fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape

  
 
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.12 #1Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
I think this is a pretty tame thread, considering it's crossposted, usually they only take 4-5 pages to go completely off the rails


Hope you already got what you needed
May 31, 2024 at 08:43 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.12 #2Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
highdesertmesa wrote:
RoamingScott wroteI think this is a pretty tame thread, considering it's crossposted, usually they only take 4-5 pages to go completely off the rails
Hope you already got what you needed


I got what I needed when I got the A7R5 in my hand and went

https://media.tenor.com/AkiAXvQsK-sAAAAM/what-is-that-brother-what-is-that.gif

Here's to hoping the GFX feels a little better!
May 31, 2024 at 08:51 AM
SGinNorcal
Offline
Details
p.12 #3Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
RoamingScott wroteI
Hope you already got what you needed
I got what I needed when I got the A7R5 in my hand


Not sure if you are serious and how much that means to you. For me, feel and control layout is huge. I don't care if a camera can nail autofocus on a gnats ass at 100 yards if I don't like the feel. Maybe that's a criteria for us lowly hobbyists to care that much about, .
May 31, 2024 at 10:13 AM
jmmaher
Offline
Details
p.12 #4Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Maybe its a function of age or just changing times but the A7RV fits my hand well and I like the weight. The last Nikon I owned that I really liked the feel in hand of was the D2H. However that was many years ago.

I have been tempted by the Z8 but am concerned that the body is oversized compared to the last 3 or 4 Sony's I have owned. However those who do own it seem to love the body.

The GX100S is tempting but my concern here is the great autofocus that the Sony has. I think I have been spoiled. -Jim

Edited on Sep 30, 2024 at 10:18 AM · View previous versions
May 31, 2024 at 11:00 AM
Jack Flesher
Online
Details
p.12 #5Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape


RoamingScott wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
RoamingScott wroteI think this is a pretty tame thread, considering it's crossposted, usually they only take 4-5 pages to go completely off the rails
Hope you already got what you needed
I got what I needed when I got the A7R5 in my hand and went

https://media.tenor.com/AkiAXvQsK-sAAAAM/what-is-that-brother-what-is-that.gif

Here's to hoping the GFX feels a little better!

The GFX100s has about the best layout (similar to Nikon Z with extra room) and a pretty decent UI — one of the best I’ve used to date.
May 31, 2024 at 11:07 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.12 #6Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
SGinNorcal wrote:
RoamingScott wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
RoamingScott wroteI
Hope you already got what you needed
I got what I needed when I got the A7R5 in my hand
Not sure if you are serious and how much that means to you. For me, feel and control layout is huge. I don't care if a camera can nail autofocus on a gnats ass at 100 yards if I don't like the feel. Maybe that's a criteria for us lowly hobbyists to care that much about, .


Dead serious. Forgot how small the Sonys are and how big my hands are compared to them. Fingers don't fall where they are supposed to in any regard. I thought I'd hate the vertical grip on the Z9, but it's what catching my hand and gives me a bunch of control even shooting landscape.
May 31, 2024 at 01:22 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.12 #7Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I've settled on letting the 100S II get here...try it with the 32-64. This combo will cover everything I do landscape wise including multishot stitching up to full frame 50mm, and should hopefully do it better with the full sensor. Then from about the 51-80mm full frame range, a crop will still be at or above my current resolution/detail level. At that point I'm only losing about 40ish mm from the Z 24-120.

I have a slew of primes across multiple mounts that I'm going to play with adapting to the GFX. Some of them might work, and some might not. Depending on what's what, I'll decide where to go next.
May 31, 2024 at 01:26 PM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.12 #8Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape


RoamingScott wrote:
I've settled on letting the 100S II get here...try it with the 32-64. This combo will cover everything I do landscape wise including multishot stitching up to full frame 50mm, and should hopefully do it better with the full sensor. Then from about the 51-80mm full frame range, a crop will still be at or above my current resolution/detail level. At that point I'm only losing about 40ish mm from the Z 24-120.

I have a slew of primes across multiple mounts that I'm going to play with adapting to the GFX. Some of them might work, and some might not.
...Show more →

If you care to, please back on the corner performance of the 32-64. The 100 II and 100S II sensor is supposed to be improved in that regard. I’m hoping it brings back the superior corner performance of the 50mp sensor.
May 31, 2024 at 01:53 PM
SGinNorcal
Offline
Details
p.12 #9Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I've had good success stitching 32-64 shots using level lines and portrait orientation. Pretty seamless in C1. The only trip up I've found is when trying to capture close foreground objects for scale or when very close to your subject. Understanding you aren't a fan of very wide images, I would still suggest you try a 20-35 when you get there. It not only goes wide but deep with detail. I don't have tech jargon for it, but I like the look. The 20-35 in 65:24 is very cool, a SOOC pan.

Edited on May 31, 2024 at 01:58 PM · View previous versions
May 31, 2024 at 01:56 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.12 #10Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
highdesertmesa wrote:
RoamingScott wroteI've settled on letting the 100S II get here...try it with the 32-64. This combo will cover everything I do landscape wise including multishot stitching up to full frame 50mm, and should hopefully do it better with the full sensor. Then from about the 51-80mm full frame range, a crop will still be at or above my current resolution/detail level. At that point I'm only losing about 40ish mm from the Z 24-120.

I have a slew of primes across multiple mounts that I'm going to play with adapting to the GFX. Some of them might work, and some might not. Depending on what's what, I'll decide where to go next.
If you care to, please back on the corner performance of the 32-64. The 100 II and 100S II sensor is supposed to be improved in that regard. I’m hoping it brings back the superior corner performance of the 50mp sensor.


I won't particularly know if it's improved or not vs the 100S but can post some full res samples. Was the issue wide open or in a particular aperture range?
May 31, 2024 at 01:57 PM
Peter Figen
Offline
Details
p.12 #11Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
highdesertmesa wrote:
RoamingScott wroteI've settled on letting the 100S II get here...try it with the 32-64. This combo will cover everything I do landscape wise including multishot stitching up to full frame 50mm, and should hopefully do it better with the full sensor. Then from about the 51-80mm full frame range, a crop will still be at or above my current resolution/detail level. At that point I'm only losing about 40ish mm from the Z 24-120.

I have a slew of primes across multiple mounts that I'm going to play with adapting to the GFX. Some of them might work, and some might not. Depending on what's what, I'll decide where to go next.
If you care to, please back on the corner performance of the 32-64. The 100 II and 100S II sensor is supposed to be improved in that regard. I’m hoping it brings back the superior corner performance of the 50mp sensor.


The improvement in corner performance of the 100 II over the 100s is pretty much microscopic at best. There is a tiny, very tiny improvement in the extreme corners up until f/8, and we're talking 200 percent pixel peeping but by f/11 it's gone. Maybe you could see it on a huge print if you knew what to look for and you had something to compare to, but for all intents and purposes, they are the same. Having both bodies, this is not something that would influence me to choose one over the other but it might make some people sleep better at night.

May 31, 2024 at 02:00 PM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.12 #12Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
RoamingScott wroteI've settled on letting the 100S II get here...try it with the 32-64. This combo will cover everything I do landscape wise including multishot stitching up to full frame 50mm, and should hopefully do it better with the full sensor. Then from about the 51-80mm full frame range, a crop will still be at or above my current resolution/detail level. At that point I'm only losing about 40ish mm from the Z 24-120.

I have a slew of primes across multiple mounts that I'm going to play with adapting to the GFX. Some of them might work, and some might not. Depending on what's what, I'll decide where to go next.
If you care to, please back on the corner performance of the 32-64. The 100 II and 100S II sensor is supposed to be improved in that regard. I’m hoping it brings back the superior corner performance of the 50mp sensor.
I won't particularly know if it's improved or not vs the 100S but can post some full res samples. Was the issue wide open or in a particular aperture range?


The issue I experienced moving from the 50S/R to the 100S was seeing weaker corners at high magnification at f/5.6 and infinity, specifically with the GF 63 (since I had that with both bodies at one time to know the difference). If I were to compare it to something I know, it looked like field curvature induced by thicker cover glass.

Below, Peter says the IQ difference in the corners is there, but it's negligible. Knowing that, I have to think that the rest of the difference I was seeing was due to IBIS (sacrificing corner IQ for better central IQ) combined with the higher magnification available due to having 100mp.

---------------------------------------------

Peter Figen wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
RoamingScott wroteI've settled on letting the 100S II get here...try it with the 32-64. This combo will cover everything I do landscape wise including multishot stitching up to full frame 50mm, and should hopefully do it better with the full sensor. Then from about the 51-80mm full frame range, a crop will still be at or above my current resolution/detail level. At that point I'm only losing about 40ish mm from the Z 24-120.

I have a slew of primes across multiple mounts that I'm going to play with adapting to the GFX. Some of them might work, and some might not. Depending on what's what, I'll decide where to go next.
If you care to, please back on the corner performance of the 32-64. The 100 II and 100S II sensor is supposed to be improved in that regard. I’m hoping it brings back the superior corner performance of the 50mp sensor.
The improvement in corner performance of the 100 II over the 100s is pretty much microscopic at best. There is a tiny, very tiny improvement in the extreme corners up until f/8, and we're talking 200 percent pixel peeping but by f/11 it's gone. Maybe you could see it on a huge print if you knew what to look for and you had something to compare to, but for all intents and purposes, they are the same. Having both bodies, this is not something that would influence me to choose one over the other but it might make some
...Show more →

Thanks, Peter. Much appreciated.
May 31, 2024 at 04:13 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.12 #13Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
highdesertmesa wrote:
RoamingScott wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
RoamingScott wroteI've settled on letting the 100S II get here...try it with the 32-64. This combo will cover everything I do landscape wise including multishot stitching up to full frame 50mm, and should hopefully do it better with the full sensor. Then from about the 51-80mm full frame range, a crop will still be at or above my current resolution/detail level. At that point I'm only losing about 40ish mm from the Z 24-120.

I have a slew of primes across multiple mounts that I'm going to play with adapting to the GFX. Some of them might work, and some might not. Depending on what's what, I'll decide where to go next.
If you care to, please back on the corner performance of the 32-64. The 100 II and 100S II sensor is supposed to be improved in that regard. I’m hoping it brings back the superior corner performance of the 50mp sensor.
I won't particularly know if it's improved or not vs the 100S but can post some full res samples. Was the issue wide open or in a particular aperture range?
The issue I experienced moving from the 50S/R to the 100S was seeing weaker corners at high magnification at f/5.6 and infinity, specifically with the GF 63 (since I had that with both bodies at one time to know the difference). If I were to compare it to something I know, it looked like field curvature induced by thicker cover glass.

Below, Peter says the IQ difference in the corners is there, but it's negligible. Knowing that, I have to think that the rest of the difference I was seeing was due to IBIS (sacrificing corner IQ for better central IQ)
...Show more →
Peter Figen wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
RoamingScott wroteI've settled on letting the 100S II get here...try it with the 32-64. This combo will cover everything I do landscape wise including multishot stitching up to full frame 50mm, and should hopefully do it better with the full sensor. Then from about the 51-80mm full frame range, a crop will still be at or above my current resolution/detail level. At that point I'm only losing about 40ish mm from the Z 24-120.

I have a slew of primes across multiple mounts that I'm going to play with adapting to the GFX. Some of them might work, and some might not. Depending on what's what, I'll decide where to go next.
If you care to, please back on the corner performance of the 32-64. The 100 II and 100S II sensor is supposed to be improved in that regard. I’m hoping it brings back the superior corner performance of the 50mp sensor.
The improvement in corner performance of the 100 II over the 100s is pretty much microscopic at best. There is a tiny, very tiny improvement in the extreme corners up until f/8, and we're talking 200 percent pixel peeping but by f/11 it's gone. Maybe you could see it on a huge print if you knew what to look for and you had something to compare to, but for all intents and purposes, they are the same. Having both bodies, this is not something that would influence me to choose one over the other but it might make some people sleep better at night.


Did you do any IBIS-off tests to see if any differences? The lens doesn't have OIS, right?
May 31, 2024 at 04:16 PM
dougorama
Offline
Details
p.12 #14Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
May 31, 2024 at 04:32 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.12 #15Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
dougorama wrote:
Did someone already refer to this post?

https://www.aaronreedphotography.com/gallery/why-i-ditched-the-gfx100-and-bought-the-sony-ar74-instead/


He tried hiking with the 100, what did he expect?

Oh wait, I hike with the Z9...
May 31, 2024 at 04:36 PM
Jack Flesher
Online
Details
p.12 #16Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape


RoamingScott wrote:
I've settled on letting the 100S II get here...try it with the 32-64. This combo will cover everything I do landscape wise including multishot stitching up to full frame 50mm, and should hopefully do it better with the full sensor. Then from about the 51-80mm full frame range, a crop will still be at or above my current resolution/detail level. At that point I'm only losing about 40ish mm from the Z 24-120.

I have a slew of primes across multiple mounts that I'm going to play with adapting to the GFX. Some of them might work, and some might not.
...Show more →
I think you’ve chosen wisely; and I think you’ll think the juice gained is worth the squeeze. 👍
May 31, 2024 at 04:42 PM
A74me
Offline
Details
p.12 #17Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
dougorama wrote:
Did someone already refer to this post?

https://www.aaronreedphotography.com/gallery/why-i-ditched-the-gfx100-and-bought-the-sony-ar74-instead/


thanks for the link, nice to see a pro landscapers perspective.
May 31, 2024 at 04:52 PM
Aztatlan
Offline
Details
p.12 #18Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
dougorama wroteDid someone already refer to this post?

https://www.aaronreedphotography.com/gallery/why-i-ditched-the-gfx100-and-bought-the-sony-ar74-instead/
He tried hiking with the 100, what did he expect?

Oh wait, I hike with the Z9...


His primary complaint seems to relate more to the shallow DOF of medium format and that it forced him to focus stack.

Whilst that may be true, I think it is largely equally as necessary on full frame. Plenty of photographers just stop down to f16 or so and call it a day, but this turns a 61MP file into little more than mush and is certainly not my jam. I focus stack virtually every landscape image on FF, unless the entire scene is at infinity focus.
May 31, 2024 at 04:55 PM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.12 #19Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
RoamingScott wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
RoamingScott wroteI've settled on letting the 100S II get here...try it with the 32-64. This combo will cover everything I do landscape wise including multishot stitching up to full frame 50mm, and should hopefully do it better with the full sensor. Then from about the 51-80mm full frame range, a crop will still be at or above my current resolution/detail level. At that point I'm only losing about 40ish mm from the Z 24-120.

I have a slew of primes across multiple mounts that I'm going to play with adapting to the GFX. Some of them might work, and some might not. Depending on what's what, I'll decide where to go next.
If you care to, please back on the corner performance of the 32-64. The 100 II and 100S II sensor is supposed to be improved in that regard. I’m hoping it brings back the superior corner performance of the 50mp sensor.
I won't particularly know if it's improved or not vs the 100S but can post some full res samples. Was the issue wide open or in a particular aperture range?
The issue I experienced moving from the 50S/R to the 100S was seeing weaker corners at high magnification at f/5.6 and infinity, specifically with the GF 63 (since I had that with both bodies at one time to know the difference). If I were to compare it to something I know, it looked like field curvature induced by thicker cover glass.

Below, Peter says the IQ difference in the corners is there, but it's negligible. Knowing that, I have to think that the rest of the difference I was seeing was due to IBIS (sacrificing corner IQ for better central IQ) combined with the higher magnification available due to having 100mp.

---------------------------------------------

Peter Figen wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
RoamingScott wroteI've settled on letting the 100S II get here...try it with the 32-64. This combo will cover everything I do landscape wise including multishot stitching up to full frame 50mm, and should hopefully do it better with the full sensor. Then from about the 51-80mm full frame range, a crop will still be at or above my current resolution/detail level. At that point I'm only losing about 40ish mm from the Z 24-120.

I have a slew of primes across multiple mounts that I'm going to play with adapting to the GFX. Some of them might work, and some might not. Depending on what's what, I'll decide where to go next.
If you care to, please back on the corner performance of the 32-64. The 100 II and 100S II sensor is supposed to be improved in that regard. I’m hoping it brings back the superior corner performance of the 50mp sensor.
The improvement in corner performance of the 100 II over the 100s is pretty much microscopic at best. There is a tiny, very tiny improvement in the extreme corners up until f/8, and we're talking 200 percent pixel peeping but by f/11 it's gone. Maybe you could see it on a huge print if you knew what to look for and you had something to compare to, but for all intents and purposes, they are the same. Having both bodies, this is not something that would influence me to choose one over the other but it might make some people sleep better at night.
Thanks, Peter. Much appreciated.
Did you do any IBIS-off tests to see if any differences? The lens doesn't have OIS, right?


No OIS. I don't remember testing it without IBIS because at the time, it didn't really cross my mind. And since I don't use a tripod, IBIS might as well be fixed in the on position. IBIS that doesn't overly degrade one or more corners is a must for me.

---------------------------------------------

Aztatlan wrote:
RoamingScott wrote
dougorama wroteDid someone already refer to this post?

https://www.aaronreedphotography.com/gallery/why-i-ditched-the-gfx100-and-bought-the-sony-ar74-instead/
He tried hiking with the 100, what did he expect?

Oh wait, I hike with the Z9...
His primary complaint seems to relate more to the shallow DOF of medium format and that it forced him to focus stack.

Whilst that may be true, I think it is largely equally as necessary on full frame. Plenty of photographers just stop down to f16 or so and call it a day, but this turns a 61MP file into little more than mush and is certainly not my jam. I focus stack virtually every landscape image on FF, unless the entire scene is at infinity focus.


The monkey wrench with regard to DOF is the change from 3:2 to 4:3 ratio. Most landscape is shot with the frame in the horizontal orientation. In that orientation, the increased vertical area available with 4:3 can result in a dramatic increase in the distance needed to be covered by the DOF. That increased distance can be problematic even if you keep the tilt of the camera at the same angle as you would frame it in 3:2 (half the increased space is at the top of the frame in the sky where it doesn't matter). But if you choose to keep the same amount of sky in the shot as you would with 3:2, and you tilt the camera down, you effectively move all the increased vertical space of the 4:3 ratio to the foreground.
May 31, 2024 at 05:30 PM
ronno
Offline
Details
p.12 #20Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Whenever I read threads like this, I wonder if people are actually making prints… though obviously some of the respondents here are.
Do yourself a favor and send a few files off to Adorama or someplace and have some 3 foot, 4 foot, prints made for you. It’s maybe $30 each. It’s cheap and you will get a real idea of what these files look like. And how minor or undetectable the differences are between cameras.
It’s probably obvious that most of the differences you can see by pixel peeping have zero relevance to the real world or prints.
Even large ones.
I’ve had three and 4 foot wide prints for sale at the MOMA museum here in CA, they look amazing, no complaints from anyone, more pixels would not have helped. (These were from the D610/D750.)
I’ve also had prints sold at Sotheby’s auction house, etc.
I lived in New York City for a long time where I went to endless amounts of museum and gallery shows by Richard Avedon, Annie Leibowitz, Sally Mann, Sarah Moon, Peter Lindbergh, Ansel Adams, Steve McCurry, Sebastiao Salgado, Irving Penn…and so many others.
It’s all about the content and nothing to do with the grain, pixel count, whatever.
Huge prints, small prints, so much lovely work!

I would get the camera that feels good to you, *the one that you are willing to carry around with you everywhere*… That’s the one that will get you the shot. Not the one that sitting at home because it’s a pain to carry, or too expensive to take to the beach.
No one in your audience will know or care one iota about these details people squabble about on the forums.

Getting off my soapbox now 😊.

Edited on Sep 02, 2024 at 10:39 AM · View previous versions
Jun 01, 2024 at 12:50 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister