your previous recommendation to directly compare the respective best lens options is a much more practical approach and less prone to confound things with irrelevant issues. The respecitve lens choice is likely going to have more influence on the resulting IQ than the sensor, anyway.


I'm shooting an Arca-Swiss F-Universalis. I can put different sensors on the back to compare how they do using the same lens.

As I said a couple times already in this thread... that's not possible for most people, and is quite beside the point for anyone who wants to build a system around native lenses. Hence the realistic option is comparing what you think is the "best" lens for each system. That's not perfect because two lenses from different systems are not giving you truly comparable results. But so what? Ultimately people choose one system or another.
May 28, 2024 at 09:33 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.6 #8Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
There are so many variables that go into all of this that it's really not possible to make a fully informed decision without all of it in your hands.

For example, when I was comparing Sony and Nikon before I made that switch, I had people saying they couldn't see any difference between the transition zones on the Nikon and Sony 100-400 lenses...well, after shooting thousands of images with each, the differences (in favor of the Nikon) were readily apparent to me. If the improvements the Nikon offer don't matter to someone, or they didn't have enough experience to know what to look for to make a qualified statement, they'd come to a thread like this and proclaim "the 100-400GM is just as good" without knowing how or why they are wrong.

So yeah, these threads are useful for gaining a GENERAL sense of what people see, and why they make the decisions they make...but there are plenty of people shooting GFX that are straight up wasting their money if they think their results are better than what FF could give them, simply because they aren't at the GFX level of skill. That doesn't matter of course, everyone is free to do as they please, but there is a level of finesse required to maximize the gains when we get to this edge of photography.

And after 6 pages, we have one online article derided for its failures in A/B testing, a few folks that have both, or HAD both, and decided that the heft wasn't worth it and use their Sony stuff more, and a bunch of people justifying their purchase on one side of the house without having tried the other
May 28, 2024 at 09:49 AM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.6 #9Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I had Sony...feel like I enjoy shooting GFX more because the colors look more accurate. I honestly just don't even attempt to weigh in on here, because you want a system to cover all gaps and I honestly kinda don't care at this point with the gaps and just shoot. Granted we shoot very different things.
RoamingScott wrote:
There are so many variables that go into all of this that it's really not possible to make a fully informed decision without all of it in your hands.

For example, when I was comparing Sony and Nikon before I made that switch, I had people saying they couldn't see any difference between the transition zones on the Nikon and Sony 100-400 lenses...well, after shooting thousands of images with each, the differences (in favor of the Nikon) were readily apparent to me. If the improvements the Nikon offer don't matter to someone, or they didn't have enough experience to know what
...Show more →

May 28, 2024 at 10:04 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.6 #10Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
JadedWriter wrote:
I had Sony...feel like I enjoy shooting GFX more because the colors look more accurate. I honestly just don't even attempt to weigh in on here, because you want a system to cover all gaps and I honestly kinda don't care at this point with the gaps and just shoot. Granted we shoot very different things.
RoamingScott wroteThere are so many variables that go into all of this that it's really not possible to make a fully informed decision without all of it in your hands.

For example, when I was comparing Sony and Nikon before I made that switch, I had people saying they couldn't see any difference between the transition zones on the Nikon and Sony 100-400 lenses...well, after shooting thousands of images with each, the differences (in favor of the Nikon) were readily apparent to me. If the improvements the Nikon offer don't matter to someone, or they didn't have enough experience to know what to look for to make a qualified statement, they'd come to a thread like this and proclaim "the 100-400GM is just as good" without knowing how or why they are wrong.

So yeah, these threads are useful for gaining a GENERAL sense of what people see, and why they make the decisions they make...but there are plenty of people shooting GFX that are straight up wasting their money if they think their results are better than what FF could give them, simply because they aren't at the GFX level of skill. That doesn't matter of course, everyone is free to do as they please, but there is a level of finesse required to maximize the gains when we get to this edge of photography.

