fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape

  
 
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #1Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I can assure you 20 is just fine for me. I find shots in the 14-19 range entirely boring. I’m accustomed to making panos as necessary. The one place I wish I had more width than 24 was when I explored the Columbia River Gorge but I made do.

SGinNorcal wrote:
It probably varies with the hiking you do and your style of shooting but I would find 20mm not wide enough. When I'm above tree line and know there will be huge vistas, I have skipped the middle of the range and just taken a wide and a telephoto to save taking 3 lenses. On my last major trip, I was missing 36-105 in FF eq. and didn't miss it that much.

May 25, 2024 at 06:07 PM
Steve Spencer
Online
Details
p.2 #2Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Scott one thing you might want to think about is that you can always use the Fuji GFX in FF crop mode and use lenses that would normally be for FF cameras, and you will be using essentially the same sensor as in the A7r V, (although you can have that size sensor in any aspect ratio you want, for me a big advantage). The bigger GFX lenses are only required when you use the whole sensor. You could build a really good kit for landscapes with the Zeiss classic lenses on the Fuji GFX and many of those aren't that large.

That said not all the GFX lenses are huge. The 30 f/3.5 is not that big at all and the 50 f/3.5 is laudably small and I think both are good performers. If you add to those two the Hassy C 100 f/3.5, which is a wonderful landscape lens you have 3 small lenses that are all very nice landscape performers and all without a hefty price.

I don't have the GFX 100 or 100S in either form but I do have the GFX 50S and I also have the A7r V, both are nice systems but I have always felt the GFX was the better system for landscapes but not by much. I suspect it is even a bit better yet with the 100 cameras, but I wouldn't expect the difference to be huge.
May 25, 2024 at 06:09 PM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
SGinNorcal wrote:
It probably varies with the hiking you do and your style of shooting but I would find 20mm not wide enough. When I'm above tree line and know there will be huge vistas, I have skipped the middle of the range and just taken a wide and a telephoto to save taking 3 lenses. On my last major trip, I was missing 36-105 in FF eq. and didn't miss it that much.

Like you, when I need my really wide, I usually want right about 17 net Fx. But 90% of my landscapes are taken at 24 to 50, net Fx, so the 32-64 on the GFX is my personal nirvana lens and why it’s on the camera most of the time. Why I said in the other thread I could get by with the 23, but the tweaks available from the outstanding 20-35 are welcome.

Apologies to the OP for taking the sidetrack 🙏

Edited on May 25, 2024 at 06:28 PM · View previous versions
May 25, 2024 at 06:25 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape


Steve Spencer wrote:
Scott one thing you might want to think about is that you can always use the Fuji GFX in FF crop mode and use lenses that would normally be for FF cameras, and you will be using essentially the same sensor as in the A7r V, (although you can have that size sensor in any aspect ratio you want, for me a big advantage). The bigger GFX lenses are only required when you use the whole sensor. You could build a really good kit for landscapes with the Zeiss classic lenses on the Fuji GFX and many of those
...Show more →

Really doesn’t make much sense to use the GFX camera in crop mode and use adapted lenses on it. Why not just use the A7r5 in the first place?
May 25, 2024 at 06:27 PM
Steve Spencer
Online
Details
p.2 #5Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
chez wrote:
Steve Spencer wroteScott one thing you might want to think about is that you can always use the Fuji GFX in FF crop mode and use lenses that would normally be for FF cameras, and you will be using essentially the same sensor as in the A7r V, (although you can have that size sensor in any aspect ratio you want, for me a big advantage). The bigger GFX lenses are only required when you use the whole sensor. You could build a really good kit for landscapes with the Zeiss classic lenses on the Fuji GFX and many of those aren't that large.

That said not all the GFX lenses are huge. The 30 f/3.5 is not that big at all and the 50 f/3.5 is laudably small and I think both are good performers. If you add to those two the Hassy C 100 f/3.5, which is a wonderful landscape lens you have 3 small lenses that are all very nice landscape performers and all without a hefty price.

I don't have the GFX 100 or 100S in either form but I do have the GFX 50S and I also have the A7r V, both are nice systems but I have always felt the GFX was the better system for landscapes but not by much. I suspect it is even a bit better yet with the 100 cameras, but I wouldn't expect the difference to be huge.
Really doesn’t make much sense to use the GFX camera in crop mode and use adapted lenses on it. Why not just use the A7r5 in the first place?


Well one reason you might want to do so is that you can shoot the GFX is FF mode but use any aspect ratio you want. With the A7r V is you want any other aspect ratio than 3 X 2 then you have to crop the image smaller. You don't with the GFX.

Another reason you might want to use such lenses on the GFX instead of the A7rV is that you can mix such lenses with lenses that cover the whole image circle of the GFX to create a set of lenses that you prefer. For example, say you really like the Fuji GF 30 f/3.5 and the GF 50 f/3.5 better than any of the FF equivalents you can use on the A7r V, but you want to add a good 85mm FF equivalent and a 135mm FF equivalent for landscapes. Well you can use that GF 30 & 50 and add to them something like the Zeiss classic 85 f/1.4 and the 135 f/2 APO and use them as a set of lenses. Such a set could be preferred to anything that was available for only the A7r V.
May 25, 2024 at 10:41 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #6Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
A bag of inflexible primes is not my preferred method of shooting. If I’m going to crop the heavier, bulkier GFX, I could have shot the full frame with something easier to pack and carry, and more versatile to boot. At least that’s my rationale. Modern zooms are so good that the days of carrying many primes to maximize IQ are gone.
May 26, 2024 at 10:47 AM
Steve Spencer
Online
Details
p.2 #7Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
A bag of inflexible primes is not my preferred method of shooting. If I’m going to crop the heavier, bulkier GFX, I could have shot the full frame with something easier to pack and carry, and more versatile to boot. At least that’s my rationale. Modern zooms are so good that the days of carrying many primes to maximize IQ are gone.


Ok, if that is your preference then I don't see the GFX as being for you. Just as primes get you that last bit of resolution that you don't get from zooms, even at stopped down apertures, the GFX (or digital medium format more generally) gets you that last bit or resolution and color that FF 35mm does not. If you don't care about that or simply value flexibility over that, which is a totally reasonable preference, then I think going with a smaller format makes a lot of sense. For you that may well be the right choice.
May 26, 2024 at 11:04 AM
dcisive
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I would agree staying with the A7RV. On the subject of prints it's interesting. I'm a paid professional portrait, wedding and event shooter. As for prints requested it's a bit different then your scenario. My most popular print sizes are as follow using a Canon Pro1000 which does up to 22x17's.

8 1/2x11--70%
5x7--20%
13x19--10%
In the last 2 years I've only printed 2 22x17's.
Never had a request for anything larger.
May 26, 2024 at 11:35 AM
Lukacs
Online
Details
p.2 #9Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
MF is for the best IQ for still photography. 60MP FF is not that much worse however in IQ but far better in flexibility. Excellent zoom lenses, AF speed, eye tracking, also excellent resolution, especially with GM lenses, and Voigtlander APO (35-50-65-110). I'd go for MF for absolute best possible IQ, but that MF sensor not that much bigger considering a definite step.
May 26, 2024 at 02:26 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #10Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
APS-C could satisfy those printing requirements.

dcisive wrote:
I would agree staying with the A7RV. On the subject of prints it's interesting. I'm a paid professional portrait, wedding and event shooter. As for prints requested it's a bit different then your scenario. My most popular print sizes are as follow using a Canon Pro1000 which does up to 22x17's.

8 1/2x11--70%
5x7--20%
13x19--10%
In the last 2 years I've only printed 2 22x17's.
Never had a request for anything larger.

May 26, 2024 at 02:31 PM
InFocus2014
Online
Details
p.2 #11Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Last year, I did an environmental portrait shoot with a friend. He was using a 100mp GFX and a Fuji zoom (not sure which one) and I was using the A7RV with (mostly) the GM 50mm f1.2 and Sigma 105mm f1.4.

After the shoot, he sent me, via Dropbox, some RAW files to play with. When comparing with my files (we were essentially shooting the same subjects/backgrounds), I was just AMAZED at the acuity and color depth & richness of the MF Fuji files. Admittedly, I am an IQ junkie, but if I was not restricted by the confines of matrimony, I think I would have ordered a Fuji MF camera on the spot (of course, I would have later regretted it since the latest Fuji bodies have vastly improved Eye/Subject focus).

The Fuji MF platform certainly will not provide the flexibility you are looking for, like a 20-70mm f4 or 24-120mm; but, if your workflow can accommodate some incrementally additive shooting with big/heavy, narrow focal range equipment, you might find the sacrifices somewhat worth it and end-up shooting that equipment more than you expected to.
May 26, 2024 at 02:48 PM
dcisive
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
APS-C could satisfy those printing requirements.

dcisive wroteI would agree staying with the A7RV. On the subject of prints it's interesting. I'm a paid professional portrait, wedding and event shooter. As for prints requested it's a bit different then your scenario. My most popular print sizes are as follow using a Canon Pro1000 which does up to 22x17's.

8 1/2x11--70%
5x7--20%
13x19--10%
In the last 2 years I've only printed 2 22x17's.
Never had a request for anything larger.


You're not wrong. This is what I discovered on my last trip up to the Sawtooth region with a A6700 26mp APS-C camera. The details of the mountains with it's meager 18-135OSS lens presented similar detail in the end to my Z9 when viewed at sizes that already exceeded my 38" Viewsonic high rez screen. The Z9 has it's place, just not as you might say necessary. Hard for me to imagine a need for a 100mp monster.
May 26, 2024 at 02:58 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #13Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
InFocus2014 wrote:
The Fuji MF platform certainly will not provide the flexibility you are looking for, like a 20-70mm f4 or 24-120mm; but, if your workflow can accommodate some incrementally additive shooting with big/heavy, narrow focal range equipment, you might find the sacrifices somewhat worth it and end-up shooting that equipment more than you expected to.


This is reasonable. The question then becomes is the output THAT much better as to justify the headaches of all the concessions that must be made for it.

It's entirely possible I'll get the A7R5 in my hand, remember why I moved to Nikon in the first place away from the A7R4, and just keep my 100S II preorder and play with that and see what it's all about.

If the Sony output is demonstrably better than the Nikon with these new optics, it's better to not know what the GFX could have offered me in the first place

I noticed @mike reid liked your post, c'mon Mike, chime in! You are one of the few shooting the GFX system to its capabilities on FM.
May 26, 2024 at 03:30 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #14Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
The other thought is how to build a competent landscape kit around a 35-70.

Would need a prime to cover the 20-22mm range for wide shots. That's probably the CV 15, which is only 19 once adapted, meaning I'm cropping deeper than 61mp.

My Nikon 105/2.5 would be extremely serviceable at 130mm effective.

1135g for a pretty patchy focal coverage.

Sony 20-70 + 70/200 Macro is 1320g for seamless coverage of my most used 180mm.

This is the real heartburn.
May 26, 2024 at 03:58 PM
rdeloe
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
I also presume that I'm correct in thinking that my FF lenses when adapted would have .8x the focal length in 35mm terms, i.e. a 40mm ff lens becomes a 32mm? And if I used the "35mm" mode on the GFX, it would use a smaller portion of the sensor and go back to 40mm effective?


Comparing field of view is tricky because of the different formats. Using the diagonal makes no sense to me. I usually go long edge.

A 40mm lens on full frame is like a 49mm lens on GFX (comparing long edges). If you're comparing short edges, the 40mm full frame lens has the field of view of a 55mm lens on GFX.

Yes, if you use 35mm mode on GFX with a 40mm full frame lens, you get the same field of view.

I've been reading the thread since the start because I'm curious where you land. Our use cases are really different and I don't shoot Sony anymore (A7R way back when), so I didn't chip in. But I think it's fair to say that if you want a relatively light, two lens zoom kit, Sony is your best bet. The GF 20-35 is small and light, but I believe you said you find 20mm too wide on full frame; 20mm on GFX is like the field of view of a 16.4mm lens on full frame (long edge!). The GF 35-70 is excellent (small and light), but the wide end isn't quite wide enough for you (maybe?), and to get the longer end you'd need the GF 100-200 (so that's three lenses). Those three lenses are 2,215 grams (725 plus 440 plus 1050).


In terms of printing, if 300 ppi is your target, your large prints (call it 40" on the short side) will be 158 ppi with the A7RV and 218 ppi with a GFX 100. If you make a lot of these big prints, you'll notice the difference. If most of what you print is 20" on the short edge, I doubt most people would be able to tell which of the two cameras you used (317 ppi versus 437 ppi).

Edited on May 26, 2024 at 04:03 PM · View previous versions
May 26, 2024 at 03:59 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #16Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
rdeloe wrote:
RoamingScott wroteI also presume that I'm correct in thinking that my FF lenses when adapted would have .8x the focal length in 35mm terms, i.e. a 40mm ff lens becomes a 32mm? And if I used the "35mm" mode on the GFX, it would use a smaller portion of the sensor and go back to 40mm effective?
Comparing field of view is tricky because of the different formats. Using the diagonal makes no sense to me. I usually go long edge.

A 40mm lens on full frame is like a 49mm lens on GFX (comparing long edges). If you're comparing short edges, the 40mm full frame lens has the field of view of a 55mm lens on GFX.

Yes, if you use 35mm mode on GFX with a 40mm full frame lens, you get the same field of view.

I've been reading the thread since the start because I'm curious where you land. Our use cases are really different
...Show more →

Thanks Rob, I goofed my math and deleted that post Of course the FF lens are "longer" on GFX because they are covering less of the sensor, duh! Brainfart on my part.

I'd be better off with the 21mm CV instead of the 15mm and use it in 35mm mode IMO taking this into account.
May 26, 2024 at 04:01 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #17Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Then you get into "edge, but not THAT edge" cases where you don't want to remove a lens in a challenging environment. This is where the Nikon 24-120 simply dominates this space.

In a space of moments, you can go wide and punch right in without sacrificing any resolution. Of course I could crop a Sony or Fuji shot to match, but you're losing a lot more MP in the process on those to get to the same composition.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/52937645721_6b4f971a22_h.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/52935702565_49bdb7d740_h.jpg
May 26, 2024 at 04:05 PM
rdeloe
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
Then you get into "edge, but not THAT edge" cases where you don't want to remove a lens in a challenging environment. This is where the Nikon 24-120 simply dominates this space.

In a space of moments, you can go wide and punch right in without sacrificing any resolution. Of course I could crop a Sony or Fuji shot to match, but you're losing a lot more MP in the process on those to get to the same composition.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/52937645721_6b4f971a22_h.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/52935702565_49bdb7d740_h.jpg


That is a good point. And in medium format, I don't think we're ever going to see a similar solution. In medium format, 2 to 1 seems to be about the longest range we're likely to see. Even Pentax, which had a very deep 645 lineup, never did more than 2 to 1 focal lengths. I expect it's just a function of weight and cost. Smaller formats rule where we need a lens that stays on the camera and covers a big spread of focal lengths.
May 26, 2024 at 04:09 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #19Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
rdeloe wrote:
RoamingScott wroteThen you get into "edge, but not THAT edge" cases where you don't want to remove a lens in a challenging environment. This is where the Nikon 24-120 simply dominates this space.

In a space of moments, you can go wide and punch right in without sacrificing any resolution. Of course I could crop a Sony or Fuji shot to match, but you're losing a lot more MP in the process on those to get to the same composition.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/52937645721_6b4f971a22_h.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/52935702565_49bdb7d740_h.jpg
That is a good point. And in medium format, I don't think we're ever going to see a similar solution. In medium format, 2 to 1 seems to be about the longest range we're likely to see. Even Pentax, which had a very deep 645 lineup, never did more than 2 to 1 focal lengths. I expect it's just a function of weight and cost. Smaller formats rule where we need a lens that stays on the camera and covers a big spread of focal lengths.


All true. It's why I sure wish Sony would confront Nikon head on and issue a 24-120G instead of a 24-105G II, though in reality, either would be VERY welcome at this stage.

I feel dirty thinking about investing into GFX and getting a variable aperture "kit lens" as the primary zoom for this use, even though that's basically what the 24-105/120 are as well.
May 26, 2024 at 04:12 PM
rdeloe
Offline
Details
p.2 #20Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
I feel dirty thinking about investing into GFX and getting a variable aperture "kit lens" as the primary zoom for this use, even though that's basically what the 24-105/120 are as well.


It's counter-intuitive, that's for sure. But it's an outstanding lens: light, relatively compact, and excellent at every focal length and nearly from wide open. I'd love to have an aperture ring on it, and thought that would be a big deal. It wasn't.

The 45-100 is also excellent of course, but it weighs a lot more, and in terms of image quality, I didn't think it was better.
May 26, 2024 at 04:18 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister