fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Niko...

  
 
davidjl
Offline
Details
p.4 #1New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
It's too hot to go out during the day, but I managed to get out the door at 7:15 AM or so.

Ten snapshots from a walk in my neighborhood with the 75/1.5 start at:

https://pbase.com/davidjl/image/174732992

As always, click "next" in the upper right. Click "original" at the bottom to see a downsampled to 3600 pixels on the long edge version, "auto" to get back to a sensible size.

Yell if you can't see the exif: I'll add the f-stop used to the title if anyone thinks that'd be useful.

Jul 19, 2024 at 12:22 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.4 #2New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
davidjl wrote:
It's too hot to go out during the day, but I managed to get out the door at 7:15 AM or so.

Ten snapshots from a walk in my neighborhood with the 75/1.5 start at:

https://pbase.com/davidjl/image/174732992

As always, click "next" in the upper right. Click "original" at the bottom to see a downsampled to 3600 pixels on the long edge version, "auto" to get back to a sensible size.

Yell if you can't see the exif: I'll add the f-stop used to the title if anyone thinks that'd be useful.



Looks nice

I've been shooting mine on extended lunch breaks yesterday and today as the weather got sunny. I don't mind the heat, I kind of enjoy it like Finnish sauna. Will share some samples later today once I've had time to review my shots.
Jul 19, 2024 at 01:51 AM
dieterson
Offline
Details
p.4 #3New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Juha, how do you feel about the increased weight (balance) of the E-mount-75f1.5 on your A7CII?
Jul 19, 2024 at 02:12 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.4 #4New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
dieterson wrote:
Juha, how do you feel about the increased weight (balance) of the E-mount-75f1.5 on your A7CII?


I've been shooting my 50/1 E-mount version on my A7CII previously many times (mostly with the Sony GP-X2 grip which I purchased after getting that lens) so I got used to the weight of that one and 75/1.5 is somewhat lighter (515g vs. 590g) so I've not been having any issues with the size & weight so far. I've also not yet used the 75/1.5 with the GP-X2 grip. The balance might be slightly improved with the grip but it's been decent without it as well. In case of 50/1 I definitely prefer having the grip.

The weight feels well balanced (not front heavy etc.) so the combination works well enough but when overall low weight of the whole kit is a high priority, adapted 75/1.9 VM could be a nice solution (I also have that one). I didn't have the 75/1.5 VM anymore since I traded it away after getting 75/1.9, so I don't have any recent experience of using 75/1.5 VM on my A7CII...

Regarding other aspects of the user experience, I'm still finding a bit strange behavior of IBIS when using automatic focal length detection with this lens (same as my first copy). When focusing at near-infinity, the distance scale shown on the camera's viewfinder jumps quite suddenly from 22m to infinity and back to 22m when moving between focus distance threshold near infinity and at the transition point there is some kind of physical jolt on the sensor relating to IBIS, and sometimes at infinity or near-infinity distances it seems like IBIS stops working while framing a shot and the view becomes quite shaky. I don't see such problems at closer focus distances though and if I set the focal length manually to 75mm instead of using the automatic detection (I think the camera will use 3-axis IBIS in that case and will not utilize focus distance information), I'm not having any problems regardless of focus distance. I might just keep using manually set IBIS FL with this lens to work around that strange behavior. I haven't seen this kind of problem with any of my other CV E-mount lenses but I think it's got something to do with the focus distance data and how it impacts IBIS behavior, and it might also be specific to certain Sony camera models and their IBIS generation. I also don't think this behavior is specific to individual copies of the lens as both of my copies have had same behavior in this regard...

Other than that I haven't experienced any problems and I'm enjoying the lens a lot so far.
Jul 19, 2024 at 02:57 AM
dieterson
Offline
Details
p.4 #5New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Thank you, Juha, for your impression!
Jul 19, 2024 at 05:20 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.4 #6New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Here are some samples I shot with my A7CII & CV 75/1.5 Nokton E-mount lens (my replacement copy) yesterday and today on extended lunch breaks around Ebisu & Shirokane.

https://photos.app.goo.gl/kGuGzxfE8A4rUrom8

I exported them via C1 Pro and applied some of my favorite filmic presets. All shots were at f1.5 or f5.6 and with electronic / silent shutter. I'm looking forward to shooting more this weekend
Jul 19, 2024 at 08:38 AM
Chris_88
Offline
Details
p.4 #7New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Thanks for sharing your thoughts Juha. My copy will ship next week. Other than three ultra wide lenses and the 15mm in particular, I hadn't heard of sample variation being an issue for Cosina (which probably means little). I hope my copy is fine.

I don't mind the new design, but I'll say, I would have appreciated them sticking to the 58mm filter thread. 62mm is in no filter's land for me. I have plenty of 5xmm filters and plenty 72mm and 77mm filters, but not a single 62mm.
Jul 20, 2024 at 09:49 PM
davidjl
Offline
Details
p.4 #8New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
FWIW, I'm not having any IBIS or distance display issues on the A7R5. A quick test showed IBIS doing it's magic at 1/4 second, twice in a row, resulting in images as sharp as one could ask for as checked on the camera's screen/magnification function.

Also, FWIW, I'm happy with the balance on the A7R5. If anything, it seems short for a 75mm lens, at least compared with my experience with 24-70 zooms. The only slightly heavier 21/1.4 feels noticeably more awkward and front-heavy. The 75/1.5 is only slightly (11 mm) longer than the 35/2.0 APO.

So far, my only complaint is that the lens cap is a tad fiddly and will fall off if you're not careful. The hood has grooves so a third-party lens cap might fit. Might. Since it seems to be an odd size: bigger than 67, smaller than 72. Sigh.

Jul 20, 2024 at 11:25 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.4 #9New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Both the VM and E versions are a true 74mm at infinity. I can find very little on focus breathing online. I don't have my VM with me, but Bastian had this to say: 'Most of the Voigtländer lenses are block focus without floating elements, so they show less focus breathing than many modern AF lenses but there are of course exceptions.'

I can't find even a focus breathing test or comment anywhere. The rapid focus ring would make it pretty obvious, so it may also lack FLE which would make it a very old-fashioned lens. In fact, Cosina include the 75/1.5 in their 'Vintage' line. Many rate these lenses as perhaps Cosina's most engaging photographic lenses.

For a non-standard focal length, it is turning out to be very versatile. The sharpness from f2 and especially f2.8 will make it feel more like a long 50mm, like a soft-cropped 58mm. It has very good volume rendering'. A much better bet for walk around images than an 85mm. Many of them suffer heavy breathing too, exacerbating walk photography.

If you struggle with focus at f1.5, use f2. F1.5 here is an 'over-max aperture' setting, if you will. Lens contrast drops significantly, and it will slow you down.
Jul 21, 2024 at 12:45 AM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.4 #10New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Someone here may report the extent of focus breathing in the 75/1.5 for us, please. The one you want to know is how much change from infinity focus to 2 metres, a pretty typical portrait distance. No need for exactness, just what you see.
Jul 21, 2024 at 12:45 AM
davidjl
Offline
Details
p.4 #11New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Focus breathing.

It's dark out, so I'll try this inside. Just looking at the image on the camera's screen, with the camera on a tripod locked in position.

There's a music stand with an A4 page on it at the left of the frame 5 meters from the camera.

At infinity focus, the width of the page is in frame at the edge of the frame.
At 2 meters focus, about 2/3 of the page is in the frame.

The 35/2.0 APO-LANTHAR is pretty much the same story, maybe a bit more of the page goes out of frame going from infinity to 2 meter focus.
Jul 21, 2024 at 05:47 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.4 #12New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Today (Sunday) I enjoyed a long afternoon of shooting with my 75/1.5 (on my A7CII) at Ueno where they are having Ueno Summer Festival around Shinobazu. The weather was quite sunny and photogenic, much better than yesterday.

https://photos.app.goo.gl/RQt8M1WoizdT59qH9

I've been enjoying shooting the lens wide open and for infinity type shots I've settled on using f5.6 most of the time. These shots were processed from Raw via C1 Pro again pretty much the same way as my first set. On Saturday I tried using the GP-X2 grip on my camera but I left it out on Sunday and I feel there's no real need for it with this lens.

Overall I'm very pleased with the lens. I used to have the 75/1.5 VM version before so I already knew pretty much what to expect from the rendering / IQ and it has been as I expected. My VM version had "focus creep", i.e. the focus ring moved on it's own (extended itself) when I just walked around with the lens mounted on camera hanging from my neck. My E-mount version has none of that, i.e. the focus ring has enough resistance not to move on it's own and I can also safely leave it at best position for infinity shooting and keep it there as long as I keep taking long distance shots.
Jul 21, 2024 at 09:31 AM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.4 #13New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Chris_88 wrote:
Thanks for sharing your thoughts Juha. My copy will ship next week. Other than three ultra wide lenses and the 15mm in particular, I hadn't heard of sample variation being an issue for Cosina (which probably means little). I hope my copy is fine.

I don't mind the new design, but I'll say, I would have appreciated them sticking to the 58mm filter thread. 62mm is in no filter's land for me. I have plenty of 5xmm filters and plenty 72mm and 77mm filters, but not a single 62mm.


Thanks! Yeah, I think there shouldn't be any systematic or common problem with centering issues with this lens. I hope you get a fine copy in one go. My original one was bad on the left edge (when shot horizontally and focused for best "infinity" results centrally), especially around the corners but all around the left edge, and much better on the right edge and corners on the right side. I tested it at f4 and the discrepancy was quite noticeable at long distance shots. It was also obvious that the left edge and corners became much better when shooting the same scene with camera upside down keeping the same focus distance etc. My replacement copy turned out to be fine.

I've bought a lot of CV lenses (currently I have 30, but I've had 10-20 more that I've traded away) and most of the time they've been fine without any issues. I did get a bit decentered new 40/2.8 VM back in 2022 (when it was launched) and I also got that one exchanged that one successfully at Map Camera, but at that time it took more talking to convince them to exchange it. Luckily this time it was a easier. Otherwise I haven't really had problems with new copies. There was one decentered used X-mount 35/2 as well which I bought 2nd hand from Fujiya Camera and there they agreed to swap it out to another used copy that was in similarly ranked condition and that replacement came out fine as well.
Jul 21, 2024 at 09:44 AM
davidjl
Offline
Details
p.4 #14New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
philip_pj wrote:
"If you struggle with focus at f1.5, use f2. F1.5 here is an 'over-max aperture' setting, if you will. Lens contrast drops significantly, and it will slow you down."

Here, on the A7R5, focus peaking works as well at f/1.5 as it does at f/2.0, so there's no need to stop down. I think I'm seeing a bigger difference between f/2.0 and f/2.8 than between f/1.5 and f/2.0.

Now if I could only navigate the Japanese menus to figure out how to persuade the camera to only do focus peaking in magnify mode. Sheesh.

(I took a bunch of test chart shots at 2 m (with the test chart center in the lower corner of the upper 1/3 of the frame, i.e. off center about half way to the corner), and the differences were pretty subtle. Thus the "I think". I also shot the 65/2.0 and 40/1.2 at closer distances (to get similar subject mag), and the differfences were too subtle to bother with. Well, crank the sharpening a bit and you get the image below.)

Here's 75/1.5 at the left (1.5, 2.0, 2.8, 4.0, 5.6)
65/2.0 APO in the center (blank, 2.0, 2.8, 4.0, 5.6)
40/1.2 at right (1.4, 2.0, 2.8, 4.0, 5.6) (no 1.2)


https://a4.pbase.com/o12/29/138229/1/174740513.X89uaerq.Nokton_v_APO_Sharpened.jpg


Jul 21, 2024 at 08:32 PM
Juha Kannisto
Online
Details
p.4 #15New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
davidjl wrote:
...
Now if I could only navigate the Japanese menus to figure out how to persuade the camera to only do focus peaking in magnify mode. Sheesh.
...


I think there is no camera setting in current latest Sony cameras that would allow focus peaking to be used only in magnified mode or only in non-magnified view. The Peaking Display sub-menu only has on/off setting + peaking level + peaking color options and in the Focus Assistant sub-menu there don't seem to be any additional options regarding peaking behavior.

My A7CII and all my previous E-mount cameras are also Japanese variants. It's annoying that there are only Japanese menus available... I usually try to refer to English Help Guide when I need to search some particular menu item that is not easy to find and then figure out where the corresponding options are in the Japanese menu.

I personally use peaking on + strong level and red color all the time. I have disabled automatic magnification and on my A7CII I just toggle magnified mode with AF-ON button when I want it, mostly when I want to finetune my focus for stopped down infinity shots. For close and mid-range shots I don't use magnified view that often.
Jul 21, 2024 at 09:22 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.4 #16New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Having been at it for decades, It's easy for me as well at f1.5, but I have noticed reviewers mention the issue, so trying to help those with lesser vision than mine.

I can't take to 'peaking'; I trust my eyes and peaking often obscures the fine detail that sends the 'press' message to the brain. I want to see the target. I've got to see it to believe it. I don't trust cameras' electronically signalling, be it green dots, lines lined up, or whatever. As with most things in the world:

show me, don't tell me.
Jul 21, 2024 at 11:18 PM
davidjl
Offline
Details
p.4 #17New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
"I think there is no camera setting in current latest Sony cameras that would allow "

Yes. I was joking/complaining.

I use blue + strong level and so it has to be turned off to think about composition. But I'm overly persnickity about where the plane of focus is, so I check every time. I just moved the peaking on/off from the AEL button under my thumb to the C2 one behind the shutter release: it takes a larger movement to get to it, but I don't bump it accidentally.

Jul 21, 2024 at 11:45 PM
Chris_88
Offline
Details
p.4 #18New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Juha Kannisto wrote:
Thanks! Yeah, I think there shouldn't be any systematic or common problem with centering issues with this lens. I hope you get a fine copy in one go. My original one was bad on the left edge (when shot horizontally and focused for best "infinity" results centrally), especially around the corners but all around the left edge, and much better on the right edge and corners on the right side. I tested it at f4 and the discrepancy was quite noticeable at long distance shots. It was also obvious that the left edge and corners became much better when
...Show more →

Thanks, fingers crossed. I have owned half a dozen CV lenses and no issues either thus far. I've only ever had problems with the gen 1 of the 24-70 GM. I bought one copy online, which Sony accepted as faulty and I got my money back. Then I bought another copy at Map Camera, that like the first one had an insanely weak right side between 60-70mm. When I exchanged that second lens, I was told by Sony that I couldn't possibly get two lemons and was given a choice between having the lens calibrated or getting a new lens by Sony via Map Camera. Fortunately, the third copy turned out to be decent.
Jul 22, 2024 at 07:06 AM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.4 #19New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
Dustin Abbott reviews the Nikon version of the 75/1.5, but it's well worth Sony users considering the lens seeing this video. It's also good to see a consensus developing around this very fine lens, and the growing realisation that what some rate as faults are actually intended to be present as part of the design. (It's something also seen in Cosina's deliberate and distinctive bokeh and vignette, they walk their own path and it's never bland.)

If you want something very different from any ~85mm and you are open to artistic imagery and a very distinctive colour palette, it's hard to go past this one. The amazing level of detail at mid apertures is just icing on the cake, but very valuable for those wanting versatility in this focal length region - from MFD softness to fine detail at 500 metres. He's right about the Zeiss background influence in the title, but it's clear Cosina are moving on now Zeiss have removed themselves from the market.

YT title:

Voigtlander Nokton 75mm F1.5 Review | Zeiss on a Budget?
Jul 28, 2024 at 04:55 PM
JasonMello
Offline
Details
p.4 #20New Cosina Voigtländer 75/1.5 development announcement for Sony E, Nikon Z, Canon RF
These new voigtlanders are just sexy.
Jul 28, 2024 at 06:05 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister