p.17 #1Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Mark’s workflow might not be everyone’s cup of tea but he has an extensive portfolio that is levels above everyone posting in this thread. Some of those making snarky comments should realize they are only embarrassing themselves further.
p.17 #2Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Grenache wrote: Daran wroterdeloe wroteAztatlan wroteBy all means compare on factors like dynamic range, noise, etc, but testing sharpness is largely redundant.It's difficult to compare sharpness, but it's only redundant if you don't care about it. I don't think it's unreasonable as a comparison point if we're comparing high end systems like these.If you shoot high resolution sensors through a low resolving optic, the predictable result is that the higher resolution sensor gains you rather little. So using that to evaluate the actual relative merits of those sensors is pointless.
Of course another great leveler is aperture. For landscapes you'd usually wana shoot closed up apertures for it's larger DOF, but that will also limit the achievable resolution. And this effect is independent of sensor size: as you close the larger and the smaller sensor systems to equivalent apertures, the limiting effect of diffraction will also be equivalent.Actually no.
Actually yes. [sorry, could not help myself]
Diffraction also occurs at the well of the sensor. The smaller the well, the worse the diffraction. This is why there are trade offs with cramming more pixels onto sensors. More is often not better, at least if you are also stopping down aperture…you take a hit twice. BSI sensors and similar advances in format help recover some size in the pixel wells.
Well, kinda, but not in the way you seem to think.
Diffraction due to the aperture limits the directional precision of the light falling onto the sensor, hence reducing the optical resolution of the image as projected onto the sensor. It does not affect the light intensity.
Diffraction due pixel properties (or BSI, or pixel lenses or whatnot) reduces the light actually falling onto the well, hence reducing the light intensity. It does not affect the resolution.
Your statement is correct, if the pixel density is the same and the only things changing are the dimensions of the sensor.
My point was that a reduction in pixel size matters less for a lower optical resolution optic (be that aperture or lens IQ). My point stands.
p.17 #3Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
I had to laugh at that pic. I’ve now sold every single one of those Nikon lenses.
alundeb wroteThe lucky place to be, is to have that affinity to the square aspect ratio. The best lenses for the 35 mm format are absolutely outstanding even at 33x33 mm. But you need to know exactly which lenses.
I think Scott started out as bad as it is possible to do with the Nikon mount lenses he said he started with (if the CV ultron 40 was the best).
Yeah, I tried the Ultron myself and it was just "no no" and when you said it was the best out of your bunch I thought it might be a premature conclusion to write off adaption completely, based on the ones you've tried. But you'll figure out.
p.17 #4Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
It is difficult to take someone seriously when they say that they rather shoot 50 MP than 100 MP with the same lenses for maximizing detail, but I will give Mark the benefit of the doubt. My takeaway from what he says is that there is room for improvement in the GF lenses, and that I will hold my horses a while, not buying the entire lineup at once.
p.17 #5Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
alundeb wrote:
It is difficult to take someone seriously when they say that they rather shoot 50 MP than 100 MP with the same lenses for maximizing detail, but I will give Mark the benefit of the doubt. My takeaway from what he says is that there is room for improvement in the GF lenses, and that I will hold my horses a while, not buying the entire lineup at once.
His impression of the Fuji 50MP vs 100MP sensor might be related to the microlens differences that Jim Kasson has documented.
p.17 #6Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
snapsy wrote: alundeb wroteIt is difficult to take someone seriously when they say that they rather shoot 50 MP than 100 MP with the same lenses for maximizing detail, but I will give Mark the benefit of the doubt. My takeaway from what he says is that there is room for improvement in the GF lenses, and that I will hold my horses a while, not buying the entire lineup at once.His impression of the Fuji 50MP vs 100MP sensor might be related to the microlens differences that Jim Kasson has documented.
p.17 #7Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
alundeb wrote: snapsy wrotealundeb wroteIt is difficult to take someone seriously when they say that they rather shoot 50 MP than 100 MP with the same lenses for maximizing detail, but I will give Mark the benefit of the doubt. My takeaway from what he says is that there is room for improvement in the GF lenses, and that I will hold my horses a while, not buying the entire lineup at once.His impression of the Fuji 50MP vs 100MP sensor might be related to the microlens differences that Jim Kasson has documented.
p.17 #8Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I was not hacked! This is my 20+ year full time combined experience endlessly pushing photo files of every type and very rigorously testing them (and especially how they handle all manner of protocol of sizing and sharpening) for my profession. I stand by it.
As I said in the original post, I know I will get plenty of flack, but sharing the experience for those who might benefit is worth it to me. And I’m not going to debate here.
If someone wants to come, do a workshop with me and put what I’m saying to the test, I’m all for it! I do it ALL the time with people/clients. Some of my clients have become some of the best printmakers on the planet. It is when we really put this to the test in real world enlargements that people clearly see what I am talking about. So far, out of many hundreds of obsessed, very competent printmaking photographers (over the last 10 years or so) there’s been no one who has not seen what I’m talking about here.
For better or worse (and with full acknowledgment that I will likely get many people debating many of my points) this post is for those who might benefit.
Cheers.
Steve Spencer wrote: Mark Metternich wroteBecause its my full time job and incredible privilege of testing all camera bodies and lenses constantly throughout the year (access to everything) making the highest quality and biggest enlargements possible for top national and international gallery photographers (I do the their post processing for fine art print) I really get a very strong feel for the differences of all of the camera systems out there. You name it and I process it. I literally processed 112 huge images this week for some amazing galleries. All huge enlargements. And I’ve been doing this for 20+ years straight. And I’ve been obsessively pushing the boundaries to levels people are skeptical about until they see it, constantly. This year alone I did 2-40 FOOT prints and 3-30 FOOT prints at 300 PPI super resolution where you could put your nose on the print and it look perfect!
I’m not a fan of, the Sony A7R four or 5. Love some of the new functions, but I just cannot stand the cameras. And believe that they compromise quite a bit that affects quality.
Im not a big fan of the Fuji GFX 100.
The Panasonic Lumix S1R, combined with top Leica prime lenses can do mind boggling things (by far, the most underrated and overlooked cameras - including the Leica SL2 - ever produced in my opinion, for sheer fine art quality files) especially with their auto in-camera, pixel shift mode - HD MODE) producing nearly 200 megapixel images (as a single raw file). When you combine top glass with this camera or the Leica SL2 (they are basically the same camera and I shoot with both) you’re talking about unprecedented file quality.
The Hasselblad 50 megapixel mirrorless is an amazing camera as well because there are many Hasselblad lenses that exceed the resolution of the sensor, which allows you to get insane 50 megapixel photos that literally blow away any 60 megapixel photo from a Sony. Do some manual pixel shifting with that Hasselblad and you can set world records.
The Sony A1 (Alpha One) is the Only Sony that I would shoot with (If I HAD to shoot Sony) because they stayed at 50 megapixels which means that there are a handful of lenses that can meet the sensor resolution requirements. That’s when you really get a killer image. And this is where the GFX 100 falls considerably. I’ve never seen a full true 100 megapixel image (from a GFX 100) that was as good as 100 megapixels can really be. And I’ve tested files with the best lenses of the best f/stops and the lowest ISO
In fact, if you put the best Sony glass on the Alpha 1, and you shot 8 to 16 pixel shifted shots (or 32) and you handled those photos by manually processing them (new and much better ways that I’ll be explaining in my tutorial) NOT using the Sony software, you would have a 200-300 megapixel photo that would blow away the GFX 100 at its best! Combine that camera with the very best highest resolution lenses and you can get a pretty awesome photo. But you can’t get the same thing with the A7R4 or 5.
The $100,000 Phase One IQ4 (when you include everything like the tripod, etc…) coupled with the best Rodenstock lenses is a pretty dang good set up. Especially when using a technical camera. But I definitely prefer the quality of the 100 MP back. I believe that even Phase One went higher on megapixels on their sensor than any lenses can fully supply.
Getting into pixel shifting is awesome (and the future) but there’s nothing online on how to truly maximize it. Everything I find online uses the worst upsizing algorithms, the worst alignment algorithms (and does not at all take into consideration some super sauce techniques that are absolute industry game changers ) I have a video tutorial that will be coming out sometime this year where pixel shifting can be pushed into realms that people do not not believe possible. Absurd quality.
I’ve tested these proprietary techniques on just about every camera system. Hassleblad, Phase One, Nikon, Canon, Sony, Leica, Panasonic, Olympus….
The Fuji GFX 50 can really do a tremendous job as well. I literally would shoot with that one over the 100.
But for stilling a single shot, the Hasselblad 50 megapixel mirrorless is awesome. Combined with best f/stops and top
Hasselblad lenses.
The Phase One IQ4, 100 megapixel back is pretty much about as good as you can get for a single shot combined with the best Rodenstock lenses at the sharpest f/stops.
But if you’re going to do any pixel shifting (you DO NOT want to use the software from the company) you want to do it manually using much better upsizing algorithms, better alignment algorithms and about three or four “secret sauce” techniques, you can get insane (world record setting) results from cameras like the Panasonic Lumix S1R or the Leica SL2 (with Killer Leica glass).
I’m doing a mega pixel shift image testing with the GFX 100 right now (all day today) with all of the “secret sauce” techniques that people do not know about and it looks pretty good (400MP). Astonishingly better than running it through the Fuji software (which is mediocre at best in my opinion). Best when using 32 shots. 16 shots can do a pretty good job. But honestly, the Panasonic and the Leica just can’t be beat IMO.
⭐️ Lastly, I’m NOT at all saying you can’t get pretty good photos from any of these camera systems! You can. I’m talking about world class enlargements that are setting new world record standards people have never seen before!
How controversial this may seem, and how much flack I’ll most likely get (like Dan piped in immediately - which is usual) is just par for the course! I totally get it.
But I have been constantly and passionately pushing the bleeding edge limits as my full-time job for the last 20+ years when I’m not leading workshops or making educational materials. It’s an incredible privilege to do obsessive testing as much as 16 hours a day. Maybe I’ll slow down someday soon, but so far it’s pedal to the metal.
Oh, and lastly, a top Nikon mirrorless with top Nikon glass and the auto pixel shifting that goes on inside the camera when processed manually can be pretty flippin’ awesome. You can’t go wrong with Nikon.
Where Canon falls is that their sensor has an anti-aliasing filter which softens the photos. We definitely don’t want that at all.
Hope it helps.
RoamingScott wroteI'm curious to hear from people that have specifically shot both the A7RV and any of the 100mp GFX bodies for the purpose of landscape photography.
I'm looking to add a single body to my cabinet for the primary if not sole purpose of landscapes, with the caveat that I hike and shoot, wear the camera on my chest with a Peak Capture Clip, and that weight is a consideration but not the end all be all. I rarely have a tripod on me.
Nikon is simply taking too long to release a small, high resolution body...I have a 100S II preordered, but upon taking delivery of a GF 32-64, immediately second guessed this decision as the weight is just nuts for such a small focal range.
I bought a Sony 20-70/4 and A7R5 and will put them against my Z kit until the release of the GFX to see if the gains are substantial enough for this use case.
Again, only looking for input from folks that have tried these 2 specific kits. Appreciate your thoughts.Such a strange post coming months after the thread was dormant and so odd to claim such special expertise while at the same time making claims that clearly don't make sense (e.g., a huge difference between a 50MP and 60MP camera such that he would use the 50MP--that has lower dynamic range--and would never use the 60MP camera and pixel shift could work with the 50MP camera for mind blowing results but would never work with the 60MP camera). Put that on top of this coming from an FM member with many featured thread wins with outstanding contributions. Seems like the account might have been hacked.
For the record, the Sony A1 has 8640 pixels on the long side and Sony A7r V has 9504 pixels on the long side. That is about a 9% difference. That is a tiny difference. It simply can't be the case that one will work phenomenally and one won't work at all so it shouldn't be used.
For the record, you get more resolution in the output with a weak (only capable of producing low resolution) lens and a high resolution sensor than with that same weak lens and a lower resolution sensor. There is no such thing as a sensor having too much resolution for a lens. An excellent lens (capable of high resolution) will gain more resolution with a higher resolution sensor than a weak lens will gain but both lenses will gain resolution with the high resolution sensor. It is true that a really bad lens will gain almost nothing on a higher resolution sensor such that resolution is almost totally determined by the lens, but it won't lead to less resolution. Likewise it is true that an excellent lens will get much better on a higher resolution sensor such that some of the best lens' performance will be primarily determined by the sensor, but in most cases the performance of a system is affected by both the lens and the sensor. See this excellent article by Brandon Dube at Lensrentals.com for a full discussion of the issue complete with measurements and the implications for magnification (i.e., big prints):
With all that in mind, if you want to make as big of enlargements as possible, then you want a high resolution sensor with the best lens you can use on that system. Both the sensor and the lens will matter as by making as big of an enlargement as possible you are pushing the limits of the system. In comparing the A7r V to the GFX 100s, they have very similar sensors at the level of the pixel with similar pixel size, density, and make up of the pixel. Here we can be fairly sure the bigger sensor will be better. See this excellent post by Jim Kasson explaining why:
That said, lenses clearly matter as well and if you are using better lenses on the A7r V, then it might produce better results. And getting back to Mark's (or perhaps someone pretending to be Mark) post it is true that those Leica SL APO lenses are phenomenal and might just be enough better than anything available for Sony or Fuji that a Leica or Panasonic camera using them produces the best results. I am suspicious about that, and would like to see testing demonstrating it rather than take the word of a self-appointed expert.
For me personally, I have quit chasing these ultimate questions. I know I am not going to ever print at enormous sizes. Either the A7r V or the GFX 100s (I only have the GFX 50s, and it too; and I am sure the Leica SL cameras and the Panasonic too) with very good (and not even the top glass) will make excellent prints the size I actually print (usually 16 X 20 or 15 X 20), so for me I am unconcerned about what will make the biggest prints. The answer for me is that all the systems will produce more than good enough results for my needs with a number of lenses used for any of the systems. So, I have gratefully given up this chase for the ultimate....Show more →
p.17 #9Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
Mark’s workflow might not be everyone’s cup of tea but he has an extensive portfolio that is levels above everyone posting in this thread. Some of those making snarky comments should realize they are only embarrassing themselves further.
Many of the images you're referring to here were shot with cameras that he claims aren't good for anything.
Someone making great images doesn't automatically mean they have any great technical expertise. They, of course, might have some polarizing opinions.
As an example, I went to a workshop led by a quite famous photographer with a great portfolio, and he demanded I used a 35mm cameras because he did not understand anything but 2/3 frame proportions. When I said all my cameras are 3/4 he answered I cannot participate unless I get 2/3 cameras. The topic of workshop was something like 'open your eyes'! It definitely opened my eyes, but not in the way it was intended.
p.17 #10Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
olegkin wrote:
As an example, I went to a workshop led by a quite famous photographer with a great portfolio, and he demanded I used a 35mm cameras because he did not understand anything but 2/3 frame proportions. When I said all my cameras are 3/4 he answered I cannot participate unless I get 2/3 cameras. The topic of workshop was something like 'open your eyes'! It definitely opened my eyes, but not in the way it was intended.
Reminds me of a songwriting convention/competition I participated in years ago.....I had written a song in 7/8 and the "producer" who listened to it said I was "skipping beats".....
p.17 #11Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Mark Metternich wrote:
I was not hacked! This is my 20+ year full time combined experience endlessly pushing photo files of every type and very rigorously testing them (and especially how they handle all manner of protocol of sizing and sharpening) for my profession. I stand by it.
As I said in the original post, I know I will get plenty of flack, but sharing the experience for those who might benefit is worth it to me. And I’m not going to debate here.
If someone wants to come, do a workshop with me and put what I’m saying to the test, I’m all for it! I do it ALL the time with people/clients. Some of my clients have become some of the best printmakers on the planet. It is when we really put this to the test in real world enlargements that people clearly see what I am talking about. So far, out of many hundreds of obsessed, very competent printmaking photographers (over the last 10 years or so) there’s been no one who has not seen what I’m talking about here.
For better or worse (and with full acknowledgment that I will likely get many people debating many of my points) this post is for those who might benefit.
Cheers.
...Show more →Steve Spencer wroteMark Metternich wroteBecause its my full time job and incredible privilege of testing all camera bodies and lenses constantly throughout the year (access to everything) making the highest quality and biggest enlargements possible for top national and international gallery photographers (I do the their post processing for fine art print) I really get a very strong feel for the differences of all of the camera systems out there. You name it and I process it. I literally processed 112 huge images this week for some amazing galleries. All huge enlargements. And I’ve been doing this for 20+ years straight. And I’ve been obsessively pushing the boundaries to levels people are skeptical about until they see it, constantly. This year alone I did 2-40 FOOT prints and 3-30 FOOT prints at 300 PPI super resolution where you could put your nose on the print and it look perfect!
I’m not a fan of, the Sony A7R four or 5. Love some of the new functions, but I just cannot stand the cameras. And believe that they compromise quite a bit that affects quality.
Im not a big fan of the Fuji GFX 100.
The Panasonic Lumix S1R, combined with top Leica prime lenses can do mind boggling things (by far, the most underrated and overlooked cameras - including the Leica SL2 - ever produced in my opinion, for sheer fine art quality files) especially with their auto in-camera, pixel shift mode - HD MODE) producing nearly 200 megapixel images (as a single raw file). When you combine top glass with this camera or the Leica SL2 (they are basically the same camera and I shoot with both) you’re talking about unprecedented file quality.
The Hasselblad 50 megapixel mirrorless is an amazing camera as well because there are many Hasselblad lenses that exceed the resolution of the sensor, which allows you to get insane 50 megapixel photos that literally blow away any 60 megapixel photo from a Sony. Do some manual pixel shifting with that Hasselblad and you can set world records.
The Sony A1 (Alpha One) is the Only Sony that I would shoot with (If I HAD to shoot Sony) because they stayed at 50 megapixels which means that there are a handful of lenses that can meet the sensor resolution requirements. That’s when you really get a killer image. And this is where the GFX 100 falls considerably. I’ve never seen a full true 100 megapixel image (from a GFX 100) that was as good as 100 megapixels can really be. And I’ve tested files with the best lenses of the best f/stops and the lowest ISO
In fact, if you put the best Sony glass on the Alpha 1, and you shot 8 to 16 pixel shifted shots (or 32) and you handled those photos by manually processing them (new and much better ways that I’ll be explaining in my tutorial) NOT using the Sony software, you would have a 200-300 megapixel photo that would blow away the GFX 100 at its best! Combine that camera with the very best highest resolution lenses and you can get a pretty awesome photo. But you can’t get the same thing with the A7R4 or 5.
The $100,000 Phase One IQ4 (when you include everything like the tripod, etc…) coupled with the best Rodenstock lenses is a pretty dang good set up. Especially when using a technical camera. But I definitely prefer the quality of the 100 MP back. I believe that even Phase One went higher on megapixels on their sensor than any lenses can fully supply.
Getting into pixel shifting is awesome (and the future) but there’s nothing online on how to truly maximize it. Everything I find online uses the worst upsizing algorithms, the worst alignment algorithms (and does not at all take into consideration some super sauce techniques that are absolute industry game changers ) I have a video tutorial that will be coming out sometime this year where pixel shifting can be pushed into realms that people do not not believe possible. Absurd quality.
I’ve tested these proprietary techniques on just about every camera system. Hassleblad, Phase One, Nikon, Canon, Sony, Leica, Panasonic, Olympus….
The Fuji GFX 50 can really do a tremendous job as well. I literally would shoot with that one over the 100.
But for stilling a single shot, the Hasselblad 50 megapixel mirrorless is awesome. Combined with best f/stops and top
Hasselblad lenses.
The Phase One IQ4, 100 megapixel back is pretty much about as good as you can get for a single shot combined with the best Rodenstock lenses at the sharpest f/stops.
But if you’re going to do any pixel shifting (you DO NOT want to use the software from the company) you want to do it manually using much better upsizing algorithms, better alignment algorithms and about three or four “secret sauce” techniques, you can get insane (world record setting) results from cameras like the Panasonic Lumix S1R or the Leica SL2 (with Killer Leica glass).
I’m doing a mega pixel shift image testing with the GFX 100 right now (all day today) with all of the “secret sauce” techniques that people do not know about and it looks pretty good (400MP). Astonishingly better than running it through the Fuji software (which is mediocre at best in my opinion). Best when using 32 shots. 16 shots can do a pretty good job. But honestly, the Panasonic and the Leica just can’t be beat IMO.
⭐️ Lastly, I’m NOT at all saying you can’t get pretty good photos from any of these camera systems! You can. I’m talking about world class enlargements that are setting new world record standards people have never seen before!
How controversial this may seem, and how much flack I’ll most likely get (like Dan piped in immediately - which is usual) is just par for the course! I totally get it.
But I have been constantly and passionately pushing the bleeding edge limits as my full-time job for the last 20+ years when I’m not leading workshops or making educational materials. It’s an incredible privilege to do obsessive testing as much as 16 hours a day. Maybe I’ll slow down someday soon, but so far it’s pedal to the metal.
Oh, and lastly, a top Nikon mirrorless with top Nikon glass and the auto pixel shifting that goes on inside the camera when processed manually can be pretty flippin’ awesome. You can’t go wrong with Nikon.
Where Canon falls is that their sensor has an anti-aliasing filter which softens the photos. We definitely don’t want that at all.
Hope it helps.
RoamingScott wroteI'm curious to hear from people that have specifically shot both the A7RV and any of the 100mp GFX bodies for the purpose of landscape photography.
I'm looking to add a single body to my cabinet for the primary if not sole purpose of landscapes, with the caveat that I hike and shoot, wear the camera on my chest with a Peak Capture Clip, and that weight is a consideration but not the end all be all. I rarely have a tripod on me.
Nikon is simply taking too long to release a small, high resolution body...I have a 100S II preordered, but upon taking delivery of a GF 32-64, immediately second guessed this decision as the weight is just nuts for such a small focal range.
I bought a Sony 20-70/4 and A7R5 and will put them against my Z kit until the release of the GFX to see if the gains are substantial enough for this use case.
Again, only looking for input from folks that have tried these 2 specific kits. Appreciate your thoughts.Such a strange post coming months after the thread was dormant and so odd to claim such special expertise while at the same time making claims that clearly don't make sense (e.g., a huge difference between a 50MP and 60MP camera such that he would use the 50MP--that has lower dynamic range--and would never use the 60MP camera and pixel shift could work with the 50MP camera for mind blowing results but would never work with the 60MP camera). Put that on top of this coming from an FM member with many featured thread wins with outstanding contributions. Seems like the account might have been hacked.
For the record, the Sony A1 has 8640 pixels on the long side and Sony A7r V has 9504 pixels on the long side. That is about a 9% difference. That is a tiny difference. It simply can't be the case that one will work phenomenally and one won't work at all so it shouldn't be used.
For the record, you get more resolution in the output with a weak (only capable of producing low resolution) lens and a high resolution sensor than with that same weak lens and a lower resolution sensor. There is no such thing as a sensor having too much resolution for a lens. An excellent lens (capable of high resolution) will gain more resolution with a higher resolution sensor than a weak lens will gain but both lenses will gain resolution with the high resolution sensor. It is true that a really bad lens will gain almost nothing on a higher resolution sensor such that resolution is almost totally determined by the lens, but it won't lead to less resolution. Likewise it is true that an excellent lens will get much better on a higher resolution sensor such that some of the best lens' performance will be primarily determined by the sensor, but in most cases the performance of a system is affected by both the lens and the sensor. See this excellent article by Brandon Dube at Lensrentals.com for a full discussion of the issue complete with measurements and the implications for magnification (i.e., big prints):
With all that in mind, if you want to make as big of enlargements as possible, then you want a high resolution sensor with the best lens you can use on that system. Both the sensor and the lens will matter as by making as big of an enlargement as possible you are pushing the limits of the system. In comparing the A7r V to the GFX 100s, they have very similar sensors at the level of the pixel with similar pixel size, density, and make up of the pixel. Here we can be fairly sure the bigger sensor will be better. See this excellent post by Jim Kasson explaining why:
That said, lenses clearly matter as well and if you are using better lenses on the A7r V, then it might produce better results. And getting back to Mark's (or perhaps someone pretending to be Mark) post it is true that those Leica SL APO lenses are phenomenal and might just be enough better than anything available for Sony or Fuji that a Leica or Panasonic camera using them produces the best results. I am suspicious about that, and would like to see testing demonstrating it rather than take the word of a self-appointed expert.
For me personally, I have quit chasing these ultimate questions. I know I am not going to ever print at enormous sizes. Either the A7r V or the GFX 100s (I only have the GFX 50s, and it too; and I am sure the Leica SL cameras and the Panasonic too) with very good (and not even the top glass) will make excellent prints the size I actually print (usually 16 X 20 or 15 X 20), so for me I am unconcerned about what will make the biggest prints. The answer for me is that all the systems will produce more than good enough results for my needs with a number of lenses used for any of the systems. So, I have gratefully given up this chase for the ultimate.
Well, Mark you have posted dozens of beautiful photographs. Thank you for that! Respectfully, your posts read almost like an advertisement for your workshops. You have special knowledge that is "world record setting," but you can't share it here you can only show it in your workshops and that knowledge will change the way we think. Sorry, I am not interested. Maybe others are. If they are more power to them and to you. I have highlighted what didn't make sense in your post and why, but I am sure you can make wonderful prints, and you may even be able to teach some people how to make wonderful prints too. For me personally you style rubs me very much the wrong way and I am pretty sure I would hate any workshop you offered, but that is just me.
p.17 #13Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Agreed. 😊
If you don’t use what you have, until you can get what you think you need, you won’t use what you think you need.”
One of my earliest mentors told me that. (Ken Duncan AU)
I also want to reiterate what I said in my initial post that good prints can be made from all kinds of systems:
“⭐️ Lastly, I’m NOT AT ALL saying you can’t get good photos from any of these camera systems! You can.”
olegkin wrote: RoamingScott wroteMark’s workflow might not be everyone’s cup of tea but he has an extensive portfolio that is levels above everyone posting in this thread. Some of those making snarky comments should realize they are only embarrassing themselves further.Many of the images you're referring to here were shot with cameras that he claims aren't good for anything.
Someone making great images doesn't automatically mean they have any great technical expertise. They, of course, might have some polarizing opinions.
As an example, I went to a workshop led by a quite famous photographer with a great portfolio, and he demanded I used a 35mm cameras because he did not understand anything but 2/3 frame proportions. When I said all my cameras are 3/4 he answered I cannot participate unless I get 2/3 cameras. The topic of workshop was something like 'open your eyes'! It definitely opened my eyes, but not in the way it was intended. ...Show more →
p.17 #14Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
This 3-month old thread suddenly got interesting lol! Here are a few thoughts/takeaways:
- The OP successfully worked out the original thread topic and is happily making images with his GFX100S, and the A7RV was not for him. Congrats Scott!
- I cannot emphasize enough how important it is to find and embrace what works specifically for YOU in photography, whether choice of camera, lenses, processing style, teacher/mentor, all of it. My own personal camera choice the last 2 years ended up being the opposite of Scott - I sold my GFX100S that I found frustrating on several fronts and am thoroughly enjoying shooting and printing with my A7RV. Again, the point is we are not all meant to be forced into the same mold - there is variety and individual choice and many different paths one can travel to reach where they want to be with their photography.
- Since printmaking has been brought up, I can give my highest recommendation to two teachers that helped me become very content with my own print quality - I would not have had the confidence to turn the main floor of my home into a gallery without them: Charles Cramer, and Michael Frye. Both of these gentlemen are true photographic artists, excellent teachers, and also humble human beings. I love both their styles, as they each produce and teach printmaking that results in a fine art photograph that still looks realistic, not over-the-top. I have greatly enjoyed viewing their work in the Ansel Adams gallery. Michael Frye’s educational material is more accessible since besides in-person workshops he also has excellent ebooks on landscape photography and processing, and has lately been doing some online sessions.
p.17 #15Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
It would be great to see them pushing their glass quality like Sony/Zeiss has. A few of the new Sony lenses are amazing and really pushing to make better use of the 60 MP sensor.
Same with a few Leica primes, now that the SL3 has gone to 60MP (and it looks like a new Panasonic Lumix S1R-2 is in the works and will also be 60MP).
IMO, we are definitely in need of better glass with the newest sensor capabilities.
alundeb wrote:
It is difficult to take someone seriously when they say that they rather shoot 50 MP than 100 MP with the same lenses for maximizing detail, but I will give Mark the benefit of the doubt. My takeaway from what he says is that there is room for improvement in the GF lenses, and that I will hold my horses a while, not buying the entire lineup at once.
p.17 #16Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
And of course you are here (as always) to give me a hard time, as has been your clear perfectly consistent negative norm for a decade or more. Thus my admittedly slightly overly blunt reply to you.
gdanmitchell wrote: Mark Metternich wroteAnd you know nothing about.Of course, Mark. As always, you are here to let us know that you are the only person who understands of Great Miracles that are unknown and incomprehensible to the insects living sad little lives outside of your glorious sphere.