p.15 #1Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
GMPhotography wrote:
I would like to try that Fuji to be honest.
You will love it Guy. I think the last Phase back we worked with was the IQ 80, or maybe the 100? These Fuji files are so much easier to push around — I still use C1 — and the camera feels like an Fx body in your hands. Lenses are Phase/Mamiya size however, and so a little clunkier than contemporary Fx mirrorless options.
p.15 #2Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Adapting lenses on a Medium Format system is not the worst idea and actually these cams are mostly landscape type style so you have more time to focus and basically more time to shoot as in most case your on a tripod anyway. Lets be honest anyone that bought a A7R in the beginning its really are only option since there was not many Sony FE glass. I know I did a lot of adopting lenses and got some great results from Zeiss glass, Voightlander and others. In medium format you have the same issues with not enough native glass and also size and weight thinking is pretty much it is what it is. Back in my day the glass from Phase and Mamiya that fits directly on the body was okay but not the best around, when you got a Tech cam than that's where the IQ came in but of course so was the drain on the bank account. I spent a fortune on even a 3 lens kit. Not knowing Fuji that much im just not sure what lenses to turn too. I have very little experience on Fuji but I know a few folks that shoot them and some of there glass looks very good but a few just seemed kind of normal in IQ. So I can see some advantage of adapting . I think maybe more for character lenses more than anything else. But that's up to user but in todays world most of us that shoot Sony have gotten away from adapting lenses and simple because we have 3rd party lenses available. I would think any kind of PC lens might be worth looking at as well. Honestly I thing its worth the experiment of trying to find better. Your in Medium Format now and gaining as much IQ is a good thing. I posted that image above but was looking at some of my images from Medium format and the IQ is killer. Im all for enhancement of your system and gaining IQ. Seriously if you bought this Fuji system where you not looking for better IQ, no one can say no to that its why you did it and I totally get that decision. I do wish I had some lens recommendations to help that cause but I don't know enough anymore on this Fuji system. You also have Hasselblad to look at as well and they always had some great glass for Medium Format back in the day. Actually the direct lenses I thought where better than Phase direct lens fittings . Not that Phase was bad . That lens I used above the 80mm was there normal lens and maybe not there best but being in Medium Format with there sensors helps a great deal. You should look around there maybe be a better focal length in some adaptable lens.
p.15 #3Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
gear-nut wrote: GMPhotography wroteI would like to try that Fuji to be honest.You will love it Guy. I think the last Phase back we worked with was the IQ 80, or maybe the 100? These Fuji files are so much easier to push around — I still use C1 — and the camera feels like an Fx body in your hands. Lenses are Phase/Mamiya size however, and so a little clunkier than contemporary Fx mirrorless options.
I have actually thought about it a few times and as my retirement grows it would be fun to have one. Back in the day these things where chunky chunky and more chunky and what I am seeing today with Fuji and Hassy these lens look really nice size and weight wise. Much easier to transport for sure
p.15 #4Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
The MF system is going to be quite a lot chunkier than some of the small Sony bodies and lenses you’ve gotten accustomed to. It’s not very obvious until you hold it in your hands. Definitely a remarkable achievement compared to MF systems of the past, though.
p.15 #5Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
itai195 wrote:
The MF system is going to be quite a lot chunkier than some of the small Sony bodies and lenses you’ve gotten accustomed to. It’s not very obvious until you hold it in your hands. Definitely a remarkable achievement compared to MF systems of the past, though.
Yea that is certainly the case but think about it for a second no one bought Medium Format thinking it was a weight saving decision. Now Sony that's all you read about is weight savings and size. Hell I used to lug 500lbs of gear around the world for decades or at least rent it when I got there. My golf game suffers that bad back syndrome of lugging that weight around. I think it's clear folks that go into medium format that size and weight is not the primary reason though. Certainly is nice for sure but if you went Medium Format you did it for IQ no question and weight and size advantage is secondary to the IQ. Honestly im all for seeing folks get into medium format to improve their ART and get more out of Photography. Hey I would like to pass the torch and why im even here
p.15 #6Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
GMPhotography wrote: itai195 wroteThe MF system is going to be quite a lot chunkier than some of the small Sony bodies and lenses you’ve gotten accustomed to. It’s not very obvious until you hold it in your hands. Definitely a remarkable achievement compared to MF systems of the past, though.Yea that is certainly the case but think about it for a second no one bought Medium Format thinking it was a weight saving decision. Now Sony that's all you read about is weight savings and size. Hell I used to lug 500lbs of gear around the world for decades or at least rent it when I got there. My golf game suffers that bad back syndrome of lugging that weight around. I think it's clear folks that go into medium format that size and weight is not the primary reason though. Certainly is nice for sure but if you went Medium Format you did it for IQ no question and weight and size advantage is secondary to the IQ. Honestly im all for seeing folks get into medium format to improve their ART and get more out of Photography. Hey I would like to pass the torch and why im even here...Show more →
You don't have to go all in, you can just dip your toe
p.15 #8Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I can see that getting into adapting lenses isn't all that attractive if you start from scratch or come from mirrorless and sold all the older stuff.
My starting point from 135 format is 24 and 90 mm TS-E lenses, a 200 and a 300 mm that I know will cover, and some other stuff for character. At least.
p.15 #9Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
alundeb wrote: GMPhotography wroteitai195 wroteThe MF system is going to be quite a lot chunkier than some of the small Sony bodies and lenses you’ve gotten accustomed to. It’s not very obvious until you hold it in your hands. Definitely a remarkable achievement compared to MF systems of the past, though.Yea that is certainly the case but think about it for a second no one bought Medium Format thinking it was a weight saving decision. Now Sony that's all you read about is weight savings and size. Hell I used to lug 500lbs of gear around the world for decades or at least rent it when I got there. My golf game suffers that bad back syndrome of lugging that weight around. I think it's clear folks that go into medium format that size and weight is not the primary reason though. Certainly is nice for sure but if you went Medium Format you did it for IQ no question and weight and size advantage is secondary to the IQ. Honestly im all for seeing folks get into medium format to improve their ART and get more out of Photography. Hey I would like to pass the torch and why im even hereYou don't have to go all in, you can just dip your toe
For those of you who don't know him like I do, Guy is not a toe-dip kind of guy
p.15 #11Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
GMPhotography wrote:
All in NEW is like 13k with like 3 lenses . From my seat and what I used to pay that's a bargain. Something to chew on.
I will say this just to be clear if your looking at size and weight savings than MF is not for you. If your looking at IQ than its worth looking at.
But three lenses will never be enough, and then you start finding out, and this takes months of shooting, where some of those native GF lenses fall short and then you're off finding third party lenses that perform better, and yes, they are out there. I started on this journey about two and a half years ago and now over $50K later, I'm still not done, having just bought the most excellent 50mm 1.7 and hopefully getting delivery of the 500mm later this month (over $6K right there).
And when you end up loving the output quality, which is so much better than those old Phase backs you were using (at least I think they were Phase) you'll be on a mission to find the best performing lenses you can regardless of brand. And you'll be pleasantly surprised to find that lenses like the entire line of Canon t/s-e lenses are great and the much maligned 24mm t/s-e v2 is even better than the lauded GF20-35 at equivalent focal lengths in the far corners. And many of those Sigma ART lenses just rock. Not every one but at least a few. The list goes on and on and there are long threads here that go into this in detail.
In all my years of shooting digital, the GFX is, overall, the best experience I've had, and as a landscape camera, I shoot with everything from 15mm (on the Canon 11-24) to 500mm with the Canon 500mm f/4 and soon to be 700mm with the new Fuji lens combined with their teleconverter. Yeah, there are a few gaps in there but nothing like what we had in our old analog Hasselblad, Mamiya, Bronica, Contax systems. Now that I'm primarily shooting for myself, I only wish I had this ten or fifteen years ago. And there are more than a few images I shot with the Canons that I have reshot with the Fuji.
p.15 #12Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Peter you fell into the black hole. Medium Format it never ever ends it is a battle for the best no question. I had all Phase One backs P25 was my first even at 22mpx I loved that thing than the P30, P40, IQ 160 and on loan for most workshops I had the IQ 180 to shoot but I agree that was back when , today its a different world. This stuff is stunning and im afraid my wife would swipe my handguns and take my ass out. Im kidding
Honestly I do miss it and that feeling has never gone away. I may do my research on these Fujis. I was reading that the Hassy system seems to be not so hot. Admitedily im a gear whore no question.
Now I will also add we had Capture Integration and/or Phase One company reps bring in all there gear for attendees to use. That was a treat for sure. Makes you spoiled no question
Just found out today who gear-nut is and he was my partner in all of this Medium Format workshops. We had a ball doing them
p.15 #13Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Or he's all toes.
gear-nut wrote: alundeb wroteGMPhotography wroteitai195 wroteThe MF system is going to be quite a lot chunkier than some of the small Sony bodies and lenses you’ve gotten accustomed to. It’s not very obvious until you hold it in your hands. Definitely a remarkable achievement compared to MF systems of the past, though.Yea that is certainly the case but think about it for a second no one bought Medium Format thinking it was a weight saving decision. Now Sony that's all you read about is weight savings and size. Hell I used to lug 500lbs of gear around the world for decades or at least rent it when I got there. My golf game suffers that bad back syndrome of lugging that weight around. I think it's clear folks that go into medium format that size and weight is not the primary reason though. Certainly is nice for sure but if you went Medium Format you did it for IQ no question and weight and size advantage is secondary to the IQ. Honestly im all for seeing folks get into medium format to improve their ART and get more out of Photography. Hey I would like to pass the torch and why im even hereYou don't have to go all in, you can just dip your toe For those of you who don't know him like I do, Guy is not a toe-dip kind of guy
p.15 #14Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
GMPhotography wrote:
Peter you fell into the black hole. Medium Format it never ever ends it is a battle for the best no question. I had all Phase One backs P25 was my first even at 22mpx I loved that thing than the P30, P40, IQ 160 and on loan for most workshops I had the IQ 180 to shoot but I agree that was back when , today its a different world. This stuff is stunning and im afraid my wife would swipe my handguns and take my ass out. Im kidding
Honestly I do miss it and that feeling has never gone away. I may do my research on these Fujis. I was reading that the Hassy system seems to be not so hot. Admitedily im a gear whore no question.
Now I will also add we had Capture Integration and/or Phase One company reps bring in all there gear for attendees to use. That was a treat for sure. Makes you spoiled no question
Just found out today who gear-nut is and he was my partner in all of this Medium Format workshops. We had a ball doing them...Show more →
A hole for sure but I think a hole with light at the end of the proverbial tunnel. Really, it's all in a quest for the image quality and tonality that I have and have had in my mind for a long long time. While there has been a certain amount of churn when it comes to buying and testing lenses, it's also been quite insightful what you learn along the way and what lenses you end up keeping that might be a surprise. I mean, when I was shooing RZ's there was only one shift lens and it was not a focal length I ever used but now you've got seven t/s lenses from 17mm through 135 including two native GF at 30mm and 110mm. I don't have the 110mm but that GF30 is one crazy piece of glass. Proves what those lens designers can do if they really want to and are given free enough rein.
p.15 #15Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
johnvanatta wrote:
I think my best answer for a balanced GFX kit would be 20-35, 35-70, Zeiss 135. All three of those lenses deliver.
This is the setup I currently use. The 35-70 because it's cheap and light and delivers at f/8-f/11. The 20-35 because there isn't much in that range that competes from a handling and optical perspective. Then I have a Jupiter 37a 135 which covers and is sharp corner to corner f/8. That's pretty much a copy of a Zeiss 135 design. I like the Jupiter because compared to most other 135mm the CA is very low. I only had to spend the most money on the 20-35 and the body.
I did not read the entire thread. I only got to page 4. I will put my 2 cents in which is probably just going to be repetition of what others have said. Does the GFX have an IQ advantage? Yes. Is it worth it? It depends on how picky you are. Does FF have a lens selection advantage? Yes. Does FF have an auto focus advantage? Yes. Does FF have a size advantage? I think this one is up in the air. I would say not really, but it depends on which lenses you pick for comparison. Fuji has made the GFX very compact and competitive with FF. They also have been very selective in their designs so almost all are optically excellent.
The best way to find out is to rent a GFX or borrow one from a friend if you can and do your own comparisons in difficult shooting conditions.
p.15 #16Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
cbass wrote: johnvanatta wroteI think my best answer for a balanced GFX kit would be 20-35, 35-70, Zeiss 135. All three of those lenses deliver.This is the setup I currently use. The 35-70 because it's cheap and light and delivers at f/8-f/11. The 20-35 because there isn't much in that range that competes from a handling and optical perspective. Then I have a Jupiter 37a 135 which covers and is sharp corner to corner f/8. That's pretty much a copy of a Zeiss 135 design. I like the Jupiter because compared to most other 135mm the CA is very low. I only had to spend the most money on the 20-35 and the body.
I did not read the entire thread. I only got to page 4. I will put my 2 cents in which is probably just going to be repetition of what others have said. Does the GFX have an IQ advantage? Yes. Is it worth it? It depends on how picky you are. Does FF have a lens selection advantage? Yes. Does FF have an auto focus advantage? Yes. Does FF have a size advantage? I think this one is up in the air. I would say not really, but it depends on which lenses you pick for comparison. Fuji has made the GFX very compact and competitive with FF. They also have been very selective in their designs so almost all are optically excellent.
The best way to find out is to rent a GFX or borrow one from a friend if you can and do your own comparisons in difficult shooting conditions. ...Show more →
I don't know that anyone is disputing that medium format digital will have an IQ advantage. What I am most interested in is in what circumstances the IQ advantage becomes noticeable. And this is something this thread has not yet explained. I am assuming the IQ difference is not detectable when viewing images on a iPhone. I'm guessing it is visible when looking at a two-meter-wide print when viewing up close.
Having done my own controlled comparisons between an old 16mp M4/3 camera and a 43mp FF camera, both shot with good prime lenses at base ISO, I concluded I could barely see any difference on a 28inch 4k monitor (which in practice displays about 8mp).
So I would like to know under what circumstance the IQ advantage of mini-medium format digital becomes obvious? And I ask this genuinely because I am interested in getting a GFX myself at some stage. Are GFX users viewing on large 8k monitors? Are you regularly printing at sizes much greater than 1 meter?
p.15 #17Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Geoff D F wrote:
I don't know that anyone is disputing that medium format digital will have an IQ advantage. What I am most interested in is in what circumstances the IQ advantage becomes noticeable. And this is something this thread has not yet explained. I am assuming the IQ difference is not detectable when viewing images on a iPhone. I'm guessing it is visible when looking at a two-meter-wide print when viewing up close.
Having done my own controlled comparisons between an old 16mp M4/3 camera and a 43mp FF camera, both shot with good prime lenses at base ISO, I concluded I could barely see any difference on a 28inch 4k monitor (which in practice displays about 8mp).
So I would like to know under what circumstance the IQ advantage of mini-medium format digital becomes obvious? And I ask this genuinely because I am interested in getting a GFX myself at some stage. Are GFX users viewing on large 8k monitors? Are you regularly printing at sizes much greater than 1 meter? ...Show more →
Fair question. Here is one video that demonstrates what people mean when they talk about tonality and color separation. It's a long video, but at 17:00 you can see the start of his comparison.
The other area of which I will need to try to find a good video or photo comparison is the ISO. You can see it in the sensor scores of DXO Mark. They do not test Fuji, but they have the Hasselblad and Pentax 645 which have the same/similar sensor.
You can see mini-MF maximum ISO pretty much is around 4500. Sony A7RV is around 3200. Depending on generation all the FF sensors are around 3000ish ISO there. Anywhere from 2600-3500 or so. This means that the mini-MF is able to retain better color accuracy, better noise levels, and dynamic range at the higher ISO's. This matters for things like landscapes with high dynamic range. This is why they suggest ETTR for landscape; so the shadow details don't go as muddy on you. With mini-MF you have better performance here and a larger buffer to push the file.
At base ISO with good lighting or controlled studio lighting you are going to see very little differences between the sensor sizes: Micro 4/3 vs APS-C vs FF vs mini-MF. It's how it behaves in the more extreme conditions.
Since you haven't completely dismissed me, I am going to add to what I said previously.
If you believe Roger Cicala, and I do then the performance of the system is a combination of the sensor and lens.
That’s not how it works. How it does work is very simple math: System MTF = Camera MTF x Lens MTF. MTF maxes at 1.0 because 1.0 is perfect. So let’s say my camera MTF is 0.7, and my lens MTF is 0.7, then my system MTF is 0.49 (Lens MTF x Camera MTF). This is actually a pretty reasonable system.
Now, let’s say I get a much better camera with much higher resolution; the camera MTF is 0.9. The system MTF with the same lens also increases: 0.7 X 0.9 = 0.63. On the other hand, I could do the same thing if I bought a much better lens and kept it on the same camera. The camera basically never ‘out resolves the lens.’...Show more →
1.0 is 100% of the theoretical maximum. The GFX sensors in the best scenario achieve 98 percent, which is incredible and class leading.
RESOLUTION: THE GFX 100S IMPROVES RESOLVING POWER AS ISO INCREASES
The GFX 100S is capable of resolving 95 percent of its sensors’ theoretical maximum resolution. Interestingly, whereas many cameras tested by Image Engineering steadily lose resolving power as you increase ISO, the GFX 100S actually improves as you move up to ISO 400, where the camera can resolve 98 percent of its sensor’s maximum. While the performance does decline as you increase further, the camera stays above 90 percent of its theoretical maximum through ISO 3200. At the highest ISO setting (ISO 12,800), the camera drops to 80 percent.
The GFX 50 sensors actually performed even slightly better.
The GFX50S II can resolve 98 percent of its sensor’s theoretical maximum resolution at ISO 100 and ISO 400—that’s better than the GFX100S (95 percent) but not quite as good as the Hasselblad X1D II 50c (101 percent). Resolving power dips slightly to 94 percent at ISO 800, still topping the GFX100S and the X1D II 50c (both 92 percent). By ISO 3200, the GFX50S II performs identically to the GFX100S, resolving 90 percent of its sensor’s theoretical maximum.
This is very high performance even as the ISO climbs.
I can't find the numbers for the Sony A7RV, but I found them for the Sony A7RIV
At ISO 100, the camera could resolve 93 percent of its sensor’s theoretical maximum (out of a total of 120). Granted, with a 62-megapixel sensor, it has a lot more to resolve than rival full-frame cameras, but it’s still resolving less (on a percentage basis) than models like Panasonic’s S1R or Nikon’s Z 7. Image Engineering (IE) found resolution very consistent as you increase ISO, with the camera resolving 92 percent of its sensor at ISO 400, 88 percent at ISO 800 and 1600 and 89 percent at ISO 3200.
GFX is slightly ahead, but the FF sensors show a strong performance. There is a difference which helps, but it is small.
The other side of that is the lens and here Fuji has exceptional lenses as good as anybody but of course the cost is up there. Here the GFX has an advantage because the diameter of the G mount is huge at 65mm. This is a soup can size mount. The Sony E mount is small. 46mm and more the diameter you would expect for APS-C and not FF. Allegedly, Sony started with such a small mount because they started with APS-C camera's and then just shoved a FF sensor without changing the mount.
This makes lens design and correction much more difficult. Both Sigma and Zeiss have admitted that designing lenses for the E mount is a bigger challenge. Of course, the final results matter and Sony has some incredible lenses available for the E mount. I still think the native Fuji GFX lenses are some of the best corrected on the market today. Of course, they have slower lenses, more narrow zoom ranges, and they are costly.