And after 6 pages, we have one online article derided for its failures in A/B testing, a few folks that have both, or HAD both, and decided that the heft wasn't worth it and use their Sony stuff more, and a bunch of people justifying their purchase on one side of the house without having tried the other


Yeah I think GFX is a great fit for you and your prime/portrait stuff. The jump in quality over your APS-C stuff is stark, and obviously a bit marginal over your Z9 stuff.
May 28, 2024 at 10:06 AM
rdeloe
Offline
Details
p.6 #11Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
And after 6 pages, we have one online article derided for its failures in A/B testing, a few folks that have both, or HAD both, and decided that the heft wasn't worth it and use their Sony stuff more, and a bunch of people justifying their purchase on one side of the house without having tried the other


https://www.iwastesomuchtime.com/and-pour-used-oil-down-the-disposal
May 28, 2024 at 10:14 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.6 #12Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
rdeloe wrote:
RoamingScott wroteAnd after 6 pages, we have one online article derided for its failures in A/B testing, a few folks that have both, or HAD both, and decided that the heft wasn't worth it and use their Sony stuff more, and a bunch of people justifying their purchase on one side of the house without having tried the other
https://www.iwastesomuchtime.com/and-pour-used-oil-down-the-disposal


Wow, you took me right back to the afternoon I got home in college and found my perfectly seasoned pan sitting in a sink full of soapy water.

I wasn't ready to feel this way again.
May 28, 2024 at 10:15 AM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.6 #13Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Yeah I like the Z9 and GFX equally, but for different things. Main GFX draw is that I really prefer the aspect ratio for vertical shooting over the Z9. Feels like it's just a more natural crop and you get more information in there and it's less cramped for the subject. Z9 with the right lenses has more bombastic bokeh, but the fall off seems more natural with the GFX.
RoamingScott wrote:
JadedWriter wroteI had Sony...feel like I enjoy shooting GFX more because the colors look more accurate. I honestly just don't even attempt to weigh in on here, because you want a system to cover all gaps and I honestly kinda don't care at this point with the gaps and just shoot. Granted we shoot very different things.
RoamingScott wroteThere are so many variables that go into all of this that it's really not possible to make a fully informed decision without all of it in your hands.

For example, when I was comparing Sony and Nikon before I made that switch, I had people saying they couldn't see any difference between the transition zones on the Nikon and Sony 100-400 lenses...well, after shooting thousands of images with each, the differences (in favor of the Nikon) were readily apparent to me. If the improvements the Nikon offer don't matter to someone, or they didn't have enough experience to know what to look for to make a qualified statement, they'd come to a thread like this and proclaim "the 100-400GM is just as good" without knowing how or why they are wrong.

So yeah, these threads are useful for gaining a GENERAL sense of what people see, and why they make the decisions they make...but there are plenty of people shooting GFX that are straight up wasting their money if they think their results are better than what FF could give them, simply because they aren't at the GFX level of skill. That doesn't matter of course, everyone is free to do as they please, but there is a level of finesse required to maximize the gains when we get to this edge of photography.

And after 6 pages, we have one online article derided for its failures in A/B testing, a few folks that have both, or HAD both, and decided that the heft wasn't worth it and use their Sony stuff more, and a bunch of people justifying their purchase on one side of the house without having tried the other
Yeah I think GFX is a great fit for you and your prime/portrait stuff. The jump in quality over your APS-C stuff is stark, and obviously a bit marginal over your Z9 stuff.


May 28, 2024 at 10:19 AM
Jack Flesher
Online
Details
p.6 #14Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
Yeah I think GFX is a great fit for you and your prime/portrait stuff. The jump in quality over your APS-C stuff is stark, and obviously a bit marginal over your Z9 stuff.


From a guy who HAS owned and used both, I can assure you the gain from the GFX100s is more than "marginal" over the Z9. At least for *MY* style of landscape work... AF speed, AE accuracy for action sports and wildlife? The Z9 all day long. Is the Z9 file horrible for landscape? Nope, not in the least -- in fact it was the single best digital file I had ever worked with until the GFX100s'.

Now how to describe the difference? I did earlier in this thread as respect *MY* eyes and processing experience, specifically in C1 and PS (I don't use LR): Take the Z9 and cut it to Dx size, and the difference between the FX and Dx capture using respective focal-length for similar framing are about identical to the difference between the GFX with any of my lenses and the Z9 with my best Z glass. So if that's the kind of difference that is "marginal" in your view --and I know for a lot of folks it is-- then you are going to be golden with the Sony 60 -- *IF* you can live with the noise and color cast
May 28, 2024 at 10:26 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.6 #15Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
gear-nut wrote:
RoamingScott wroteYeah I think GFX is a great fit for you and your prime/portrait stuff. The jump in quality over your APS-C stuff is stark, and obviously a bit marginal over your Z9 stuff.
From a guy who HAS owned and used both, I can assure you the gain from the GFX100s is more than "marginal" over the Z9. At least for *MY* style of landscape work... AF speed, AE accuracy for action sports and wildlife? The Z9 all day long. Is the Z9 file horrible for landscape? Nope, not in the least -- in fact it was the single best digital file I had ever worked with until the GFX100s'.

Now how to describe the difference? I did earlier in this thread as respect *MY* eyes and processing experience, specifically in C1 and
...Show more →

My point is I regularly look at Marcus' work, which ranges from his X-H2 shots to GFX 100S. At web resolution, they are indistinguishable. If you pixel peep on Flickr, the GFX stuff is obviously better. It's a no brainer that anyone who is pixel peeping the differences would find the GFX file "better", but the end result/output isn't all that different with normal viewing.
May 28, 2024 at 10:31 AM
letchhausen
Offline
Details
p.6 #16Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
rdeloe wrote:
Unfortunately the Hasselblad CFV 100C has a major limitation for that use case. The wide technical lenses produce strong banding when shifted. Owners who bought it to use on technical cameras and digital view cameras are not happy, especially now that it's been documented that Hasselblad knew about the issue.

This is really unfortunate because it is otherwise a great option. There's no timeline from Hasselblad on a fix (firmware or Phocus).


So, are these people using Phase backs? Not that I can afford that either. Yeah, Hasselblad's plans over the last 8 years would be called...diplomatically, I would say....mystifying.

At one time, I was interested in the Arca Swiss F Universalis (DSLR) with the Sony Rotofoot thinking I could be using my 4x5 lenses and get some movements. I noticed that you had some experience with that using Fuji. Was reading your report yesterday. If I could rent that system to see how well it works...I might be in trouble.
May 28, 2024 at 10:58 AM
SpecFoto
Online
Details
p.6 #17Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
liggy wrotelol… first world problems for sure.

Accepting that short of carrying *everything* the compromise that suits me personally is the 20-70 as a one lens solution.

For dedicated outings I’d typically tailor the kit to the job at hand. Yep - cropping at 70mm isn’t ideal but if tele is critical I’ll just tote a longer lens in addition to the 20-70.

This is part of the fun though tbh. If you were local you’d be welcome to try my 35-70 but I’d feel the need for the 20-35 or 23 on a landscape oriented outing as you mentioned.
As a fun morning activity, I dug through EXIF of my favorite landscape images. Many at 24...28...sooo many at 43 (what?!)...and then it jumped to either 105 if on Sony and 120 if on Z.




OK...I am going to suggest an alternative plan instead of adding yet another camera system... Keep your Z9, as NIkon will eventually have a smaller FF body with the Sony 61MP sensor you can upgrade to, and continue to use your current favorite 24-120mm lens. But add a superb landscape lens that is near the 43mm F/L you came to find was your most used, the PC-E Micro Nikkor 45mm f2.8 ED. While no longer made, great copies are available used around $1.000 and it will adapt just fine to your newer bodies.

I used Nikon for many years as my main Landscape and Architectural camera and once I got the 45mm PC-E in 2008, my photos jumped a level. Yes it is a MF lens, but the tilt and shift feature brought a new dimension to my photography, more so that a slight jump in MP could.

Now I shoot Sony and have 2 @ 61MP bodies, the A7RIV and A7CR. But I had a A7RIII previous and really don't see that much difference in IQ, as I print at 16" by 24". Mainly I use the higher MP so I can bring dual F/L's to my mostly prime lenses by using the 26MP APS-C mode via a quick button push. If you do decide to add the Sony gear, I use the 70-200 f4 GII Macro and it is easy to carry, even on my A7CR, and a very versatile lens.


Edited on May 28, 2024 at 12:34 PM · View previous versions
May 28, 2024 at 11:08 AM
Jack Flesher
Online
Details
p.6 #18Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
My point is I regularly look at Marcus' work, which ranges from his X-H2 shots to GFX 100S. At web resolution, they are indistinguishable. If you pixel peep on Flickr, the GFX stuff is obviously better. It's a no brainer that anyone who is pixel peeping the differences would find the GFX file "better", but the end result/output isn't all that different with normal viewing.


Well, we can disagree on this and that's okay I personally can see the tonal difference comparing my GH2/XT5/Z7/Z9 files at web output when compared to my GFX files. Is it massive? No, but it's visible. Is the detail gain super noticeable, not in every image, heck, probably not in most -- but definitely in some, especially those with a lot of micro-detail...

But hey, personal choice and preferences are what makes the world go around! Life's too short to not use whatever gear floats our own personal boats -- for you that may be Sony or Nikon or For me it's the GFX when I want the best file, and now more recently the GH2 when I'm weight conscious and file quality is secondary to having a camera with me. (PS: IMHO the GH2 output is *almost* as good as the Z9, even in prints -- however like with the GFX, there is a smoothness plus detail quality to the Z9 file that appeals to me more than the GH2. Again I assume that's mostly format related, but not 100% sure.)

PS: If all one is doing is web output or prints to say 12 or 14 inches short side, then I would *NOT* advise the GFX investment cost or related hassle factors -- unless you simply enjoy working with the camera and enjoy processing out a great file (which admittedly I do).

May 28, 2024 at 11:21 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.6 #19Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
SpecFoto wrote:
RoamingScott wrote
liggy wrotelol… first world problems for sure.

Accepting that short of carrying *everything* the compromise that suits me personally is the 20-70 as a one lens solution.

For dedicated outings I’d typically tailor the kit to the job at hand. Yep - cropping at 70mm isn’t ideal but if tele is critical I’ll just tote a longer lens in addition to the 20-70.

This is part of the fun though tbh. If you were local you’d be welcome to try my 35-70 but I’d feel the need for the 20-35 or 23 on a landscape oriented outing as you mentioned.
As a fun morning activity, I dug through EXIF of my favorite landscape images. Many at 24...28...sooo many at 43 (what?!)...and then it jumped to either 105 if on Sony and 120 if on Z.
OK...I am going to suggest an alternative plan instead of adding yet another camera system... Keep your Z9, as NIkon will eventually have a smaller FF body with the Sony 61MP sensor you can upgrade to, and continue to use your current favorite 24-120mm lens. But add a superb landscape lens that is near the 43mm F/L you came to find was your most used, the PC-E Micro Nikkor 45mm f2.8 ED. While no longer made, great copies are available used around $1.000 and it will adapt just fine to your newer bodies.

I used Nikon for many
...Show more →

I have no plans to get rid of the Z9 or the 24-120...and it's highly likely I'd sell off the Sony gear if a 61mp Z ever finds its way to market. Thanks for the suggestion about the 45 2.8.
May 28, 2024 at 12:09 PM
formula4speed
Offline
Details
p.6 #20Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
[internet talk] Everyone so far is wrong, and the whole premise is a trick question. You obviously should be shooting Pentax so you can use the Pentax Limited 43mm f/1.9 lens. This clearly solves all your problem, at least I assume it does, even though I didn't entirely read your posts. [/internet talk]
May 28, 2024 at 12:33 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister